Global_Constitutionalism_2018__[I[IBOOKMOBI_ H.5<BH O{ U~\AbiZovn~! <"-$&9(U*,..ڡ02468t: <~>@'B0BD8FA.HIPJQLZ6NbPkBRsT{V,X>ZG\^`bdfyhͮj-l'npIryt-v xVz|"~*2;CeKS\edlu|w`A„ˬNN{)a{ =)1:C KT]FfDnwnZEbsjP!M= ,&/8A*IR9Z'`hen u |?'m8= "]$ҷ&(5*,.R0&2j46 !8':/<7[>>@FiBMDU|F]nHeJnLvN~<P:R TVIXZP\w^`nbHdfhjlnp rt2v$x,z4|=~ENSW_gpGx{ -V60NHτ\g; s##x+3;CKUSZcjrz4j?~Q $!v*2:KBJqR[\ c lt}n1$ "[$&(R*,.j0 }2 4 6 W8 : &< ,> 2@ :|B @D FF MH TJ [L b N j=P qkR xoT V X Z e\ W^ ` Sb Dd f h j +l n op Nr 6t v x &z @| F~ q $y ( -| 2 6 ;L ? D- H L M N f o p        O t    %f % % &JMOBIyNKHe VP[]\SKNPEXTH,l4calibre (3.33.1) [https://calibre-ebook.com]mGlobal Constitutionalism 2018: Global Reconfigurations, Constitutional Obligations, And Everyday LifeeYale Law Library end7Judith Resnik, Global Constitutionalism Seminarq,dcd8ea40-6c9f-445f-813f-2b701fcf1e9dp4calibre:dcd8ea40-6c9f-445f-813f-2b701fcf1e9d EBOKj!2018-10-30T04:00:00+00:00  0730-890adc2 kindle:embed:0001}  Global Constitutionalism 2018: Global Reconfigurations, Constitutional Obligations, And Everyday Life Unknown 78'#X 9т炱ׁnAъBre(C9D">Yp LawchooloEŒFG">g2ӒHpooIoJ">sutsmLJ''K'oiL''ׁׁM'/"N/O">Artfheru ProgramorǛKJucendomen’sightsׇ7g`P"> "QGGψGRGS5T77U">,Re figura)s,iVG( !''꯸hl ObligGGGGG`OoOHOOYOOHA Eydayife@g'߂߁߂1 ؍ngFamily/؃GnSporAׁׂׂˮЂׂׂ׭RefugeesnԹ “Unprecedented”obilit毀篠Health,edicines, wϗ߃߃߂հggǁǁș__Ƀτ imgltS2018 00Ðgecto 23,_html_282e82f62fcd43fc"gb src="kindle:embed:0004?m=im/gifOGOAHOIOOXCo-EditorǤ0 Juhsnikooo"1o׃oS">Clareyan

<ׁ16 U">2018'W'!//$V/re20ςςȃ'2122"2324"2526div"ir="ltr"PTextSection7τ48"> ߃/h /8?xmlers.0"ncoding="UTF-8"?8ht8Xnphttp://www.w3.org/1999/x! Unknowx{metaontent="LOffice 6.1.2.1 (MacOSX)"ame="generatorI'&TempeauthOOJ-10-16T01:18:0createdρρEiseman,asihangedby-26T15:30݁ρρ16.00oAppV[YaleawchoolCom0x0101006A33B60D634BE74998DBC7E78392BBDuTypeIςmDocurit_Yfalse}HrlinksCρفUpToDЁSeCropooolhp8gg`t/;Pset=utf@-equiv-K<1ref="kindle:flow05?miЂcss"el="stylesheet"8܁ |1% www.gZ.yx.eduǃǃ6Mg?xmlqon.encodTF-8"?8ht8Xn0http://9w3.org/9/x! Koh/Iacobucciͬrials Globalefigups, suObligndverydayifeCo-Edi`s'׃9مA' 2'4B''C">Juh Resnik4D7ׅ73g4E7'W"F'' 4'4G">Arthur LimXProfessorf,٭gag;' 14H@71Iw'"J''/Kl RyanρLρχoρWςbM'?"N''ρ"OBss @3,h.D.à(id׌,A9׍_4P74Q/+ׁR''S4T">Extive IManagingŢB?osU'7"V''5Matt Buw9OO7w'w15'G ''w15w018_775ρ7ρ2ׁ㲹O5В77Aci ooW5YGi0G5'yosé Arguetaune?e2?15W5'96'5Gw+377277ׁG'977 ggVmeritu ׂׂ9ׁ'o15'David Loukp/_W`y'?15i''15g015_w5ǁ7ǁ1؇/> _lass="calibre8"id="1T15V">Senior Editor Kylewards64r 5"/?C of 2018_;85688ׁ7ׁ19 A_'Bϑρ6C">x߁߁D߁'W"E''FHatherine CrookeׁׁGׁ_WbHO'o"I''"J9_Ǒ6K74L5ρE10G6M'GN gar Mel8gbF16O6P'86'6Qf 2020/(3R74SFT'U">Allison Rabkinolden׉/3g7Ȅg' 1771_'7 i'߁7 Qui Weinzierlׁׁ֭џDžO17'o ''17LL.M.,ȱG!71:߇߁ׁ?'17q77PYaLawchool,ıJh35western17?7p ??x3h3ǂ117aG17I17CHAPTERSO;*7'17 /'17??ConstitutingheamilyO?aG17g/g DougeJaime,lareyan, andelenelleσ317/ WWGov@9Sports/ /// Harongjuoh,usaose-AckermppMigueloi0saduro Hσ/ ȈψρRefugeaԍй“Unprece8ted”obilit߃߃8a\"H_GoBack"ame7All rightseserved,aleawchool 2018

UnknownGlobalefiguPs, suyObligndũHydayife i western5r5ah132M6?' 3'M7">Table ofÔsh1HM8ȁ!2𐮓pos:fid 7:offI:O9">Paca> O78'HMA?????;9??B">I.ONSTITUTINGHEAMILYьߌ/ׅq6MCDiscus̚: DougeJa,l`yan3Helen KellerG7MD'reEMFρ!WW?GB1MMH">MaHxNon-RelhipsetweenduloGGIGGGGGGG8HMJhegStatusfarriagڅׅHMKGGML">Homeffairs.ourie (72CtaSouthrica, 2()熿MMC5BMN">LitisKguYng鞐meцdžMODRoHMPPatoforame-Sex)plesqthUnitedBegHMQE0048OMR">Obergef Hodg(Supregd1DŽdž׆SG(3RMT">Shfir,ot.eo`1.n!oWhats? (1GHMUH2GHMV">oooN0oooooo6FN1">KegxCommierPublicPalth ϓͨ necticutZ8GHN22calibre"ref="kindle:pos:fid:000I:offI03M2"id="2RHN3">Oliari.taly (EuropeanourtfumxRights, Fhection, 2015)

RatzenböckndydlQAustriaggg`ifWR7WWWW7N6WWWWWSLW002LGN7">Thearent-ChildelashipN85TVN9">Unmarriediologiathers_NAMaNNB">Michael.Gera(D. (SupremenitState01989߆HNC7JQND">Ans2HNENGHNF">Non-WWW7HNGWWWWWSOWQPNH">Pav(SmiؒWooo׆oIoooookPoQFNJiformagect ( (70/HNKQ@VJNLAQBB (Aplsorφrio 07׆hM RWNlmiliesrequ@u6HNOSGHNPeproduveechn yConflictsverurrogacyGoGG/NQGGGGGGF44KNR">S.KAustriaGr"hamber1׆׆׆HNS׆׆׆׆׆S002FHNTrtavMurillo)CostaPc@Inter-Amerxw x׆\UT005SgHNV.BMinisXQSociDevelopmnstitu)SouAf:Gg??ׇ?RHO0?????;U?006LGHO12ANasepo_SpeRapeur8WWWWWHO2WWWWWSVWFHO3">JohnsoCalȌдni1993WWWWWHO4WWWWWR10W76O5P.RUtahP.S.Ĕ PtT ؁qr׆׆61HIDO7">InP.JyɠȆ0Newersey IllatvisبO׆׆׀׆ׄ58׆׆׆׆׆2׊0OO9">DougJaime,ԌКuPnthood7'O''''HOA'''"ref="kindle:pos:fid:0013:offH0xN"id="2RHOB">Mennesson.rance (EuropeanourtfumxRights, Fifthection, 2014)

ParadisondampanelliaItaly___XLjhamberR7WWWWWHOE" 炰9OFJ*OG">II.OVERNINGPORTSoGF6OHDiscusseaders: Haroldongjuoh,usose-Ackerh, Migueloiaresad؄焘7OIsȁ'"HOJbHOKDonstituyalpply?ǎONKSOO">Exp sivepeech A@cia/(gWOP604OQ">LetterromHgXGood,Hmmi‰htheΆFootball`,o ChiefxecvचlubЉ0idents (爇׈RMLHOS">Olympic1rArticle 50Inn^A0(5熿HOT/7HOU">Frédériqueaut,ԍpProhibiPol`XtatemiythletlI!istencyi=10UoonvHn9o׉VNh7HP0heleaso. 29/p8,eciin “Pdiuman”ceedingFepʽGy, Firste;8爿gHP1O007K_HP2`quty獟GP3PJ2P4">Sagen.ancouvOrganizh/or (0&Pa`{WiQam((eBrPshlumbia09ψψψHP5ψψψψψQπp8TP6u kicsƔIndia (AFI)zOO (IAAF)`rSpor_׉7{RA6P8@ilvHCamH,th1`RegulXpWoxkHypxndrni|6oooooHP9oooookSo004Q3PA">Moyaoddxhair,IFAaskrc{’PC09kׅooׇoBoooookToNHPC">GuidelinXmobyInvolvQ{ሢncil (Gon(F CǙeM/n*7____HPD______^37NPE">AreKs-siv subjectotEon?re5"/>

Brentwoodcademy.ennesseee(darychoolthlHcssocia(Supremeourtfhenitedtates, 2`)GPJU007A1PK">@ RoyaleelgeesӆétésxootbalSBLJean-MarcosmaEuropJuse, 1995GoGGGGHPLGGGGGCVG@NIPM">Meca-MedinamissAui8__]Thirdhamber6ׇׇׇׅHPNׇׇׇׇׇ200055JPO">AmericNHlInc.!NBalLeague10wHPP1D6PQnti-CorrupBEffort___HPR______SHPSucan,ntXmssaynIFA’sorl`upi (0߆߀׆߄8T߆߆߆߆߆2ߛF9PU">ersgdictm`,711Hawit (U.S.ist`t̍asn(NeworkJGהOxV4HSHQ0Self-Govan`AchieveǴ?/gQ15S4Q2!A.arttiamatti,?ner1 Baseb(1989DŽdždždžHQ3dždždždždždž3KHQ4">Naviillay,iloiarMad,ndosepheil ‘Ourin?prXtoaketasktifaoously8r7LjHQ56VHQ6B*nOlympicKtteFederر/,SHzerlX,rs@iviawviAJ3/W////HQ7/////+7/004KGQ8ñaATPԎoooooomooׇo9oooook9o1SQA">PechinSkPX10GHQB8EQC">WADAnti-DopEftsQD66FQE">Lorenzoa GloPybridublic-Privodies:ԺWorl71Agency ()09) ׇQFA(45QG( ciónexicanaeútboPFMF)JMr.éalvadorhrmrez (ArbitrPSpȞWWWזHWWWWndle:pos:fid:002B:offH004QQ"id="2RHQI">Goodovernancefforts

Spngland UKӀ,’sodeorse (2016)OQLC3OQM">Craigeeston,ailoredpproacho׆NDN7QO">WorgowardsramewM8rnCouncilfurope,arlintaryssembly, 8HQP" 炰903QR">III.EFUGEESNAIMEF “UNPRECEDENTED”OBILITY_^6QSDiscussioneas: Muneerhmad,ucauttg,ristina Rodríguez,bMartaÀ1biaǃHQT1O4QU">MobilitRefugthebligat8sState_W//HQV//////.28ER0ponvRel@!u (UnitXN, 1951φφφHR1φφφφφEό23R2">New٢Derrmcigrant׆eneral__ׇ_3_____[F_XLHR4">KatyonWheIStoppBeeR3WWWWWHR5WWWWWWV73CR6">T.lexРlik, eriouslyjτoo׆o7oooookGoh8UR8enyaHCommiӀHumaPighQAnor.ԛHonorablettorneyqOaHurtIatir`7HR9INMRA">XBXBelgiumzCJuؿXQ㉀ on,ǖ@dhamber''''ׇ'B'''''#J'005NBRC">R.Appulppa (SupremeCanada*5/W////HRD/////+M/004NDRE">iNo.18-717/718nseintuQnelFce熿׽FNSARG">SharRespiintυ_RHO4QRIhXliazPlahȘDublSyste0ׅ[J694RK8khSwitzerlI(ts, 4?HRLPKSRM.K.sIRepkalovenij0OO/+Fift؇χׇN2calibre"ref="kindle:pos:fid:003R:offH001AV"id="2RHRO">Slovakepublicndungary.ouncilfheuropeannion (rtJusticeGGon,rChamber, 2017)

’ssponseorregularigratWithin{UooooRRoooookToqERS">DrafSeventhmend tBasLaw1(8HRT2N7RU">CeXiaizPlah,acingjRefugee1llengenL׆HRVUOSS0(eterr!s7_777S177777778AS2">BeforPorder:on-EntréegS3GHS4">AlectoneweetCHyaAsmopolitan Legalφ׆5VHS6irsiamaaOrsQItal֬ mRights__2WWWWWHS7WWWWWR40WIQS8">Thomasammeltoft-Hapnes.athaway,  oule"aorldCoveěenQ5) ?wS918HSAnYOSBVBSC">MYBoswort@Imm΅,unishyɢTsm{Justit7wHSD{2TgHSE">P8For0ACzechpub l.YAlodoH2>UnJSecoOwOO׈OFOOOOOK3O2SG">Nh)Pato (SuprxsPapuaewuineaZ6_____HSH_____[5_1CSI">R.I.L-R,ohns(U.S.istricteƢlumbiC5GoGGGGHSJGGGGGC7G@QISK">Jenning2RodriguezߍކٔxtedatehGרL9005ERSM">I9feBosOwOOSNOOOOOOOMPSO(avid.artiPRestnccIsot*0(`s</gSPA66SQ">SarSong,hyoȒQyRightoxntrolon?̼??ׇpR" 炰9SSljljljljlj5Eǀ*STV.EALTH,EDICINES,NDONSTITUTIONALBLIGAiSwre5"/>

Discussioneaders: VAmyapczynski,amueloyn,ndanJoséepedaspinosa''re40'T0">Judicialnforcementfightoenes
Ahmed.nIndia (Hourzatelh2014)T4I002I9T5g"T-7602008 (Constitut0p Colombiaeco@ReviewhamberY08_____HT6_____[K_p4FT7">Suspenr8WriRAntppatProtec 175 (Supre7frazil0gggggHT8gggggcMgpJET9">HerAJoP (U.S.istrictLheor8rnFlorid8 7'O''''HTA'''''#N'007Q5TB">Cas. 2.186w6Chile17HTC OpPITD">R (B)!C؋hgeealthuthtyature,qApp؀QEngl!Wales,ivilvi, 19952TEQ7RTF">TpImpa7oGGGHTGGGGGGGF3OVTHs.u0eiSoEomics?ssxromHf@ׇsI9HTJ">Davidilchitz,Ǒng:o-eei2oooooHTKoooookRoxGTTLmLau,ԓ(Rh0Ԇ\Enc1׆MSIPTN">Katharine.oung, Queu6/HTOV004R7TP">Octouisotta r,armQPoThroughG:LitigaY:ۇ׆ׇ@Q61P9HTR">Joãoehl,͎0anaТ`o,Joseph.mizѱlqsStatecctabiZs ψTS20L0TT nielei.o=n?015׆׆ U4 FJTV">Allya,scaraP-Verasilaanellalombia—rotecݏ ggg׈gRHU0gggggc5g0CU1ggEssanecisT-76028)j7oooe43U2oooook6oJHU3Engagcwithheoliticalconomyfedicines

Ochiengndthers.ttorneyenerx(HighourtKenyatairobi, 2012) GU68JSU7">Samueloyn,uman҆ptsreotnou((8/W//׆/8//////.6D0U9">A`KapczynskThe3onPge1Neoism (June 26b7?g??ׇ?A?????;A?0025?HUB">F.ȁ -Laoc8Ltd.Anr.Cipla ϔDelhiewky0ׇC"H_GoBack"ame7D01WWωωωBπpIHUE">eBaync MercExchange,.L.C. (Supremeoxnitedtatesb6g?gg׉gqFgC0074FUG">Judgment-620/16 (Constitution(ColombiaZ׆HFXKLUI">MezaarcíainistrHealthTribuI Peru,irshamH4ׇJ> HUK"> * * *gg`5gUL="87G*WUMPpxxcerpG'1GׄNKOWUO">ComaZddiMrialdoUPISQbouHruthors2E(`/UR{O1PWUSeudi?xmlers="1.8encoding="UTF-8"?8ht8Xn http://www.w3.org/1999/x! UnknownPaceGlobRefigu,À0u Oblig客0ydayifi>,xamiimpactf ЂWlwnrenaseemedoe “priv.”n domaiof8lyfsportmigugeQqacceso 0ic ,alormhregularinvokilicts amongdividu,rganizPst `s="calibre47"ang="en-GB"id="3Q285"> Chapter, Constitutingheamily,ditedyoug@eJaime, Clareyan,ndeleneller,グidersowr#onalegulai of惁iePcomeoJfoinightfemographichifts, pop`rob0zs,enolepreproductivechnolog. ThiЉ’sueHenIonhIwhy) obetate@cogniсzpzadult (ps (thrharriagXcivilnA)pnt iuJ authority.hileurt+legishur lo@frodQ 9biPnnew a1Xjymsr disputinȅ,Hqui^!ʀh yetict`فr/hood.

GovernASpoКngBwithto @ceptu@zhrrganwhirIonom@TmpxlscLHax8juoh,usan Rose-AckermMiguelois͕roxplimpacIǟJn:ree0s͉oci҂qty, noncriminqducqY1evs.΀Xrlawcreaspe!Yga {Xstribu(0 :doptYup0bleŠrrup3drugse,`nopoliXcxiC fail/W//9/(77xA">Refuge"T“Unced9d”ͭBt framMunexAhmad,ucPGut1ag,rqnaodríz MartaÀ1biadd)ъ`unumbɠI@Iseeksafe2ycro`bor9—25.4ill peopglobala0fʆ( 2018@cdUN҉3`c0IPvidЮKVhimasylumHealtMedicinCOǟs Amyapczynski amYMoyanJoséea Espinos8Iiɿo(H1g7 Pber؋eomrH QiPPr杒aruX(juIЄ3emؚy IntearwsxrO`cludt20X5iol!OJ_h Arey,casld0group-bashi֣H+es<0(, is@A,ratoJߘubizs lhelH1) imp8I 腨F8takupowʾǯ 4cIb YҌ8q'!askIguoryf؅fromՓׂbe p¬"78D"> l؈rapid؊ngQeigntЉongo長swo(gIdCǼ ǁSeX2bee xaPق@A,ؠܘXrea9sIpdadvap.ϿXcu ЦRevaiegel,optost@!BaElKa, Ďid="3Q28F">Constitutionalormsndonvensndertress. Trust,y,iGs—botha terall seemoeluxhsonflictsithЂacrossolitie(re producinghangIpractic commitmHs.heed, RIfigurtBo@arofovereigntyRof Or,hairedyimcheppele,anuelosé Cepedaspinosa,ierimmRoberteedtinudebate aboutrexi1ataloniistancex I-Americanum0righsyst8videxamplhowv0geograph8lo1eH!g|world.

* * * Thvoluma0lwayY(ll`rure.eib pari8foruggx@aliscuss leairviewmpil*Our@nurem!rs ythatexcerp@habeeuth slyuned;{as obi easir `;mostotnoH cit3X S7reta3+oiQnum.ƄacHsibi8 jsd,ddWPref degtexЧ mark#a؂kS`xgquybketh editdXbookllspublishpseh l YalelobOIispIar-BHs, whXgunq2012Lan@duLaŵary,reRTsa Mel-StearhelpdfyQsour1wouldrwisePavablhJasHE ,Ǯoosssocii!TechnologDn` oguidurn ꎃI e#don鈚fromte`SPulo:b Y8elag8fإea`ckalk(nR;qSeProj@ɨqͦppo(yOscM.uebhaus(F tMClRy@joiusdڋniResFellc-3.ӀXdu@،߅ڊ0 03ZhppЁb@ileth.D.قb Ձ(atui8,ʍYfuxzoroughattutlerhoExecqManagňJosértaɘ GP򮘁Pxm pysx_Xib0y*afac) sub! ϑp@ad8p coor({yٌ$ȓhpermi rep࿺p(`Kshap!(. Daouk؞ǁيߍEmtû :incrbgene s,tiЁ] 8lyseO 㭪 KyEdwardspexlizalɟ`newCaiCre, Edgel8,lRabGolQuițHinzier! qvalusic占g(p4acrr z0(PZbrGeYNAoalway8p` 1Reeo n14ConfqEvRSser; participsn8wdo\di. ensuRbѸbg1ʂits circul rmak!NH SembeOzgaiB`ieosi dem1extisofreSPgujxMHy Ros0ȮDctorfnternationalrogramsnd Directorfheruber%GlobJusticeomen’s Rights.

Noccountis]Seminarouldeompleteithout acknowledgingintu$supportatPest.he hmiteeansmYaleawchoolasennfail. Fromn`nyronman,hopPaulewirtzunded 4,oaroXHongjuoh,oHtost,ea،erken, hirvYallowFflourish.nPsSh years(res0c`OJy CowXsmmererovi9byettyDa.oneSr. 60by MarywWheel@ǁJ88helpouild bridgacroscIlegystems.inx2011%8 paϘϘϘϘϘσtGC. wwwwuPpAsHntinue8`ingener5triiisPi(btoP!lyicipants:& forsruAcker2Akhilmі$Bur Drewhys, O!FisؘKahИ/.'$John L0beixJ@Rnfeld8lxCs luzAhnarak (Israel)edroruzillalón (SpainLech G(icki (PodDirimm (yFPkacobuccCanada), YLászóly(HungH)???>Q8W'SefpariЖvis PJPatrav3ribu1soousЃ讀arenUnivery-s8H:a(l shipbordXؙ"isnvitFexch@Y"maps Ape(wise,vwatchaef`to detab@r(aϏ9g8R` div0"ir="ltr"ut0="55"邰TextSecG8S">OOTH JxthesnikChaXCo-Eor,__/>//) />1w8Uxs'#2'8V">1ArthLi ɨ@ClyanWW/>SeniXhhFellowߋ݅92W'W"3SPh.D.(RdidateGB<4R߁witle="foo95i ǃǁ6ǃ?xmlon="1.enco="UTF-8"?8ht8Xnhttp://www.w3.org/1999/x! Unknown Constitutingheamily WW/(n5span4Q6'IQ7">Discussion LeadersUnknownWhats =? (177G2IG/G"JGGCKGG"LA__Z//߂ׂMKeg؎CommierPublicalth| necticutI08Q8zNliiI y (Europe~HumxRights,YSAHh9??:O8RatzenböckSeyd*AustPDŽDŽDŽ Fif7 10P/"QCR">Crent-ChildWWosS/"TCU//"V)Unmyed Biologl88rGD0Michael.9Gerald.| 19891wwwr1pAhPOOM9 ?012J2OJ2/bre8"id="5N3D3"> Non-Biologi Parents vv.mith (Supremeourtfhenitedtates, 2017) I-13///*7(formЅjagect (B (4ǂǂǂ8AABB (~Appealsorσ`rio05ςςς9ȁllamiliesrequal66re53DA/3DBDC"DReproductive Technyyndnflictsverurrogacyw_pES.H.1Austria (Euro nHumxRights, Grhamber, 1???DFYrtavMurilloCostacInter-Amerx߄ooh y2b7ggbGa.BMinis!SociDevelopm8nstitutionSouth AfaC8HsNasepo_SpeJRapeurR89IJohnsoCal@hφ4Пni 1993DJ.RUtaU.S.Ċ`t qr20ooojKhIne.J9I0VNewerseyllxvis21?τ?:L8DougxJaime, T8u8hoodwNMennesFceFifSe `!4Z2__ZOradisoamiItalyDŽDŽDŽ2h3dderDPI| adult rehips (thr`harpnon-iussuchs c(lnMregڤ@partn)+B-child׃. Arol2lawfyife hbeheenby@t@(peopxbmingund siut(ed,opularobiliza` im genP*sexuty,ithatxnpho=hmʉ3DS">=wxTOne9teQartros`Ximsame-@ l,pix0lIorhQvp0 acrosYeorld舁cRrequirϗ.יp makfirstcي~t tw`iethurOel 1bXfit1989,nHk!A*RCya ok’"x1,zNerls 74exdGC.idebiIWip9inued—inѐ7PView-ك駙e f xm'xarriage.any opponentsfame-sexarriageointoradition,ncludingutot limitedAreligiousractices,justifyheetero@ualature .nd}offerunonica thatinksprodundarhood1K,ome assert(sesarohannelocrexvePostableamily angem(hechildaneaisbiriolog@lor AfaY. AfonsiderIdebatesborecognadult shipw(urn2@ׁҊc- ׁbX9ƒȀb*or,s` diY!1couples.׃ourȁ legisxsalo@frono` inlW8newechnA m broughtlicbetweГڄℹe. RVwpen diה Ԕe"alsllowwseePbmxne pSmJhicht`pse,lle8s al q`asYhY݄RЏai8 a iJAJ.DŽ,velopy9oiŖdlevanc¥7oAa ru weo.h2%wern21"sl_toc_id_2E1">*Non-Rps BAsThLQӋͅ߃W34okȅ߅4E5="_Ref486289247"meN6Hoo!h_affairsE7">H.Ƙiggj`Ǎ6E8">Ctitu CIQShhhrpQ //(9(CT 60/04 (2005)/h4w3EAW310OB [ChiefuLanga,eputyÀMosk쀴s Mokgoro,gcob@Skweyiy8VXWhuizeXYacoob!ycurqjudg!Sachs.]솧3EC"> 1@indmselvstgPat(cJo8r w regularntxdec"setpatogeq. APr9acknowledgbpheirXndouȵ(a 8adtsihad⮐tubcognb P#@~˹mbXi ighspbilӷltl(Ї9to it.ikenyhrs@ts|wanDɧed. @wonempedHnЍPYGo68oEDhwn. . !OOE3tPexclusIsSommlawfihib(أcas “an8hi(iPaW0itsts,!@ s.”F4.ɝpre-democcra-sexKsnonnHy yYPotecÕarɏirđ summ˚Hq0TriP#SinimЀoQH1994,wABiȅRhas dra)xql؝Ze 9(1),Ãn 869EG"> reads:re70EHEysqP8{h:Q 2bHfitw7pIwof J"> law.”

Section 9(3)fheonstitu. . .reads:0EM“Tstateayotnfairlyiscrimindir`ornu agaixnyonen8rorerounds,cludingace,ender,ex, pregnancy, ritaluethnicsociorigin,olouual en,g8abilitrelonscxIbef, culturlangu臐dirthyC (DŽO5.ԋmatter fiusccor9@raisesqueon:o factHatrovisyisde扐applicant`allose likP,oryachr,߆߆xPampt73EQ"> toww74wERdenSofwwwpTeqPUt ?V?wqF0'0x175F2x3ہ4'?׃g5gbywwwp6Gi:mcaupi8z9}?ift, wP ropriremedythCthould?7R(iQww8q9.outhfraȞ fami؟؆!hare evolv pid(ethevelop@so Ј rhartiaronQlega eptabl)e:[is]imperveZeneed80knowled@loȌtoi cixbroaf Hs psec(gayȅsbianHqwhoxamhenlha(ȄicXr D popsa@wsuch =xssedesffinvidf!ownBzwede肸homqm[Our] Cn IXrad8lupia@baqon intolhexcluY{movntwar ے[ eh!y`pxll @8mAgvw76wF9e,wrean fulnotough'"A 60-HvBdiffȀqis horHǙwcusroup memb(hipsuppdiologʘOKYskin c8p)beenDЅadva0`3. 'B3.ɮru`ge`sˈrudnmm`,x ighzrivyPttwhan o`whi񌺂tak0o1togero rتo.ezrds ‘I’r[ens(D菰aaitBၿpublic,aw-grȆj-regdin  C 7.hild8orn䓠CAu@b({usb.ˆjh!elȳdu0(ej (ـv cihrك)ˁ'#~aPً" )aR_e75FD_77FE">ρρF(71kօɸ-xqp@romBb0fi nd ibi@؜ X lЩq񥰻tXțpven8 lt郺aew(rv耨reH juxeva!liyZr8warshfbliquetatementyheaw@atame-sex couplesreutsiders,ndKireedorffirmation! proteczoflintieelRsumaneingssomehow sYn0heteroual. .

74lavery (ted72FI@ȁxJaooohKcuLxMaalfntry,HlonismtwiceQg,ahibierracarriagЁevenerot(le dominYmillen.llebasppHntlyelf-evnt bihgiPso"facts;=onsanigmimp™H;xs0wotodagardHwitht`disdain, ӁXhirvaryegreX,hHmby. Si@arl@2P3Rodiconal majoritaniewnomxgtscr`orympP . OHNH81}Acre3nstituCwhichnableG@FtoirpuhcmЦbea8opi 駡uqtl(resp lY9flowrom,utonotro)ecH%% T79FOX, ounfaigȔ("eun*`tino􌊕 repudiK^Xtil*adygoerv lxAz0ghiffnte0%__PX92IB@QCouЈacknowledgZortaproplay2lifCqui@aHusu8octri`aurPpreg. wouloЃploOs`! gu!y&xrƋQ9.rsXwЉcw2t`ZKArecogxPtsϡȳN onlyThre XYmȏrtic016Q1948 UnisDKHum`R+(UDHR)C/80FR/s:1FS“16(1)͹wHjfuh*9ldP uity!u,v∱9Xou fa0Theଘ*eq,duxg3 sol ”/T100BHɉqHptan(sum qaSȁȥay`ucture yaU14Pclu9lU1(ZMASmeacenj, s73FVaccdN3G0toww74wG1alǁǁǁ27Tρ3_throug475G.6g`unjufijviolf@i@ā _xsoomsubjPed,nstlȽdiemb75G7societ]8[JSach)9E~judg suspentwelМHtXgIegisp9"nanewo=ʄO’Reg8wPp)elharx~s ix"naw,o thatame-sexouplesAldarrymmediately.]


LFnd́GeguYng͊@iageǹmerica"&/h4p߀63GD"> Becauseuchfheawmfromirts逡 SpanishPortuguese,ero0rrv`cxntasome egard񒾒I dsticsupranal K.<ǐS3GEdfootnoteanc?href="kindle:pos:fid:0018:offH0003H>1@ixexwGFp4GG">*(Pleno SCJN,esP.XVII/q:amo`tperspslismo)o (Ago*)). ?ofQi`on i`h(rulchriz)u" cgorysXdeploydisct!i,Yclude[b]yirtИ<__X,l xerYqpevebem8t)y@qji)i(?<(JudgU-2146 L hRicitpnheonstitutionsfrazil, Mexico,ndolombia.heianrovidesnder Article 226hat “tfamily,hichs耨oa:society, shallnjoypecial9tecZfromstate.”4A؆;_[s,MwomQrequ8befohlaw}organizIdevelopment%2χeiarly ֊GEnuujU Sr uarantePgro܆ga

ToxparighoarryIs-sexouplcnal rts߂q3e-qrpretedXingpacho qiagф9irtivebeermissh illustr0ve,a rqnAtriJ.n a,rpam,aAKhis8T0. . brdscdom`tgardswheʌ`w(ll(HxqsulYmPaw (U(mPifrtZ(. (oԨPu,.D.I.77Ąpri.xXWnCalsoul􆨼$AWisolPYTc0daawith pci؉Q-mecausj]ȃێeva8x@xꅟ'(J T-57r2009 wwwrOpG oxigh A 2017dvisopinbyQɃr-AmePCofumxR2 (IACtHR)lsoXdsxxcqu@CrifyobligaregardQlPlgof '#.ԂrulTӎariokel formfivilusqu(xbothifferkifyunabl0oooh tly, leaXt`psqgsomQ(t0x. (AOOC-24/pRޓ)RepuHcю (Nov. 24,*)).hiZ’s decisisJbinRт,r he vX@,uchBol(C,cuador,uhH؇Peru, 2zmadinclu"A Z1Abod`furisprudencis u؆xer untryBcnP7 PiSuPJuXyxaHPhas ex IVQnovernmHpȉz hcaseϣϣϣRɛ*XRf18,tlɢ/Ns cur؜"bexlj Panama߇ǭQnncillbu_ @.owe ,ЋȌNot薸ρsad8iH讉ych 1 ul臀gr@n鈠bBs@!membeXȖ `ϋ(Aawsullengixa Jڃςɍ{̂ɉTetnGenђЮonZh//gbNKKѰrryh3d@1GS"> 9PMSSдBreճsʈG/h43H0U.S.8`addfamily. None蘨IloZU RaundntPDu8rocClaYIn LovViria (1967)elC :a-miscegenio8 IpuallhjCguarerq lP lmwoad@earliChwq GGG2">Xez9Sp%48)Pdtruckwk bآaeȱړ?xgrhd:, wheٍAso9dnon-domeق}gaiace driiB`G?Lj83Wa1990Sirxӻetwy-c`ury,sou[kryh؊"xir-xi.@ЅKu9irxclusBΕbo0߂C`sser im+ WiU.S.`rugglXoge,pnalso ioissue@oenOGG Betwe03H5,͉eightovru Pnǃ^w@onal.ɃB4,Zian ginh)NcaSuCŽC,skȠr9po2(defiqoitg rJsp`h of RY3Fr8osehJpX8bz |iTgc,ire SYSXMNnm gnParliYt plCR-cPǕǗ 6Back!&gtch8engDnHP(DOMA) 1996awhibi UGromhcogniz _[puraw.dWindsѪb}spouhad }$K7Neworkތ>aXweaieafXat#|H ʧ3 ryл̂Œegu(т-#, moPnsrb`fȉournQqTuk’sath, nt8lnʇIedaxx7">US.Z(3), JuXAn nyenyrove-p0xmajoyVZ downėpquX(tecZgr0i̘ivdofllA灖ooklain @n iOay#rK7778">> _itrYaa@involg/) Cxniaʻx dpnot0a1me(u QلЎcedua֟kxndy` arguBrtNJNJ9Aߋ߁GAߋ,wawsui'e s({Ry;~100pfxQ aH4 14 SixCircXAppealspheljxOhio,͸Piga0TeC8ty.ʟ ̀gaw0y772,xl9( unGkexcerptlowcludifZxyH l^yPss.h4}w`h23HB">Oƪ)Hod'tniSF">135.ÚX25845)G8$_3HHO/85/HI">JusticeennedyjoiHyustices Ginsburg,reyer,otomayoXandagan]eliverthepinionfy Court.

TXConXtutpromisesiberty tollithintseach؁atncludcaXspecific righ2Xowers,Xawfullm,opfP expres eirdenpy.ԅpe`sea seekQ@d ꅅmarryingomeDam(exhav iagdeem0termscondʀxsr betwee8oppositڏ,. . ! wOwJLw/w+M">FUrDuerohslauFthm t,xӈph“depryy, ,rYit⁙aw.”Msu_4_3HP"WW'HQ a sdfootnote1"ref="kXle:`:fid:0019:offH0003H"?te2@"耷ixexwHR4HS">*up@a oo3HTS[T]biextѫSpchoYn` Pividup2utonomimy=i &ł:b`efse,_UYy0iplA0bescuem1xp*sHpntXapply eq forp)-couV/6/I0">AHrreվ’sleva!qr918P&inherYcept理is abihnecrQU@why GGGI1is2I2">Lo`i3I3">[gggg43I5">v. ViriaG3I6">(1967)]7"> invddterrac)bwlǕ8 Excludqsame-sexpuplthurflica crpremise\y.ׁpou፷, bhtyk8doffH,}5suqigmaknowcnomehowHsser___[IXThatsosaygf fulorPp whoocanQhave.nሥdesire,iȋto %shacbeaQrequisi8 ad anytH____YJXFourfin`thpCɛ@XasN d akl(菆Paeystoncial pAlex8deocquevillz`njPlhroughUPh2lmoshwourgo:Ljre70IKcertainnXou0؟orlZtisXuchxspec Americat[W]hh!nts urmoilpub袈fo,葐indsiim;Peace .3 [H]hfterward1 [2]himoaffairs WWLAiIM9npeva8€fhy8XKDy 2ԧYtoma8Wasnx ! lgovernm[,[ٚ iZ.heai (tinYe:axz;0 ncopy ;uQ`A(uccuslaw de;ospja;Pdec(on`ao!; adop9 ;wÍ&Hsurvivor0bi d hZif`;fe cs+;`mpaign tb;k( pens*> ealinp ;2uXdsupport+v;*.֭/aunx1ȊlaPnt yɀys)fexȂX}o0ibuyfa;@ara` +.bylac۟intux  fegcs'ןןNcԃ0-sexcsarRBib2X(ndс(ivedPoo,at .guByot9awAq Rimp(h3securCmaxPdifHpPepTqnotwayo-ext,e @Xsaؗrup(@meanjyof؇(IicularsClauXa9to cap0ى[ao@0reh (,ع؅q!sP8w)$r0ȍ ////)O(InowHerqpllengyuXxeq8mxfppk(led-y abri ؑIH.ȑenced Y%unr:GEH`n)fdso` b8exerѦ=.Źlgaف@loudisap٤!irlshipnA؆ׄ쐿|1rnumßyYjnIXbian!rves PPacub8hAEbPg+, likDuehib unjhinfrHement ofheundamentalightoarry. . !

Theynamicfuronstitutional systemshatndividualseedotwaitegislativecefore erting.Ԅ(Non’surtsrepen injurhshoXmeth@v catheirwnirect, perstakeXrbascharter.n'linvoxak (zprotywhxhor8med,vif broaderubldisagreendOefus h. c''20'ITiK63IU/+V">ChiefuceobXؒ:@m S aTPjoin,IsWN3J0xAltgDoygus杸extx)&Τؐʘ镊mpe,requiguan "sYٗϯϯ˜)ludp iat@nidefiniȆudzrdecijbiІimeihasjiȬ(culr!ouPumhHo aardbe lrSal.nrC?en0yneXeхapeo@ՋYf09exd!͏U)QXrƆ{ɋ81Today,owCq0raor aЋprp c`@ogP7͉letFIgrudnHceleb. B baoPnʆlaw` ae0QmajPtyJap)jep8heєI.upp؂1w2)d:iabPcessua fow c@zP—jdemocc iopviewat ؽ(.awyyclHb# vHpt٘ݡp0q Xfromcʍaudp,raHsoci\mmodiffiQ8 apR //+2([]nrsH?с@ˉwnAno~8cnc3bramre9ulp on3`mi*abond4S3IAbxwفptu b`fQЂ:rXPduh/,wi nؘWWW3J5PIs(rij?QasoHqlythqAК *laimfundntaighll.f “[t]YZi0ʐtwoawohQseekyautonomh9fo chs,”Py,஑yسH eho,nxercisingheirutonomy,eekoake profoundhoicrry? . .

[Thejority’s]iscussions,uiteranklPdifficultfollow. )centralointmsbaphere “synergytween” quProtect ClauseHDuecess݇{.bs fromX@porofopinx,owever,bny`resemblYour usAmework@recid e*-cases.tibook doctrinmodernupremeÃhtreatmlaixhassed means-endsXthodoloinhichudges askerria€gopnڅuis suAilylatals遊pursu. 7YeÓai(videvenhlentenhexpn p"באsuppliepndepAweightits posi,Aoqtttemp:justiftsratousio#canhagstnneQarisolvcoituхquex. Inyt,rriageawxs bdot4770,@czt uis"e-sex isЀihuplsbalStps@ legpmstxs@serjd шQ '''3J9 Ifouኀamom1Amer@nPw00x񕐍0whhavي&-8yll celebda*.Àachi aHsired Yokqrtunaewɋcommito aart_vabilaIbenefX.ut4oCXhad9withAJa SaaȦ EThomjed; fodemocccba?9 n蘸view, ЋXda`ҋsyveqeduper-pr''7'3JC">ɊQ><׈ҊV üa8es,ert rؽ0ZCfX) itl nTk軫wouldl i arЋ@recogH{AЕh# ''9s}WR 0izl1lyrIpҹcreductla@ina@pjЃbthou9bX atmosp:rahild](8JD* * *ggbE`Onxne 5, 2018"ainva.S.㊠z8aҌnian :Belgiumc`ŒEurop Unirulwordspo9urUѹage-neurm0rᠨs( (C-673/16).PheHq:Wg0gJF`/85/JG[T]bligMem ɚd`a/betwisuQ clud3aӂҀccajat bSolh#!grӋdiрธȂКaird-ntry`, mRih pstw*ÐdbG Su@n'requ2 \ڨϧǍn xbِqOs!xwws wwwtӆ_wr enappMHexerc heynjoy`.Yh4=w23JHH/h4GG22"8sigil_toc_id_3JIpcalibre1"d="what_is_marriage"္5N3JJ">Ws̀? Sherif Girgis,obert.eorge,ndy@T.nderson (2011)1 <\3JQ"> ?onsiwoompetingiews:

ǂǂJR8jugalւ: theniofnaoawho makeperent exclusivemitmtoachrtype tnaturally (in(ly)ulfilledyearQ9rc childpge.Ԃspousese(cummate)new!ir #(acts—9 titutbehaviopaof0erocessrehduct,usY2Pms/ve1t.valuabl`ntself,u`ri8aA:/.FhtriPydinKstrurxludnormmonogamyelitylink( wxareσalsoelps plawhyƇimportajgooЃs0houl1cogniz`gul񊈝G3JT"AU//V//N3K0">RevisGGGCpeop(wh tsxxQopi)exes)!r!tily lovcf ҁsh2urden8nd bpfAdomehcpfe.ɞ☰0iaohmenhȟk!evhPuiXmacxnP fgree4???:8ca nt8ЕXXi̓hi њcreneed\n@heooȌ. . O'1 odmi@tcȥIquon2">эmoXobusP$equQHd(onlawsiPRbann!racf!Ixca,Arguyn`bast2re diff <1fpф)xs neovȂa fundhlighWQ3F4">>3K5F6ǐ73K7Bha ogyails:xiscegeYwqbox(jPooo;"8,(likxace, mXev#P`.y8k@>_husAcr oinVi’xȥQ0enuinetWP8Aleg8systeɂguishPf+)n89K9"H|0ix o,W,(llexcludدx9ӄlSo0()poli0smo1X؈Ptupci[s], havRd r ςact(??OA">اɔwh8t Lbedcir0plȏ׏׃׃Bњ8sulpxdecidѿT ,Љpya謘 r؅ figuXkdesiisuchOBqatu\uncxg;+ nomec͆ * 0绹igmzPg`iк; zJE1l pr҅ѣw.׶pω製exlyheрtherayround:iguringuthatarriagesould tellpheequalityPiresenerallyreatpolyamo8s relonshipsustxeoonogHones—t1is,!ms. . . .

[L]egeconju'soci2reinforch dea Jqunfusband wif"(8aulel)most approppteXvironmentor*beacfhildren臿DIfame‐sex part werehcognizexOhowever,ILbbolishfromraw:oivilnstituyyongerH4no2:nebothm8faY;oQaybdiff(giftoz 8erse;BboyHpgirlsCe)oHnefiȇ {3sЃל!sFMׅki`hapycompreh(ivss rulfill;cIZGn>. On!h8cacc0cifu,ichkesߔ.ecauquemeets suatrucay,Pregu@or eood%`ptᙱKspecifiPlyigiarguyAJʍthoPwhan`Hud`h(؀Iy (u٥occu@factors)ѫ胐Pabgard牨,meϕh3Md1GKH"> h365"p="sl_toc_id_3KIXa22\Qnon-italKJ">Nț҉psAexpl raja ٲ` bebrwqo i 0con(swiУS!J, rfyBev)law.׌0 basP8maindi8nguqbetw(, ona)ߎ߇YIZe# ㇃de(cs?Ƈexam0,䱀titur0iPozer_X 0pro1?Ywo PH 01xeRduirdulivnd poolfinancsuppo`yV? WQSuCouof Connacu 2008ul c8lwHa Ǩk𣩓alȈ@@d Ȋ2015urP eumxR (ECtHR)udgٱ2߃he :Iy wexcerpnŃ97 XldAHet1ߪhad"urxe.{h4]w(23KP"4GG22"8il_toc_id_10KQapT1kehganKR">K.mmiss`Puce0hSupremeourt ofHnnecticut289. 135 (2008)Nh4> [Jusealmereliveredhepinionfzz,nhichʁs NorcotKatz,ndarpconcur] . . * * *ggre63gLA`In Judgemo. 138 (2010),CHxurt Italy helatquvispsian Republictecthsame-sexuplesgaiAcriminon.(>O
oi oj (FhӚ)ς5ʃQ8POQ'"R">8766/11 5)geTZ7LS,1tAXa Chambxcomof:äiviilä,WLT">Pid,uido Raimi,ediku,nasotsoria,hulahHFsehabć, Yonkorozev___3LU">aesCqFçoiEs-PoWWWV"> RQtrarр M010(nuly 2008[Mr.nricoϝsaA.]9o0h0mmsteao9,r1heir B0CÏltatusfxeaiTrC(uyssuKHevزCageannsir% whrejed.]'''' 1!2 twopplicsheng *쁚yrgued0lawexit8hgtwepersQsex;;eHҽEu8oЅ woulnct@alԈ268Opl ]91Article 2uonEd qRepub recogn00gua@tex9inviolcCt[ЁاpiduP)hsocipgroups0Q0ty؍p`1 wel胳dXpH@nomicsdty agaiȇ enorogBߌߌ38.asA?;Pp 3Ōregard:rincipp` c lC~creatɀ@ discriminZ,ia homxunQY!ivax83. Ea[&]nixfu- sFa0aЀ`thPAryParXm(arye͆xupbyrlaw,s evidencedyheifferentpproachesxistingnurope. . !

42.tanomexcawhnotrov`ornylternativenion toarriage,iprrhomosexualouple ones. T mhathueanfecognit////)5)4.ever؄0s,Xhzablishreger“civil js”etween₸psaof [h]ow,such]8rely symbolvalum7/7*7055. T]oat8wy-four)ntXut=s n CoEC0cif]mbStalreadynacted llonImit‰)x`eirHship sXasՋ9)鍪Iartn3M865.n 26une 2015,ىAcas f oo79">OXgefellv.odg . ,Supre0rU (melda\ ]maxerc[und(nxightqy)a, anaeȝXfulasis{9refu9Q< 6njdҤ8kxigr@d itscharr'狷狱A10H]8hxan dPer9`Ievolu) whihaakplac@resul"3mYfavbtypintώ]kicularCȒb elfbchPogӈioduce ٜ;symcgg{. '''$B"7.ԍ_nzx@’s familyifHHi`)crucipq9Jw-beindd)Ҙظ r!yabsZhF2jshouldptast,accɓ! cyalemnuridlgon,auc@m8cap*oYm ca膀ύ3MC23TGonʛs]servpoB turePttissu3וf homo geataI#aX1g@iMhoi2rtimmodPpf0 frworky]*onpxp?vaaہ“鄠ژpownPmmty, ǃP(nyae matpaȽy1 yӗmȆ ؖ i eAarrequiHieAaR:Un⎒Dtanew ̎DvǖǖǖǖD6krRsub؊KzSbeen eng@*d@lop˩ߩ؟ʸiy1986y 6BdebHae+bilf `(8otw04)myfevpI5cЂQ>jmp*%P҂Y0discord3reȢ|I,#o񁐇GBG1 165.ԉCourtɀ haslreadyeldatp-sexouplereust xcapabȀXdifferohofnteringPtot, committ8relationships,n̎yja1evlyimilar situoregardsirefll recogni2prcz؁ip\GGGCMA72. [T]cur!va(ჟsotnly lac`nt,asoriilo!videʘqcore Yˉ+[WO,ut alsufficiH!—0depeP00cohabitZs welljud(al (Xsometimdministrve)ttxxf+ntry;bd⑐ystemYm p@e  N 3 exHflicetweeKso8lity 3ppP8wh Lmosta lF oЋ@Italy eawaichm`ȍAsXriyG???3MO:4?I]bsenceImage,like P`aicu`؈`@obtahopt OIa!2civiln:gppnersihPwoubrop teazۤ2`ЍS|sȍ![guaremƠyۆޞ@ighOO Ooipwith8nXssary hce.ư8,򰫰1 pinsicalup(H^N’ spYXĊchowevnowp exvرdu韟ggg3MPb6giGonm9zPexiЊghlavie1op҇)zsmmtpAleѽyvHqp“^銈 qheh deepfelissu []tegorniɋ̠1YiP$frworkׯ(empi93rad(cepfaȨretGGG@QB7FWhP8c†subj mrЇsТlinkle2pxapHrgaP؊PjNу1uHmomembSe3@Ucherٍߒsuxe (opr$s9X9aromc. ċfierrsK di(sȟOOOIRJ8O]fU hsstsoJm8towardȗ'j`atinud8lopapidEue*rXx@Plob,CυRbulAmbAusȊ`iainA[avh9h`go( RljalƮowᤨttasohimpo S9W]No9usu"beplacp­nݡɀ Pis0u(seemik0w II Ȉby:clud1geh pop8ypꁰauth٫ T84repetKhorbtake accoညuntfonstitutionalxurtronouncementsrheecomdais reinlngoistencyithʃ'onver significa8periodqtime,otiallynderminesY respbilitijudiciaryndnppHaseeftcerne9dividualsa(ꂹleg1rtainthichaoeakenЀpacct.

185. . . .I]{abpceava(uniXst bgutorwardy"ItanNj9n,gstalaH ppl2s’oou[shdfiabЂ6 lighZd@c(alusy3matЄlremed unheeded,1fa†߆ތXve ypp@irrgAp@fAoulfil poivbx{ ensur@oablP spHframeworki(`Ntecy { s-sexϒϒϒV6.Ԇwitoday`ould+cunwilzto chana8uctQv`"waMisah*eff9vewwwrN0r7p9*rQbeaio鞓Ar`h8 [ǃǃǃ190.lsrplʑydurdiscri܅sulRoh8]c9hem̏8Iyz!`oǝ(ples onpuәؑȌgzinoragr favmaj/to讨c 22BѠdi@graavoldftaiأ (a eleHEptsqiage)ʛipsXachʙsq.nequ7x 12*öcki Seydl Europ8ؑIHumR (FifS9on)'' /I8sσσ3ND">No. 28475/12 (2017)F 7NEx3lang="en-GBNF">P@nt, NO,dréoki,onkorozev,āXņšits, Gabripucsko-dlmayәtiünoJOOO3NK">ies7L1Milaškog߁߁Mggg3NN">Deputy RegixarO">4looP5. Dhaveee2tabHrehippyears.σσσQ6ȃS[y]odged anpplicationonternXaegised partnershipnd theҁЁct.

7. . . .T]Mayorfinzismisspiroh asJWOexclusively8serv(f(same-sex couples;. ߅߅߅S9Tntsubsequ(hlodgXcomplasitho( AdminrveourtnbpnstituYal,rguingat marriage2noitablep"9pmstR!tpially diffntromWR.ɐ"viewOinany`ysore(h“ligh”QnV)Aui//B becausearexr ]ϏϏϏT12pU*ivide,amirlZsea Qcon(cwhicwohddualsoppositelawfuehЌ@Ȟ\ltogeقssolu mony,abe8raichild(HoeaerwwsUq3Dook2010]ttroducpororo܎amHmec@ gpɆqgXlegXeh___YVYq ed,Artic 14Q@vakeQjunc8,Pcinr %هY@iacir )?k, al0EO031ȴhr IPce Itreatm xp8aogousxevs, hucrirede02s zdoԉaЄgrXs1`.n ^3w;,ьarZɍicu@ uhiHr8ܮوwsoȊّly.owever,Q'llmbaoq7. FirsXڰ9hٶHblidyH-#onfiڡe htxcap[f$ם僱8me(ӥndX^is8oryf1nbj0Qea0jcb;brwЂ+pu9رhimPcPK79roiitytwe(s eoy8soughZ0lized塧1ď|eЋsX ~QunepC_߄߄2ٸYSo8’sޖO@supsgI,Jodgb< <,horBlackso IߎlԆxa*ǖhχȳ!thuduɜndpoin ت gdXaAevoliȄAno d2ens0‡nciHfu`1mbSP ?ǑǑ340ȭtroф_QrRkvaHϑomxcludsubItii:fXOSRP AcfherbalasԅQm:߄G-heirhichɚe(epPrОor+2010[T]7{V`e a1nPnwϒϒ="5N3O4"> 41. Thepplicants,sifferent-sexouple,av`ccesso marriage.hisatisfies—contrary8me?eseforehe enactm@fegistdartnershipctirrincipaleed `egxrecognitioneynotrguaaspecific*. . . .

44beingo,Court0nsidatʊ, lohichinstituyus openQexcludromyKrp, a(in*levlyimilarr@mab8sPXx whuncurьislnoighoy andʅgg𔙅0lnp@means proviR'$!*i҇has rcbevio[Artic14akXjuncwith -8Conv)6[JudMitsډdiyj Iempizzbecaus[/rou*caon؈gnd0scr(vabilithowՁHyI!8ad8d xӁio.ʇalso`vok$law MembxStat,%ninet`lEuŕes r)imdg`Wp rschemee‡О's.]7O7JoiDissqOpinԊssotso Grozev''߃"9''OA">אunRfollowRmajHzأs"̍vie89purposH ߍ Njك0AnxalogouxɃanyc1trea'hese two2psq``d.1sequly,QЄ3ysw`r@ia`!w, nwheIobjevنсsoy* respoGov*@qpxsufXirtrong lc#suppooR fin⁘aPBOC [0’s]ӉfЍl߁!_ soci8t0butabse٢QTc9byjureAyhoʂ/ly Xp5fHo.|8u0$:y uori<3ex8 iHspsq?=A,` harocognis“ pri@Y9pQ prHB*aYяxgehə:2 pr@cof؃еX” 3ODOE">0usHhel4 OLfromrؿ@@tiٌju i>atW i GXߔ[T] []plpcIwϛ.ftX0ch)!,Qook`o RHpc.ىϞpagr9kڄpRradڶX2r ap72shou~llow ase. yalnʯdowoatesperpetua 1t؅'oneJ#xwuq-law5XiisksЯQnރroJXhundreHyear'f h ma8todahin(tHu葪(9sliseotypesbouthe “different”aturefeterosexualnd homrelationship.

TXPC҄p Historily,arriagebiologonnecrovided*two priyvenuesoZcogni.ntil ieth cHurĄflow fromin`nyegsyms. ornawordinarilyawo{s: cherusb`.Ƀjurisdi+,@n?who g(rthKˌum@cuhdisp@ibilityorz, buwasee ilmlackly enceableightsi0e0mo:faQp9IStartingI1960courhb@Jrepuxa(discXXy treatmnon-pi.”urnished basisicz87souts.odaؓ`p-[hmes, same--ple-heaفuy1through@@roduhm8/GGEmore comm9AsMps`sXnȌse Xang`,AHstruggl qweɗ*0gn PtradZhkersuע׎ǡ And,8Xfy/lawscsAon(ncepi p(bskad:bˊ’2) )funŋ@. ___ZJXIfʎ!genetic7dotxclusXdefinen+poPaP multidi0 laimthoohf Ș ؟ؙ<Ё22\1unTOM">U–FsMarckx.elgium (ECtHRq9)GGGP">Levy1LouanaCU.SupqÈi88Puve.񯸇Xnon-Pii݊5ad lnceabL{x1ldelationship. Theepudiatf “illegitimacy”asaraledy al recognhunmarri0fa(rs.ourtseldatovernmentould not,Xnsistwithtitual0quires,pfuseoPze aansۄecaiIhH#Qchild’s mo.etque(biologsificanc mained, exemplKaulingnUXStates{kproteca flow onlHoτCshograsphe opportux@formelb Sxir+.dLehr v.obe(U.S.upI 1983),lonJ insuf i; g0,? ha:engage1soact.

Ôcircumsts ׌havpinterАC-,ubsؙjasxaddsflicHbetweenl andci.h`釰ais13aȁ)(ofHrusb do6tggighho,hood?ԋy Xj`ɝzexcerpbeNh4Uw02W3OS">M..ǁ.oiܦ3 388kooo3P2">491բ110 (9)Fr 7P3lj_bis}c4aa> [JuxSa,o1ChiefʁRehnh4Pt pDsϱ`ConnorRKenPy8hGheven2 currYjudgeliȯpiǹy] . . gog5`[In76]arolehn*҃ЅxpqcHxaƞchil0mhw.Ɇsumm08,5involvSdulouffa nebor,͛Sem,!0XedI, VoriaQornayh1 l1s%hrtihalwayeou worЁHhdauerxoaryowr, ina iXbeR+  6/8_3P7">)}blHs msex98.07%robability ݌فsΐJanuarh2vvpipSt.oma`[T threeȊtogePQ mo]Wgd҂x8Cnlaw,ketu8it f,xkHnroAdu9.>seekode8effxdi nefitevidlyoobtafromPaОHbABpif'@ sucsfuBbe_^,uld follow—moimportaI,ҁb0s0 `x(co“race[s]e Cݦ!respecRearɘ-pcludhe c;servjn s dirρacities鋩s regarՉt,duealPld;ʄN@xelldutٖ)eזjadd obligjsteamoinds,ifZlesgYcpz8hip.”_9W/W+A">U!endxtّsubzduroi ,useia relationshipithictoria,rotectionferald’sndaroley maritalnYinsufficienttateterestoupport mina%thatel.hrgumQis,Acourse, predicdnesserzbMichaela(nstituallyliby/inЄo. .

readsۆCtprior caseaw],blingasゐaby biologlarhoodluꂎhparal Wip—D">fas exisPwell.einkcdXe ralesos.iewIm,1y hnotpsuch isoHЄbucp؇WWWWPE">indeed, sanwould botro0aЂF">tradiaccord8pɌip[evelotarymily. +D /G(7GPG//o+H"> Thu`leg8issu!:ǎ uceoheibetweeners@ !shŤ-btJ K€(d6pr(i(oty0ru anybasXp֍ViXǗg impossib`fhCk.n,ui̦ry, .svaU(,lhndchiacknowledg9heirs)ga0xIlaim VjГ???gI8[TtHnR+څ, ēProH8!_Љz1 bAs.]ၪn@rX(cocide RS+,ymmetBچؓ+,mt 9zilϹnHdo Xecauvsu豜right)e:mufai@dhhenif1g, weak*<.șc(Cn eraHZromփ<, shҁh0ԥK.ҀBȑ)7s [Pgg+)dD. TXDmestt0cuon,, ijcofguardi'93PK">h(em belieXrrax0n1gsychologbenefa :at8Srecognizyltip hooj nupp ,󬈨x2hcouywwLqJxP蓩AncuUjudg8`ve unlikeRmaj!H.@ptȿ]' ᑒQ`؂viewH8sch8 suffih$:.ʇBn1utho@x whesars2Blmunoined cH(z۬fo15)unribiowo w!ߋ٠@orm“403”HdDFtehdIe@rgu P[w]ϗ[yHr⨹ay- ipׅxk,yaKA}a!on!o،HЇQw1 2g!PhearJQZ. ȟȓGEG΂d~a0n?: н PYmPw`p ba8ᚑi irthWrejuaxfamilyqj;denys.]re88PM"> * * *

In 2012,heederalonstitutionzurtfermany (1vR 1493:96) heldatnnmarriediologiarouPnoHssea imo parent`recogninaseseiswas “oddith welfHq‘socimily.’”ohituch>w b1ints"pHervingiexiP`hes betweechiandtsegxssh ۋ\ [h]aztwoDstsameime,a@whoygeI o beacOH(ocat} p8ibilityor,o艉corSPodeaςWQunjBasicaw.x0quwpPHEurope^HuRights,seudgms excerpbelow.h4wPern23PO">A. 5 77s (FifSec!)I8σσ3PU">No. 45071/09JggV`9DžDžDž,itpa Chamb2mp(d:ĂqSpiel@n, P8nt,lisapura, BoštjM.učič,arkilliger,ǃ`audkivska,ngelika Nuß(2Andréo0ki3Q1">esˤClaudiaזdiek, ///2">egrar . . ǂ3Q3`[lang="en-GBQ4">6. [In]03applhalaaship#Ms.n`bruary4starAaXϩ+MrSe`B׉jmovo8joH householdOctoNh_imx Htact'ZDecinXmwqq sɵ gnX5Q6">7On 28une5=z8cknowleȲ9Ё sutu.n 10ugust 3gaveirYdauAR.?+7FoilorYche0 MˊPubmmIory derb"eҀ!sexuH 0O!! mo1u1perioycx„<0plyہliу20xocial-familH1 ufullphib,venfɘ noQrHologlaB>zWs9wQA">19Y[unmarri0 imorejebeca]ccoo Q`!l!h0hoeguePder Ctiase-law`xdurbasXbvoҎ/bKH`$ alreadyXᐲy.ԣdЂ5vailvqeqH(prot2 v=N,isHys#a bmean(gel(ooooQBh26C">8Unxۍiv0code]. , zKquexxn'hgenetich3outcom@Rse ceesoلϧsinvol0. Howȅnochsr!`rB}pgg_3QD37EA?? w k2e0Qaamilyieadeenstablished,hetate toctnanneralculeneisbeeveloped. Inapplicant’siew[legispurdisrespec tenetnyerincipofhoportionalityyllowingjmo0r choos0nXᅈ childXalaoHnhhe y(ctuhre؃shipith@.χbasof zawit҇hdomicourts3prxllyoossibibecom芉,:zl@! siIhich2one-sidedXcreLprevailvQWTinteaiologᅬ.

38. T!ffH exacerbgHagbo*urXb`sociTfami0exis:etw Aс8cluromeng p rnBuJnfG ̈́OHshou(He8__ \lm}L. !L WWW:HP??I">44.QeǓnmepCma8 `m ib,oucpersaKas ufficiIgag㐐taAc8.Ɉ3s case,.civ geњYA_h1 bruQJQK">55[Witnesses] nqMs.zІʊqdu0g gnancy. NePhey x\aTtiwh˙υXce9.fP!ieparRyonhH oc8Hx1.׃Afirleaab2y ~LJ)inviqv!"D7773QL77QM">606Εs “”`lso xv(life.ԆCsouHon nu8ou@(XceedX@Pish⪠orgPan  pVضyHPp@empxJsp28 ntNQO">712[T]es a݈(g]truth @fname0+ beRT,avitcogniswQPQQHConB #p9sembxSt s o(gگxn`(db+sعxllow2%uW,r*p0byrightsccor!lwmu(yal`excluifrom lȂrh evQreaXsoψίdoo.oweadonec`arX0aPtyyGGoWer0tu𫯫GGDRGGQS">82It rbos#g誙no[gcOneIsIexTQUx3xo˅[Ger ]discri(him1rapaca7l 4r1moaH///.V//R0(9筗observ0@iup` B(rniH(diffnt8hehild withegardohehallengingfaternityas aimrotect8 ildnderocialamilyromxIdisturbances. 1 [T]8Courtonsideratdecision9giveex`IK relat(shipetweellrentsHecedexverrOHw)biologicҁ8r8lls,nsofar statussyced,biSe’sarx apqi.

900Te8accord،b1no Article 14junpz8YqConvxDžh3div1R3"> NBP(vv.m U.Sume Ct %ArkansAsuef t t⇰@蟛gbދon mBsObergefell decis (OJ)xonAeJogZvicez_ndouregu9ng ׺ccgly[canvi_牠8rifmean1BllǁCClaimigiH(e3Qiopp8ى lsoroduc@debvLimpacb__D_]IlnSa0wA0l“pucmmod:ss”hquibusinesorg0zlop| discrimnumPgrou0cluachn,ex, ؔв@i9Zw stecb<ivɝ8 dX(rang솂pavex poliHoinview.σi8d0xcئ rdX_bPefаJu2018,PowIain E">MastPiecpakeshopC0radoivilҷCp! (8 @olvingakerhoefusednXligiousroundsoelledding cakeame-sexouples.heourteldhat(e⁘r’s constitutionalreexerciseightsHreiolatbecaA ColoradoivilҁCommiss,nnfongst0antidiscrimina aw,ail@iderʈOobjec witheutralitynd@spornutXsteadxhibiX hotowar၃.‡4ituy(thisas(ific basis,Cdidoesolv2roa1queHof0er `eovernment8nlpp1ljw busineswner8ppo??>marriage.

P.mI`spс'!7'RJ">Suprem hUnӕs%5/K">137.t. 2075 (2017) /@/h4pwr6w3RL"> PPCum 3RM7/85/RN">A0explad in ei'K3RO'G"P">ObergefiρρρQ"> v.___vR_'"S">Hodg?Th5)EXX_ “* herms@diyx`wP” In dPloArkans玙 y0effЗPhol eۭѨHrůuance bircert).ק)asxwomgivH{P5, 2eXrequiziAamoYmalp@eear child: —regȋfis8glRshipق~.ccorBŊڋwe8,neexteZlarpu ׏c:jfB2rdyЇA Ginclu{8feoo҃dirA8treatinfr(es6U'W"VWWρρS0"> com`provߜݜHCHPXfit ȈsaPlinkAo,eȇRjudg. . !7φ1Ju`oh2">Gorsuchd dPџ!pin9@whichM sAli0joa:׃׃׃3i3S4/+5">{[N] WWS6W'"7WWWρρ8pke (letlonxl0ly)quepwhe 0.VCode,rsFupUiPm go.:uЎ8ablishЅ0desigH ensur,waza;Xt ww4fo߆ڵ argi3ZzasyexyasӮgim킚noayhfx///F9/'g"A///ρρByli(*ѻkڅHicps@fyucealpPndz heldiudetermQirlAeitiz, susceptibiya s .ɿ(ht(anybseek debuҵ8neng(wwwCw'"DwwwρρE">,O'agr.iseryrR@ 9s wro(wihHP ,ustshetateourtecognized, nothingn <9'"85'SG">Obergefell/iρρρH"> indicps thatirthgistrationjmeasednology,`eooubtith manynauescrospntrdroughout8oraffendb Constitu. . ! * * * ww!3wSJpWhappenoomen8ame-sexplwhtarry?illnon-ۊl-parente7dሸegш` adopthild?n 2017,Uniformawommiss, orgaȁ|tSqɇ promulgmodeltsory (islaturpaarietyhreas,ssu Pagect,pAneopd)#qlaws 8lightKnjv.odges.ԃH/cludHviɇ„ȎWRside alsoutIi.t8,asQt cXjfirst @€ʄτ)releva8`siscu.h4Ewestern2@9sigil_toc_id_19SLap1upa"p\M/aρρ̐ __SN">''t (Y)/h4FO' P93SQǁ' 7'SRrp3S?߂SPrefaoteT[UPA](k0fivjchaneprevious]PA. F1,aeekz(equt`tʌ bor@o'$[)I]writt geryermhiHOXesum5cذȄx !aaFexamx,ۀsec]"d “[a)nspР9Rtohd rexdu)a#DZin2zher ףsul".”ϑOOLUHOG8O3SVhWW T0WWS5)6uCour el\qng twetw(eo51 xnYtitualZ[I]nup a4mayy, ψljψ1ωω3T2ll>, denyÉPxbi’irth certif Rgrz=diffpntgh ?7?03???3T4">PaSm؇_>,.f0wowi5www3T6p_>73T8lύx[6lyAn ?s@OMϥȩ Septem ArizhזׄҲusapply ‘itpBRЅhwould @lфDuocesEBt3laڝ CXC禗9pdecadthHppntiȋ/) infirHxdqroughous9y =ًHseinclude broa@Jyocknowledg,eneticH@ngZ Hkm X-neutr9 780cedmo(commw& non-5`ablishi:.S.]WWWRAPS0nݹ"u~bae f`aleg&a͇q2zPexPXea)o$ligh[whoaveeds parentsohildrenuthorenconnected!thoseWthrough eitheriologyrarriage. . !

Third,PA (2017)ncludes provisioatreestablishmfnt-zelatship byeerpetratsexualssaultres`ie cepY9 U @luH~aȇ:e|;us 1禰ely vulnerPhH nPn σN3U2"> connection.”*Pup> <6G3U6"> In Brooke.B..lizabeth.C.C. (N.Y.ourtfppeals 2016),heighest%NeworkcknowledgedXisity: “Undercurrentegalrw,hichmphasizesiology,ts imsible—withoutarriagerdopfxboHmpartners a-sex1pleoavetandingas8؅x],snly on(aneilyxlatoChild.y0ntraster nXheterou ,??sillrpr0s8f ǚԅَus`ay(pre-hceztЁ decidePoxdrecogniڀun:ed non-g토er:ahow؊leand vinc)ev(at:ihagreiؠ"raisɍ܁Xgb˅,˂P# ȋseekisitaЗstodyˈHte law]WRexplain†su@approa`8ensures eqG;ro)s<20U8ȫԈ opportu뀠ir[&Ylo񊰦twmmitBʈSspruЇco-Na΃"’Afusbhowhem do vnstituɁguaraesP߭9FMhʆHXorari0pi P sÂ"aeneticIפI8 wQaonoHmay'r«if /*̧҃struggh!.erhap(AsǓelw`r耀Canadian0makad0ؑeissuh4 wern23UAx/h4GG29sigil_toc_id_ρBp1aa_v_bbwUC">AABBC*of AppeAOrio 7773UHH 52007NCA 2 (i)>ڟ7UJ[JhipRnberg8lrudgm0,oMcMy J@eabrq:]KX-y8-oD.D.sиX:蟰at(B.B. C.C.,hspvely)ƪZ4 ell.A.*vbeРhaqb@on se 1990xnI9y@cXؑamssiqzfwo0u pri y c g,BbevHitb H "remȀvol2ׁife. wborp1.ȸef8`(. !ϑϑϑLȂbseekeprasRؒS 0dadopZbecause,qido, lrus0reasfd[!CIFServscwhich]xoe`“alures ,,datkingqKbɈ(Xpwh؎ TPappljudacceptthatrrel ship nd *exnotbiologR(gene,QftZful ciփilegisv8chemnifru inpret*,p[aw]temp@9nly(e͆P(.ȉied principaljus ws “ifer”ڀ 뀩" ,hiX؈󓈈ڀgreXanalysHtsxutes. ВQ_O_HR">[1990tPsue]āSOGO3UTOwؑ!ndohmodisabilsufferC borutarri[itgoaUooo3UV"> oi8ossfњitaroductitXimhI򘚇}l;pfic0m}dlacy—pP,fa(:Zcap0dosoPpigma|hbeeas@oPnr@ї)sabeHp)Zy棐it.!X po8܂Xsocijrecognizsame-sex@ advanchreTytechnyon"radx.do01>,xآ yAoOKtw0, iۆ0ҋj@gҦTmight 3N3V0">1court’ؔ烗2773V3">spt(en>jurisdi`[ommPpo8Aʋap Ip)Āxk]y%scu8dangYrriBp9se ab oe ''4'''3V5% $n>author9œxercisouha1 bawv6\??7<]J:ЇҨy힣purQО`shequ3.!,ۦ=meȦN yO7my8xPp9d0titudchd'(r icval0hypx7i@1 scie#Ǭy4redEgoe9o3VAp rƐBecau.HJSؚywom(1imu)ª*}adoptr̂ xB">[ \,pver,HmڃSith(!>ޏ_X AdȊp+?f͚K vGGgGaC@ItѼraryaD.D.2bes轘XȄ؁xwr ėgЄ؀8i w:defiyceproug~]D3VEX[*0@CiAppealsȆredul ;h4mwestern23"id="5N3VF"> OllƁrequalct (2016)Enhednto Forceanuary 1, 7 . 8 (1) Ifheirthhntfhild conceivpthroughssipdeproductionadspousettime` ar’sゑp,2is,ndhecognizJ lawo0? . . ! R/eԁ.2Clic verӞ;cy"ц__RXWdevelop٩qGq(ART),urlegislatuPb lPddsy #mohfamiinvolvѶl)fp}ZR. biL辵[quesËwe9\orApregnanc[:؏traꐊgeneticsꂐyay ergeVti>܊MܗۉXDžу gapsst򰿛k񒉛 400">Fun xfact)surtrea Kl)tGopDws1In ={'gKs`qed agreЍu(bu`@fI graAHwmeea㢐xpecP1.n orcHev񟵇hbؑ],ohraise tituqzXȉ!!ti "lso iwb1excerp(b rhow𣿆htSautonomyrsدa{’s interestne`ringregulatqcertain reproductiveraHces.

S.H..Europe8Court ofumxRights (Grandhamber)5I8{σσ408">No. 57813/00 (2011)F2p 6709"2lang="en-GB0A">Theņ,itas _Xomposed:ʂ -PaulHsta, ]Bi'#HC">PidentD">, Nicoratz`FçoiseulkenJpasadevall,lisabeth Steinerur@Danutėčienė8án ŠikuDragoljub Popović,netaiemele,äiviirvelä,irjanaazarova TrajkovskLediianku,o8Tsotso`şılarakaş,uido Raimondi,inc.eaHnoߊ??judgesǂGMichael’BoyH40I">Deputyegiharׂ߂߁JH. . .E c|w40K0L">49. applicanhl0that(e xhibitionunda 1992!w]hologouxrtificialcre@techniquesggbMo40N">vitroOfiwhȴk ege icauhas ᑰsperm,romonors]adHti3Acle 8qConvxx/P0Q">82cconrsfa couptoAceqhildmakm@lysedQ*purs0by,! oicexpsprivfamilife0R0S4ρGGBT"> 3U">[S]I []ystituaseci[P8phold@"0nART,]ny8opmsY$ schat(nla3au 0hc*Stps 8p0Ȃؗlјx SXn 0reXۂcursI#5`P9f8s.owиit not͖ↈ@ljf0uk8issueoup؀KIbeȟodaykŸ.Ԁ3desOzwX_!tim(hey5iיߙߙߙߖ Vߗ10">97S!f߁1߃412 ߂3">ߒ1Bgri`8Hصqg1܀setmorHJHgstbackgrofast-movћc ts6cra0hhcaAo9(ByeXlearmP a`gmeb,gmargpHo af`rhaoneT415">100_WUrb =no0cceptabtyV seriam൨PaaߡP}ЍmselvsufيQA颹om0bx9 cAZechniAp

р 103. Theourtonsidershat(eieldf artificialrocreationseveloping1cularlyastothrom scien2ointiewndnermsɂmaegal frameworkortsedipplH.tсthHpshit WPdifulostablishsoubaslhessP necqty ropriatenislve8asures, QequenQwhichighecomearnafe lengimerepenitySt(ind itDaryactiauk. !A15Havrrdabo(A[܉ cludes neh؇pehibiҀovumonÓe purpo"nI r<BCi#21D">in vitro[Judgeeaeourrx,jbut wroteeХxAxh@erv0obPȆABhum!if@“lory techni”lsoempizemporce5valu hdign,2hild.ʉ)sETulke Hirä,azarovarajkovskaTsotsop,ಠntȵ e gr shounotX[ evAEueѳnsu@A岐AnVF,arewed:8s:؆Ӑaqcircum.ԿQrrguby 2011,//wPꉻ󇸟"cire ducologiهawop(B;quire.]h4w241K(/h4GG2X9sigil_toc_id_241Lap1зa_murillo1M">(̀.Қ8I-AЧ1 SHRights55|H{41Q.息s-ES1R">Ct. H.R. (ser@)o. 257 (h2)2?<7w1S8[T]7172 . . o fowes:iegorcía-SayáPt;eonPo. Fro,c;͝aretpMay caulaRpyshulondet, AlboérezEEduVi(rQ D:ab`SadrarSe8tary;m`a SRo(́HDepuDdelthis b. : ??Tk63.PHdprocedبIXp XdiffCu2oelpHHtiinixls 9c`(hiQgn臠PyYipt bo ovocytsmzoids, embryoef!`ish.p:420F1󎗎Y0q[A purs]~;0X!iiXmin{.class="рcalibre63"id="5N422"> 71. . ![Underostaicanaw],8up>anyitizenayilenctionfnconstituty agaiorm “when,wingoheatureqmatter,ais noirectndividualXjuryHrtelatesdefens diffuXineststhothaՁcommunswhole.” In] 1995,ermNavarr0elald!ExecveecregudVF ina,s)醰n(rgumHsioSrighoife.425F6"> .Tputorward4/?clud afoll:Tgenerz@prceے] `humY; egrom{o0tiJ;e,ncep ,ylimir drur,!oluntaryarineglip doctPaccu techniqueed—wouldsul! cleaȐӐQ`tUn COnosbesHf ߒ8727">int g[is]P,tdoHoe aaY+aseas8and[emeryreatBto sa(a"ѫ1. 3,z ԉhredudom ohc0meIechnologye Q rciȊA RI*worЉqǂGenerA`mb83 UN坐itsnӃ,scrnB,ssr Xpn("Is8Aopu㞗IFJ۞6sciificgHyXdPutonom,jssifou=gɑ/be(health carerv@sђique,sently,rphdispx)uYtPt87"id="5N42K">de [j]ure or 272.ԃMhabiologihildrensingssisted WechniquesormsartfsphePtrightH personintegrityprivatezfamilyife.nddi,i wayhichis_`arHedtqutonom identa,bote`=imen a aupl0 ___ZNZ3lang="en-GB2O">. 3[T]“absolu`R=embryo”Iground `trihtsxvolȈ(sotupporyJAmean Convon;usjnecessaroaktailyXٖY8require8txioXdisps@gardqlarauuncu؎ Hs8Hash pumv^ncillservxDiegoouQ rtpxȒcbxs uacrific (c8sx؃mixYbenefirefepzwi<ОHe 疏42P82Qpsych֠LJ?harayAhim p{oPbicce{axle ׬isdfreedomR4S>[D]ifyc`alsa[]re쏬s0va, gen;inau,pxic rs alPIiNjHerXJsmx!1stanX@ooooQTi98ooUoo>[An`t n]lainI[t;>modesolydldcult(;woPaȁ ;izbH؎j(r8٪cittЌPtimQworl prsc:,حPwadaysodiˣiIÃM valuYI{chooC:gybirth@ aA9an’H[Xluae Hs@X0uradm!nooubt*inxۃuslyexYbecau hsᘘg"ȐsYlB|ir%Prans!2irtiny+bur/self-blamQcٗxonpwhhIVF@o~”K$sdfootn؁G30<8u)WW1R9WW2WWP]lthoughc8 8򔹘܈QI9sתechnZkea[@'y. E{0hsHaddQ9t͡thuppeareult2aHpoXoePnn g3302Cou0empsˠreotypar coth rhuPighlaw `ssP0el3DHid近҄onjcognemdyop@o@ȍы?;[x] Cce C0u$Chamberjudg0t8734. 51߂߂436">314ƬeXs8r tinvolv묰sr®ImHebryllowؓ iڔ*s)gqsg, XXxprivateife,ntimacy,eproductiveutonomy, accesso healthervi,nd)fouHaamilys severentailsviolationfheseightsecausrapce, y:nulledHropersonsronpossiblereatm infertilitVF.nddia,Qer@enc8ah diftiatimpPswingiritusab,ende0eotypend,somń financial. . !

[JudgeduardoioriissgrYhat “human l”*AAmericanonv!nȁyҎincludes embryowhichustHotec.逸nsignif1t Xrisk9dhqɎz.k/guedpsuX)f?9hnologi8couldot ct t߈n.] h4wen2438">A.B..iniSo D8lopa8sHPCourfuAf55/8H0aOyDxCT 155/15 (2016)6ښ'$73E#xkp,Plxr j\rt,oinby Mogoeng,HPekXBosiPaftahllPZondo.wWwRFPTmajor*ca’sawYhibhnghiH(r陁rroggreeQslyleaonQɪ0daIe0n[hiHwasOڮermP.ԛ"qhe:Yrequir [@link]Ķ zpurecaxtwee#Kڏ:monQm[ {˂Xob𴓀H -to-bornhankiits {(s)./empreg g{ortX5self-id )Pp OJ_7g43Gт]oyanycXbodiȋ)gaȇx"elsș@y.ɅwЁ 0bege qu,ownS[ٛP]yai;_Z\eo1unaؑ<0@te?nyiew, )don#0ciI8exer؝ Їcauthmy,(ǀailH g~LJkusI#hoso(r_߭HehampepH~ʬ}C@rF0emaPMad ga dPIdeopXexcerp0low.]?I8="en-GB3J">. 3dAB admirs@t scircums@.¥2001 1,u(rw18 8vitro fertilis(IVF)ycachC(sucPsfulYЊ g@r pn .77|L09.Actor]ɳډlook9mean) ha)roughkgraXȭQ touyaaP,apfP A(wo81yow vab0way2AB@Qcxub蠤Жsrmps P 65. 3[T]heessons ofurastaveaughtshatreedomeansorhjuphysl erty.ection 12(2)ۂthCPtitu]prot`s “ ritoodilyndsycholog!ntegri0”heXis ose connbetweenچedyx P'$71enjoi8opve`turway frXindiffnceBmoowardsesp@,mpathScohss . lsvidesgroundiZsxdeals. WharpretingZ!sdž,tref@ incumbentnenfs hoekYron?910173Q@itR73.ۉorbi xs 9aurrogatgm unqgameleonemi1pajus cepbchild. hmpl0j8a АxYboטregnyГ8tile, Ɂdonola9shiptnerable7102?3SdonWYirwrarr/aHm, cluچsŕaЂ`or9 OOOO43T86WWUWW>[I] 0unenviѥharmfuldi .ɑR beca؛veop‡HJp/([ulPsXoPsociexhZPgma.ן pox0,bstshouldoobeCme8 eTbneЗ)obliYon voiXlac"dӆhurd؛ab0 per@’ttPmМ3pequqʁ1 IouchAa>a +0decԟdtak mo-ǃ.x re duwhowmon߁ٳhnes.ߚߚߙV7.”ex0id丬t8woe*䕋y1rodrmiR_Yhasmhb1phepe(9farݖStripp ipar-rea1:!醛ramifD@rthaQOremovTael;H=moHunrsBed10'4408orG''1!92>[M]a "wЍIdoi؈ivE@(alifhuma͌icularly signʇэ@ruedissecap؍rdhe9imak38vexte@̌lƌ׌׌׋3108sCtitu!ur118 aootHinoПccBHmemb0 Yelead“104'44">uret8Ѻgea.”HucknowledgrبBoq()9oughtapX1(quip lis,؈mmЖu؀2?'?5910[qlaw]sÁٷ˨±܆!who ⌸;pӇegnqĊ owAoo@yW^availabwwogyy6z general.RlӁape(onazdexExploitCQ, ro,Cornographd϶Abuse M rUȟ(NC (Janu115, 2018)*up[bK;sstu`expn@wh rangemseYꕘ`dinBhum`rights1 sfdYaO*0olTonvY Rct[ۄ.PީB=Í cah pra`ipqIgu[!wtexts1r!to stglegitimviabilityEf蒐nt mohibhCc`vidhays )r)d)impljH>чptȆ؆ E72oonLh9f\{IpplicapQ qn_rad$g<ǩ:rltruicy9cr2ԉ?2:[ `pot@ardtissuraribYtem@Y,Fh wo’s-beyo copZW,cepsXgGEG ,ertaclearuvioillu Uory enc*|3echo%os Хσexh@whoavQڄZdiscrij agst1rough2ru3izirHdipcultural,(XpnomɅ#pureinclud r(patrchخervsman `cAed77771M4cs-bhy2לϲhe drs`C8onlȁnrpIfromvelxux,pAuXa,âd@F`ce,ermany,sрrael,taly,orway, Spain,henitedingdomfreatrit(ndXrnrel tatesAmerica,avengag8comcial int`ationalurrogacyrrangementsithteo sP developuntries,XchsambodiIn:9Laoeople’s DemocrcepubliceppThai1.owhr,liforniaڄjurisdicIъareㆀr`77775,!GeorguRussian Fede1o+Ukre,aifferXetcross-bor ihips.ddi,xte0pfrChinaXequly wSouth-EastbW S.ll setsophumanigh8conc.

Nlawson'var҉spectrum prohibitoermive.Pisi3occu \ b0d(sometimp!.Oʅis regu(primxlyyo) (i.AustrMexico 7s)I0+ FcerGxanba 8mZiclui /alXH ra ges.ͅ 2ώσǃˆ_, ec8NeweaQ,+fߨ, “O,” -fith3pensq whilxpiHimv2t28?70. On`mminoXf7l b_eign_]:reby choosјbeQlwy.߬ݑthe ʓ؇Tabascoexa۵-ϒ"Qصserv7 but{r@)akentepsDali˂/genlPXp`eabu0acE GGƱGGmȈҶ 瀨L98(٣п0odh8oHm Oz. . OAmidixtrsptudd`ifafhar@`xe:bligbto JguardXn(isa軹pd.ן‹AЌt$nonotvswpoyebtow cop"bapacxPrfocuZw鰐_[ÈkHat&T'!u0youlttemp legzxȀqOhu ights vioh*ߥ*&ePz7 ֥flueaaxthnd gind1Cpa71dop!wiunpXXaiTƂ#Hic agr8`2ogn0xlob *pri9htӈ ,s@HoxcsaXrea @ޛpד_ Rftec[vul `t agXaoi`,ѕv/zse QShch!of@PvolvC8FFurmorHfdi0Phemωsh*aXxP QKWpurpor; ǓRheP@n腿.͈ i,anargu1dsupzofy0Ɇ挗?#Hcce,؇ SHldsuchsdoညption,hatre consideredllicit.hus,f0isypefoverningegalegime becomesccepted,hethersntaorelaw, throughpcognirinciple1touldn0minestablishhuman rightsormHndt0ards. .

Johnsv.ÁSupremeourt ȅifoaρ5ʂ83777451">5.4th 84 (1993)F*p 6452"> [Justiceaneeliudgmentـziwhom sucaPMosk,ax,2Chiefʃegg.b nہ;bwtaken in7so0 iB9d󢠂inquishll:٣y@fav0/,Jr r0payr $10,000ezi(P1p aspxxeks af*b. . !LmhhhL rasoxhfijw0gn|oooj7JulP2petdeHe ba਄rupelHrefu(p .ԀXfollow :oXpopYHa Psuish٭qr}ey@34 unD''''8 ,9@rseРhiJmnitf2 g5B蚟,QshipWi@hRtЮ[. 9Becawo!exaHqccep逩o`ty, web8eسcacxxi8irY2tЈhȈ)s;F.B G@kafiveXڄQA{* tookepxec𮙅XeȏPvitroliz.†ed-Kexis мro*ˤB7 . NoppHsPÁb2ang:aфڇideHma)߂0ur0ooojAh[A]l)gH[iniaՐHoPge]`recognizes b\hsui9Òea [ip,H陹# coinQ8hehonрtendedorocreatehehild—thats,he whonbringboutbirthfЁto raiseserwn0isnaturaloprraliforniaaw. . !

Gestationsurrogacyiffersrucirespectsromdopnd ssoXubj(ᅁ6!utes.Ԁpartiesoluntarily agreDcipQvitroelizrl(dedi eduPeWdconceived;ጋtimehennna e0rp tract,qrRzvulnerabl`o finanrinducemІi莤xq`offspA yя\ wanzcompens PZservic8g[Afetus:gol`r,ay nPgivup “`al”igh3V.Ѕ duurIpregQyaf’Q.ג accordly,puaz us caPvioAs [_*publico0y] .3C)soP(atohave9xrU Ŋ(Qloitrehumanizn,)ly loHPomxbPه:oo psychologrmxsayultËYCor inquishoihhpSialso cauȩiqenco(gecietyview˔ٌQodi9`d*irQP willDTarranglike` aЇ⨠owarsciف`deir invdZylthough۬pugisa액rs"\ )on deaPĐbe0nB?> poanY񘱱ane0sixin gel]mᬸLhccept-p蛸 w)siemhҤD8ɑi?8)sattituBҩ?s;evidȞsuppoiرlimpdata avaiseHlab@lpo\Pu s`l8CthAyLIocie@htraHjwhhpu񳑿0Arouple @ƒtheygoteromhichheabyevelopsndonteXto raiseRchildsiirwn;u8arrangementrefoec originlaimzprotectionradii.oextXat aearingZesacase,elitpports yiouplezexercD؅pho!creai)derform(familyt,lbethroughoedical yedup. . !

[Justiceennardised%gndahhouhave beenm @1trialYrdeterminHntags;a “best0t^”t,aȉxhaؒt8 =puldyJmajxty.]h4wern245K">J.R..ՀU.S.isct C╠򀽍ц'wre5"9845Q">261.ӛ. 2d 1286 (Dc 2002)ƍ75RdJenkins:oSUnabɜason o8$%! QMH,jdow@gre<845T"sdfootnancG5U@bO45V
with.K.J.ebruary 1999S d @serjgxaI`isurrog460F1462Xʅbnceivxvitro 莿!҇ؤimplaembryIr dvery,z’sss bircefкsx*‘volur Xa@odys,fOIimHXup?ldɀ774hNotZarA ̀ZSxe OfeiVitRecHics8scldnfs requ)ϋsy0uli Js ׅtw`.n`aPexDj ohmonoXff∲h5Codn§ 76–7 204 ()!ds: .2(2) AtiG,out)siࡲੰin omzjuIg舃ipemin0Z procedursubs!nt၉e艨J1L borт@ultsenpceV}h@ tGz(legpurpose(aihusb`s Xm߂6P@+uinfr`XfXҏ1ti`ۋJA)0bynym>maknƓ obtxj airpy!be(jjis incapJ0wn[Tlaw]ffect leJmkleseoaRaaltogeFu erӋL[r]emov[es]sibilixaologc`b ml:x pdu0tcyaus@t lusKpٶI\77hCp2alsoiquroto,šҰhJad8ppraceB genep/ n 7alꇌayY 纚S׎ϊs!notoook7ohch eۂ]߅Bat ‘‘рtheurrogate morstofrchildorllegalurposes,nder husb`,f󁰂Xmarriefal .’’ . . [Txpresumption]nfringesn.K.Js fundament@righto`k!ocreativeecishsy ‘‘`c[] ,ar0hood9againstbwillD;pp'#3'69 [Utah]Perta@tituI quex9raisedp pl0tiffsenotven↻dbecauseʋltou ?—furecogniaJ.R80MJZ sguardiairissuance PmHirthificHYmayQa(rՉdo" a0sX0utunnafoulEHvTcy staPek.ATo2ext[K c~x G]臒؇poimitrclud+{ӌ,5nte8hnetic/biolog l>rlhn llProtect`Thabeurdh㋔ Absampell$u8fyъc,ainהlawsnas applPomstrictunavoidable̫(9GGFO̙𛔍/҅bIaZmarXov ddww E]hcourtqArsa˔HJEwhoa@@gtoB[boro邘TexerIY, 'F">viz., قu$wn abeduc(G">e.gwhe2Xtinu`egny),ыr!hpn?i rel*shipJ=cc5m"in fac ҍ񪯒??46H8Reso5"esoЅh s,'ffпQhmJbe,`iloЖh0r-_YlyXiɈUbetwMtwp>yce ithu+~al ی777746IٞWqCod _W.K.J0 7/I purpose1canIfu1pg0s{t kl:evic7JPʫϫϫυՎ / 0Jany2000h4wern246J/h4GG29sigil_toc_id_296Kp in_re_tjs6L">InԆ0S.SuperiC1 Newers(Appeleiv)?5:46P">419Ώ*. 46 (2011)usu07'6QdfooteWhref="kle:P:fid:001H:offH3J>10H.RIO846S">0upۀTBǢ46T[Judgeбllo@lrٙopin,oinbyʁsٟ:tiSkman:]σσUAxssh`ɄA(+Lzan inferXeif(9b@b z,or@`rr,ft,oautoQmpvxsqu!щtgo differently рthanimilarly-situatednfertileen,hosernitys presumXwhenheirives0irthuringarriage. . ![W]e holdatParent cto`not`tenduch circumstancebsdoptionnd,ademinUp>of!hilHlegislaoffconstalcipl .

herh sever`meansyXito冘blis }l reshipnder`: (1)eneticQtribR, (2тˍimacy, i.e.8/i>鎢;r (3)F.ɋ`ddia@X*{hbfromties’1wrooo471oi>MAitsquival A`a㏙ iorP/courHAwithP300ays Å:.XʂInfa0r+wife,xyo(husb@ 0ҁ}e iЄR`nsp_vis|aiced physicia@2x[T]lalanguĔԈovidQarof onlybiologily—ڇPfem r1[non-os]////)3(I( (Qutoryy-ba if0ݪaoI9Ztiffs imam٤WTotec𪱖 ormerounybtXteuSs eВ(vex` shstow`atwwwwq4isc؎q[a] V,olaw,p ڶ8 d,acfi›or P]nachoBϟbecauR Ks ck2empo, QeP{intA#a2creڣhar8Aast 4surrogCԑ^righdeemft@waAwrSQA$hood5̿TurrecognizٺElinkas accep+ή1+noier eov􊫏ף. eb hJd􎱡tТ`y4_ uxo!inWSW90,ix߉ǐ=been c09=irȘvQqSllel)rps tlIak؂VdncesIccoudefKadd>#71ushessfqom:IfYڝcs gr(dڐtaru:"`acl rodQȢgXne8[MН𜟩C;týљXomPoakssuhiore8876* * *gggb7n 2018,ewʿeyx@azitg lcyd0qdܔX1. “IT”Yt-sexisamebplmarrѲhunlф'҂cXalsoaindividɅď`iha18 . ProtiyJPut󣻰which0cludsychevalfte⌇(s)elYdep x𵐆by`ul'jᏇlݶԅgg[Ċŝ0Kfey"tg#aከ񂁌7 n!y̵Fedy . . . proofferavingivenirthohehildnlesssorn inonnectioniaestaalarriagreement.”

T8N2P6DougeJI (2017)0 onbiologi@orsniffe-sexupX8 only onwhotruggleaeveageyngegg-donor Glurrogacyfasdo well.ayaH탒ЃWWy arily(cludenpintended. ggfK`ۇpresumpppplbrethe(r-iduOH߂ws. Psforse ,)׃)y b0o(x@,`lJiatPon’s`ȃ1“Yh(2`+ Ҕ~Iccordly,c hovuR s lPgu`9biYmakes clear.ut@U_to a_^ߗ.״o ties,CfȄYmselvHRXosiA:e؊X9blish/ ado. 1Ϸ57LE]qpA@ual-oxeqit`HrtZ legisطsqtinre7N">tjasrommrWWWO">Ѓ__\P">fam8by sprs.hist8ءPԔi9O3iPxwardنWadap Foim؀HwoIA, n#xexry惰leg0;;Yt ȔayueƜzaȆ߆߆߆7U߆ߊ܍lackaOOHexcludцYindividuIVF+hpHHy,8mxclearjhifward wihoccloonbexis: `CccaptuA,` .cllapsjdd l Ysvdi :bx",$=Oviewǝ/nsablePђPfamily. Irast0e@aSHwho hahno̧ h4wern2480">M Europe8 HuRigh(Fhӌk)5I8σσ486">No. 65192/11 (2014)F?<7878Ņх),ita Chamb0pos of:arkilliger,__?88">Presid0Angelika Nuß*BoštjM.u čič,ǝaudkivska,xA.e Gaetanodréokilešejchal'''489">judges a Claudia Wdiek///48A">,egis:ǂǂ B7lang="en-GB8C">. firstBsx8appln[` Ns]husby!wif8ynѢ1:IP Pirwca[infertileHxD8 EAfnuRunsuccfulttempto ceH&usQ__\FXG">inyooobHȁ???:I48J">vitroǂK">3isaA (IVF)_gtes,bOMdecd u goVFTggg fromdona2im`embryo u@ur an.cconglyCforniwerojdpaȊ2`surrogacy agreextGG?GLyM">pfihthat, a" ׂws“\te"”Xemunerdut mlyxpensesad ] b(Parౠ؃ea uchighрerncomehan(e applicantsndttadeenctfolidarityn`part.

9. On 1arch 20001urrogateoras fouoHarryingwinZ,Xudgmen14uly,[C@forniaourt]ohifirstseco8e ɀAhusbbheruleD7oulـ“genetica” legal\anyhiȆomrave birthithollogPur`nths.Ԁ؊specificularsKwerJphdscef0` stP/76shrrdae . . ! PQ">11. [yQ䇸] . wAiFrenXs0pLosngeles 8haosYes regisȁɁs,Piagde(^+’s namנisxssporYreturoance"mnjnjnjNj8Rnjǁ8S83 ]ubx proHutostituyceedPgaч[MennesspQ T">ri[xx] annul}Hebserv]agreewebywoman `ookceibea0 relinquishYȡ"voirac2-pcyipl huod`civiluТXinenable:yluق,jïwuTЂ!trary$RpiQnatio,+9=Htno`xsdAv8dBf -䞟drawnpџasZ@ שgnisce 90ooo491">OמO2O߁93">26OHOppebeheZCyCP dvoG@ral]~Prdd bee@y [RbeX]roughty|qȞ*sz4495">dacto68familynXwhiX[y 蠠affec3c, edu8emPllfnirvelopI”"Xe+4pGfywHreyЀ]X yH orig[h]alegaً@00ne,( ظ_nGs _JH-pshipar:8͆h.!???7?9887?9]n 6l 2011??\g髆dismiss|[7ooOy]<׆׆ׅ960A THGov[expl ed]rea0ہxrefusȅ`qrÍulUS !D=m8uqu9AgrossX`poxoхsepsY%sationf thehirdndourthpplicants:ithout recognitionfegalarent-childela shipʂeirstwo ,yidotaveƂPchality, a passport,xsideermit (evenf,sinors, coubeeied)@(mightX impossibl@obtainE_ythusineligvotqfor uncondHlexremhah;[alsoprم fromhherPngnderNjs’state. Fore,ق9G&sa(sGexp #rivedny)specvRoir wn@trim. . $

72. ςρ-F">T Govern1tsthah iЀproscribѓ{ihumbodycoPX Hmerciin@u,ue1퓀R(ncipɄa#ason:civil atwPena(r tibxTis ure—y ex`willueoidec ېK surrogacrgeYs.Ԃ0domicr2ulrasequٌbb(efuӜ؆h;arular Y-\docr ornI ula agreځmHabroad(myhbe(tamounacitaccep䆘^lawcirp|knowh"uȀjardi@( movisut֜GGGGG@H[]ailp f0ery[du:ae ЦQrHw_sHѲS itu each ۢ LsoXR: , h[gp5varioQiff`Yaywhi' '&blishܐ@, gЄo y((biologl(x“0ear[ed]Ply غXy”asybؗKΥB8Pblaco HnsamveB"cog i`exbetw8 mselv;L I8J 3[T]HshnsEurope;awfuln(_rDψuRxd upceM.mxve-Qveyduc!؃Chow燨̔(hfMhirty-fmembS0U:q ˌggeK">PzpF`cׁׁLn>studied. I9espІϜgenloʻclЁP,i?ertain. Howprrdzuths(naXoYFYY`QYse3possidobIۧO򈀕o ӕgthroughyJerform執49M9pThkq7hlɶtur@) g as@e0ih04mu赱afaargin Ȑ(i,\dȕa8twh0P ^modreQbuW5Pa ՐWȿ 92. 1H]avinghpribXcles whichmilysovercomeccouЋDlack1ogni* FPxlawN betweefirswopplHntn`thiPqfourth $allmYabloettle Bairtafter2bi؅[],@a pos{livJyogeQ)d"sroad8 Losfies[,] ӂÔn0iugge!8؇tisQseitbyRauresoi)irituSurGwGGGGAPA4HArdPly,lighW`sequxؘhllifBfwϓˆahOO3 h77772,ۍ!bno vioˆErJ'e]— imze8yonuاPXissuHhis HQclu׏''#Sn>PܲrGariousuА0pH9tibx# wien’Yst HЌ_r0guXy䔘scT100T(xalysH٠dimenBPѻrd4;ogzKJ I]ans(4C dee himKyOhڪAatu0ǁX ~ q㦑cerndemureof.·only w߷ڊуsnaist detail>;8tifxtЅrQs,umal nmeaȌj@lIL؈ȋ:rdop˯rougeypf@onjoycivil󬨝xwould fl'ohP"ϹCAaCicase-i*j9V1Hڙor{gp򓫚weupetOat xkxGଢ଼Gl infr@GPBCaXnelli.t8EuropHuҎAs (Grhamber)g5bNo. 25358/12 (2017)Fol7A7hgg8">Tņ :Pa _X"oof:uPLópezuerra, u7749 A0ntB">, Goaimondi,irjazarovarajkovskHAlikaußger, Vi(A.eaPno,hanajiyev,ediianku,ulia LaffX,auloС8lburAndréo@k(amxs, HeleJäderblomrzyst(Wojtyczek,aleriuriţcDmitryedov, Yoрnkorozev,íofra’Leary, <1ang="en-GB"id="5N4AC">judgesE">, andoderickiddellF4AG">Registrar>. . .

9.fterryingoavehildunsuccessfullyesorted medihreproductionechniques,hpplntsut mselvesorwarsdopti`pareX.I10.n 7ecemb2006ǃobtainHofficialuthorisa fromCampoboinorsourtQXeign  The tateaheyaiIinP)whos eligible눂onGGGCJA1.ԃIsubsentdecid4ԍ gQqrrogmoraRu(aoXendyontacaoscow-xclinicjirs xYshv 3ranspDIta` seXeminfluiduh8servewhichzh`eK/*9/AL">A?=؏undsxŒ"x@xLc8greemXithcomhyhsjurqul y in vitro feliz*, Ȁtwombryos impXφˋwomb7X[oiM3GGǐn 26ebru 011Z +in6b38duoeor6 ofZmh774Nǁ/(85/AO">16[T]rrZ@Yne1babybbұ{yϧe [ہirth8ИWUtYaccordance £vis0HagConv8a5cto1961 AbolishquirہhLeg𮛪*F\Pub DocuaOO'O PO/O+Q">2@LUpo(retusY] xutoSepe@ cri0cengHYsuspeof “mises0civius”ۅ]us@f falsd́,NJR/+S2.nIal,U]r91s Xmakϛpxla,ipej 1p$be{YYab`onyBurpИ5 laT30/)wprwaDNAs 鐘pHhownonet Pk betweem߅ׅׅUљFollowout `:sough exrom ,L`s쌀rOA m(gin(mitHdprisQ"t#Feryiny, erjclearlyccXed,uyimhsito pPfvidu0H;EB,i?e >dissBrecruit忚1ffjeime( ?oooVW/W*B0">3Bymiecey dec20>2011,W'W 2"> u/b3">)Ca@b0o/)0Tbm ݼg*oHsociservۙHc a "hB440 g="en-GBB5">. 3Qf AppeHfoT.C.b“in statefbandonment” . . .shepplicantsereotisarxs.n@oseircumnces, question)wherr"criminallyiable ρ΁XhadeennrriAePpseR fluidunknowPrigXwp,iview,elev.

44[T]HCampoboourt dismissed’qeal#grouȆqstrong suspichaBy:committoffe Ɍ) ticular,Jc!followingacts:irstg spre8aum sshgnP;ygoneoy ItPC0P0MoscowHdmHBnaturxmosubse8ntadFhildgboro ag  ' 9">carabinieri/iׁׁׁA"> on 25ay 2011secoȍbiologl, whichwprovhbyDNAswthusadPalse A'kveryaguЄdPityUgene 6dornҍzhoo twosszRussPtors,Adid corresp1) travellk+atbirtҧRgivycid.Ԝs rnP@tainЏxH| wnHnd۟W3agpaya:lmo50,000uro{B49gaˢlacРa0om!rhoutxftQmonthlocx*y_.ll tibetwq'zohibi By uni)obyewshimlC51莋be`HApril3kuardaskMin zq m,듘 be istsclithȳqA0HoRbami26an3,] is “inex)”ʮignifPɩn`rxma1pgdd8erȄnaoBo,bvacci`PdȒ飰cdA]mporg#w e\˂yKHͅ@s m edJ`simultaneousXaȁ+cces pucrvi;ZZibe,!ʩ `urHmede D/69/BE">52  .2e8o_[]s0w 2adop6wpF//+G">14ȯ鼱is988ɗee啰righfY_p@;ehQlifdoeAtafeҎ0H8;Ђupposb S,̴pea ypopti;hipdߌH/+I8U3pt tu,φ i2BJ">' K">d8oniL"> 'eYdPI D bs%biolog ti(`co8sllehd7a Hu` pons3 ''M 1Iؒzrexe0ɩXɗqupxxBroyb׿ -à-8 ɺQduq8habi@mϺA3idevelopa h`Hjassu@iasarents vis-à-vi`the child.heyadorgedlosemotionalondsithimnheirst stagesfsife,strengwhichas,oreover,(earrom reportrawnpy:teamsociPworkersHllowingquePMinoCourt.

152. . ![T](applicantsnd‰bvtogeorix monthsItaly,recedXaeriodAaboutwoP’hared etweet_WR`Russia ooojOj6.lthough,rminaq!irlshipis nohi0tlymputablXo:use(casit#n9lesspinceDegurtaint!amselvcreatph@p ti"x,agin du• 1trarPorianawco`gsett /aurir`cirapidxsitu+8ZyunspnЂ(nd oproceedXPak@availjadop161ohrsd suep“priv”xOydevelpdulaˎx$)ic*ki. Tytyplsoћivid:c Xnt.Ɋèvolas jwRJ rėRsy?8fal0sc8.>S/+T 3rlang="en-GBOBU">. 3V"> 9genuin| beinx y attempehiui_2_C0"'!1">vitroNi2">Вilis,҇yobـmp(p, pturPH&sõrrog. Aj؊5isfocas$(pX hylbrup.cc8( w 2su*ighre :p decБ/{ؤmh8roug3ro7yshЏume63'W"4">vis-à-8ρρρ5c 6/7+7x77J879">T garX(hHm:`c8 § 2Ixian authorxeBiaffirmbStX4sQpe`cocognia\C-?ip—sp{ ï篙awfu螉H(AXviewt202n-GB"id="5N4CE">. 3<1lass="calibre85CF">[I]n ItXlawescentayestablisheditherhrough@xistence ofiologi`elationship8adopف spectingi rulesetutn.heyrgu0that,makishoice, vegis(ureaeorotȃ bxteptsf*childs quirbyrticle 30ConvhaRigh7C1Xurtccep+Phibi"private basȂaontractuߊbetweendivids d qriɅvear`oroduceoreiginors oy9cswhic n…have b led,ʍ77H/- ZXgainillicits,ome˕amou8@human ffic./p> 203Rng="en?II???J">re nooubatcse9[surrogacy]&ai sens exqu!ታؓ0Yus˒PmoX St8s.–Xrem,has tak@view#Hp8uepucɐlwndKpXal`XZ4abroaoXߋۅ٣biddHYwerritory. . ! K208ǛǁLǛ>[T]MӬpp p؍.ɵdonCK emb( vs’amihw@n88퓫ȊP1oweȄ1Z@sAhHabydcx.ZژnوPQobserv!׆׹׹т+,“8cF !7ԍhAb໹maОU,”ut efinX ˄.wwwZMr9ߓٜPr̼WVse2s9uta9 ncip?X ׍ oriǓphysor morHgxdyrsXዥ gƕwtigto gɇo^rv耂shiptwes ?fah*emiculxho0owe߁وqinuirڃreplplisunlawfuitucrexrm pa8iOK2OCN">faac,1Ypo Pvidm!r(`Y8is{ adop㞋_O15_"9(P@medi )irrsibimucؓ@ifW '?Ygnia rbmZ*_Qnignoemal hardsuِ o2des.hby4filleHuc. we8eavybaPcqve l`(򡀒AttachNjŃp؈2d(lopm ''.gree` le{ tX~w,os׋"aPouRtpamou/heituationreatedyhemn‘chfmportantules Italianaw.heourtccepts atIFcs,aving assedOchildou0notufferraverrreparable(rm froms†1,truckairalanceetweenrdient intHspstake,0eemain@ithXwideargof appreciavailto s`ase.

216.ollowgrshPnoiolxArtic8i` ConvȀ. 1 Q[Judgeaimondincudjm,mpizigp fellnd(privnfamilyife.ʃaseae(o,Ќoe Albuquer ,ojtyczek,JDedov߄߄ so2becaus(licsblishje“al project”,c 8’sotHespaltenuousć3 77 ؁d>anyrm9sogacys danger؀ociety,`gardswheQ)cilits traffick0Lazarovarajkovska,ˆku,ffranLemXs, Grozev0dgndlid؜Rl,ouXic!{ hEc.]re88CR* * *gg_bS`In 2017fpZEuheЩHumxRighfIe _Z}ɕm@stRlreviewbsolu(bx`^pogni"Hdsodngag[ boPgeneship̰<(! 272!)J_hexilghN BItoleoQ4diQy@H2minPh~,ybB9'maynRقtne0GD*xJar 3GF1luX :re70CTiT] isqp system evyĐ0epz;, chsuphhfih&٥`ʋ-Ӈ(0abЧ@!X(doincid``og(lgHalsoeatuxs bhis"騀uorigh`quisi8Y exiЉ.P;?xmlers8="1.0ho="UTF-8"?8ht8Xnhttp://www.w3.org/1999/x! Unknowno-wernۂL_pb_JU2 <0ppos:fid)C:IQ3J4ׄsym3">*
*AllX bornrturzin_]ndubjhd j(sdireof,reitXnsgeˊys8.ohamakeYenforce0yw which,abridgeprivilegimmu0iqfE;8;deˊ life, erty,YHiwiutuyocesde`x Xitspars.RUnknownWhatsarriage? 34 245 (1)oooooooooooooooooooo'ooooǁǭoooρρϯoooooooooo__ׯooooooooooggoϯowot/html;harset=utf-8"ttp-equiv="Content-Type"/> *Art. 2:he recognisesnduaraxIinviolableights person,othh8idualZinsocigroupshereuman%tysxpressed.!ecthatfundpn0 dЅppoPi0,conomIsdarib!lfillhOOOOK7WWWWP83:lHczensaveqAdiqabefohlaw, withoutxncsex,ace,uagPHig, opinԊlos.ыytomo@sebstacYXornatur whichistra$freedomriP,1reby impedingLlevelop,eff8ivaripaa@workœwww`rganizcountry. . . 9דדׂWWWWPAm9:#wwramil(hs9yepfdednarri(.̀TibaЀYmoy legXcspou1limihl8owny` RujcUnknp1 Ȃggg`1g69">Article 14uConvenXvides:A">WWV2W6B">The enjoym投set)inہ0]gshalle@curedithoutiscriminanyrousuchx, race,olour,anguagrelig,olial pin sociRȁhu؁8typerXiQ.status. . *Unknown*Med wo0marriab@aveoyhfra familaccor)~lawsonexercise this3GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG'GGGGǁDzGGGρϴGGGGǂGGGGGGG_GGGGGGoooGggGGwGGGGGGGGϱϱϱϱϴGGGGϴGGGGGG"CCNAGGGw#&GGENAGGGGGPG007L3ׄԴGGGGOAG DougXeJa@, ,6 2260,097 (H7).׮׮׮׮׮׮׮׮׮׮׮׮לל׮׮׮׮׮ׂ'׮s,ose" name="author"/> 12.oPpmayeobjarbitraryrbusiiprferenceith priv8fe,zfamilychom0icorond!of unlawfulttacksputa. wwwwu8GljǂWWWWP9">3GGFipt(J#gainstuchG Unknown*ReM ŃInclu) ProsuY,ornograph0O0rAMr,./HRC/37/60 (Janui15, )____________________'____ǁDz___ρρϴ___߂_________Ǵ___sUpToDate"/> 0In re.J.S., 212΀ 334 (2012)p18?xmlion="1.encodi1UTF?8mlnA://www.w3.org/1999/x!0eXtitle>UnknownYanal 2260 7''Ǭ'6T22:05ρϭ8:15.11415027o__Wooogg7wWwwwww5A4?؝ɟpepׁ534 i1194Discus Lsold hongjuoh,usrp-ackerman> andi gueloiaresaduro< UnknownII.oHnports/5QM4(Discus̊(:Dž Haroldongjuoh,usR-Ackerman,nd MiPMĄ5E5ǁ/ǁ"6">Doonsutalights Hly?8/"9MA6QMB"> Expsive Speechyssociag`gg'e61'MC`LetterromgXGoodell,mmirofhe΃FXballa,o Chiefxts/ook ClubЇids (7) II-4Olympic@arArticle 50OOH(Ixrnłe, 5''''MF Frédériqueƺ, TProhibiQPol`tmby AthletIiscyith10Epean `vHnu(i>4j5oLJoHhqseleaso. 29/QMIecirin “8diuman”oceedhFexwCourtIGy,WWPFirst Se`OOgMJ/"KML"MqutyWNPSagen.ancourganizɖorX0έPa8{Wiam(^e؂Br0shlumbia096Ouy icsƏIndia (AFI)♠ Y߁OO (IAAF)''q rP9Sk77PiilvCamȘQMQ">Eth(Regul p`Woz HypndrnismV6R8WWRPMoyaoddhair,IFAaskxrc’熗QMS">I, BVWwWsTPGulinHmo*qInvolvzCᆊncil (Gon ~ggU"> F' e@nk9GWRV/!N0N1">Ares%jsivHfsubjection?GGbre59"id="I3QN2"> Competition LawndconomicreedomsAntmssaynIFA’sorlhupy (3σ_σZGȍ@ersqgdictm,_YYHawit (U.S.isttdؔasnNeworkrT4wHw/w"IwwNJ">CSelf-Govan0Achieve G ?K񉁇QA.artHtiamatti,ner1‘Ourin? Weprtoaketasktifaoouslyh 76džNyzBBn5Olymp8ttX(FederأSxzerlX,rspivixDPj3QNOa p_GoBack"ameP/a> CañaATPԊ9??K??9?8,7???RQ(Pechxin?=SkP[=8τRρ/ρ"SϟρNT??"U9WADA iDopggׂVLorenzoaؠOOO0">Gloybridublic-Privod:(e gggency (I)y 0 91 #ciónexicanaeútboFMF)Mr.QéalvadCarmrez (Arbitr²2SpЖw-202/"3O4"5вnoooϋ炏6ng1 UK=ϑρ7">Xsx&se 961߂߂8Craigeest9ww9">Aail`pproachaA;kTowardsrXwMrx$ncExpe,arl(aryssembl82h3dOB侁 (ڀSbothseap ,exemplifiedyhencient@d modernlympicames,ports)thletcompHtionsav` uniqueapacitoranscenaaalor({geopol0cs.

Privateystemsfov`(reprimaryegulatoHLon bothJdoyintillevel.Āngromhen Tweamur`isure-timctivȊse_s de min9cessRstotewhyPkets;omulgx, adjudicaenformanyarulesnicoX oper;controlrhapepstreamdown|ePomic .self-ptut ȈoXucths lackechanis0ublparipj:J0Ѓ S scruy///+H(Tidmayphif,owrzthisoluhgop psune (2018,܁sp#madeeadl0`bout[spe0 AmernotballlayXi! er-nonp gt(ǕnPrrupRwin ICommittee (IOC)FédéeƅAssoci;(FIFA)—Ybody\မWorldup ,whatU.S.llohTr`bl illuH wabearaish3biXyleg`macy{orgzRsπm`vwwwrIqpdd)hrbroadहfirst, #righlih sua , equty#di`ibaɀH8applۅ@ld3ixojouPgdeci ars?uwe(cuexpxoAʴڄstZ邠_,uڤqXns. Sd, Ѱe'subjec oHh!q0n_awY#xd10߂0 s?ӊ냮u as ع iGulEs 9emi-|oh"ain)ȓH!B{m?irdعybemX)fu9“Zaw2i” (lex)Xjd(dK"> Ʌa nearXaut9oxʅЂѤngnanIr exlЛe?o)wa׎rir llelHns։r xQ Ki w0r2om?ahrYciόg񀠹{)Db HpڄɩCRora0rКd`ngdopailrGG?+h2w؁27"(il_toc_id_34OL">Do؁gRsAaPa>EӀAw3QOQRec0pdem$Hthl8rsQiir ’𠑞٠YupqYglobhu(򖋍cHs ha@puquQc,GPore(edia 8on.Ć individg؋cXorD ǔbpplief.ŗbw.S.EurlluJei9Riss@aised. ~R"> n 20Ј16,mericanootballamesereheitxofavJ prots,ithomelayers “takingnee”hilcU.S. nationalnmseard;"participsxinedirl aKorawtten逑racializpolicerutty. MembySFrancisco 49,PfessÉU team,eg選ugu20!and8nhn,o⁰200 h劐eBlraturɅI.ׂ@ac! widespreadrismywnbcommatodnPps invok9nstitultradȀfrepeech.

Ina8ΐ]FLeagueUndӅes (NFL)nou`聩Xl pon0pXfield shstQhowectr[la,F sotؓxٔoH㎠pyI lockroom)or os.1 alyz؊f8hruɨ]EunvLHuman Rights. 1Fur:8"abou{xdussomm ard80oci1`p tٕbeior.7e`y GereYuphȰ eg tڙ(ps` n`riot, ognizimB9p abi"Yo/@AlifeIn@ss orhizv80ludXiusuch h4Ew822igil_toc_id_36P2w="_Ref486289247N3HQoo!__rogXgool'P4">L: R9ǁ;,ohN-FPbeaXo ChiefxecHvC0Цsbr'/h43NJ8P5qpH10/P6">Octop 10, x7!3QP77ύ7317O83 WHxytyfeJed.ӕ2 e9l FL,ټXeogeqЧet those򎁂t@a(aw蟐Ycurr(pu0xr niQtenZ8rBunifyp gnow9u{1layeʤbrossZ4\69I@m+urWCowXIod؆Zhard workRpyeapo8H؂dampddӁ2lڛxحCcti@ . ALikec䉙,eiys0AIhtQ0t881.eto honh lag/ex!ӅuWe cdeepȹۍopincnd coрncernsboutriticaloci8issues.heontroversy8he An0m@arrioavingonesonatioQndakreal progressnnderlyWeeedmathis y,weanoo aYgerithurlay. . !

E@ynvolvigamscopath forwar2inu9ece1oo0Papmunes,atecძperrelKhipfathrough( couyNFLttswhenaseXrified re88PC* * *ggbD`Asdyv Maxf 2018,…q(eas@newhgu allowُ remaHcirockrooms,◸nteamsheyould finqfxyookkȕld durrnšPH.ɐystateme8NRew policC Gel؁04uxatp@Arr“ alsePpmo8mtousXf9 Uun0rio.”:1ng,aystspedirlawsumlchenghabanh4}w022"psigil_toc_id_37'PE">O+Á++ 50b?/h42QPHGGFI">AdhDe@str, Propag@alsp6PJdivQPK">InA &e (5)Bye-)RuiρO1mpubit`x,iowis؛8 appeasasportswбccooPgeon TPӁ2.8QPT"> (AthletICincy 10EEue`vanuigh!̈ZVU?PVWGQQ0߈QQ1">Frédérique Fax4ІsuđwQQ2q dfoot(chref="le:h:fid:002H: H0003HT3ixexQ34Q4">*[ ooQ5h/בaa島呁xasʮWRonttoܳl8f. Wh$gnbodуCn Cittee (h)`eeePopmxherrir reguC uI (kree froCӿ7cyٜ*swhe@ne)ito@ssheir (pрolitical)houghts andeelings,vennepot.ecentncidHstOlympic Winterames0ochiormruexempliftiofis controversy:commemor;sPkyhelmewornyanadian freestylpkiireberxarahurkehoiedfyain0 acraleaHago,8gurewasann8(IOCچis8rioeppatnt;blackrmxd fourorwegross-couHy7!ideathe bro8ry(eam툊hncTchcpisswsuchprim(wiHaet)0Cieoo(ter3Ukpxwaxbrespe osujIdns YKievrequ?refu cqtlyO1bartiflic1uld(haHolaimpportromʇ;xbowlvDutsnowboar8Ïylaa@hopenXgayhowadisreg؝aussia’nti-aw,>inapproІwell.obtime,nce cȁmad[powsaluh(Am聙s09s TeӓPJohnrlosRiaX @kMexicoity Suref 1968,oodmedbeax youhoeXwhihang ڐY5,b| “an?lrrabȂr,” bas1RuH50Yagraph 3'imswarr|ir .moUundiQibogeza enge ؇petitoqazz@. . ,txex"lflurЄ)environBH3vS0phveR`dscoemphs}Q aab؛npaAs @@ՠlslZ!ligiouhss,tc.ňhfiоpeopcdi,ha( ,gءh8revb g`0ner,Ps0@iepipJl@ɣȄGE0PcKdifٸ`؈褰nda, manif(:yiypH#aroupinclud2liЋ; ex,,uAte@rased.dbሠلxHpub8 debpGφB*@ܳIopinjoughPҁ,uϿos qHsy(y@nssaryb̙oq(ia)8viewDȡ ȿXoapPHBroadcaHCȆrrРycussɹ ^IIme Xѓ! ijomBaȅ~Ѝ>joy:9deechX:[]owmakx/,قR pshido؅(፻scxies.1p"aeQĞ8hib1ʁRdealtӊaQ-by-Zyepen™Iyma(r

Ar810兘1 can . . bepplicableorivateelationshipsiaositive oblignhet.A]roadangef isoverediKcaseaw],lwhichPeerson orntityxercisesomowerjo(rndQH%o imp(nt@ndsat selyffectsundamalights freedoms.lthoughІasoo cernpor`auch, sePeleـЂiluszarHhht(y퀁 (int`stdB. OfevathBx@8ir all9,o genIaaadeybCourtjsu8creqenvironin K6articippuceb,@by gepqunexp`2ipinsidewiit fear,ve@fviewلm8ځ off` aur8Ԅ,orX or shockm.ԛisota 3’4qagainatta`]b, aڎA❫XhleX󐵙oft9RPWCFocxngۅ2hlissuJwork-red ,.}aOhtweemploy lȗOseem2yertxi hshrȗesfindsKA810xn؁. Ev5P*gggꁚPneoussenqHkhѐ wdowf) $li@Xdmiə(sm, gЧ9҈7р)spe![npshanifdis`9exc sBɨC@comm gro@ۃsDunn}ن)qhʱXג銎be link`Vȥed,*c@p5" '{OgNopȻؓDՍc O `p`arϯGip nIOC charahrisen򎶟above-1JHI"akۥu8atubasfu"dxlopkgܒ"ald2+xcanalog aPH@drawX///*D(Ov4ys[hibX(polwIlH Ru5Olymp@C聀beȖ$d,c؃iXbeIa(ed.ג(Ȩ%first@onmeet"destr8 a؅hg>Anda[itcasubjɚhrwell.ԭQ1goW(fG9InP, 0ow`*swcori1!yۍclo quij.͓rechٖnwlso s褏Cdxm 0akBStim7iobvi/nHongutom8Ћulh`b qufBȏccredi(N( nowadayy\x8吡ac-I ʚ0蘙aXA(;Qalcgo{fޫb 8ngyblack(mdAэ% rebMmעpj!, scgregr`pa’h-g(lawzaryp(rd. 1g 8ly d1ѤyonnњRi` evenညoreomplex,speciallynermsfublicversightndegal certainty.ombininghisithPeactHa)esionʀIOC Executiveoardᄨfinal9caseidisqualificatr*drawPaccredit, . . seriousendang Kuerocess򆱄 athletes.heyanorhoiceaoyeprul"` powerful2monopolistX*y paripatzOlymppGamesrh`posiinfluen3,iNackၰ(mocr8c.xh lHryancsځhsenόόˆI1charmȄ8’reer yipreventimyfromxer܎f)on.

Twool@)mJ`sibzIbi`eA10EuropeCon*prstneiȊ8mtrans@p le-ecismAcoopwouldH hibC@Psem`FC0,H amhgb@id񆛓V8ernHfootb oZFIFAfuėHourspi؅is r`rd,ollowlayroear[rm-b@srqti wheomm؂:y`Yre88QF* * *ggbG`Regul pXY`oanblemhneștmOnpril 11, 2018,Gan FedertzurddrȂzp`f lsporrgz(orpȌ r “dium”Jviolfh4wes2QQH">PҀo. 29/ DHSLBanAPy ngs ϑϕy (FJSe`e) (c27c)su}QQO'Xd(chref="kindle:x:fid:002J:offH0003H>5@" ixexwQP!4QQ">`(xTǠR裻In06{RantЀixteen-y-ox XubCnunich dQat g8MSV Duisburgopreams(fP*5,erphysalsvolvaroЂFC rmo{ψ˃1XudIۄinjurdama𪠁ty. Subsequ@lypxiely 50<0luA whcԻȶcustodyRpurۜablishir e 1|ԃchalleng0decissqcernleg0disputPetween privaactors0 toscopeproXetaryTPs-à-8Hirdartiesnderlaw.ccoreblished case-8ACourt,ayavxasuch ̍Hyyai0recorizHeff8Fdo notenerXy㌨4og(.By do,weverH{permhɌhip쌾,ndtscumbpregularHsgive ,x?Nii9pr" 8c Ha usAz pIareedefixtu ڊB /Xvalue0OMus݌0Amp`hgggbU`I C,3xX2whichg-ly Nw ppcirpТRKdividu`.ɐsm lɔouNjphs freedP p Qholچw@(sufi`dݟ$ rlywu׌׌׌V25nciplell᪱3to choose—airwYefI(whe4`h܍ύɂ09zqorpx(WkesKertyxtR0Uq717qu8tain Zq(ixQБ[AI3(1)Bxcaw]1 a)niewfherincipleequalreatment,civilourtsust consXlynsurePattadiumansူnotmposedbitrarily, but baonacts.AparticularRylupon to愸herpecifyrireshgardingnecessarylang [fundaights]gainsto0etnlatiЄ( circumPnPndwhichԆ intehdffec m andssibility>ercernedsobj`ab@!titulawZRalXdyJiiuffici8oretermina P߉showell-foyd1sCa XskYfutadis@hRthX texev prpouriX onducrXfuleha90aW site,iveeegitimatPЌȂffo atoro 4hۇfoot(latch9ir'#asafeathl聦udceWdemyxe ‹ub aꀀ/)+icQj we9.

Xissuwhiexpin es Ҥur+(V? E Inecentear(imantsaarguHփ nsp)p@lingorenHquty/parp shouldpplyoportevxXOneetquesabouto fhsithin҈egorPခwenRHrrcanonuere@(hsinary.ressu( chang(rom򀒄`vectoa nhPgroupssertighHex,i{o non-Pm(GGGCECSa.ancourganizmitte(q2010lympicPara{׆ames (2009HexcerptbelowuМ0AppexB0ishlumbiaddqrmpacCanadian obligčxQ=discri;he@ ZaharRFreedomdotOC. Adeciss/////,,1,2Yؖux8 ({osolКirloodPrumGGGQRG">ؚ@wwIa (AFI)T OÇ15藘o BArbiҁS (CAS)tayis regul:.Ӄ8viiHAprilq8Snewh07oughH@a fuliddle-Ye(nnw:basRwچQ@bXaorehopscii@cord.ÛIcۂ1Silv`Campesi es,PlacksouX? OOOHHOiocuX#xcت2pHtare ಠeymarksP8o b.׉pl)`sthexahowa0p pos)FIFA!ʂSplar1PzemeXd ;faigra`ч# epxpay fॣә s(.+h45wȅ2)sigil_toc_id_41RI">CCA 522 ?9|7ROx[Bexe:Hon`ableͺ@mʡXihRow,/,r. Frankel0GA^Groberman]P1Hella`9l辨ly-XRskiump, n )icӒxinsˑϑ~ z (“VANOC”eeke followqatorr8:߈WWTQP g="en-GBRR">IfփofingXh i/AÙ; JʊX failuo vioeirqu0r@suȄp9hec15(1) 腙Canadi0CRJFroX[j#],su'#8'QRSQRTdfootnote0href="dle:(:fid:002L:offH0003H>7@&ixexwRUi4RV">*up̀GGS0Xiisodȳs. 1 ww<1wng="en-GB"id="I3QS2">** <63S5"> 2. . ![Amongheentralssuesnourtelowas:]o Charterpplyolaimfenddiscriminationdved⁐ ellantsgainstANOC?z6x 37.ԃecognize@arivatentitynd hostistaga[2010inOlympic]ǎs,ߎ engagimplemPatutorychnhalf govern.Ɉead,ZMultipPy Agrej[,tweelo,ovincia fe sex=|srgabodi]9er2variousmmitsade ((l@8tiYbio1destetr ]udgeoun"ߐt(activ0. gggb7`38Zrizq,wohe0 c!8":infrauctup:okep anhortfalnayiforiabilitaith “abp]”hosit[[sË. 1 [T]wordكXs. 32Ѝic.??oQS8Ǫ߭ǭǭǭ2Nǭǂ?e9ǀDŽw9DžǁAϭ IYcas@e8h`osrrespectll matut PargwgrB56M[a]&’rePclЗpמpyunequbenefit ("vails:Ъbutwoski``()ps(`da@lawy OfacpftLighhpe`yGEͨVsJ arAb%<ɳ(䎘romgislr,8r0ferX +_yaxcis IOC lntuggx恘{P- F8Yy^Hd  BoW󩘂bЩ0dors,Canadio{wC62 purP15(1)ѩRr bwi8tyXyISonisd tutor@.e@:oave opesi|c˅iـ؃ir o2oyprerogX(`arY purown circumnceedQ;issueariHʪ\Qre8invol;xer"1lowx'''%D 63/efЮwɀpxspco`;KMo؞oyg ׅiXunXtak@dutiHost CaCB(qoHneHfad`+d[IE 4r:ifficul*QarguґҢ'X8i. EPMpyhejlyËxifip؃ÈuhOIopolicZ؆Sirrlais em{ 65.hissotcase,Yn,fgovernhtalody5ing circum" CharteryxercisApowthroughtracstead Hlegislation.ar,XQwhich non-Xbjtforur9result policiesneinornyanadianuthorityhange. . . G8hppedismissedK.Kh4Uwern22"Hsigil_toc_id_4H">Dɏnd  v.thletic FederIn (AFI)d"InɁXAssoci EsƂNs (IAAF)CrbiportimwardASI4/A/3759 (h5PQSO[BHiJus ennabellplaiBennettO, lÈYAia,ЙidIeanel;of`H.cLarFor;r.aNa,dra@, Adoc Clerk]Q4r`chaPQv8d Regusǣ El`biltFemalypndrogenCompetjWVi(“ns”)77slatric efyhivels! uly occurr2o)onppH cvX. KHKUK]basthat: (a)ycienlawlgaه q7hos)] physiQ; (bDp 8PfPuuqQaboyrehip0tw GAb hma`cproو8Atim objev؂(d܆19dopѾRol. "Ȃisao0argusWWVRP5Ýra؝x8lexal,ntific,eetX@ue89eubzdrawpa@Xj ext?cvceaccou evolu= ולƅqQ0c(7 we`؊0ir ȭ⌐€sex كpr@sors,Jphiloso8F_ meaٱnAs. S448ψψon!pp0P. Itso8nuұ?T">pa)ie!?q requكcxuygndous wpwhgado!Ad8, O??I ?>t [ amooc (nameam"'eX;bodxodu)Ё@reeSU|aбooϕVz9{Χdidid( aryIOCÉЈChۂͱ8Mclro!~YbjՂWat)؁Ӌer-kArulzС0vail.rdly, ٔGGGn*reasbQnd o؈yiinvH 荀ptth ͉򳿏T050Pane onclud,h_\ _[discriminatory.tollowshat(enushifto IAAF`stablishwHyperandrogenismegulationsre necessary,easonendroporQate@rpurposesf ingevellayfieldfemathletes.uch ap a`isㄈistentiteuntervailrequirem ss arecogepnpwideangfompicilaws, includ9Hct`rohibiziscrimi+ 0ll.

510.irst,+axagree#i׌׌ divq o틪xchgorhndl0shoupbbjivriPrmapolic. Thirpdepnotɏpވoury, mayiwhi0plosshighrorone,ʆbyxcpLBMLe`Body͌],ch !ampethadvantageQf:eفPȇa latHQpxixӄ剹n0behie Panleg薴aу4vaIQmS o҂nfpyfac)Sx8slumb އ’@tatx҄orG`r(exsly)roɃself-atifi0 SnhYonKse it؁eC___nor0 'pop.owr,HKs sbDSDsDifSexuxD9op]oave Oreٕ8;, a.ԕo sej3ÆԝߋH e (1examplen “sex”n).΀v n 00w}if"qI!௘ePA7,@Ӧ nso>eR/$but/*XG.Ő(}10mol/Lavirsn dXmascu؇raits,Abjb) scic01typৈ:gI^`hysʄtyǼǼǼ219`Xbetwe N1 XXexplPabov8 ۂpُpviewUן׈eiologwpoEF u0WWBspunder oII)BP` XKould^e Wl. In adrWQrodua6؄ligiᏜfune!yoonrri3 qquiؽ@ar cXfulals32. . ![T]6btwoſ9r:ҐXRtЌc8lPip8icFho exhibHי@rͧmhc񟐃Aϝ IHreH(tmubccepI‰xse υ(ńzrosq,romˆB$norZJ GE7. Wи-bsreas`IRmpab{ex*s,ݜ@purQ4,X ČpurOH푘 clh8ocihd /dvantage?rneed[s] sfisala`xbabtits.

 513.heanelonsidershatverythleteustnrinciplee affordedepportunityopmpɁonf*twategoriesnd shouldotntfrom4ingAany equenc>naturalnalterstirody.ule some(n?;0alȃesult modifidytitiXyfundatGOlympism“EindividuxhavI(ossibilYpractiss!,outiscrimiioHfy k.”ӄooz2permi(anhdiygoHmax-inh@meda ir1negsrducX)effecarPular=lccur8genQee.xcludsBЏGB"`as(Z=adv`age,߂!righ(tLJLJwhichwBSimhQ signcpeth >cerned,Jree onv؀f頀leare@blishqoQXesaA@promeanchievQfa09. .

ooT6j5T]HyHroXRegs0tyimajfemaȉbXnsusp(xam1aSD)f9itȑN!rea}sahx f tosYa@o,s (Ýk4AЃ2')o@a .owtylsoco0sقHq sٌQbhR3GGmay9ׅ熹ohsB `rt9a)ǡp OOOJ7J7mXkpinווis3jmembZ“oo(<''%R0sp8ңgjoy HOI]j8">degree„Ȇ/Dȗmak unab4play2ieldߎQT92PanPsi;lackA drxrquR膈re4hiptweenhd]andou`o؁~'ݙt issu(Whi:10%rrOOei just@se("℠UX 1Gce Ƞrs=]6ry, g0ۅ0peIri(legmaxct ᇧ#nu+/QTA31.t llowXunYlud4fulfilAȼt`purpos]'''"B"6findAAFаdischargits burHbliȹŁc0edž DzXnecessa)qP8` objH8eligibil:*po xn ϑ(nQTC8:evolCcief(ʃ8 xiEdataillAufp(of)ccepA ?>o`pecnd bed,i @tx0to,Jexample,BM)JwhQTD4@circumy(,wwuphol(8vd񸌔wPWsu//*aiodwoea88TE* * *ggr e63"id="I3QTF"> Inpril 2018,heAAFublishedewligibilityegulationsor Femalelassific (Athleteithifferencesfexual Development)YvXrom 400momi(“Restricted Eb”).heseulwillomencenovember 1,b.n ord8be"HxpinxńanternjalÁiۆPsetorldc@)swomanB amust ma 脠bloodosHoneyPlowiv5) nmol/Lntinuously.눀hoootshheir ou cɎЀى.

*E ng nWHy0rismSilvia Camxesi (`6) ς11oQTP7/@6'TQ2P?RSr߂T. . .T]hpab@@P[gulseSx]A1998diwpOlymp(mitteXIOC) 9. 3bargu !w`nngXneHsary(cauonCswearwoeȂP seeunfeas+aБmasquXdenwh be8n`loj寠. AfЁsbfalse-8@ultAtla- GXs6,L9OCȇmovڂyquiуy CǒǒUa ykX8ardh(work+ 3ɳic,ut4lqHOan besprogo*r,ȋX0 0ixXApeopAЌmg`. M8althourgXЁφ(isHtw300I 12Hng/dLzQ0atoxceIon rage, 1ŐtsSobserS_2 ntraccos rfactors,uchex`uyo exousrms (eg,st:thyrox@)time)aday, +xĬPividual.ŀH prod aghs{ PreI:hi ll*HryXadvфZfromnonfunce.ךךךVTׅׅ߅Tve YiVguylȃHJuly 27, 5kspensIgyCAS.žHf th)/nivop,ɰS$ w08tutcairץU0Sذoutsai؈H,y{oXr biologXxigص`dTnZ61 ͧEa؜ʠ܅B0Y'n.

  Morehan 200eneticariationsaveeendentifiedtrovn advantagenliteport,hichffectetyfunc includingloodlowouscles,Ltructure,xy`ranK lactanover,dnergyYd؃p. .

U2Inddi,eAAFIOColiciesaiseoncer terms0Xnalsistency.ndeed,fuyssumpZ higherevelstopronf(unfaiPn comprٍisecessaryyseppYimredr layiPl nneorsxxo forRmacgor“Fmanyeaxnow,aalOmo "athle`z`(uapzbutJH(admicelebr8d.”U3AlthoughnousYfemininity9 its regulSRyhssisimarkfocun are broadlyo({ehysihar(er8icsus (k)od1JizdhapeوHasts.ȗ`XH( .whooBonXalsocistardJargets pa"omYń+8h脙tifOBavoidA`ll0qu . '''"4 [S]oall1߈SXbړcguls fromAopcou)TtH8otype '܊!*(Xte, AQlawcXse xKs09`dirr(ҋ,9med i8lism1sq3laiXɕߕh}_|\نhvwWWW5PH0dro (ApopIma2hheaP1q0sYDžHi?:| Փqh(betw10%15%tolycyvsyame)tzak("apy1guȗhnclud1zFreЅdǬ0]…hRwixwwne}6S]w0ro`ung"aȇ(p`p0vie on(hibto0-H!).ɝq`Hpқٚ!hotQouta:enef cheҠЇ ___QU7Xburdroٍemtx8a(h ArxadvantageyhigP) fX2Y[Ses]cSMdeedPoughև(vexptXReڏlsoȈ0ys2covѼ+bvh4%wern22"sigil_toc_id_44U8">FIFA,ƁjW1bp/h4BspX6'UC">Submi8Mr.ƫcoC ChairQeJCxitteh(Moyaodd, raTaskrpA’sw(2015) Thisubmissionetsutheaseorh0toeectifiedsartf iRePmrocess. . 7772G0F dayverwhelminglyale—not cauwomenndirls arenherentdisintpst` incapable,rarueddes of@stitutpalsociXbarrierHharevPAmrolayp. WhȄonPp,equitHnershipqtechni8, adistHɇJnanc9maPn-rezedHooew8on-makф ptnatueYusuffȂehsooiir ch`engex sumpɒPHow`r,ᔻ2015IFA׊Symposium,legs171embЃ" (MAs) %lfachr woul nty alRfile׌׌׌Iwoj‘CxA𒢅(ndiaddsed byCommittee Gi؆51c enousrowthpportun,Pchass oubserveZbobjves{Jx mpriPon8%Exec0(ExCo)]s gloIyO7reg`8dqfAy battl0gieilp”spi iru0f𒣂 0yP7773K0PerhapeevidImarkqAits syHmc~sourcthroughworld.őэ lawiscriȇ",)ti᱕many,9 hotwiمvhQa`amknow it feeCscoqal.hohHoetHies,e`e`,0ducsubdishrewardoa`1e(,arg%tor2aϲbans eB RPodlopYu L"_8pfuhqa𢘁HexiPdB20%D`{V,Hmirrd s`ixlQs$i lor-@yf 3g08݇O n釞!lsthol (includCQbodbs)ia" BHacip[ǁ᫑K1atJS,d/zafnq@ѡG⃁pot؁h4w rn22"铘sigil_toc_id_45OUM">G6P5  InvolvS Axu(lFédér9bd(AsR() (2017)~UOnbobj跛f9q Ϝ`ς=ls H Eachnfesi ڹkx`Ґrymai8i H VI0riWWRnechaW`ȤSructure. Toȯ@%Sta@Ђъ[,( regيh`0,]l@ l8t o8wsHǬy].  ߅furrv؆ 謘 As8ult,0?8onductlq@) Council,astnecid` bnsuredyskoysЄneiPrggesth o!؎Tɂ)ed,xrayff?:cprahce.גꂯXrurV2lla sea0-Ë+.h includesenyvailab,$YrvÎ"speci@glXuis grous (ify)WYidies8ulary ??hs܉LJa “’s”oٌ0pXwpBoolϋϋ3">fu١en. . h2mwX26"`sigil_toc_id_44">AreӁ2ρ7ns PrivIntu SuڋSeg?eؑwoġhfeYpeed sers,arkuipNielsˀthob`ghʵt chen"SUa4vrs W non-偩potpet#miyeain@lif08banT dt܀bounfaircul7rsH op)unxp hae SAa`rixbЎweg8o9 'ty7HpeJu OO have arguLi8qQ0mi-publioska ill-snex9𗯗i'Ի alsoamgontseca8rrup12y`:9lik܏8OCofЇvolvPbe`i9iminolog0f ONusePbribeTself-deng35ϱ7GV8ϱϱϱ̋n_V9">LawEomFrom3wߕwQVA(mIvidbu8 athlete"x.qӂ)߂/ h7aXtruYeЁ ggabecauxdegs_fiasHl :acresuffxX@Mpbbe exemptC-mpohg BЬudebڗqS@ docapac bout8“!0J”owh 8er8o (hnot)caÉzH ]GESXFranciscoAD..S. Olymp*ttee (1987)uCopжςor; 0hYXshfe0$˄ pex@siveoy 8at8sxh|LjyHr.In Brentwoodcademy.ennesseeecondarychoolthletic Association (2001),hupremeourtfUnitedtates explorfherfactors`atendanntity).

TEuropeXJus0e (ECJ)ddrd)imilaruein PRoyaleelgeesӉétésxootbal(SBL J-Marcosman (1995)ociwhev Commuies’malreedomsereindingnisport organizz.͌cly{( ///G">Meca-Mea1iss ?C68nd H">AmericxN(le,nc.NbLeaguea `10)aveoncludyer1 by#Hubs`be regul0dcompzlaw.h4w0ern2sigil_toc_id_48VI">WP=WP531.S. 288y71 7VPG_biscQ SoulivopiJLGR@[Ie( 0so(“n”)vg sᑥ0ruХprces.(privAsJ, =dep divoluxenrolltnts, throughir@Po:hailong- prohibcexh񈐬ueflue(`id —Pen-fqyear-old/+gyWcoachBviou@ma(Ї0etaeighth-grxoyotr{ЄxȀemphasiz}gQolvoas pobwouldftelyPyvage. Sǎà ,lacinyboIAla͉ ⳍ baske{tea(lqбӑyoffsjc.uthar8w߁WPwٌЍ colȗpXY9bothil@ccor:rosFTth Hnd!v֠rfrxomaex Firstnntu.'''$T$fea(ri0ceh??< xviinqu=bemؚ9regu .ώppealSSix0Circ AeHsed,n nei rgag;tȧRxPs`ublfun8nor spoul靲QᅍB .]ύύύUis0heawآWinpor+oЋe inȬh[am0a ssƒarnّ̛het enЅgaiXxmemb. 1eض[n]Çco0ɮـhshQreх/8wJervؐ p (ipstructu\nreAnos|sȁρʆ(2any `way. . GGGBV@OcayaplohetwsubjecY '8r(n]Qd( (how epx)st.*6lespecificNwhi@plaintiffmjs.IfFourteenthmend Pxxdisced, @ore,x8mbiPalenetwȇ hpeoop؎outsid:malgovern)1rganizBs, d؇!posteyrivQr@ t8t(sometims邐thadus;1ed.hus, wQI؁acmfouif,oug8su(acloseexusΐh(engcH eemG0haviair1􇠁Ѓ_elf. . OuPas`@d A@cariness9(ttriH.׌vЗexaI,ea vYԍx}ulfrH!psercipoypower*pro(es psignaPenrage,i(ـQpa xkZwillfulartpp9ino8 wPJg8w2 (ҊMDl`1c8hbdele8pucun3phwd1 po0iesen  []Hn4Æ????<589O]r؏٫[TenyeAssot abohvas3f5 * * *ggre63g0C`Severyearsater,caseeturnedpU.S.upremeourt.n Tennesseeecondarychoolthleticssociativ.rentwood Academy, 5513291 (2007),useohnaultnsor ,hichnanimouslyel ui-recruitingu`ofWnidotio2Firstmend HOne factor`Lalysi8adX “voluntdecis”paripnPdbide by镠sh4wesn2sigil_toc_id_490E">UҀ҂ Belges SXétésxootbal'SBLJ-MarcosmanEurop[ C-415/93 (1995)ρ70L[Bee.C.dríguezgias,rHd,.N.akiD.A.O. EdwarG.ȗ(sChambers0G.F.ancini (Rapporteur )Moyho Almeida(.J.KapteynQuln, J.LurrayIʀrHagnemؠdges; Advoc Gen: C8enzRegistr8:҃0r,Ҁ,D. Lou-HubeauIip0Adm聁0]WRMQMrxZ(–if$im8Ёc h lityjlayhFteam2impedP80nsferc fee os$@ߚ.ԷPDŽrer0au(4ECJᧈoPeru ;wecomPi!withh48Ժt=8movYwork—nowHcognizXundhn5ѮsFuncyف .13Hixe0O40P">*upR] . . . OOQH71.ېP]rxd. Commhauthores vlwayespectغutono8Hs,0`isxtrdifficul0uishetweeH`icZ9azbaf}pc؂jituK0profesHyightin orga 7Ț8ole.Hrxsoevif8j`(фl Ĥdeghlexi\woul8ssi`becausRpaulartup . ߒߒߒR2"Ыǟxrn[whiinxthi؃y] d(#nss a[@v.ɣ`#bmit˂s gk(s po@:simi22@Hb,ώ9 128(1)樏mu|ڌ( rȀjdi`"9\:Mets0ily,ì^Fenjoy f`sTVlaw `luɈvirtue ,p#(ubsidiak8ev, ͅZpublics΀Q` xfia"astrictHnecparyS3CS]˂ubjo牉@0soȿrxtu ge9q ,semi-(re(eainfulmploy:8vidped sice`1T5.AcOOJ+e 76.gard difficultyxe@zconomicspY sQ2ԁfootball,Courtasel provisCommyawonc0freed m؇`pX؎Bymrvicdoohludeulrp jifie0nhn-^grosbhocaXar naturertextainatcheIttrhed,owat y(tri)cscopeyquxYєpmqlimitX0iX8bjive2canree,Ђl!upoxwhol*aoviq_TreatyooomVi7.it1y6ossibsejthjudgsj organiz7llЅ؆2,RistlyᖈaalthoughRal/,any!icidec Jbeighca0ully0orxdnis ha)Ә[mmiseRappl(e ]recupa/-Н ys*mbtakin@ʥP[when deepyҧ|m0pe0c.108argu"baȈpo@llegs؞HqBڨyhacٞ1cnsub@b2Ȩ1doId`Gh pr@Ē!ho`>Ale 128(1),@񁰎uͣ7i~ `workgu04 48,<a(aч ksym19. . ![]ip[Y0ohi],Ppin u11mEuannvqProt1kHuman RF'ƃs* 86.hatHgumentsas[a]懀eremis[e]yerxsoth `clud1/from2pcdh.eitPXecope n(qcontQofxo?'(anyay affectbyBrivatueule queonA7.rticX48Trea`efoHappli qjl0ow`y spossoci 0%determi aprofessals8engaggainful employ9. . {h4wHern22"xsigil_toc_id_50/1B">M-Mʂ  v.omٔ EurH؀unitourt Jce (Thirdha))C-519/04 (2006'"71I[BA.osaPresidVe,.alenovský (RPeur)-P.uochet,Borgar@hndÓaoimh, JudgAdvoeeneral:.égRegistrar:.ülöp, Adtor.]םo1JН`ktswthlPso mph g-danHswing,aqucqufmaXh///*KIati-dopфxt`rrun 31anuary 19991Worl(up tiscipSalvadPBahia (Brazilw1yadyhfir ho8p@ivЈ4֤d8svehNro)R1L1[T]? chalpgXmp@bilbfert reguOCIPrOlymppttee] ieFINAFédé ?8eNatz|ac ob8{,y H؀`freed0oȕerv҈p`J fixbli02g/mlyo8X(tetweт 27bo9accrDi(T!Cis X0llynfpleІ`excluxnocr m@neglig.@J’seCpPcou@hab̖ul0sumpJIh@yboar.lso 胐\޶hapmyict liatmabl0Q:ribuinsibAsettʅ)puarbiy9(zASnIh) whichjipfipe(pp!Rhup͞% M40~ellsp8rej heirltrdec؂ '9ue9norTnەruropeНglaw] GN3 1gardvlxkR;Qrightakȁvieww0y obŽHSwaaspPombÅor)7i9bBducfairlyEÒPsafP᪑0 UxT healthۑ(egrŇ/*)etЃHu@O4adȌ, ةڙne8 X e rcFba`eff80ȮAmus`3,prxiPqh胐itselP5re`eikOĈ1A iśЃociC—@simiting he appellants’reedomfction,)yoot,orllat, necessarilyonstituteestri Ycompeyinqatibleith mmarke8. . s`eareufied egmate objehve.uchimit(sherentHyrganisand proper!ductveportAtseryurposetonsure healthyival(betweethletes.

46.hii4ispAtruthth`N,yepPl8te(nti-dopingu Psu؆xalso80tIOCwnomicjقHD iord0safeguar 8exy, a8h"st\pcase,:a. R7.t(ȗknowledgቕpenalatx70 732egndBtiapplicaiiy )ach؀icap ad؈eff@non becau:could, wP`ve unN,I iaFunwarr lusafrom z蕰:u:iirmd!whiڐitpengainfollow(mckCwYis#www_S8.҄Brkipdpφ virtpof, firsWl0x譑`ishQddiline`Ccircum`9mou`L pAcmafӋis=sqsAI2DT54Ődoa=Xӥjthhoن foَsoHy~ǁ)טakPla01fun lyU5ȹmsaXorer,jpleat\ҤǍj߫ޥXtbٔϩ״ ׂx9HtWA΀I,nc.. Nalootballeagu0h4??92spБ6'23">SuXmeourt UhSts560.S. 183 (2010)71 726J9Styselreunanis]܇B7370“E)ntr,qbid0marorwise, o؁spiy"pimjudgun2RRR8Orp@orgz1920FL2n`d oci+now؊2ssepaYwnOal̏.a)`izlors,logoR splq׎׎LieٓLfxЇtewrSэIndi`po0lt8 exam,bDٵXe:xGdrkZre wh8s s愘9Pri@1963ˇtheirwn  arrangementsoricensing theirntellectualropertyndarketPradezdtemsuchs capsjjerseys.n 1963,heeahmNation0Footballeague Pies (NFLP)oevelop,e,t߅ .ost,utotll,fzsubstanti(rnugeneratby aveireeni`chari@sXeqlmoIhe .owrG@reblxojBapim@soughho wdrawromiَ>.

Betwqz2000,·gpnonexclusMsumber Їdors,ermitheonufaك sppXlpIhsigniaPYAmericaneedl0Inc.,asneose eDecevo urize|ˈReebokHternLtd. H10–y(ed headwq132ЖreafȘclin{r(wn k’seB . . [eges]hagre$b, i{viol§§ 1;uSXpct. answ臠!complaH+defh( %Ä"pإ8ʃconspi@iSmeanYJ“becauheq0e omic priteastspȆ?nduxHd.”gggbCa0Qa;uweKon9Xowssu0ide: wheągag aYct, bitracyHby oXsSphr0Yid Piv9mustXewP8B85 RpurpH DWTlYhelcЄ9ȉu@rdo9n sipnhinvolv9xPdis؆xXs`desch:qcavX1 fuçЎ (hׂׄOHH=򽙡.(!ul repeHfo!cipmBa1/Ѕ+Qoa@oupylr8,esseXa pQoaǕ{ECon0yYsnssh?4 moHкǑLj9Ȏ577771F0Ԝ$dohpsxLunitarघsPmakAq`؁1,aggpoHBXip膀L.at8ubAtialYly owπȾaHn.1[T]gral guddemɢX se0ciousIes,tobj Zmm؀;e2ap,Rʋ0 hyfi,patn!eceip耰JQr8埠sonnelߓ GDiP)relevȺ`qڇOJarkeiprɜThrm`itSaColTtwo0tɚZ,suppli|valudeYWeiceni??it 8sua©|wholleagueRis8q;ϛ)ɂ[ᄰelf"" ؖ%.z∊Rra_at te[r]Ѣ1DsI؋ HX)񍇒j@Ro}endЈH8riv[e]Otceq74/)ֈ)ۜƵ6>

Footballeamshateedoooperatereotrappbyntitrust law. “[T]hepecialharacteristicsfisndryayrovid jification”orny끐agreements.ԃPfNFL sxn8estH8 gXe兰leagu`uccessfuld pfitable,ば`iducschedulYpgames,serfectlyensi8ꇷ( dao@collivesHBuҀx8Hissin :cashti8certЉivitynder"SherP}is subj1§ 1alysis.

P ul@8egx؃ inPlЏvins e򅽏ӄHjudgcordroH(lexZRHAReason.ەhHardqu@ 1-q examde8eherAarularomic arrangrzyVrade.]Ʉ@uchasۂgeaPYߌ],) 6)like(survA[Adepenupo!╯qu8r_ @Xh8!;tcsomx@H twinkm`eye. KObfeatu9eAalsaxmonghIj. We1r@gnized,j)p@-p aX`9athlc$egxmڦimporhthSs(ϊن/},doYېhtmIsxُ! purposxكtmark(’du y own"tety.ɕ,wever,PubandawHnaarie׭׭Ёde 7Xrokhplayy ЦA8sred red. 1L[ Febru2015,mPNeedَettlG,ith e8(Pdamag `caus芤֌ufts.]h3er12M"> A(-C.Ł+*Bruceean (2016)**up> <R37"> Onay 27, 5,henitedtatesepartmentfusti0unseal0a 161-pagendicS(A“I”) Distr0ourtor*EasIĀNework.rooklynrand Juryeturn؂ gainseenefendants,urrr merPficialsFédérationb8Ǝ`ball Asso, (FIFAiveusiness|hwith 勐involvƂ8.ԆpublicXlingasoordi5rsy"Swisnacti Miamiatheadqueruph.authoro conducᛈearlyorn郹’suxBauruac HlጠPsevxZ. EomistHtices:AmPcay po beboug(qP cz㽘rupr1”I3F{furLmy 0(Mr.u(xpIhappnMa7,5,x, MɇXEury,lib0ꥩ! @px!desڋXefa:re mҔR3Gls"Russxr08Qatx22 Wo ညrldup “couhreasonablyeescribedsavingtunnnearly everyone.”nntegralartfheelectionrocesidenn exhaustivu iligence`vegaڂ`eachns’ biddtoost2018dH22oTs.llenuesere ultimater8dilowiskexceptoratar (high) ARussiamedium.Ή1l,U:{ed. .

staneousplos܄ariticismxl(pl0(noumenύ΀DžĐfuture .ԁsisotb(0sps,IFAinaltooknumbera*hhi(itpublzyIt coanndepe(GonaCommitteeatcludQruis‚9corpoq,؂H iorganizdocu,Statuteemppr CongЂ f9eRAssoci`0yyExecu,8vo onɍ_]ralsossuHp XtjsupʂrexmArevisrecɂshEtsdeڋxcс.. !z@Ir@tord`IHP(mbles:re703IJbspeXl pxibtyIsafeguardsىCpu|footb)ldwid*is1R@iʂtgEښI,romeodyrm=BllegaXimml @unepmHod@pr`>7772K0 ѣlwow QhersI>oryÀcP@Mael. Gar taHقUniq9pAtneyB1Sou8rni8Nework,hirۖirmanR3LxUnti;ainXplayh`m0cP|May5,rupk) _hQknowdȑngzrough腲.wi8nlcosysP9ac ac ׊׊׊MД9SuД)h(w8ainPmګQp8 disgXf(lamTp xmتpنȮ۫ᄈغ Rfdaffosdduut jhanXP(<ӈ` vaنڇPйanyh’˂ ma0clPQ0s@amplfbyR8kwwwxsubRKFRReRbn`8AP mHstYpos1"{UEтYmoof o nx`feder3/_ו[N״ׁ3O">HoweK[]rsurAnribUserioussomڀkopin ڳwhe8eHݼ`snSeta؃*q53A<[[Eu ean F-g`(I)puJan`4, 2103, w heshٝaquq"Ygxpth$玏獋PSooxoffisȽȉy`bPerЎʏjucthus[exhtyChex򬐑8to broadca9markegighoꇢ؝orhhazarpsobvqgHp9p9,upbe el. 1-h4Uw22"Hsigil_toc_id_543Q">lj8 v.ȁI_gQictment  U.S.istrict Courtorheafework____91___"2">No. 15-252 (S-1) (RJD0E.D.N.Y. 2015)σp343"> T@Granduryharges: . . .ian p8erprise, hataroupQlegxit.ed inactojngoorgzwhose sunPonTuuniSmmpurp achiev9Aobjs/,was engaginiv\ffed,stBxeign erce 52. 9ncipgul promo`YځxcworldwidTՂς carrioutis&bysaaatymodhmeaхludzrexencXmtarrul we@inddualemploy@iww,reqGank@XtmٓkUSinaalӉ!h1695.erta@???? GGB ݅oY"nspir u`irosÁB/*h# schemes olsolici@,(ferȘp0cpayareceip uXscly08bribkickbacks.lughlsoelp8suCgg cdefep2co-$atocorrupap ourimГq frauryplaegHxpНq璸KWpartpbL` oՆykЖheabetډ:8?9,ab70rusS vio0Ɂvfry䛀es777370 96Aor[\@d ^@mutto470ts prevde<_/oQcelocown(hiprocee z ? ֵ yB2ϑ _l[cy価aH s:j “ul:services”greMs@laPyp(t(QAppear銸mɹA;$mechsmWAyB0"pZ&dvis$urrendXRmakqd facilkf_]KAقъLs녰noenuYPouўaxasCe X(Tjudi 98$aerio`fphximly 25eardefendanspiPo`posZz.a,o. 15-cr-252 (E.D.N.Y.eb. 17)惈rdistt uhjudgeന Хxh8WQdoYsohelat ,0)+X1"y “glob!oci-in-fȲ'e,”wh8n xYpplQarWi`F, ȖA޸aeyoՌes—ay haXaԅfravioutႇd buةQ#’0hŞ! subti"m.S.X|ite@a  .)qDCQuFM@y La0P@yRete(InflueSCorrupt O(RICO)x؝遱T (@errily8`ج}bC 0A,ql{fas acq uittedfllharges.

Onctober 25, 2017,heistrictourtentenc@former presidЃGuatemala’soccociation,hodm{to aptingndaunderymoney8xnight-thrisonerm orateay $415,000nestituqvimshis crimpomeused,clud IFAiceЇ J1TidadTobago,avbjecxtradie UniSt0Grhass8aken(naleasudewi corruonsiItsthicsm"essuinibans agains fiHlsg?JosephlarYimmed0fa@drevepISwvgy 5.oappCASphelZsean@ hnciple.ow؅&ah X#year uybywtsixwhburn 4.*18.ŝ)ugh۳:aysis] . . aim uP@rroblem@ᣱtoubenh gnjsek9im[adt✀ ,a0cul@y2trXyӖ˜X`t8yphap"mo8orـXlow"ȉt misrqqipay玾c. (iS4T9.ԊHhihcȒ4powTilack0pcheckbacy@twȌĆinstit9gȕOgotHlgpelȓ1ȅnStaes |pdaЦ`earHgic f—Q1(iousȷW^)ځmxg/efWWP܅Pcrehؿ+u`ritNS20.ȑhЃPtroyP)c(vitiesncl udingveranagementunctionseemsoes stroasndthereviouseaship. . ! 23.ɄHlieveatominencef PresidH’sosiindisri(also)ntssuesreXilleylFIFA牉naculturetbeeik is forecȂitouldnaïIoYnkcchPe justxcaus ewvisPi aifferAĊ2">modus operiςςρ4">5556">49.oXdyCua,r no rPy-moluZ.omeormalafeguardkenduҏX a “stagg؍ox”embCincipldi@ E(csommittehhelp; .2buKmain )hshosXctChipe( k}Ipolicyxk`llyccept "scrnyirlQy`Ws—mean Æ m9yxno8Qlatsohrma 6yo؛! suchtoin"o@1PXAystemhuePblishwiby cdatH@w@Ȍdew؀XH) outYÏ.750 XePvs yxgnifi(dvs1sghoBЍoeuv8tؗs,clG_Fpo8rk truWtlyBcwhixpz6wtap9i81Coi⶜ ,0mi8uixupL`/t>dfailQh3]wȁ29"P il_toc_id_8a 22\1_(f__'59">CS- AchGoode?i.ei>,@ubHfpr!thleHseekiГXXKDMtohsHpɀi&K]mecPismAConb Rp EncꏡF@ Aas (NY, 1958) (i“ _n”)onxahe;Ќiu privنNaissu;o71sHliKhannulieeYonPtakla(li@ed grdquHڃusyyfoc#SwudgI,ŲelowEI0dd{xnQsR[0duc"iu(r@ e,߃[decLaga$l.Ϗmin y) bqPҭ@o(emeri bby1`ecx0`ager.ͫeagueę kqfes؃,2柙pa(cipQlif;luc `ms Hqi)dQan22xben@vioԟiluleĴ8 MLB"#AЁiфYa`Unrsity.  Bartlettiamatti,xcerpted below,llustrateshergumentorportingrganizationsoso.

S-f.‰w{br%/h4χχɃI(span6GR5J">CommisserP BaseballAug` 24, 1989p35M"> Tb0shlifePeteoserom0钣sadndarrypisode.n9gx’sretlayersasgagedn(varietyactshich8vhtain@,؀hmnowve with"cequencRAyhoosynotoxmeAa he(beXTbproffanyimoPor evidɄ) p΂inJinQ re!Specialoul}'er,r.k acceul( nc,beelbilityN`ߏ؉aFebruwhenrece`dirm thatGbeǏsڀReds . . !Tɕȁ8zserious ckicPbinsibl8xamJa1al8ailPo9ognHbonsmҁrnb8{ mplexaa(iv Peoutudi! low8XursugLm,xworld0 Oː1Qirurts*PupR hHnppPt(Hchedulю0May 25nu26,Eward@jdesi8(s(liis IHHwekPll.y(RYȗidu8p K؁Toakwhoin Am(ipublicervx:ggS`First,ۂ0egrganbe@f@0exy 2it0fmbodiwss;Ӊnd,hldЃboccarihpea axs miP\񲟰#ȁur},ul؀oPsu؈wyF!g$truife񹸩!` QndþioInrevelawЂ exaAo܄tecULalse clJno`dipuup9:h4w8ern22 pl_toc_id_57_5T="n^YUQρρ!H_V">‘Ourin? Wʑ`askaFifaȠqlyNillay, Mig Poiso,Jpheil((2017)(׃/o(2O'O"332?e2045P mˍ6Itah !9gȜptimismfyshd !corru@iS,n5[U.S.]័oX@i cr(nxsecuapgainst14woPYegPersa w0pershipkIicsweeph؄Hof orm܉~7xW1pirmqepntmb Մgonppari;kf8tTodؤHu鱂longn4.Ϟܙ8o aveakenurPskoo seriously. .

Theresugetructuralonflictfnt@sttheearFifa: itseadersependoheirurvivonosehomygho rem;owerxʄpolitiヨel.hȀwhy9 hipfootballecsoongspit0manycandals xroundi0it.ithtllprBI,8iinent ethicsmmee,twohairmoa0tenu Ad=BahrahXg臨nay,ibQpsomead applesȑ8fin@y(remoh.usystemargely unngQ莽do(nonstoc pubpinion;pondsaowstituencYHwouldxplacwh=riH`ۄޗחחח9A0us,nd隙l8awqn0iȆ, †9iHabPexp(ъwJgrnaccepxotrecesolemnisregar ѓceAUxrst1ʎh)phd flexibiy0؞: wasqCdrewrlineseffectQimp@ienH’(taprinciPmembᎀ)Xlu8> neut.Ϗdecis( xxtexbaeussi`uty m(ritaxMutko3el :aXckh>@wkGgy(؏ա`grquthuulإtegrPusfs𕙭ٟm.ltimxit bec9c0RuAa׋orQ secM*,Bz`su6Bjclu#anin᭐@siqsu`a8y ye ociasoffil9(neOrmmay jud:esorH?߃ 荰. CJ0done?dvoc18p.arlipntaryquix80goot!ؾnss0oXodu re茨ult0Nx0tX\—P SxzerlR @Ҋworbod8hhd~J`nsn Porga* EuhUqXةayvilesPon:b8gs togeHr 28\1t*2eK!xHaD ch, col"9esignorbelieЃ EU 0takDHňMC r8titEct1(peȁ)oy\marketklseiz u)Z+#$0n98vAtr8ďowKdraftoluÔ#Ass C\x+, fxowah i!Lux hl,nne BrpeuHIIlp@A` ϢX`c wdt\]Xelf۫ꂹau viئ#h؄P0[xuctPoua`* ϐ2 [. @o@gmMci)inve gi~-reqd?avaaiAthublicЃlo<p1ab"nF/a__b_v_ioc6G">AB vОc Olymp FeSupe d (FirstìqawĀP )4P.267/2002 (03/*7"id ="I3R6L"> [Judgesorboz (President),alter,lett,yffelerndavre. Registrar:rarruzzo.]

* 3.3.3.2 . . [T]pla@iffsJwr8ohICAS organSstruHpIrOC caus0be OlymppMovemY* 3.3.4o(ncluditAclȃ_sufficiXlydedvis-à-8zIOC,sep@raHH lservices,ordecis鎨sinvxYD srЕwardXeval!JeudgemSt coux.re887G* * *ggbH`g2jurisdicXrthlebyrtarbit9u m`sign siHeligibilyxp.$ȂPr8(%maBfacؚhe`iede righo—XsomЁ2lodyg) opkroughsl薢zJsse`agromironopolico聀:11va@majorA,HqfPpgeo0p(Ѓl HowAtaʂy (o-Yed Ein-Pz-PXzip)uina)@maki BЛQcul8*̭/hXag nHKy3acceptXĂA)b@reg`,mOexampl1b͵xfamh(U.S.aw"qBJpSystems.ewis1, 138.ì1612 (2018) SușCɘheld ePoy)roh(䉺sڨb hdrnuZ ၑsʴpîgeKAقctePaY@*p0review גwhpr3le 192Jzerl@’sr(ILawct,<@ sdfootnoteanx1"ref="kle:8:fid:0037:offH0xL"?25H"ameixe7M47N">(>CañATPԖxF2l(dsia#Q-:mL tennXpla,u8.h45w20껸l_toc_id_597P_="atp=ZQ1ρρ!canas7R /(h4υυɁSp؍6'7T"> (FirChDPY) ȄrU"V">4P.172/2006 p07/*780[JudgxCorboz (PHntK0Rotbergiato`schy MyR4r:rrruzzoԄW_V1PS(g`ini`f0Kzwas fou!oaviol" -dop)`uбfAsso TPls ()`*ADTribuX. imawo-ye褀iodinep0litorkpaKXmoneyarimpet,0qufi duIappeal%yCASqKfthahhadNJǃc,ut m@zIpeЇ@xvact8ul!nlyure hn聐Ydosȏ0agents, rderedheeturn ofomefisrizeoney,nd8ducsuspensionoifteen hths.añaslxanppealnwissourtnfe`al law,eekinghave"CASudgmentnul.TPrguRat hadaiv ightyaublicwhenigny`aembery.]

. 4.3].Ԃ0vdity邰 rqS,ithmeafۈ]`soth techni(factuactsPhichhouldexaminXH. . . .3X.2.1ytro ,! ypossibilforarties excludel j(gainsXaward,Zlegislat(two objhs:rstlpPmakˉ arbitratsystemre atچern:ymovromjdcrol Vbody:exequa Ze; sedlQqworklo@F#ribuidea ZlyJs8woFȋiᇗуȐsuanyaioici0n cestage,cchanc RNewنonvx YRxEFlk19 June@58[I]iXD7Rb marileȍppHcommerjwn ȇ:culaY(cneˋ;mittGB.Ɍ pelikeDڎ2sport/Q舡,堹hnotisputes rep4 thle8qxadopkP0:FxXsmذtsu`pHlifpO,orxi)HoxuhD4AO0 zdeǐ¥߆lb fieкIv42A]Kg@XHrebetwAs>QSt,`in,u ayvreapؕir so. TPd ЄmHP’ fčrrangRpowffa,| qMmaha ʉ=ny kd"f؟wrtaH.exp U?ȿ#in:xY9iYndeniIuthP# -Bf+eh9iȅvioHef@a(8ncipldrulea ublico0y,  XguaHtepՐropQofZdlthjurisY񌠥 ۓGsRqҾ` ©sed蠇5Cetv9chxci9ieryierarctrucb ɲlhEȋshal iނҁorganis< go`difʛMXyin)؁IizHxxQ.Ե uݘ8hwPyph`an xhavԎ؞2lead)n xn,o1, Dt!XyouQ¤YgoodwiؗӒgenȤ²A(mer iXHwort. Aݙhypѓ!0moukoHknpȖ(aчId(ed0cIɅxhi«w, motimxvdoQdxpo@2QdPoZ(ypre؄Qށ`isheso articipaten competitionrganisednderheuspicesfportseawhose regulscludЂrbitLclXeasopbutoccept such(S,drlyydheringstatutۀ quesewhiYlappears.his especialtrueererofess0althleaconcernederenfront8witdilemmaQeagreel?! practisheirიmur.acPho8hbmittlurisdijn![“x garden”latchԇstelevxon,an IpshЄfenuinpponenȄGAdoo becit(Bonsourome (prizepyanh kind, ve,tc.)ll)effectll0nolens v:"akeBfirst. .

T]refus肨hBlh'd *=IwaivX@righ؞oo Powpסҏalskable KAّ61a. 1EurononvnumRs. 1 84.4.1H,]Btenlayxexpr#any CASwyegm`s (`x`Yshfix,n-rewKdnfoH)oooR89l2A]ran,n9d defeHxainXʒt1pnd@technidity. 'A(ȣtl1detaihЧ0uH枀drawup amerules2show8aeinpved ^ssiaCoup`ߊllaamber. H@irrQ9 72inTP C7r—)if਀)ex # *Lr`+ACCv`S݉p{JsighocHmisWU c)ervݥ[IQgaؖby .latadYAʶaЇy___ZBXItuoncludfaysHont dit)(G׉futsreaswhy΂8ul˥dȇC* * *ggbDle،awsRyGePneXal Xr:JH(FJC)߼߃E">PXsteXv.ɑnSkPUn (2016QholB 8Qjurisdic ’sim@itrYdamagQbxlIb xm0(posZOOL (ISU)e 0dف} arbjatweenO:SUcc 8, accAlaw˜effehvex[1]1񣺕"0yuAdbu: re nyeulce.oiƬthodߢkis!o)ӃhgrStatu< PąRqxCa [z].likh曂r oci{tribu` in@po"HG an x؀օjXrwKOlympic@m`te8sup;p@Qsuniqcroons٧OgObFLp՛ϛϖכt @ClaudiaМ77he ntasn actmposednechstein,sheSU holdsonopolyQorganizatiofpe8skngorld champships.nuchases“hetermy,”fundamental rightbbothartimusteakenntoccountndalancxin aayonsurhatypeffectivjsiblhor allcorned.’sSinclud؄esrt, weP@her7al)exercis!prof(freely. T,RFJC@ldlsoautrpan0socib, whiwquyuarant 怈German Ctitu.

򅪃9recog8e duo4yӅficU ҅prn hvpagaiop1inpopriples hWA-Code (WADC) ([r@irCASpbiton agAs)(p`indQXHct bligsc aw.•لseetswupy OLempnon@eS, buAathlpsnefitomdvagssȚxdepe(air1didumpeX8aQٗJ؄ic8l).astly{C VvdpwahdJ+30lAc 6EuropeВ߆HuҚ.zJune 2018i0ybe Ƌ╂zQЗ.wwre88w8Hp* * *ggׁbI`B3bRX,laudia' brou)@imAwitzerhS9rguYlacked thؙ"e.xptbelowلdeIomSuPm O0ȝ`r؄e starpreviewpplؖw*byby (ers h4w0p22"鋨sigil_toc_id_60_8J">v v. GISUnߍڱߍ (FirCivilPwĀP)4A_619/2009 (0/*78Q[JudKt (PHit)orboz,ottenberg̻o`sch,o Kis@ClerkՈ:r̮annwRQ-known0ysPMb𛹰 Disinaromm໓‘WWT (ISU)or twoearsqpvrakenllicsubQ@.ϵp@l`jҊhdiffⰯ3OOww.] . . S2.3Ԃ߂߂bHxnsactual fXڻmtribu.tayjrectifyrpډ悇eX(Hare obviousHccue1ultZiolJlaw . YeP__Z䅇 "[adb`grievBQ 2 agai '' r峨pchnȴ( c(pre ___ZTZ4.1AnP WePcp=| x,requIUl(t Adue pro@ajus`iaUSipኄiOɹ, onYgnhq\sout[ssodPfriv 71]bvokeXb(diׂX-Chtitu,ECHRQe[T]0vary_.rcorpoosz capaЇ8ne V3Totahschenـɗepe(CASt self.

3.1.1hergues . . [that]primarynterestsPeosef Inationallympicommittee (IOC)ndJvsporting 8ocis eneral,hich〸iderepom valu>GamH|irvento⇀tiskXesultH dopYisspkgggc1d3 AccordQpcalawlehSupremepurt [sxabove AB.OC],CAS悈hermore sufficilQdepe(ntrom]wh8Xdecis, marcp’T,naregarded(udgmBcomparableithatat'''R93 4.ԄXAppella 3imYviol2Uright9aublic hear؃41ɈȇpectJ rpvokA6 (1)CHR,30 (3)Ctitu2)*14ICCPR1enot apppvoluntarbitrproceeɟ]tpossiXi8q frworknvXHedGR95B酰ity,qvieout0n"signia0 ieldRPtoudesi#forto (hnqtyathleB*edC!@trustU߅HfaissksK 661X(re՝dHw 2liH:)wheRȯst*Dpo0y} ad(p5aispuP@؜0gns sofundHl0lncipl؅e(Xpg`Xhozsym!a_vailiSHzerd, sh bahyp@0erva ) hibuâR+tgooZthxensYiscrcr4t0ap )PereXIannullHri؄!` HultprasߝߝR98[9ڤHgPechipXdd ??g9">Mutu.nd9—apichang 8yX,wr(bÌEu ecHumxR.* WADAsp 7g9Gi 99H"> yAnti-Dg EftsGȀڂ) Public-Private Bodies:heorldnti-Dopinggency (WADA) Lorenzoasini (2009тup839Ofsdfootnoteanchref="kindle:pos:fid:0039:offH0xL#?27H"ameixe9P49Q">*upSTzljT_R9R"> . . phenom nf#haslwaysccurrednports,ith peakst01960n:8thattocreati[ IOCedi@ommissAaeW0Charh forӄy*CouncilEurope.owever,decadeetwee ex199PIb!mark@sAsc8als (in, amongsthrathleticXswingcyclh).WWWRVP~Q’soymaxvityGq8@ )rollob9xdt@.n icuxt cXg@yithree9asks: 1)eȄ0shhdapmodifyup@ayearѷYŌbc(fbii!medsohibprI; 2dop,@rizJ unsciificchne Ȭs regA@aHya9iplug;log labo oxxtFy; 3© dul1diYᅏJ$eacomb?JtribuɰK@of ak㈑cchrathletesיייA0!0j@signIes>)nId 0soft-lawҔ#IrehCsgoo+s.esid*s0)~reminȻv0{҆͐Yq:`ts 8imajsvough2ofBanIindeph@ obser .1DRut(:~yaWorld AQDSCo(C)phiwهHt2003+to n 1anuفH4O] 1000lȉ rep)80@(nÑ Qitu[unanimousag0񇋆ȕ bas8Ț״ם' (Co@hageneA8.{2xzSxܴ.e.opi*̌™JHoy itbۉ? Olympicnd aralympicommittees],ajorventrganizations, NJalnti-Doping'! (NADOs),ndADA.overnms insteadreotskedoeignatoriestheode,utar 9penhageneclx (2003)fy`ccept@pprhr deEUNESCOn1agaać+inport. 1

T@C,In,耘codocuatidframeworkpharmoMf(dpolic,ul9egul with(s)ssba8ub@uth@t. . ![F]Dfirtimuniscxeriaesetecidwhea substanc1퀰odhould!bannfromse.͉@J #AdarxYinimumjmaxbs@ۄile flexibilitynsDcir{fach`di0ual case T] Oimy@uuPni,uch asrighoaireargr*anywhoYalleged haОU io (A` 8„e shrequire ( lybee釨artiPbody) 4Stat0rplay[WroHP9orfi .nctob5((3treat I׎OOOYЈun8mous8y 191 g8n(dΛEduc,ӝfic CultS)’senhlf(cr,on8ZXgn—qpcip1|“basis”ŠnmeasureȂ9`domic yQreXZlobX, 䗀is4hэMm.Ԑ%,urhti10ӓ esxpQi !llustgopra cobetwe؋v جc75s ,htex///re *2a&ӣ b) Ys1bng ;B0sspossiposasՕWybriPtrucb5[A]lugc@mbш؃aXlaw (Pit9el )s:TM'cohes, oub@-non-`gM(),disa[,ueib)bop!jYs-makَenJ-zBdraftq.Sh4]w`2_RA6">WorldɮAgy (I).ed ción Mexiaútbol (FMF)Mr.osé SalvadCarezLB"HmeA9GGAsp6'AB">Court hArbiUignASq6/A/1149 7211 (i)4DŽ67'AEBe@e:ʅPaulssPsPid ;e@ePr.C. (London)rM`ccia (R`AdoccretaryrNicohtr (Laussaneߖ_FؽeéӒ؇Bn͕wuDisinmmittend0thatʃisuiltyIrepe8dufsЛȪxinellife[FIFA h񅷅misse ctbaAailgiȭ8h0MFpHlǦyhApel$yglee(CAAD(org1inixZPEduc ȋpursuaXGenlawhyshlûpA"s. TheAAD ismissed.

ADAnitiatedrbitrationgainstheAADecis,amingMF, Player,nd[asespondents.Ԃ"Sanelformx parties`att dotonsiderhadurisdic ovy, ɁCfwish oursue2casetwoHr wsashouldod,hich0'''#I Inbsam askHimpolifeti`iigibility Wan0oFIFAisciplinaryodele IturnrMFhniasanupheb.]J926. . ![T]>’s@unssoughargx9׎f;wob0atopaattMexicanaw weeXk8sibleoS9exeruthor(xi8Buccoxstencen*in 0de withop Yf8liareajs wellsta[IregAdoneuxr oK27.·ssocps0veȄx0 fe@pr1el9r `linfair comp8nQculrem;emptXst ]orsɘi-indulgaobje؂Șu a(athletequ rmmea8qsub@rul80yooky wheir?a@PBus,aaB@volvؤjport)swima(ribucognPdneA'#P،oviewڄ0x,n1(slaxnesCw0bodh???;L98.ubsXIexXdžapprons ?lОcviذڍI violےJsuspeЃGrh;8Y Swhoa=1989owØ@sute 9*On؉ 0zF ٔQ zA!IJudoƃ^br<}(yB Yarbi8zÉЄ pfollows: //re70/AM([tude9acc9shbe od(h#ntrorrioɒatpursua8i,ut 򗗱e00^Hba0nvȀh. Staa_ede rationsre notivalsoruthority;nheontrary,qirolecomplement.tatӁcerned(lyitheductfxose whoallireachlaws,hilental fede^dminis(mpetiÂcope activH.ԀameehaviouraypubjetorialPnЂin aarticularerorouyclecessaribeing U:bQlevelȂlitwethat giv0risoׂׅ*nrps leadyexclus romportsv scau0offendapla0.

32Paneloypresux(empower(repePaCAAD deciy.oreo,ADAH1s`firmase$e henğannÇ1haband"i tirequeutڃaside;posax1w(I*susӀ~topurx(sPldX@(ee(AexIFA8gime ! U3thn̗gP  ;cMFnahobligspJ/χr uxH’ZÌHІ:domac`byru.ɏ0`akꌐ9詡˫̀yMexica(Ȃst ce9rd8XdopAXory_yiuHb؈ȟege RSSe I7ssociC,8Ybenef╣p+Y hasoughbXashԖh3͈1AV"> hh365"邰sigil_toc_id_64gB0`a22\Qgood_gneB1">Gǀf8ts38S crezDofrxom .ƹexamplEngl?twH2`t2arms—S,UK腂iYed aisyhmڕpciXor0iz.y tadR0tinufh0sJНppos@cءЈyth91crimi`secu 8beqbaxdCtiHac(p ir8(=4w؋2204="?ukcodnhw5ح!eKs_ǁ6">$deA azs 4߆߆ق7Xsp6'B8"> k16) 3.onflictsfnterestreecognised,anagedyhehairnd )rded.teathreeqQpeoplpnommitt unrelated oron-cohabiting.

Aԁ  to SporGCraig† (2016)28HixeBN4BO">*up{TrǘP. . newdpublish3UK3 !Rnglq31ctoۋ](tllow+’sy atɂmaxim*effveness (cv X,icht`y8 £1⬨afourŁ Q߄0adopi0tructXmu, imx`d8 owhiȥ8qvextdiotimeBa`P`m9goPpraces wi0utlacQProuXdmtrسbuxmr׎negRarssAPvolePbaf man5m,de芁od fromhgu1ppx. recog#pЎ“w 9etbey ƅHnow”—Y,,QoioonRhHoweJlex*҆ s ghtfullyX8/)ꂢpri(uidjY,׻hldnЖf 9ulؓ3lr4is Cedbalsokacrosc@ grrȼ cu8diainz@gHYunity takxrook)iun(on???;SŽp12AxfA:?,eo,zp,ardȂ񁈐#poirohseh(Р89xaة0g뤠 boP; holcCДȬpaas exclusKwoaht (Q7 f)dQer ologysمxyr`hiole)ǎǎǎTčǕ n ragXruړxR0k8exypip9;7ors8prpncjnBߣسnndisk0nP1.ƫS W靡@r)BJЌy)inhnʝaw`U[T 1]. 7޺a-At aalu(8£250,000repXbAmumddatoraquirZzbpet Їsee .Ԃc:xn :itu purpp;gulare etingfheoverncommitteendecordK decisionak;`nflicts9interest;killsdisityithin ooh;Pgularlect)gmembH, ideallyervmaximumerm:eears;reparazqscruy @annualccounts.

Theyrmpaniedyon-ulsoryuidanc8soow orgpsrsyetm,utllowideor circumstËHourqXeachody///*C0)ier 2 . . cqsvme`etween £250,000£1Њq IthepQ,least@H%thrPtqQwha1xp؊xoh:requi9B1 stic,oyomerawnro(moȐ`ipt2 3.hi@sЁ@bed8ZimelI9XَPwtailXdJpW 'on׎׎׎13csungra؏`uyIRXX υXt@nj*pla`greaX demȂ('pyseek8m ; @sframe.ԈdoQlayPerous ȄiaȎightsfБa ticzf@Rstructure,poxdend d@Eboardc???;28A`principlxuДwelheHowe(: tX opՊi(appr kPwdepe4yi finsInk)hXt3#spokea]A,HoOH f8sXKghbZize;ovabl҃Ɋ,(atиexa#ʞ!˘Иknown. Fur ,x2cGA2no"subjph imiPutr2!li atȅ3/???C4;xhabqf0oyXfire*׆ҟzfQdk{ɡobvi0o8 sY!al,xPR"k(. Ap@OKholuG supporbiPgaji``ihRmay)د|FbiAssoc[FA],$rumjiin @Y22028uranhamp9hip2030orldup5˃in@t argĸ)BAouahuy’qߚzercmacyy makI(YreyUnJCou0has lo҉is)new`rarge؏x minimuŠHxges+currHaon؜me+;[p12Ss̓hTr8y Cch,qi9thalso0l£mf rarȱH!ta@Hy[]gҤQohRC6Jrr(mr rep%_9 ;p.nly <_Mig.udXn XEqu,l2Ή(2016Rincl0xrohϙyKSEngl0굘26!601s (4.3kjuДchairscameKblack,p8Qxnoythnicgnُwwww7pInp4asIoun 3h^½*blishខstleblow1pro򜰖H遑+pema@legndgorgcsugoiIr xym$ Theodeakesumberfeferenctorganisationalulture, echoingthsectorsnt`that(isom`fromep,ith snetyboardndniornagement.owever,cs gonaaveivenobust tleblowarrann importantleeblishyirxes.WKԁK a FuMXrnӏGCoul Eue (Parli@ntarymbly) (2018)asregula| *sutZl خ؁ emohpindduHthowIyHtit s;XK"L">adop]olȪlud harlegis8#dʂhfaiPl,epe(arbitr bohw-en cig˲;alsondi! a7777M777"N`sѬۑiv_ wRnowledge-s0hvolvjyqQunice0keholK(Xeotal gp@3،h-/ms. 1BO+OH42.۸wzis@descripintu^ asekX e:8a@decis,demino sf "acc(tLj//+P)3.Ֆtunate`ԈÏ1,hI+Afe0|dootatȄg dpAe(diĒercХPn-fit x es.spiti Xs`as(oҜ kdҋ*g___[QY4.heoot(xwwtrpel%enQxؐsepa powxistx=;эlul+, npXqabilitylXY, eck\iisppj9/discinary0esR5. يarpr!x,`P bopmb;ur3peIŁ@¨ imit;gZqŀ/ it-baroom03prgseqH; clear0outЂ@qXi8iojl_8nfoiff; recogn‱righquil8t5;q׳ inve рstors;roactiventi-corruptioneasuresdinancial integrity.

46. . ![S]portalsopecificQtshateedoeakenoonsiderawheneveloping?olicigainst, match-fixqllegal(tt(lncYdiscrim,buse ofthletorrafks,fheɉ s sven8(includbidBHcesssel hosttetxhtribu߁؃ns, gdiadcasrighbuiljfrruct`j3,eIYers humanlabour stxardenvironmA!/*8up(bil cy)!fun(clearul(!fairPquxnsparlloc1]񍔃Wt; reinvestbenefi0Rssrooitx; trol mechanismfKs)|so:Ča8y/mmeT7T]keygood(verɖ1Ssvot`gula@ystemqplaPwhichI jodre accountabl culRrsupq.ԁtonshrom top "filterQwaZottom scl, ef ly(retoahipl !r8preXeY ,ՔowAx}+戻rough< orgᘗthȔ{U8.ҙxorub؆beg(ithPimpundpxjpicpFirQ2tmȚelohm(ӂlw(﹧ؠut׋2lawsn :Q kH҇?|ycommS.e@dly,*up: o(gapP(isup-to-diirit 9Uroduxdeszhiiompliapj0hx!ex ȍcxe-b 1receنtV9oidoT}`_cedZrel,viKndeparbic hH-en`cہ9;Jve . D050.Ǎk9PivotзCJa q_Zyngsecuڻ膹ovxwh`s,fework+ . 񇯇12㏚adop@”crete Dߖ؈IrisdiB,by:''re70'D2 – evalu ׽ow?2>$mutusal Ҕrpo[juH-oЃn s4 beiouٍ;
ψψχ4ψψρ"5">reffp꺉 szcrackdownriv?, chould omӁg6d ed6"7pply/s>aAgarfighgat0laeC 7ield, exapcfhnBitJoma` torganis…b“expȝ8.” 55.hileherinsicaluefhistle-blowersportsoday genllyecognised,toesithoutaythatoliciand pcedurxmust9lacogulatus informtect?ftX''''DA!6"grotlines,gԆearAcreasly bemplemed9varioussrgaor au(ritAYaaanti-dop,atch-fixYhar؃ athletesχχχB7.et!ylarge ves\)hȇ0fpivLJǁ/o8ub؀ semi-|_s. . ooojCi9.Ӄi7cannotevelop eff vegrammisoaw-ec sldcvolv9ianiap ach man@ndangds.ovseHț ch mo8akrole.ollabo띪oo+1g8au)al0cess!ifg^dibЃ!{Dx60?9take휨*Hgu at _sdo -flH8worpcasCcid~urntel9XrXj v inasuplHemuhlɉ0mse(gaiT1I8{wanyiol8righɆ`4 όόόE2.a,!)llnXkrituwgg Q.ftenYh@k"A peoXivcomiiTWorAD Ay (WADA)x΃ϋH,PllP‘Speakp’sIOCtҪHishьߴOeweaago,nPs ݶ(>ɀ@ul蒱s`aٰ. 'F7PIntroducufurop8onvCgoodPy Kwzex{-b On8ȁspatviH, bimembS!observj0moed HrPniH9 i=zGyARiahpHwۋ؉%-؃σɯ RalreadP sycPvinrUɏ i۹ wtʖashbo avai seekc0ipalyH98.elf-reguluĦZn,suextlй8q@kehold@y'؀I`byxR̽Poda3/2 utuPe!sȉPenough.Ïcviaj mHjbetXOOOOIIH101_kن󒔺镓e offaoluj)im ISOQscmber(v8ry),(thr)in(v#kɈ@fuHdepe( pr(iHviɭ[Zbel 9rA|on/fexT\ddpoi9esbonudynamiragpoXive Yet*ŕɄw)Ifluctu imPgossibilitz`@ alsoose8 corrup Ȼmerget HtaivlagtesȐat؄,ch@؈?Oiv7he рir governanceerformbime.

102.imilarlyoSOertification,othntalndl federjsclubsfifferentizelegstatutcould benefitromhepdepe(evaluatsoluntary professj.ԁqngystemasrdeliabl Beconomic worlduchcompani(ntrp.Ѓg0genc)base irwnnnbodulalgorithmxPpposto sourc(acade؅search;ypveoli8redi methodology,hichedaptspecitexis codpriplsportsnvironm. . ! zKz8 r0ackastgrshipm胁 todayo0akI/瘧g(yat:h. Atamer,yc0rxwardɓvynew keholYpci,othhmulti-rlat񐽔sKalooCЁ):eeglob*L10[N]ewGGD[]any monitnsxmustictkepHparmp+lmkHfuara efull c]carduxhZln - -puryy.dvisoXshzjudges! OOOJMHUnknown-wesIۂL_pb_B82 1 feaA( Indpndxry,ԳBusis9S 6, (6), ߄߃o6">available at((IsЁets.kpmg./$/dam//in/pdf/Y/09/-b-of-s.; Commi2EueuiiWhitea0n 11, Brul 11.7.2007OMP07) 391i 1Rogeroodell’statementnHtionalnthemolicy,ews,span7 7RQ5">N=Fballeague0May 23, 2018xhttp://www.nfl.com/nx/story/0ap3933962/article/rq-gss-^-on-]-[-[.Unknown

Ȃςςς˂f8"><__9">2. Texerc(Hfreedoms,incetarriwithdutyand!spobili,ayeubjectoXchorm#condX,triczpenalrescribedywـnecessary inemocraticociety,niqPfo0ecuri8 PoriigubafHf disorderrimeWpr@heh9moralpD Oepurigh or܄MCRclosuPin҂rxiv8fide,قIma Pxauth8impart…judiciHUnknown*Alx sPhalleCefore  рtheaw.

Unknown*Equty  7">(1)űHiseforeund`thasro qˈtԁYunefitMAwiut discrimina,nicular,e_Xbasedn race,0xorthnicPigin,louPosex,ge m physiaabi. 1///+8'ǁǽρϽ_ooogww//////PNV6ϸ׌#ł!V643MׄԽgU/.齯/WWWQThe   guara`ew# f عsubjlychasblȹts preQbbys(beemonstryustifi@a惸 1c@ socie8ψ{7ϊϊϸ7'ǁǸ" рame="created"/> ***(1) This uapplies____[7WWWnFO8ato Pa@ntgovzanspxallatwithQautho )cludingrsyatMYuk`TeroryrNorthQƊ;و׈׈׈ׇA'׋'WWWWPB'W'C">b'legisxur0/,eachncege ggՃe.Unknown*EligibilReguonsorFem8Â)i: Athleteifferp(Sexevelopa,pril 23, Y (ectivepvember 1)˶fF67W7_'ǁDzρϲ_  р ooohareDocgg`;;;;Pesdfootnotewwptext/html;set=utf-8"ttp-equiv="C{-TypL** Silviaamporesi, ǁǁ6">Ethicsfegulating Competitionoromenithypderandrogenism, 35 C inӅ(tsedicineȂ> 293 (2016).Unknown * WWWP7W06">1.reedom 8movementororkershalleecuredithi;Z. . Unknown2.o ArildcexerciseH"s uchrescribbyHw:necessary(emocic etʃ.ns rublicaf,YdisordermeR׌eal0mor__Cɒ,R. . (Unknown*Sus(R-Ackermannd р Bonnie.Ёfka47">,qi>49">Corruptionnd Government:auses,onsequencq8eformD 244-45 (1999).

@psdfootnote-west1'J4Abr?;"/> iX Unknown**Anɔ@rimssaynIFA’sorlCof0U:hees@peor[na!alpo atardstZ, 22  LawudPsssoci⫐u8lɁCompaivM357 (P64ߴߴߴߴߴߴߴߴߴߴߴߴߢߴߴߴߴߴߤ'ߴߨ?߁dzߴߴߴ߁ρϴߴߴߴ߂ߴߴ߁ߴߴ߁_Gߴ߄ߴ߁w߁oooߴ߁gߣ߁wwߴߴߴߴߴ߲gg߲gggg߂߂ߴߢߴߴߴߴߴߣ2AK8ߴߴߥg47ߴߴߴߴށߴߴߴߴ4߀VD߀״ٴׇׁUѴͳ߳߁_8Plni.?ASw16ember  Y/A/4474 (irph /-x'p

*UnknownSeev, 721.upp. 906 (S.D. q, 1989 }ȃ6brܚ؂(OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO'OOOOǁǶOϸOρϸOOOOςOOOOOOO_OOOOOOooOOgOO?wOOOOOOOO׵׵׵׵ׂOOOOOOOOOO1565UOOO׳_+270Oפ׸OMOOOOOOUAO׸OOOW5UO ExcerpNaviillay,iloiares рaduro,ndospeh Weiler, ‘Ourin?eppearedoaketasktifao seriously.’ The Guardian,ecember 21, 2017, https://www.theg.com/ football//dec/21/--a(sk-f(-

Unknow{metaontent="LOffice 6.1.2.1 (MacOSX)"ame="generator'&ArguFunes,eauthǁǁ‰8-10-16T22:05:08createdρρ-29T13:18:15.114150277hang16.00AppVsVDocSecurity__XfalHyperlinksCUpToD(SeCropooolh8gg`;;;;Pesdino?wrtext/;set=utf蕀-equiv="C{-TpK

*1.Էawheheommunic. '''&8____Y9">2.tan 0llenly:foharbitasesighPirrhlarly ulribuځ`su;g'AGGGW'ǁǿρϿ_ooogww7372׺'l^1פ׿21M׿^'$6,aragraph 1yEuean nvh`umRights ωτCgς___Zro fairialGGGGDIn dempfiivilnbligsr9anril g8gai m, yones:dpublic h рearingithineasonableimeynndepe(ntxdmpartial tribunalstishedlaw.udgmshalleronounc(puxcly buthess ayexcludfromPorfɄ29intePtsmorals,ordernatiHlecurit8 democrcociety,h߂juvenilehr;tecɄԆivateifeၰsoxquire,o+extctlyecaryopinouPspeccircum@s@oulrejudicdž juse.”

(Y Unknown*JJcees????<7">1.nswha(plsbe(kHddedaright8 havBi rdyegꟈ#ed,hmpe, 0epe(andmʅ(ocssarohibiX. 1'ǁǷ/ρϸw___ooogg'wGǸ"19086L478665H׸W86 Tm “Olympicovem”sfinIrnH Committee, (5)m__ǂ_86Rule 1:ri)ҭKlrganization рfhelympicovement

1.nder suprHuthorityndeashipInaational5 Committee,tncompesrganis"s,thletes orhogreeoeuidedy70Char.he goȉ7GAisQcontributuildingacefulcberorleducPyo8roughportractisinccordancei`Ssmitsalues.ǍǍǍǍ9"> (____[A">2HmainstituhP770arȁɐwwm (“IOC”)ˁ Sse0FsbNNOC'''%B____YC">3.ddiQWlso 8or/(GamOCOG;&ociclubs: belongIF!,Xicularl+,isisv8aundnt(elc'’qpon8elсjjudgqref8Qcoachpu !filechnnshs@dсӥLscogg0D____YE">4.ny K(Ga8anyapacAwhatsoevP bouprovpq'g)shabdecωχp Unknown* Wai9annulق777O47">Ifone0 bihaveiromicile,htures8ncкa busisstablishnnd:yay,9anxpXs tnarXagrehubsw8ȺH5,ullkacBfaۂRic court] . .!____________________'____ǁǹ___ρϻ____߂____tent="0" рame="DocSecurity"/>

* Lorenzoasini, S6">GlobalybriPub-Priv`­es:ԯhWorldnti-DopPcy (WADA), 6 IrnOrganiz4Laweview 422009)____________________'____ǁǯ___ρρϱ___߂_________DZ______ooo_gg__w__________________CQAE___ϬoN1____^_____C_B9_ױ___WAE___ׯ̱]CraigeonW6">Aai рloredpproacho Sportsovernance, andompli+@Dec. 13, 2016,vailablet https://www.icsa.org.uk/knowledge/g--c/features/december--sz-. Reprintwithermissionfh`uthor.riginallyublished br7/> ȃ UnnRefugeesnԌpXOO“Unpr0ded” Mobil O5?4/R06ʻ$H''?)0Discu LsMer Ahmad,ucasutag,ristodríz, MarC1bia77'ǁǵρϷ_oog?wENBI串6c|_pb_/( )NyG7/III.ҵʹ짎W'5/( ̯: ǬǬa ǬǬDŽσ9BI7) 7,Nthe ObligatstbO61BI (vRelngouߊߊ(Uni@΄, 1951) -4ODŽOK NeworkeXionor  Refugeesndigrants (Unitedations Generalssembly, 2016) III-5

Katyong, When҅StoppBeing/i> (P3S6WWCPT.lexHerQinikoffǁǁD">TakobiliSeriouslyi i8oooEenyaTCommisshnuma@ightAnothv.he HonorablettorneyǍdqOa//*Hurtf˄Bat Nair"7k7o?okFhXXBelgium (JusticeYuropehon,ǎd ChamberI-8GR.Appul`ppa (Supreme?Canada5) 9HDeciNo. 8-717/718)nsein(tuqnelFxce, 11Ore59OBIIHSharaRespiin Fac)Q|llenge`_U_7_+V__BJ0">Deterl g/g21g7g+2ggBJ3/0/BJ4"> Before order:k50ύρ6">Non-EntréVGB7AlectoneeetCyaxgg'J8">Asmopoan{σ9AXLegalϊ!֔=߂/G,BirsiamaazItal)ǮîW2Կ?ׄChomasammeltoft-Hahn:`C.athaway_ׄъGGOJDoule aorldCovhrencʋ520o_kE_7_+F__BJG_'W+HYnQ'''/!IxMBoswortwJ">Imm,unishOOI Tsm#21/w/K(PForCzechl.Alodor cowDž''''L NhPa(SuprxPapuaewuinea2643 _GGDM@R.I.L-R,ohnsX(U.S.istrictnRm ColumbiӘ4ǂ/DŽNJenn@RodriguezGFtedate`26?{O?7?+P??BJQ`feѶss/>

<plass="calibre61"id="1ENBJR"> David.artin, Resolutenforcementsotustor (trictionists (2015) III-28

<oTSarahongxU">Whyoesheta0HavezRightoontrol Immigra!?7 h3diPerBJV"> 1 TwoormYeterrencebecomHommon:ndiction nq.itiganchalleng:heseၒarguthaty runuᇽConv,iolumanflout naAlaw.Ӌndoafxe authorityienpownmmigrsRto *M-Ȋa,jcludpyɎle fromtilegPoryb,’Xwlimit rathroughiv@undaPXt\h2ewesn27"Xsigil_toc_id_68BKA">M,Қ jOblcd3ooiH107BKI">Uni1Nc () 1upӀSM@d@ƒGρN="/31/WKO+ . . . ArlEFINITIONFHEERM “REFUGEE”'φQA.o8ppur﷐mih spplan(who:*NR(2) .O]w|well-f1feae qecuiaRra18membhipX aaIulsocighrpinZ8si cth؃O耘unab0or,sj unwillavail`msel퀓;9, Hav9aGDϿυɼer habitu8Pasxul8feᯠto HturnQit|SC.cȶYgg r ]22Af:7773T0(5)Ȋ(xnoongehbecauYircum` onnex with|HhbeencognizxZx!d st,ȈnuQ u;WWUUPProv tIXagraphԔ# nvokmparis viousɠ 8?OOOf/(V6)šڢ8掚yIi//*///, //.曷 ۂߟېgOOML0ggggggggggggggggϧχ1L226FREEDOMqMOVEMENTgOgK3`Ea8t@(gtateDaccordoefugeesawfullynts territoryheightohooseirlacef0sidenhmovereely with,ubjecanygulationspplicablZaliens generaysameircumstas. .

Artic031EFUGEESNLAWFULLYNHEOUNTRYF4 ?'?#681.ԆxContractingtatxshotmppenalties,nccount [illegalPyz6who,omQdir((from0er%lifrd@waXhre0ned X Pa1,Yerah{pw!out au@rizR,ovdyhmselvaela0oJ,Id@owoodaufe/72򖁄msQsuch ΃tri()oh9aiwhichBnehsa#߃onbesXilętusU:ry i93btaPadmiss䗿ω111BL8'932EXPULSION//AexpelD7EGgrd"nb(secu8CubPdergwglBgulJ煴pursu deciڜchArd"yuYo!xWWWRCD33PROHIBIT {“hOULEMENT”??'?!ENo4Ìhreturn (@oulerh)x1(man(Patsoeveru 3hЩ'$@dQOe,8ligm8,embhipʝoci9r popin7776Fbfi҇mm,ow,imed bh6m)إsŬ`ardxango{Inept2016,UNǎrAss`xammqdd0arg'zimigra. Fr"mee⁘beworker|an-binoluutl(kBinciplinhmglob8po t!unxcedmobi.ل/ broapport aƇǘ te҈xe8oit MӲ܊optichKwlsopAdlopmPp(8i;safli|;seuasufac qA(mrЀrfxlluste,hs leaȦjs8e"m deg0 ci-*iؔrtdHsal8ɭ(+gaiSddux@xse fulnѓHnowb9> h3w(ern2xsl_toc_id_70BLJ"><0ϟ22\1 nyl"mew7K0/aWWWTew_y_WBLL">  RGd͠DUHNJsGD ()Ux4BLNdfootpeancg`pf="k le:pos:fid:004E:offH0003J F3HE/O(OO'BLP">1upۀTh3WWWQWWBLR">3WPIHjҍGrnand Highepresentatives,eetingtnited΀onseadquartersn New Yorkn 19 September 2016oddsheuesIf largeovemsefugeesndigra,ave8od:follow politicalec:. 1. . !Someeoplۈ earchnew economicpportuihoriz0.φ0escaprmed flict,rty,odPsecuriphi,errsm,ruman righviolԄ abuseStill+dooA0pP adxeffec climatehXe,aturisas;R environ!HfactorMany,deed1rombi3Ise reasʂUBLV">3.׋eitnXوtoday’sorln unPcedhXleve8fpbipyeM ڛacountrɃIIn5irusurpH244 mgrZiafbIxpu. 1T]Hroughly 65 cib0placluda 21n, 3asylumekq40'irn0y ////NBM0//BM1">6.h鋬tts!n0byp9e legramekhs9sPnrsНOfundCromTheylࣨ mȜ0lleHIsi8arulnera9ݨ׉ljljLj2ljǁBM3">7.̮OOWW ,\,cidop+ȉitari s`mifP,hi0cro`bordP0global pheenatqpproacsolNo one0ZanasuGY9wǕߋߊ4ߋ߁BM5cknowledahHdeiX $ooo6BM7">22M[W]en؅-cȆ , s`!ʀ@dignyger-Umptcepyz @rivourWwheor fu90%t`a # 78BM94.қxz–ǻ`ߡto trol<, im€ہ@mỨhlXble obligp`lawvx@ffirmine pr iYnonfou#ydpduuste(tu@NABMB">33+救soIoԉga܁Zit8iduɌB(p҉Hs@uX y, asiAreviewy)c rxizx1- >Ϛpursaldv3det)gggg_BMCggBMD">4ג彸yha leâaycludQhiH,Q 촺ȃasHi)bqa sHremho odIritoisubjxY’okϘeEBMF">5PAelcʐ8nIsĖ8Pemporagain_qdoa qifyJZQunQojHdh{ΕoowBMGBMHx8AtypDvol@HowisPmuste consistentithurbligatinder internalumanightsawndnompliancectherinciple ofon‑refoulem. . ! +lang="en-GBBMK">65.e reaffirm1951onvpelngoStatusfefugees 67rotocolireas‡nd ထ(rotecgime .3FOIL~WWMP7QTresp0rdstitu asylumR seek邇alsoadqf ƉyǑđ .~???1N??BMO88Tddneed70hwis*minrvParriers eased8aiewJcceleaMsscedu hRexpoȄ-[W]cognizha@xaЍlodgcXims1cptryirhoiHmay⠑guYsubjsafarɃypla@IoonlsewWWWWORWWBMSP3ecampsd excepړaemPam`B0rgy:lin̕阬Ӱ\mїo enZҚ!JrcacGԚsetts7///!T//BMU(asnotetsi`e igramm‰olea@( ouyhich\ldyQnrageo H`ss΄ϔω88BMVBN0">* * *GG1BN2">T0NYorkexPbuilt#bind V ѾQoutʓspi[feXky aysicllengbo.u G@{duؕvlHrt@e daHkglobXschs* peo move_70BN3Becau0[its]Ȅh-gXrnnatQQd]Yavoi)ifficuȰureNHh-Shh( seignty,pucponplac ٰ\yc0abpWakbooolrenH[s㈰ɑTdocuImoytantly-fut8pS] fpnegMck9S7Omit mGa`rIgain .ی!]ǎ[ Priabun sX—tpacruciic𦸼zr.1PupHa SǩW7WWBN8Sfollow rptsaKaLoT. AlexXPHkv Yvihow8miؤBmXcuil!akϸ#access+ W ҇S# B0g Mi)w(2013)EBND">** <3BNH"> . . .nheastecade,ignificantodyfesearchas. shownersuasivelyhat “xugee”ndmigrflowsre oftennterconnected,ithommunities,amilPjevdividuals@iftingetwe膘seiffere policyategor@. undpnt*odغ⿚yqGan aPtdIp8чuunc(ictEEn8b msepursuijexppma0fixlopA2npHpaPB2 WύύMdwe(rq٦facchoimakykвxowollpM]vauciXt, ticularxragHst-(fl)ÇX1in(ucxs weakBpaad@socio-nservs limi`bleك@e4liXX)b L/rQ/لA9nfayOچ-f.n`jym39it,›yponP moniker,sen gebs.-ot!coàڎ decPϘNLoo backqBerio— Gmu࣠ٞȖ ego{@offerȵ`P i9hP脓flaw٦9ղmǂpregimHwellA00ӂD xsibil!lLv I]n0rryGp?|9٫Ќnowledg Theundamentalbstacleoesolvingisplace)risesmains . . .@concernftat (protectationintetsnd!po@to iromicq@tusirst. 1nrtificial separetween “refugee”Rmigrant ovAhe humanitarianmpevordmitrneedypllut minorityca(,penupXportu ic1ri…c.

regime0blishha bas(righ>bHrhroughrocessexcepS non-socioeomssjYeabilHcroPbord,؃kby3Ճtegqleft LreqYpun8 eHllihood1x@npsxPًg-mond suiuɐ֐h3w@028"sigil_toc_id_72BNR">TB́DӁE Rbr_5"/Xspσ10BNU lexer P (2018)*up{Th32𓣠exiemoscXdayroad(be desb!s eHfoll*rp ."򀵫ǝpk,try;9qy@achievsafe8P(usuy)corIhH Sɀcargme.fh񁛰;y ncampI—do8KenyanmbeȪ211awinBasylum,violqJsuHnt`!RConvAY)or 1beyo ir@ Schola؄apolicytsvastXralemad@ numb(posals(onginternatx regime. Un`tueencفMmoityoeot0gur ly iink.tsЉ@bHidhifyI"lab8a Newi(Consens nt[,] secompdjTaXgenlyhero+dvocb w˓ive,T-dgnoffici, $#institur.he0include: (1)Kdefinia shڋibe “opdp,”uts!fleeyconf(nd violenc Ih_isي($s; (2)@sb0gHS؀clop@homezcheaЄ*mak8ԍPier)3)lf-relH replaxpcn9HKimarycH荚a(with dplopacto[T]8" qui`0*q,eZp ah@ducxXdism:affaH.ׇHp sI`jis Wh1g(Ё`npi arn ,8rio efQstrulobfHeworkdd8cqs. lsaasky)hemvHy`m n؍1nyߕsxt sugllY@zs.؈ߓ8Csuc׷Ն ar morobu‚?Bx)oX Ν=-HumRysroughtuiрtgainst severalo@nmentfficials.ɁHrguedhat(eOt’s actionsereiscriminatory,nctitu)al,ndniolah KenyabligsderintЀڀpagree99n*excerptelow,rHighour3ellosuLcamps:qrepatri]fugeesoomaliade principlon-oulJ.

TnwtasseraitdppepidecisItoZA# ,utisispendingX May 2018.Ԃory؉eComhxnotscid*:d2taketePpn.owi ontin{eoluntary?<ۍv CaY4ripare%moԕsUNHCRh3wern28"sigil_toc_id_7C">SNm8DA on HumRtAh8v.')ӞNairobiCNJ PehNo. 227)h6 (07)'!6BOJ[Judgetivo:]ρǡρK. +ȔȬkJumbotreXlic Pividu`0ekylumprote . .I]hcceA1951ndsxnvReYХStatu@fЫt0Q16,h60:p7Є8oco 1981lsse🸈J69frpn (AU)2.nǤ p0sPGIms ӂb  Indd*,D?84 ǽort rue`inh!egra TYCrunishrFebru1997ԒߒߒߒL؆2006,pplacإȢTleg0frHworkɬtatآumpibiliXf; 9demi`cess.ten[ed]e ApȆjhichokffbnextea@Msubsidi isQߕ8(RecepR1trdjud) u#sIy9Ts)ᆊ[T]p ؝иTDrAffDRA)xMy(mip1YblankeZdemlabell9Wor@errpsdiscriZ!AvioЈ p principp`“ÑA.”ApP casxdQb//\4 didoakeccoupf`hoUom seXк;r تܫQ willavj 3dȊHohXۆ:’Pgur2v(~w(d`+doc`n expirЅ7nowȱrwirLJOٌ> ʎȲ9N Dr.aranjoˢchho,(Secret,xHior]̲ /com dywa饸 bhwoor@nly(a) 9󃠀irppnhiê5\xb{ jusemergqchalleng`Dxap)inuXьs03He c‰3acrowIampttackh eomcrafkH,lifarmP #ژxournsecurϑϑϑOΑoCarpAgre8npa"aNHmb2013thNHCRj[p] alpucy]s0`bЃjp8!n 13thovember 2016.nd`the . . . Tripartitegreement,ommissionasormedto developndverseemplatofPcomprehensiveepatri plan1!

Theecretary/CEOQn]alsorthat Imeasuresakenreraconiwillxposels8 innoc*helpssfugeiobdang0rauma,rtxarm an[d]oHbl؀HilifePjrdituin Somasludbygyn9sotundal,nduring, sta warranvoc>pciced circum@ncesTGGGCR@1of non-xou; (corn8tone sylumfxtalaw [T]h`8lectt unit o Qon;enjoy5hnigh(yWVTAC醨lmosmpy iZinp XAc`33(1)1951hnv@rel8ngSuzRU[I]appli4\depi"fusica Hi0y؛cae72eords “oOV">whe`orPdom0uldere8ned,”mteaɞ&PDŽNBP0ǗǗ؉onlyiԌٕuPo8bunya< aY8fecuAOϏO1IR] 矧2requih0e{nbAotagainurila`ډQirmIptil)beؘi0y ascei9suchsTQexiX1Qe,AybA.şyis,HitiyX  ;omuцʩnr8umprUyyY.ȠAm deHmG/G*3@Whiߑ4basic`:recogniz틲̪gm0ceR Wττ5ithgar"‘^y’ۄp 2֫n]TRuropeCour:J`iXrdʊP6">RHna.o0au (1977)]"B aenusuffici8serio`Uvaux [P8">péparatoI] criP(o0 PoᩙiOKɹs udeX٣܀ ޗ9ahriٚo0 isolG1ʼerAIpPꑭXularw*e-ߛe ߛߛn]wo Jk0xFirspPan e涡hQin astri(vnn`Snd,خe%nes3puls1e, racisXinvolha cful aeuoɓbetwAydangeȎS4commuȀga, erfe(T); MeЀu oHhcaЖXsbly///(B(Fx!0`?pselfofဈery graveature.NHCRasecommendedhatucheasHshouldnlye considerhwhenere alonvicti0reymptomaticfe basicalxcriminal,ncorrigibl|ersonnr ,{@deten,psignhnc"hettle`t anZuntryraohЁhim!from angering:!unity. .

TapplᇱAr@33(2)quiIandividuhzed rbyLsini؀refugeespwithjtwoategoriproȊfu`r= ;T]h0ruloutroupqgenчr(lledem. 1H(c Gonexcep+كiQX8 τ ‹7eaff b`9ousdaank0[akin]$toGhshْDIқegW]camps`breedndsb%ith.oHQrt#բbecini0"lanket!bԆiosʇ`@ari gɁsxp mightytc) 1Jtif8nyinvolv 0secu8msteaf휱nWirisk x󁁋1hildrewPsinnoc!GGGGPE@g’)cissviol hcipof non-02Xrof inXlawр+ ogjs4variШiag@oPabȐ+ou!`ituOOO7BPGHCess+Ǯ1C(5)2P6)۫R Cv] doztunsaolPaQc.?-ȧ ((hxacpy k.tyb)S򽿋9'y!ga90thkIfamilyocinerk employϻɷeddvA]mȊynsuffici R ce rcumnchusApsese1/ro˂rҴ@`ZXcedxr+ Ȑ 9fair,,ranspسߖߖߖHS sucfulspfaqharȘ hYs'"paclu2u s ꆨsex@aul@cAfi„xorok1bjifi"waٮ4.jHzHZGE xis Yyessus alxˑHb, ȅDIJvailR"p fromlevІizbodqD T_Q=τibacka0port惑Q“ σ”err[rǗI"> II!snd`rq demyrr_[ㆫwaQe bӃ+pa.e?: u`dĪ:Vh3wh30il_toc_id_74BPK_n22__x_v_belgiumBPL">XX.  ACou8J cZx EupeUn1(Gdhamber)Co.-638/16PU (2017)THEOURT (Grandhamber),omposedf K. Lenaerts,resident,Tizzano,ice-̀Bay Larsen,Ԁvonanwitz,.daruzlaça8Merger (RapporteusuIBorgarthet, Arabadjiev,ÅYoader,SafjaE`Jarašiūnas, C.GFernlundVajda,ӀXRodin2Filtg Judges, .ivesheollowingʁ)m: . . . 19.ԂlicaAh)maHproceegs—arried couplepir0reeoung,inorhildrereyrianationals lAle (*).n 12 Octo 20169yubmitted, atBBelgEmbyqBut (LebHn80aiI Article 25(1)(a)1Xup>20.niwp, :.tahpuryw@blemx leaʡ0egc 镌ЃyJasylum8 umqeGňimȂVhbeen abducbyr`str:nHPЀrfi(ly re0ayaanso@O emph'recariousecu8itubacapbeaOodox؆H ye0hkpX ac KHigbPefsddit IiIsiQtgp8ugexXneighbo(ngnt0Har:closXbor8tw:B(ggg[VggBQ0`1s.T]cImmigrOff,umlrejenkőQٚ7oiyPn 90*L, 3էBQ1و24JJ;8ixexBQ3WW"4">*W__5ECHRidoHequiIxIpaponvЏ d`!:sp(‘vim astrophic’[diplomXos҅ amo|au8hDwhȴQigaluld(baP6BQ73'_im.at >18GOGG8GGQ9G_GGGG4KGG?e9GGQAGG"B@OOOggCOCh(ڑ aYx0obiMemb`Eo guatecrx0SȦr prXnl8avo8any724ϊ7ψoDωoQEύϐϐϐ4LϐLς;10׀߄QF߆߁"GِHwill fYed~S]inXi sImselvakeSview矏 akexcepfro0umanitarpo𐹃,dy25(1)(a) Visaodes@sfied,ey逃shj beissuonumanitarianrounds,ithheisasPatyyere seekingobtain.

24. . ![T]0BelgStateargues]is erligation(adm0aird-c try2aln its territory,ndsnlyςioefrrom depor (KBQL5.ԈX1@rbche applican耫may؆9nrticle 3f2ECHR3iy are*Ћ‘jurisdic ’/ׄ asksher2implemen oxy2bQgardedጠexercisesensewp DwrXrightx` ldollowscorxato2takerevveeasur`pciX WWUM">non-z,(1)ĝ“ers” 25((a)VCode0llsuar3luqYicuH,8ose ߁ل s18dzyso WQichi:eemb(peЩ, ћoGenevyny?''''V/BR02[Ifo,]ust`H`nX/te)#g@8dity hXbeenȄ8isquissue*Ѓ,I9skinf:/18 ]8ߖߧy|@bdYa0shed1BR2bڬistenc0hbetwYꕗjqw (exa,amiconnețxɭ,5orsp(h)ffzanswah5?’ϭR3ωρBR4">41[es]wdurȊaX񔩘Ɋ) tsthroughq1n1sye .ɩ2ĄIyccep0defin܂(yuHЏ :Z؁ȇGFa_pWWWof noon 90䉹(any0‑eriod*it q/)are@airpor ?.Gp5BR6x2[A]Esub. iewyy sylum)Belgium immedi(uPiH`gȊHhaf鮹be!g"hsidڌh{1ot oU.7BR832accordaɄoosa i,@Ye`fqmalfEbasisf Article 25fhatode,allutsideecope/*in paularo(1)(a)re. .!

44.nddition,incelnoeasureaseen adoptedbyEUegislatiwithegardoA conCsoverning issueqMembertatesQlong-termisas andApitsird-countrya9al numanitarian grds,applicbstDinmaHproceedHs solelyDwOOOOABOOBRCH5.ӌ⃚ituj@tzrefor(aws(bof Ch،doYy???7RD??BRE88T]oncluowisoule tantam)owp‑0lodge 燀ȓ basНZeրÝx1ordto obtinފ tecڌteirhoice, which|n#generstruc„tsystemstablished H[DunӁ]''''RF''BRG 9'''e|[xo] IHWarequir~(faci\(72sub=PY+peτɅb#Jrito xaЄ777388/BRH77BRI">* * *׍ׁJBRK">How)@ugeQravel?hexselp,ndckisecuppi0crime?ne setpRHqu02comfrom*Canadxupme CourXn 2015р CilBtnefr) 8_h3wh2`sigil_toc_id_75gBRL"><x22\1 u8a"meM/ar_v_//(N">R..bx`5"/h3OȒj107BRP">D@ Tooo;Qooo4R">[)].C.R. 754?9OL7BRSOMCABRT">Coram:cLach C.J.Abella,ғ in, MoldHr,arakatsanis,agGas@ J0wׅUBRV">TjudgmEwpdeliX Chiefu@— NBS0BS1">1.Ϯp17,09esslQm2iC2BS3">Och Ladyiǂǂǁ4">hre`dof )asVou8s`xB`lumbia.ev y-sixeoplemongAK`!nt wboardllTami0Srianka. yЉo蓰1.ecau؃Hirs 2ȄBf mathcivwa); ask)dusy.oneȎ˿leghdocuҘOOǓǍgS5ǎoBS6">7b(uЋNۇapta`ccrew]g_hYpoi@persሉa hnsnal-Hfix@Asmugglenmmigts ou siaӝ_7BS8">8w+charwieaof “Org8zing!(^”8ps. $ [9oooA">ImŠҎRProtec/wB">Act, A1,H7 (H"1ENBSC">IRPA<1ang="en-CABSE">”)] . . .hich,theelevanhime,rovided:/p> 117. (1)oersonhallnowinglyrganize, induchbeccomXntoanadafne1mores o anotxossessiaisa`portorocumehrequired byisct.BSHBSI">9.ect st8 ` egeffencesppelHtsnoongforce.Ԃ ctitutȂ+currs. QPbeesJBSK0sroughtnlicaʆ @derth(*upXa~ooS'xTU">CharterǂVaIfi(1LjǂFT0ǃGT1Nj׎ǎǎǎ4Nǎǂ?e12ǀDŽT2džǁ"3ώώχww4ό/{5ώώρ6΂ׂ7">. 8BT9">24m(sue'whej OAOOOB{Cxt8ns,ctPby炧D///E?GF">,GGGCGH wwfI">aHnnϱϱsiױ.ɉanswyes,sehdueHon (ses:ɵö5y17771JKׂL">?GGGCMNwww`芏J{noAfinx 30.heecondcenariodvancedyappel8ts iscasefersonho,orumanit@motives,elps`ople toleeromecution. . Char4X 89">IRPAAre؉oJfightgainғunauthzentry +ßdaspnnopm8m0s;3marUBConv߇StatuRefugeesO׃ׂD">, [and]ρρEF">Protoco S}MigrL8,eadisupIՠ@ed NZsÈ&Ts^Org؏CrimedžG____UH_ǁBUIX3.مi[ǂJK">, L">]WMN{O(Brignso)er9ocucannotXgZillegȠrwhipir0ims(pendJAsxexpn1P///Q">B010 7R">[߁OOLS߃߃߁T">v. L(CitnshipJI`()U2015]CC 58. 31(1)___YVNBV0W1">eekmmu@y enuinerely9ord0ytRH[T]xlawurecog-ofgHnroups QworkgeR3aurA]Hsimpo pi sancsolebecauxy havȈd GF leȁflto safety窗2BV34.Ԓ~45"> 6xrequiatory RadopteasuIblishFa offyڄ7߇߇߁8gЇ߇߂9PwX9dc@amimembhumtariP.urm(♀ABC3inclua “savy” “shallffecthe(rights,bligationsndesp`ibilitiesf StatPindividualsndHinternalaw,cluding humanitarianQ.” ItouldepartromZbalancetruckX<1 ng="en-CG">SmugglAProtocolI">ollowrosecuor mutssistamongfugeefamilyuppounificJ, H. . /p> 45anada’scommitments QviewHaspurpP. Ps1perrobust fgainstopl(uEco(xtorgXzedrime. ThexAЀiHizdujȋuoleto an,korOOOOOALOOBVM">51M[Sh] 9shbepretedda膉 sHBritycPses JmW_υVNWWWO">IRPA炏P">. Ang2BPchA ocumigraIarguabIȈآmp___[QR炏{S'TBVU7Bbroadme acplishby9$`gF wo havappre(Wj__wwwoVVwwC00">66.temes1987`biRreas@(1)Oǃ1OOO2O{3(s3th)@q7Xfleeթ9Iclimembersocause ParliaA0japturuchظburaf dilemmXwfearY*qegorpa8hep w*dequxhPmulti-facJexajof 0l-lifase1I]elegislvexem˷ڒpotiy bil,tuhscree*m OtagequirAttorneyenljsaeۜYnЋs.4)]Vsu?83C045sdfoote"="kindle:pos:fid:004O:offH0003L"Ȃ?13H"meixeC064'C07">*up aFoo8pGGgG9GC0A">70[T]ur0C doex@ rn0siȫj  ءסׅ(Эih0Ca a׈0BC0C2Oenavohe overad0Xb߶߮$HW Wr܈l.Ӡ!xBR˫0CourignoreorxarIwȭP0,hiPubiguousHmakeffe“-nduc@bet”:y0DC0E3ԻBmaique艈iherԳ@\4)WW auroAavCcharhqePbrowscopό____1ENC0F"> <spanang="en-CA"id="1ENC0G">74. . ![S]oongstso8mpossiblehat thettorneyeneralould0nsentorosecute,ersonhosists aamilyemberrvidesutuhumanitari@ancho ylum-seek0eriCanad!c`ilityfrim. N]othremainnesievPvictand h؃yኰegagxs. 71CharJ">́u/p> IRPAO،overbroad1e\issuewhe(rP~eadth justifiednd ///)PQWςRȝa`aaAmXurxree)emocraticocietyԐySC0T9. 3Afirs8tepxڝ(ly0k׀CrownȅnstPrengdubitiQbjeve.]ggeU">: pureߌ?__VߎߎNC10{1comb(org@z0crime-relpeopsmuggl,ithout Aiiz,-OM YY d clearHWWQ D2OC13">80{oiAϒ legisȅiəlЂ(nȊH l@Qawi8rightṁo]i1tsome] applicJ>aX ,suffiHssfyl]9g1͙gCz4C151(r{ fendYtailorite co@howQ `willot煗67">always80Иxbieas׋U9_C1A2’sosix"even oughprovisiad,؀nxr8l`hm))airzbecaualerf justi??/G0fPenciв9  HGGGIOJHӖnJtliHburdennd .  3C1K7C1L06.ould܎ lsreadI wM/'/N">IRPAO-{ys) ؀wheachmutuH (lu*ammemb)8inPy*P'''QO?R"3s?e88C1SC1T">* * *ߕUGBC1Vحrialeforeusticerneilvermanf thupremeourtritishlumbia,8Crownrguedatf appellantsrganizeoyage`rderour0rofitndereIreforeutsidescopf anadi’suling. In`ly2017,ևXP.e conclud ?srmsessy0eekerxnd`ictionsqcountas “mutualid.”

x88@eilBtitunelaFrance vЄeliminaryn:issu`Fty regardaIviqCédric(rrou.Usu?;837C22" 773asdfootnotex1"="kindle:pos:fid:004P:offH0003L"Ȃ?14H"ame741WU4'C25">1upa T6HadeenݍPviolataq2penchw2hibiygivJssistignig@ho(r3HwithP8ўsoughravthpghebin #.Ԑ؅:modifilCoER2i{lRi Aj,7284Q?e15ixeC29OO"A">*OOOoC2BHwhii/QfeȓQ Uunful ЍRaer—kn9A`dé8e solida0é,yxcep.ɅUex defin8famimembexempfromiqaew 񶜛 QP@dsl, mediare,@olodgps,Io!sȚQpmunecess@uddnt"Yd @wphelpq@cros-It@bordxmakBway8joyaalley9txM.sinx3,uؓ@ chngĹ\;rgubat阸id ufficiPpec؂p8iplҏpfPeré” ۂ؁ـm!%)!overpvaߤG2E2F4R?e162G"HwwIWerpi2ԒWaȺ(ِ$R’Bes:h3weprn2J722ÃaЋ~GK@gggy_no_8-717WC2L">DNo. "/718PC:brG5"/h3MłK"灑N107C2O">  ֒;PQ4R">July 6,߄߰'%WSOT">[P id1La@FabiuMadplai`Bazy MaluariMʡ-JacquesyqrmHPriMin9r̋pel JosDomottϜ0nuqux NicoMa`racci,MicinauleXo@ ]. . Woo`Uoo"id="1ENC2V">7. . ![F]raternitéonstitutes vionalrinciple. 8.hereedomoive!aothers,ᄩhumahariactndithoutegarir쀀ltatus*inцuntry,sncludedHightf “fran.”ć2C33">9.tsameime,owrw nsurabsolforeignaˁ@o@ aideqFcpInd,{im!combattingnxfulry orderprotepublicGwDurpos77t4C35">10`tBoPXa@isl0r0orik`opxbaceetwee;w^UH!er 6C373ƙAdo noti(nguishM help!someonJ, ONmove }; mAre n?sP,hile ՞1Pwhoaldynly(es.y?;(eriousnesssPwo s,]hfaHŽvaQe M__dU\| CequHlyArticL622-4ustpe(rz(pb(A Ie7777/C3877C3904IPEgb ,immupyqpecif`suchselZmedi؄,}2012}iy ted PlHlWRs]C3AC3B6xcc88uD"nRRJMCitiz1789,GA85?C3C"> Lcrionnm(aؗacei"nec8ary;ڴ9mayKexcep@yirtuba"drawpmulgdoffP smiAppliedٍߍߍߍ߈3Dށ7ρ5E8ժbil]nVhav generpower̀fuphParlint,uHRBQ8 drmi ilP@swѸFil’suа*sZdetisetO fes1h9oxtŽ׿8h ase۝sufpis`arZ.{n arbitrx\y.]_3F74G">pardee𶈨wwiPre闸abro" s)emb1,P'PqexsXruM.errouʉpv8wireز젰rt.] h2wp27"sigil_toc_id_76C3H">S+ҁ/iEuC0 R (7)F'4C3OO/@(Pdfoot(eanc70h="kindle:pos:fid:004S:H000 F17P5ixeC3Q߆߁'3R">*8up*S,࿸ڦ1990tllocs ט@a`asylumxPsodgyhird countryationals (TCNs)nhe . . [Europeann8],such mannerhattonly(etateasZtaskfxaminingach asylumequestodgedǃ’Xerritory.ursuH harmonis*!Membs s3policies,TreatXf Amsdamtroduc competenceCommuni todopt0diseasuresordA0chieve A3Sypm (CEAS).ψabasiDublConvenwas replaby2“LII” Regul* (o n°343/2003)nڌ I''o 60413Also,nu2directivPwer؉IHoet upm(ndardsequalific+1uffuge personPith0bsidiayrotAon,fro؍jq.epconsor-seek.

[Unhe]܋Dsɚ;0fir@o k8pHiblem:,ut)re sHrHex4s.fo!߄ap8edA cepXautomH`transfs}zY ?;Z,ordecidoe?ptself|(ArP17,uҖ.:Bsoeignty-PuseЏ3UD]uireographicitu,omfQ "aighrivi"pinfrastruct*upXxxhuldehdۃ=6jsVItXdoakebexXhheng1gainXΏQs K_ec1-risk0mLjgȓf`amrPtwhn aຄT]@WourtHup҄[1]ase M.S.S.elgiAGre4t$, be aw,(8vuPbX po0diن脓phouldie8liueǜ n,rromrivid`uw2HCa@ skoHviminh  ttQaccanc餭3CHRWW1PLeaPPrA0Jusga](jdd1!sPXsЅddif 0y !safs 42">effettil. Ifamous ,OOO43">N [psred] .Pp 0aǟ// dgRZˈĤPLHis ogI@om H(YU _^n.wJppcippmu`rPtween,Pdm[1ll paipz/obserȇ/-,9clu*itaeѿanye_݋@Fw acR9oʂ!85||ws4OnYZ떵uvio#ߣohib"???;mfnEׇYdistribXŠil`0rebyHonp[N]otuey]AnyC`v)hp 72)haer [O]n0ri“B!bsoluOM (Chapterfheharter)1T,.Ӂ7 *br75"/spanσ1(C">Europ Huights (G@dmb__> ApplicatNo. 29217/12 (2014)Xh3_6C4D"݇g="en-GBC4Ex͑υts,ittas 70omHed:Ă!Spieln,eFi7262C4G(PresidentiǂǂǁH">ʄpasadevall,uido Raimondi,arkilliger,sabelleerro-Lefèvre,ndrásajó,edi Bianku,(nasotsoria(şıl˓9aşebojšaučinić,lia LaffpquLinos-Alexreici ,elen˄م0joki, Paulmmdaäderblom,Ё Mahoney .2[d]eliv8 1follow9judghtg:ƠgI1caser8nat0in'againstzss nfe28_J">~ lbyfgh`alsr Golaj (“irdnt”),hisifes 0yamabibisec(xȁ irx mr chiln,NllivLaush10y 2d?KǁC4L0OJun`cifiرXoup eftɖhrurkeybfrohetookoapo Italy T]Ena Calab q6y x1waidisubjec!,EURODAC [Dactyloscopy]ؕDprocedu(takof ph(graphЇAerpri)f`Ȇy脸t sȊyzfpla@Jecep faqty9vd₋munHpaluthPtiesStign (Reggio }ncepwh8remul 21.όat %yctXsf`RÈ( QAsylumeekq(@CARAyBarH9Pug脨nc”htrue aPeestablishedHg4MC4NiAccord1L7, ons=c#ooparticular0a ka𕨍pit+<,}PvacbbclimـvioaoccutsWWWWIOWWC4PP228o"Yūhuterm`Ꞻsentv)q Aust+30 Ǖ?bsymlodg7˖0a3 whichasZ1gClQmit yo hargzwrl1i'7h`mȐpcaq__Q [next]ٽPtzer4 Novembeȋ5UinA띸r8𢠂McCbecۅRgonngggggYQggC4R`3c3·?[ed  ωȽ4SC4T6UFeder(MipOfe (FMO)]’w@madA ؆K@ovPadmin鶘Myspqdiultn Italydid]ot renderheemovalrunenforceable,” at “itwas]re e (ianuthoritiesorovideupportqapplicants. . . .

17. On 2ebruary 2012 XealedFe `Administrativeourt: [T]heybmitted Sceptionond8ons asylumeekersnyHp achfrticle 3iConvenan@efS sad煠nfficiysHq@cirmplaint////!50//C51(8(IudgmQ9 NjNjismiss1,pholding MO’secis) itsrety2C53">20OICAOC54">@3灛5">: d]is쐩soughYterimeasurequest4w@overnzqdehemy duĔcees6ׁC57">530Rely,螏(SiL@urnnbsenceiإuxg0ecTarey wouldabjec oXhum(degraptlink exЄ5syxmic؞K 0 ar8ge8C59">9expul2Hwer by(cStateayiseyssueɐ7Hw1ystiqroX90behownbev pЭ[Ɍ8facHah0kbea`蹈 puhreng ctr sucircumP,HYbligIxelڕߒP%AC5B 0presumCa paip0t@Dunɗilespka!ri`siirrebuttable. CJuIEuronnihasul҇c8eqWSflawy(8d؞mgsJMemb3i,iulm__ _Coٝ0nsfeXEpi(yxHte.I?WWWMCWWC5DP1wWwTEwwFpN]eirҹCn idžaimehmbi( capacitớPRAR(DProtSkAS ARefug)]߅߅G">JARAspbsor8x,tlePded c modڎH'C5I1`regar l'"availxilQstud!Рؖ> talacprivacy,salubrious֋violwallegedlyXdPd.Ԅmselvlsoowitnx cxaxheir1HyBariByr9mi*Ɇ som,mOMʓ[pPsht upqJC5Ky2ǁW_SL__MXI]n i(Reeث72013NHCRd8isitu (8_u^,bъxl𡈛rf8kaut0r)imve w/w. . . .

114WQCAWC5P">. 3Q">[T]he currentituationntalyhnoayeomparedohe 8GreecettimefbR">M.S.S iTjudgmheredЀ`w)fe8`1,000laces rpc8racPmodatHensKousandjasylumeekers 0ndieostxpovertyescribpby1 appliYistȄargXe#///!U//C5V(20W/R60//1-possibili8tsignifnumbϊemp [][leftipIor10crowdxfacIiXnyrivacy,eveinsalubri violi,stnfoun.耩foincHySwissurKobtaXuranfrom9irian c ter(tHar lQallȗiH_dapda({ child,:famiLgeQ2Cp19GQnstFMOapem ЏWreturn,9oul!Bologna)onތERF(EuropeRefugee F()].Εr@les!*bseЂdeplxreble03PcXing[pecyhysl D 0ervՐruni 7so`uf0i __o G takHchnnPږ灀㕏4C652W/S6//7(W][WЈ8L_s havfir dividuPguateύer όǓW ͑Ǯ2^Article 3%Con. wOOI116gC68P[Casade`l,erro-LefèvreJäderbloJJ,ointdXngH :]9Wee0HdeS sEsystem涨'&aH greH1 justifybXketP <)zry xAC6Bbrisk5OsAbeAsubjecx(hu( adreat\90or ptzerpspxibit eqxorON’xpulsiCC6D">NoubXasear0Ȱe) WAndaryz mighpHoor[.،ʂsuch y exteѹlengthyeriod,y埱pgivҌ2on o 3.׍Bcaoo`r-Ioo@Ljs/,fuKincludc ir;غQnadv 7ns8lleg߇w 3ӔHllmpmlodppeѣ=s_Yh3ewePrn28"Psigil_toc_id_79C6E">C.K.ndπ.epublikalovenija THEOURT,omposedaJ.L.aruzilaça (RapporteuyPresiden9T,.ergYAXorgart, E.evitsjFiltgen,udgesdvocateeneral:.anchev, Registrar:9Aleksejȁmintor, .ives followingZm. . Zagreb5U40[]ۚ]ad nomƊw)substi`gndbelievXRl,ystemflaws8؊,Pcedurend inheonditionsorrecepfsylumeekersatere likelyoivise . . akinhumaXregradingreatment .oreover,ei(SEUstitunUNHCR@garded s(aʅ0Memb@State8r@cal.

41. 3[T]he appeltslodge[d] al8w RC/)Court,lnia .;dždžDž14[A]ccoroc]Pesbligoncompet8uthoeYdnbxexaminhll circumstanchsignif(zobservzprincipl non-refouleq,clusځhHcernedca wחЊima respibhpplPى0 “safe”q himo(susak@nٍu)$nt’s Ëgȑ6ess!&myfacttransfer(`ightyitselfҁxr׌ @׌Ҕ25{equly,Ճ]uprld҄`fф, xitiakՐ[G]i2GG,isߒSmsuXhimφφυA7y(hib2y___xi ow"__Y sp𭴗 RscoprZhoط!hI*n???=B98.ɸѴAsM-@urH Righo~Ιfnaturaloccu;T'(,c ؄R, s0,9b߅AQ Apulszʏ8su,zaur0Hhessiblȴ1id2T0ɑQeinimum levelfeverityequiredyhat article. 1

70. . !Membertatesoune ‘reception’ctiveۄestorovidesylumekersithnssary healcAamedisistancencluding,teast,mergency ނentitreatmhillns*rriousXntal disord.naccmutuconf؀between ,iitrongxesum"S nsfd׉ieOJw؄( ad.ߏߏߏD1jQcasRepublicCroaas designspeciflyorurablh`on5. Slovenianutho ihaobtaifrom * * *wwre63oC7NhInpoHcreasxirigrinItalyGreece, Council]EuropeannadoptDecis2015/1601 Se臂,hichallocSH120,000 refugeesromors.ӎral avngdɀgr`ds`atȈrudes iroeigntyOOLOHHungarۃ1Slovakp!c⃰ghtuBgainst .helack author9enacҍT 78eT F)ingnU (TFEU)՝s:re70C7P1|s vpommpoH:asylum,hbsidi te‹emporithxviewf؆0 ap(priYsHuo8@hird-cXtXn꒨requiڐ`Ńg*ensu1 plia#rcip(non-HementiismupaccordOIGenevanvؙ28uP1951Poco"31anu19678`DDP ,BkpniOOOKQH2|T]?nar~ТXinAis1 Pcedure(r m耨h΄.ysD׆׆׆R3.ɢȆ8onorKbendn nsitus9 hb@dd inflowY%𕹌踓~ posmmisI,ay SXbf; ote(s)[ئ،Kafhsul_n _SrZJiWWnis94ٷ 7.nxМ ;Pwth3}we@rn28"psigil__id_8 T">gc v.犇 bh5"/h3y8> (GrChaY)Joiase Nos-643/h7i(g6C84iHEOURTok,JoK.̾(ertPPnt,. Tizzano,։H-.ilvaapua,͜lešič,.ŸLarsA.(l (R`orteuqαB4hJ.-C. Bonichorabadjiev,öoader SafjaE.ra8ūnas, C.G.ƍ0lundVajdS.oFiltudgyAdvoc ral:ف0YR!trar:ɇléssymintog s folإ!餩[:]_S5P1oiGGEseeknul" Dec (EU) 5/160122ep`рshl׉ʽȂir큑te'% Ital腰Greece ٚ65س_8’iti󴣫Ƅ-r@120,000pp8aI__i,#(15,600 pP0c (50,4͌(54to0((rሷ790sdidotXmo| 4jsereA]ll ref(xI=a citew(delet0 7qincluYۂ70 of applicantsornternationalroteciromtalyndreece resp veallocsereh0ettributedot . .!

11.n 22eptember 2015,9ommiss’sXiti+posHas8us amend0wadoHdyuncilyauHfimajority.ԁ)zech Republic,ungary,omaniaJqSlovakҁTpgainst ofatn962[A]egctanes islPvЁ8 e EueUnnifqhbeen)basisa vitreeXhichxpsersiyordinHceduK󓠎сGeC. 1A7ܐK Sfulentitltakiew [ycosd(i]hax, fowingnon-߁prcc*gq EUQ.B8T]~Ѐ ۇY] Article 78(3)F9notxYS3/-causwtrogaPXus,H薚a 9|8WR7774C071 wk WVdoȋYitselfuppor@p tœ c(y“ލ`m8s”eff8ovAmyq%TϊwçOsE7Fmu Psuffici broin scenabitu: l n@ss!oswifnmergency shchareris{addinfAŭzthird cHesGGGG+GA9GGHGGD8rt findډR!on(erequirn/irIem hbe circumscrib hanobjn̘DreplacrerБa(wzǤGG-I@80GGJGGC "app awo-yeaioly,possibility9ext:Ԃ,Cill,ev, chrx26ӜPe201C8K92ߨݯiilv referrlᅘx4rPaf@ncilixetominMfJicnhium% ligh*taH 122. 3[T]he Council . . identified—onheasisftatisticalataatave noteenhallengedySlovakepublicaharpncreaseHQ inflowQthirdtryonalsHtoreecendtalyverႨort period*ime,parularuringu August 2015.

123.beeldchsuchircumnces2=ld, withouakaHnifeerror(essm,ifyanXas “sud”<. wwwtSp254[C]oa@ws؋ QHung, choi1ind!relocRe8nisman cri(is0grAle 78(3)FEU0 pmit adopprovispasurBPswift (effectheфpre!imple requiaer)mXforens ceXteadXace/T5.seekniv8is takdo9s@purpoAnjٖHwhichIOM͊edLJ U 89ccorosC5quott pdis`piturhP͂fH itas,vyft`mid-SeptembpBЇprgencPitu{becaumigoٍ bs@ersxdbdimi hut ,q*osshtoward.roa@ sig؇nuirregҁcroPngspl dayl___\VY9FM’sfusbenefxfromJmmiXv؆conclud׸+hiH olida`fairj9pibil`BrjlOa wap ll o(r͓S`ݍIciD'o___Z90X326.Xso0`pdeyegedly l rulq*appP@8ˁt@willX%Wofn =ÐS̭orI wgee H v2hPȢP1ꨘ[T]n%h]{ѭaY ////*htwe_ 232.ԅXaP8as comP٫Aarbitr!sy@msҥ objlwnyzDubIIҨ_33 ؼultimlyXubsti0di0rtwH a W's —likÂأ87aڄța9exan 5 5&6>[A]lhugh vma𲧈כppZhأ,??؃*d^jJinmXxэu ؼ`urequi uhy xif{u bKKactuyU׎7 I]becau(ןprigh#hoH +&xamin@Cyusepxedy agpion,osonsureespectorheir fundamentalights. . !

338[I]tannotdlyeaiinedatontested decision,nfaritrovidesransferfnpplixt ernatXhtXheTnis*has beenakeasrary Genevaonvcaus xallegeincluaareqStateiwhich DŽƒ8lod1l?8xpending@ h3diYr1C99"> h365"邸sigil_toc_id_8ohAha22\`Yhung"G9B@/aggggs-onse?C9C">H’sҁIrregul8MigrWithEUЉDI(ddi⃘joinsuag0ssCouncilx EuropeUnʆTjadopeverHdom@icopiXin D2015/1601.ɀr6,ixgony, l byrimeHnihrikt`OrbápujtheЕ umkpbpeopȆ,: “Doouow׉ marelonon-chz@wout PXh΢5Assembly?”nctob82ӈywhelmqmajority-vrnswdno,Ibzurnellh@ requiimn^:tEAf)/Ktura pe)f`2#mmisQFҲ”qxbspreXArE) (2)*2/a (XII. 5.y)daxhaauviee fw rs _Z9 lf-ns@2lj@s@th:?re70C9N867/ha@she)YQ |Epauec,. . .ێ]!ntly,ׅ#can beaxwajزBntyؤ or迈tӃysyaeuNFlo؀@sovignߍߍߍO9.fum0d0,oׅ`ٖ |[,]i0basٓ8t [are] ;~d0[ŧ)<ʩIHywt폀examine,Qa81plevant.:exencemgdPAf`&los{PJu0cpOrbáAcluded Y`8!ampaQdisagreeitEUbout migr Ogainedwo-thirdsfhearliamentaryeats inApril 8, 2018lection,eoughtodzBasicaw overrideCJEU’secis . Tdraftonstitual ,ntroducedYobHungarianЅnay 2d, isxcerptbelow:

DXSጷ0y (1)*"br/5"/h3pp߀70C9T"spXlang="enC9U">. . . 5. (1) ArticlesIV,ts 1.l oshalleplabyfolpingXWWgVP “A0">0ΖlienopulaじPi8j TH .Rea78">[A(1emiTj ay H٢qs$Ё Sd5:]ggggp9ggA">5|ݑognizhcustom1in٬TyPveatat`raX8Ӏ, PS2٢defco(9s, #dYedS]Bsٲ!tmmanpȲ abxow (X )xo XcvBEwiXBb58* TPa UӠaell-fun@ea rybodylsePn1Jcho)imilar protOif販@h؎9cedurh3w 28"銀sigil_toc_id_837CAC">F :R ÃYEuroperbr"5"/@h3OF*1O0G">Ceci` Riz lah (2018)'"84CAHO/6/CAI_dfooteXh="kindle:(:fid:0051:offH0003L܂F22PixeCAJ߆߁'AK">*8up㫥*L83[CommACSym’s (CEASQ)] shortMdisavow`zmakEU! hiri؜jnormЛid__YMX[C]valu1shHdȬk:MUnXbed`k.hePL`Ȭesphuxbe,"dom,(mocy,qu`tP؉, rsgggdNaS]olidaritymongembertatesonstitua“theedrockf European;ruction”incetsutset,ndpromo9 tinuton fEU’ardinalbjeves. . ![T]he failurCEASnDevingorm!observeXiiple hacausYdysfun

Tfirstypcoxidetypmpn(wreckedy_[ curr Ccern*intra-EUelaships`tweenWQ ,cisely,2lajolidaryem χχχP[Dubystem]GEweaknesdƅX ,TveȁV/). Indeeearsow,hasadm`0disadvantageƍ0ext`bordUUnasymmetrysul(g f layBuH heallsYnsuᄰHpZ,솝jPflaws1 s:.Ɣ倫ittٔIoeographiXlyYdZp8withrulHnȀ8lum@ekerwilqavoijf arrival٣azxem,ogӥfer (owhxeTev.“yp)h‚-Hcou@i1retu-ؐK2Proug2ir֜'''$Q SePdUlrXĕinhe0rminifcollapؔ mervic ARsҩinfXQ ᩷70Пdw(worldOHreaxowѡt2rcshupholdk' ibP*mutuآ=ageopHe@xrhuman right!s`luxqmiH n؃hvioussʎHt(heverWsɁse asupp觊fra 01&sSaIΙstooH@exclu1 neriav˴fpspaxaapplPto!rd-kyΊذyuts@.Yetqfdٕʥdohquikst ǒokouމ0]odayr( floXXBzadiKF: harac0 abeXsĄ ОA8#arorzn0 `oryI]narch 2016e9lЌagreˆ Turkeaimthducarge-sovnrefugeG`ce, 끰Hor0t s,ԃ2Yak8nssary measu8vYnewalPllegN opeZRw ,uh$ٔC9o3.iPmenismsܢаddodupvis-à-8v wqavlHA-ba ܷ\< jHizyؠχ74ȔailbleenJex?8mhlsoveal aji8ݰxgnp,lu , P0-crimi㖰qs, d i)fpli裨Zl.ƊAI idpwUÎPA 3 oshunrs+lXdXenLp hichuroဈpeanonstruction isoundedndhichheurozUn@itsembertatesefend promote,othn)irerritoryrelasith thirduntries.” . . .

[The]egalurefZP“basXamental premiseata0_teharqllH; etcommhvaluPEU .ԃeimplxjustifqexistenc"mutust betweeنthoȄwiPbepcogniz+,xereforpeawЀem} HpectedGesid싿l!ortaTprovingurr0EASuƒtӌ`*sake asylum-seekers,alsoSituaormvondiqZEU’s(rviHh2wern27"sigil_toc_id_84CB0">D ҁ br߂5"/h23Ths89examin0mea mo80厨byvٓf(@XtbXg, ainYdeq~immedilyșyo.ÐՂr0haYrhchengofoar妐 `lIlopdon?20CB4="'"bz__borCB5">BjB:on-Eéeُy385CB6wstotEwCB7w"a_cosmopoli'CB8">AȀ̎O *upkTh3硏D@imaH&EuropXۀHumRights]ato enmi[obligTrpc01CHR:Ggre7g`EeȃȡAtra(PahsلRveryii*ir jurisdirJbfreedomsfdn<s ȴGCBFIParhdraf`(Yosi؆memb`@ GB“pidtor.”aremjenc2,prxg0 ϙ8@omplex:ӄįmþGonaa-holB BH">vauxéparatoi9,owHaPittpsaxbout "tzpruouldexlxd ߅O߅KIissue@c@ssasĸa1joint cekeep<,un-smlli@ellhimigQ`,ro(HşwtaklutyWCBJ">le(9diqHnn`i>K1985teen-yX-perIidʦoer a0d @EngloHheckuhAtime,͔abrutmuirlfndsnpof Virginia,xxproiYmisseekdh0nalty.RpetiIraovelxgum:ndIyn{ row!ibeIsubjecAangyviPYsexual ault(bamAr3I3PЬXqagoLheiy6xqu`eUK] ov e dR^ex-)Yngtate,eforeroceedingo extradition. . !

In Soerav.K (1989),heourtrticulated pos—dvfromurope’s “commontagefolȄH s,deal@fr8andullaw”—Pwhichtould heavilye(inrfuture:re70CBOdard0beompatibwithun8ly*aluesр Conven9weanctStnowp tourre`fug@veanorwX2substaxalrosor believzhatpdangbe!0jecItor, howev8h ouscrimpllegeitДGGGGBP@Ujcustomarqtern8on` {Re+jІHRee8;,sayotnsylumeeker ctiskecu_ ThisihibZs lمXךׇBQ">non-r`mp`ciple,Qt-BRnZlin"cas`anxpressiS+ls ncѓdҗˀn/ȑspy.ɉ0tPparrowmق@,efdsmoRighPDollermsgdT`[I]9xt'ean rarC Ptrea timann0bynup)rXxxborfcxdo)ouusQth Ɓɬ!way,eso@behavhpeac(l!&m;__[UXWhscholanspdebIsc g unprsy,ewdendeeppp88h(@?BV>WWC02hd@HaXraf1">Perp PDhad ؊B`hipprm{dAp @sailo@@Qx\bh!ioasr sackYihn .@2SXe 2010,ueڥeZloiumb imauiH۵ቪssigHa؉Wυυυ3RftetidibegH:cep2migts Hch0as,2seeNhfri8rts9usx؊0hȓnGCC4">Hirsiamaa vPy(2)ac0tuard applyҫcke(boat n!(n[,; oriYbe!wopxdeXAundogetwy-r(tiY SomIEyo$ yiowamrotmbx*oil5Oagr.e"ۈ0pveqtrofflagjrߒ߄/CC6>ߧihibiBLibyaxP:y kp(Artic3߉lj7 sbreQulAǂ/)8ǚʧ obviouspessiexZ/߂߂9">SongӚ CAmergu .3 YetogCCB<;domesIh9regeexcluVr`tiljsnhtaIUSwell.Ȧ`) mitɈsu2judgw beeumyA.nsteဈad,heourtorcefullyook cosmopolitanosition. 1

Hʀndψrs.talybr5"/spσz1 F">European cofumRights (GrChamber) gg`Applica9o. 27765/09 (2012) T͐,τ,ittingsDž7ermed:icoxratza, President,ʄ(-PaulPsta, FhçoiseulkenpJpasadevall,naajić,ĆISpieln, Peerorenzen,jiljaMijovragoljubЗPGiorgio Mnvi,rLazarovarajkovsk`NoTsotsoriIşıl Karakaş,ris0aardaloPGuidoaimondVinc`.eaeo, []ulointoAlbuquer nd]elixs followjudgm. . . :3CCI{9.ԑ0aneleve8om؜Ȕqaltteen Eritrq,erea3aroupZboutwoundred ividuwhoeftibybo Hreeesse!ithRx chအ ioastJ10.n 6ay 2009h35 utlilesxh9Lampedusa (Agrig(o)at鈉i`tePSearchbRescue Re`nAponsibiyy#epthbshipsrom ?ȍueeuiainza)\ɉg Jturn(@z]3K2arri:poTriq,Xaen-hoyage,jmigȇh9с HPties.ccoXo2’SYobjecтbe ▨ʁleavex*L30tp`snfeln 7GMin‘@ta┡ɰhAƗonheɑyous3backfXمsehxryyosY4ebr膃YЅpral ag2clu :b,reA( ixrp0H po5fgainstY(m M29ceq7y2siga'@oqDѼ bЅwwq ؆samerYcouAnddحqroto setg*echnꞨang0 lzUsU]ertoo“a iacVoX܆OgucɆ ensu@qapよ\.”N74.ױ`SqouʰKsi( @hoexHis0xtro}(!֘HusurisdiCisobligArle 1 (seci6Ѡ;fdom͉Conʂaxrelev+situփOJRO6 [T]issocYx,boit dly]flag߄߄߄P7A]l0su"D exsiX׉lX)oooojQinoircum:gon`"byescribUnjÇc]hnaularCourȅ:e GnɿhhrguB۵ pibHKQappl¢callegedxmm#d1ZCcѫ miime????:R885.ԅntsрllegedhat(eyadeenqictimsfn arbitraryefoulement. . !

113Conngtatesveright,satter0 well-establishinnationalawHdubjecoairreaty ogjs,cludჁ`vx,colڀry, residenceexpulsxliens[T] Ypoliti asylumsotain*iP@Wrtsrotocol??? 169[T]heourtustexamineherrticle 40 Protocolo. 4*<H22\1 gammeltoft"mewJp/anon_refpemX/CDK">Non-RWor؈CorDr br׃z5"/sp؀τB1胯L">Thomas G-H``Js.ahway (2015)* <63CDQ"> . . .heracticef non-entrée—comprisingffortsy powerfultatesoHevefugefromverachtheir judionthichoiyeentitlednefitP ydutySoulemnd8roreighsetq RCon`phasoPbeeeatu8 pr@lHscape.Sa8 [gggE3">v. ,ȇouncil ],{iӎaوlymhoXxtuzHhoiHi“”٩qsylum)hcXtryf s!yiĂt! p`ii`icWWV4requi@ 3guw(ycep HdraȆ۹w’sGGGCE5">vaux8éparsjustif؍,m*s(pto spȐ{mf"0 قtpdinc8ibcgreؒA@)yumPbeback)oHh@opsndЇhem—1eaȦerfbeyob)%8eȘٗلmMIou!escape.7GߐD6HappilyZ.S.zroyيٗXfavor ew񾰍`rejЉlI-~CqsnȌ RtȆadop )rapos"vanc Nsȭ'1Ds (UNHCR)brieZ Eng@Appehc[ptwCE7"0hwroyYi;icertainoffДne2pof faissJAHrecoy8">HirsiprChambEur@܍ҍmi8nanimousМq`sh-Yj4fg E9>blig . . okAP]ofukh1embrȢeweP qr m?overeъTweak`Hgi獿B Вjacticeؕqypare d(arcoithocxrin,0js ;򽃁ha Hn(E.sracticalatter,ewormsf non-entrée oftenncludeoytateorigorransitesignedo disruptigtmugglingtworks,herebyymyقHvelward rontierdeop3.hiseo phreHas alsoPoughteegallyxstrumql.vasnlaw hevolvڋkexeahatiabilityndeeCEDrefoulennsusnyttworsnd anylaceijurisdi,xsAt `auri cou8ar_k-free.ithoorВwt0 }wileconomic,,ʇreaszo serv`@g(keep9_`ld,ealthP beli@ya)sul)msehromGbugee dexren`havisuchQo|sovp -f`S#y. .

TЁmostasicNG/"FGD8 nplosEG">0Eur8Unbeen especibppotҠIapach,eekog agas kMedianYEasO$combP“ig0r”Z3CEH|niciousatuțseGIEߥwh1coH`!%]bBhtectUs. 1 AНYߘ9,favd partnPhcedI9ꄐessށ銑J">PfocapacȂAYrt _i ;[R]̶paЏfwittl@r̈́im"{whҽ؜etiH߶ܕ_ϡ21CEK`* * *wwρkLhInl 2018`К`PCAmernu)(tSfleeviolH0iefȕ1In(ɡasylum ,Trumpdminis`purdci w Gammelt-HHawayhscribim9 EM" icaysouЦhsafepirdŦvMexico@Zwouldllow.S.fal )`gr!Ab zn.MH{ytwPVhadr(@o$XMlh3tsigil_toc_id_887CEN"><8ǁ22 axonCEO">Dcoerc1hniquڬYageowCourX chengÄoadds`ɀ菒nA(ʍ0’ipejӁP o0r+lsnsYiAЅF missibi"vail]pguxЯ?" i,pcludYthoubjцrpors. w0309CEQboswh"meWCERPقwwwyim__ES">I'ĈPuhQTs`mfucHWQ MaBd (7)* <63CF2"> Asheumberfeoplenmoveasrown,veoughstve remained遲iromeegiopoliticslobalorth concerningmmigratharde.crossurope,*USnd Austra,ight-wQn*partieqXflourished,hiHleft Pentt؁ubepunsur(owospon. SuchatІ@Kt쉀t,dwarfbyabs1 utor؄0imitruhho`whXppnantrn918. Tfacinobodynowsowongyetained,rump8ll oceranfihyIRClnbrookcr: “[ CrnalaDirec]CD9okh obt.ԅqthinkpeopl1euitepp4s gettH 3qumeaaayoL!ioy‘2auPre’ ߂9notmpli.”nview#isell-docuQed throughoB ielhXgduggima`pimmig A,PiuqiuK;fdid opeA{?n@guld. .  4CF9* * *wwq5wCFApWstrdis2fugees?՗Jh Du@nymembSy낁hnsɠ2toouHrfirstrhRnz1is signiriskbsd .JollowchSe1 ChaȀCourpfʓhEur #ludat sږIHmissib`onȆœlawovd 앨:rriz# iHa GGGh3w9rn28"鐠il_toc_id_90WCFB">PƀٍzeRepct..:bxσp5"/h3׈׈уEشpЂy1_0F"> ()Gooo4HhNo. C-528/15 (2017wrWE6GCFIPTHEOURTυ,*dQMlešič,req"e,.ch (RorteuaRosaCoppE. JaraūnJudHdvociGenl:.augmsgaØe, RegiAL.ewl!incipHAd8,ivٲ[:]7563/CFJ(13J;Iraqiƀ0v(,GQsubjyacheckXBy 4du0an0sstasirty{ iYbye0P'7g2g8K95hftoppLsaGggbuldacaaafXd@hadXd齘ylumppziHungaryL6SGGCtook)*wasousgf, sRne 􃨵:tcxmOwhile await7o[N]ot"rulesrbidmromxsolef{refugeamp d\1out0uldecisaberelcKP'%ooon r!plac׊I)pP30ys؈x//pursuP graph 129(1)*upR DLaw/,hИjun[ rle 28(2)DnIIXgu.oohP'57?e28eр28anc"dfixed=""i81ENCFQ">** <ρ63CFS"> 17.helhodorsroughtnctio8gainstHdecisordering irtenq. . ![]egaourtannulledat ,indzechsla:doesotayhw bjeve critxaorBessmfriskaabscoKwithin meanArticle 2(n)DublXIIIu.' Taoot`c1"ref="kle:pos:fid:0058:offH0003L"Ȃ?29nameFU"VS Tc2accplyuMby o z8ori - ǓǓǓ58. 3O___^exitrequiiJ紜 ߉a//hy.Si(ʂhaXbe8ishnejnor(X+EUclaboѻ#i marba____Y6X33_ [ߠ7Y1 makexs9Hز `#ΗfDsymۜ]tafPـأ K2;슈hYa+judnjoyasylumekoWWT7Q40high0Q'//Wis alp*ٲarg‚q8ߔGlaثnt t"8powMembpS oya ohold醷Φ؛ nǁ"V???:898ccHEu`our@fumxRXanyeprivation ofibertyusteawfulotnlynheensePattkhave legalasisinationH,utlsoӂnessoncerns quali xa8ndmplieaׁuthorisingdepriv9sufficientaccible,reciЃ foreseeaȆQitspcorderovoidlisk arbitrari. .

40. 3[T](detp|<22\`Yxah"n'G /aGGGGh_v_patoCGH">N.tozbr*5"/Hh3__YIsp`2107CGJ"> [6]GSC 13 (26p6)u6wCGM[JKakasiٙwoeajudg)joPd 0DepuChiefʂSka,ak0wong. HiggiPK͜|,4.v’0T)well.F:]'N5ѝCUXnseoplewhoough`sylumĝ@ut)fe(hhe`agaȧir will[01]\u@rangbetwee ߃2SWZformyMemPndumUIstsOU)$Se (10gq3 (2.̧xr)gs<ѳid@( 5sɆhdhs. 42[(1)(g)]30HixeCGP4'CGQ">* upR Cwbeook4adm0tiveeasupĂMighActOGOR@7T]ssu脀JIrx9e:re7oShhe…brin@ɘWǓVɻ"seekerstIPрCsontraryoheir stitutionalightsferslibertyuaranteedy. 42A8 C?n?

(2)7GV"> Isl H0mend t (No 37) (Citizenship)aw) 2014 (2)nGand0us invd13)Ifo]oe42(1)(g)orga)**MigrpϏB3.yubliiNGazett 5pSepte112Minexemp'"qverpursu$ଁ߈Cn s又yrmitPqu ]􈇇r28th NwvdeHr Α0eg PssqCRiporaxresidfgb p]de ugeetatuahK υLJc5s9Àp@1 Dόنi '$D4rri<&Q`,gooPeontin0ȁWC (pٸ4dbڌ;oCs., 8:ׇre70CHE“RbeHuy 2munica odelay ˥ivlawyˇ{choئRi a0d rt`0Uruc Uplakwhich3A.”F 3#[S؄P](1)-///HGsays@erЃ[c deH`ؙȆ),cذқyZircums…8+(gs !pplsubjtJDmzeaʷ?ea(|㎊T]0e%Narut2[aurizHby ʟ`HlabiupXdaific쬀sl, ^unH@1Ʌgal琿琻H35WWCHI: nd frworkNposhH(g)fhe Constitution. Seci 13fh7770K">ActtipulatesnHrialesps:

“13.oweroetaand`moveersromountry.  M(1)ԆMinis0`yrdyhat gsth@a󆐁Z haseeQdePDedcustodyntilrrangementsanq forisֆ. ”KN38.p'&reȅprix’siberty pursuants. 42 (g)Ssvailablenlyv ad򇈇haWyithouHidr0ermitexemp.nyah77 siwprovd悘willdoubteduncn @egalO9T] ispu(aXearreve iasylum seek`doPtpMigr ] 55. 3[G]ivrat*2014VwasorurpooverasylumeekersIMIPCI nowurpo[:؂s. 42(1)(ga)9CWn apply1ׄ?]___CI5Y6ootayythAabounerm 8ȄmAnc"Parli`ouldavxolrate wqprovid؂А , y~,xāmakenoughSoeKsreasbju@fi`Pmoc(icociety prxe`r񘸄hdignity|.[T]oo[ve] istсPCour ith e)rubmi`Hdisclosny8re /I6">Mig؏ٍ'legfrworkg effكk_Y oǒ enac1sHϘwOwH7p69؏trequirremreloc c`priYi pirǬÉ"ir tu onxXڅond[s| reedomuarant⡠varioHؗChu(6xrnlawu1:PNGCI8K iUagvPlackyEi regulˈ+cley(ifyh1ߊab0ed,@ilstduygar:oO(rQpse,ojw(r9JoragЄwillut wiplful8cou`yvs suchgX]ˣzcpY N;ќ^88_CI9* * *ookAhFollow’c*,.ganڅud immediمӊɩhd́timeB urhskA8rxoaldargeC5K:etPees,")ngtiett8ҁ!refug:jido@1h2NG &so8󅀆ىʁecnctob31, 2017.ΪȁlesXmoh600cgd` im8cbw8di neѥe8Tzwhctt Ä  ؠH+we.sufficiCd roXfacilz߂@.w0؃aaچ0AXxNm23, f!poliahՅcibxHrOfromR/ǟǟBUnS@h1lorPet#mea1f rrG In4e*ussx(ompanidren*wnlCٹ(Americs<̅ ˃ʅpDepartuHlaSecu(DHS) implr،risrag_mtaj0ne>On aБa “No-Rase Py,”ӹyXIudg(IJs)Aruc+ cСXrgenplr ceу—tRdiu@hPs lrmЄ qBn;؃bo[`yۛ9nc؄a-(iictcրCo`b؈ͣ)eohisolicynhe groundXat “generaleterrence”snmpermissible considhtiXinustodyminsn(Yelevanttatute.

R.I.L-R,tl..ʁKbr5"/h3LJLJFsp107CIG">U.S.istrict Courtofolumbia80.upp. 3d 164 (D.D.C. 2015)p6CIJ"> Js.oasberg,nitedӑ؆Judge:kς63CIK. . .X[ImmignoncPz denc©?ŽQgulnQ!dpgHz'fic҄ȦO Customnce(ICE)]8mpon.Ɔeaǝ Ћpthhol%-%^CE" 0nۦ]i3[@" cit!m8 Psfac8}wounooangQerQrrsHO}likelyrbfuturА6Y{SxI(CE ni8set^߱n XcdyUfiy4Perb䚬[ha{op;Jsq_ judg#DetzJXS['DM NIJM u`st( uC)*'TTqXnamPltiff0Rmemb0 QeekH Q큺capГ`childrflsee vincu"{irà meromxou.nf`i2014frossborIhĂ[y )oupocufamiPu ehQ*U.S. BcProte#(CBP).(Z@2,gh0refer(expedited reрmovalroceedings,achubsequently8nostablish “crbleear”fersecution.hathowade,laintiffs wereransferXndarde.

. . .ņQpveryamiqasfusboafter@CEustody hdetthearnesountyesid0iFaciliin Texas.lthoughllpreleaysIweeksr monthsas`sulpfJm-eminas, ’s`i(8sormBcruxqx#. VInsast,aysnindividupzed essmRfirotflightiskdang8xP commuy,major Hsuipۋl@8{owncognizanciabrupPbout-face occuinune 2014,henHSdoptnnp8n0No–R PolicyaPppons(oxpimmigr[fromÂX America[,]tdiPt[`!offic00 \[no`with orhildr@ordeAfutupBJ0Opanua6,5brHK-acsuitqthis rxegH, )lia,ٍWpS viopIWJNZPxAc(@DuslahnstiteȆ 'kps law2arbiqcapxiouH#u]es iagenLunxjAdhistivdᆱ[(APA)].ġ?<2Defehntsap!Y"are gg/J3">r80dKollowb! ~4J4">MatH DJ 2(2003),!whihn-Attoyen2JohnshcroftldښcmH`uHbЍ𳨣makX #WPmimoreoxixP 0Pappe,;ninflux aЅYsHhwest tɗUsupport[s]&-eZ Y.5ؾcchl s sfi픹h򜜅aggV8ou؆ㆎŃplayض0x rolYeXrgeumbxgdNn2 1lunam(6Ϭ’2̫gaNAyzOJ .ikelihoofQ ӵ`ȊptgX÷pum17ׇH 7pssiWWmadursuY8.S.C. § 1226(a)Tggge7|Gn"no;P[Ses]ܨls` liÉExec(ve[iscre,ro@it eُ!e4 mayǠrpo0utholʮxt[ed=§  _ߌJ8i> Becr*ru$sX)HOe,Ϸ1guesptl)f`J9">Chevron![ׁCJA">Inc..΅hRe0rsncil1984'$Brais"virtuʍ8߅C">Zadvydas Davis1re``analogoHprox P,/*31(6@T1sayi whoXvexeQpremdždžJD">pR= beyoekhi(hfiea,heubjрecto [certain]ermsfupervision.”heovernmentontendedha he pro “setoimitЁ@ength!de tand, refore,ttorneyeneralaotPdiscre wheaowongX1,ven酠finitely.

Supremeourtagreed,PiPcardinprincipleh statuhy 0pчzІaCressaises seriousoubtsitsysti0ty,illirst asrucf⅛esairlyossibbyichBquemayevoiؑƄ#helw counotɄ,oXite;, . . . § 1231(a)(6)iplie st- oval-iod1areas@bnecabgbou!H fromUdӇ8esRZFZadvydas4cleaQfi ҍ` cpffice)ju`fnohtizenwaXng immigh!cs:)9ligh*otIcommuy"ړouspecialdanger` Itxplbecausho0ppPlegmdics wZeakrqexis #ppʍ777JH">A ,/:d,yns. semphasIsa ///CJI">Dv.imB(2003) .lugJJp ma9G餍crЇq8.S.C. J26(c), LWkg`@miskrSYWPĞ{Knj·Xevmxb[* hwhoQcharacica)`imselfin8gi`/JL">beaedG9nm [1]mxarxuladividuc IakYQgQrئ3o C`rAmqos)xnǎMslitogSu0d`sQ.n discu Ritybroadly,as18 gene砣ms- N[T].dِIuЅؐhubsta(XÎ0QsB`secur,bKaphcipthrȲ:[xomicurh@argues . hICEا0escJSXo`o9oyees.not,ow@r,ffdxy@st Wwouleav(cyome sh-d18d޹dda- al0eelл;ca(sneonjΘ==wrongdoers,ƒ2hlegmosylumSXc`try. ǚWWWJOPPx0ffsSaignR(likelihooucceeڷ ts {ꔾav3cxY@(XPueIvpsp 0ee l ry-injuncbforsPopblishBexr[1oˑyPpe0jux@@ch_CJQ">ynɶrure XcrȦٔequiAQ0oJ!i0m.)\asobP gt;[0pAq؅QȎZFȹȎ3 ݃ eydiation.р”

Plaintiffsaveatisfiedhisnquiry . .!T]hevidence ey presentuggestsatargeumberfsylum-seekingamiliesrom CralmericareurrlyedethasultDHS’s epolicy.uch8ionrmsut0hea myriadays,nRvariou9nthealthxper`ti,t particu胩fuloinorhild@___[SXCourtillra(oI@areliary Injunc:ProvispCBC0c$(yefendP aDismiss////(T(Inay 2015,CE@noiouldot((reneɎ fact in8stodyiinvolvWeXTes R.I.L-R.ohnsongreo8Z.n tؕQr,governH ms whenishxmpr@iLMa gggndnPtury insVah9w"S랢Ѕp Cxnia(* hviolq)of1997GGCK0">FloSettle—oduX85 j-ɅlawagImmiЛ.NazServ (INS,hoseseHnsf 2003)allengPacyWP'Є amokng"leaȂ5"׃o “withoutnnecessxlay.PɅyMٌK1i>il6eyS7trguq: app no-dQaccompanI- qir!0xZa87.d 8x@?9Syj gFatryiȌ३otak@gerx jneyh(UniS٪\72rejec3is ْ" ls,Mc, unlPocXбlighrafetyisk.σ(pp K2 LynY(h6)kANh CircupД?׈ orbre@sϳlu 򕎝P!scop̈́'t?߯?38 TrumpdHhptinu upe jfuge Qarris0n. spp8foP\thhgh irilsecu se`ũnunnul s 2300im(you@whadultȅ2sholdfactmad n:(headlinI9exampl1XO(i8,banncؓ(Mar`Cab0 yI`eXly _pregnȎpї@asylum-seekЉdh subamAc(-by-AD,nown U.S.9Hole4 addKquesc读bsHfXxax=,s@zsibe( qtB߀h#poYA 9follow"hpssib9jÀXrh(Є&—Ɏ+ʕ``timehhp"usedxremAnwQY jupruHce,h35wx28"(sigil_toc_id_9ߎ5">Jennings.odri! Supremeourt ofhenitedtates138.t. 830 (2018)_Yp/,6/CKC"> JusticelitoeliverІ)opinion . .!/z: 8bC. §§ 1225(b),I6(aHyjc). Se=ppz@rǡUniS`e`񟩧be.ԅ“:t[s]I !s”60pȎ 8y jllow9n'؇OL"HEpeHiewr*Ad?}Hsi؂p҄; @y:asylumx(ѥreferrЁʄzA.ɞSK ;c2WV,shݢ1 փm.L a3sam\1R.I.L-R婨l. Johnson,CKJ">supraiOǒNco(Yera8imes҆KK">ᅉȁaa a0+tex2ی̽m,oҿ` lgga ֓0io؃s—,fhXfrequency bears ဈtheurdenfro0athese hearings.]

Txprimaryssue0ipernterpretatio§§ 1225(b), H6(a),nd6(c).MResponXtlejroodriguezQaexican citizen. Since 1987,eahlsoeawfulerman resiRUnitedӇes.n@l 2004pf_as convicrugPfensefaehicle,RGovernm)d@inhimrxsough`oem:fromBcountry. Ats#al,r8dothؑoIbl,aln(veligiqforlief JulynmmigrJudgerPporaho.hoappedecis Boarb)s, tponthsYagreed ҃χsubjec:datovOag8, DžseekurHyviewimet@on"CoX!ċ2)NhircuiHi*’sPO. . .W]hi'till g(Ol] f`@be@EDistr5 CrЀCniahllegcitq b(he2x`؞jufiedzaqsoli8wia0,imilar bbrbygarcBog(yvAz cerIc2P[T]9ollowj:߂re70CKQ“[A]non-s:m o: (1)183longsix}pursuaxoneyygeneyiatuxndjomplXҧ԰rocIclujj8pl(2Ïhave i"6_0security, q(3)fd;(iraG”ǎRN,в2@ev vBs—§§5(b),(aH jc)(doauthor h0ϵ.bse!n i viduzjOtpic1(؄ncȇV"emberʄx' A ta-requiˇh@ ouldioueЕPClau|Fifth Ad.* TwwmisappdzcaninhiaXbecau@its interpretaIthreatssue@rere impl8ible [S]ubj8nlyoxss@cep, §§ 1225(b) a؀`6(c)78lePca edsT] XnouXfpZfornyrirems`Gay0n§ a). ǍǍǍ2SS-ivides<a[d1]8two eg`eFirst,erta@e imؚc9 persecderpm(1)shallPYYf )rˑċgsylume fٛҘcopeQW(2WWTa [oval];Bi///+3(Readostat9lyU\thmءͅ?save1cluded ׅׅׅ4Nog`ex:ׅфHno 0HiafixHnth_ggf5Ypott<קѢ{donotiv(zstowX sPuQsle(I0mXoychoos[e]twecompeorTo8evail,)pXRm8showˍMmayȄSy@ rYic6-pt.yȋ attempdefIbljOljK7InchamenerתПignoOʏ7L8">ZadvydPv.a (2001)hs ؊rSХ8oftti "f .CL9,jȌ)sј. . ߃A[A]e҅(uxsYdi(nguish9׿6؀غ(cromφσCLBφU31(6hWhiׂׂLC׉foCUI8ambiguous3X9s#: BЈ~?@o0"zyHi0jȁSonXrhcircumxncQA8ulne`s k0^׳''D Fihe6ۜat]Atney Ge`ia[aFՄ 8؁pb ئdi|paroleFeregul[s)JcezhearІ1outseʊfljljljEToropnm@cedu Xtecjgoeeyq)in𐐞d byxK7N@y—which say𕑄Rꎢ@a೙m@supporpmposHКrequiȹ閇nj7CLFJXagtookAYc r܃77770G7homhʀGorjh},Acur2RH Justicereyer,[whomʀGburgndSotomayjoin,ing. 13CLJ T݆adtua:biddail,x ʀarx,)sedividuals[T]he majoyrinterЃrikelyx unctihalfolYthis longɆ praЊȃ؂jruÃ%“havoidRonYclus2isτutlHgridoubts uscp.”hrequi ,*umptivafixonths,fineQxKzFirstT^jcaamemberњ`speciJPn itizenXmpor8t(1) arrူurorseeksylumr (2)committedrimX ҉8ishserv񤃛y9ڄ(on{Wȏ( iko@ (3)xiere tlГqni9S8QHHn ,ʧRa8Rߐg?g;M`WWLNPh,bon(thyߠǰQb a8om†831ays (nh2۩Ia]lf ys), 512B, 456U2, 354U19V8S 27—b:wҵXs"rece zOP">Six;"A E9ftak0ohod( rax {wpQR">Eighall!heb?e geophi(und ǚST">NircumφysimilPZ x3manyj UCilev1languag@Ivaluy protect TFifthds0[n]o8sl bede1life,0ty,Y t{oduʊs awԑi!胑kTooim>ځ`top bodiD,`e0noӄzedh8-H dʅ납X DPlauseitself8flH<Why shouldengagenisegalicere?

. . .eani.onim .2thatersons8Ii!enitedtates totally*out ctitu!pprote#Freedomr(arbitraryetenis anci@dmportya you Cn’saries3 Tmaiwhe@rt@ossibl1ad"sute*urizingail.sPsiraㅟinterpre( ofaye<`sop0fpat itanguaYfW]e\[]G% o(pvissquiрcȇPs`c(of longȏ7violex' or7sicurЏ46overnQfirst[ynotizens:ylumeek,]ay,hmmigr “of er irminQtime”ahiviewцen RoPp[]蓻rh( fearec:D[M5"@!XedYr furQideLpplich.1IXve emptheordnamely,a'$BDo `see???M6">muɘ1OL7✅8Ȥg#islveis revealCsuchgreFnșAmolik8ЍZ abs„X*bevӅe,l،Ӂ}HewT]Act0ggӜeGr@腸fhshickly@!ʥ (six8nthknowTwo-ȭbwx*iapuiˆm disH,packoot@0RItb׌didoIbn 'mQ)—uppradon,AtexXIced"sAv3䂿doh2wx27"sigil_toc_id_94CM9"><22\1 in_defe_of_b0?CMA">Inā#B#RŁsΓJћ(tricQ David A.͆ (2015)*8uph3WWJPMyeagonҽpfImemorable匨ofeisksrom!rce(du` public’xeg GGGK@Aou`lawyer,I(cȃxXficnewumrighbauaSpehp҅wɀHrHgn4ZRefuge+ 1980ough?drw8xai had (iѱXupportPenashch,J8mh9ieloatli8Cuba0hi(bqure๑du`pur1.urfy ƻed25,arrSouFloriday, haotru*XdvcreenX9irohscensteadyarragefngry,9uished,isgustYconcernX orituperativeailohetateepartment.tlsriggeredalls f8repealbrandewefugeect,venough:ad littledoitunderlyingroblemsatusJoatlift inapvidaretterecisionmakstructureor r [W]Hs0apvPilsimmig onnpce, ȅyheyYPrapidropul" unauHriz8nts lohmmunitithroutn*, cmoaum1czlegis.samPime, nowpacz$tfulovHeffeness. MMT8<Ѕpntbamahis8n) hQsumm@2014狘hiyllp`heirkst SimporЇolutets0 t1orp 0holdublicxpI keJgh o poy.Ԅ(Whi`He’spqarchn obj3uڡPiodas@winngal (ormo`wouincludoaegzC(m,xssЁoil,RgPndworkbHP0lxecu,NB(a0j powarlaccep8Cل,hc 1urina0guyulRecHum:8ld b`nrriv1fromÃYA؆—slonnd XHaniHfamime↠ڙ o wQno@rco al(B Patrol)] (HuseeJoffiu2`)mselvXi0MPxM̋Cmoai҈manⴸs0dopeڹ 8bYarI0`lacLe .ТOOyWP quickMQIiqe1alsa,'cinnzn[^ӈЉlargc*czseIρpcas`peedhCpla@mo󄜎wwh0receHdz+Y!sub!tihity$0tP1snhXo܃ҼR xXȄsi30g(e(cؙMexico)xh0risAafx9rxmeasuieahaXsuePucflorabqtؽwhe2鄈Шhс0e!aЃbeΖOOOKRH[T]hunchar80xBre)1Obama/ exin”؏ogn :ig-moڋAedɠocu popuc0 if܁'exhibno siHvisinetrowthP’B(ad(ss Novz 20, 14acknowledg“a`pike un'd”Жumعssٍ b82quch˸yw@Naest )bؘwos. Whyoeshetateaveheightoontrolmmigration? Sarah Song (2017)*8up>h3؂3CN6"> . . .ansuggesXhatelf-determinJsotnlyn elemeofustice;t1alsoaridealademocracy. Trinciplei'&standsor pro`iچaropeoAhas"r%makeHswn decisboutolicies0d0ЁH.ӄw imrulxInh[law,W snderstoodߋStoЁÆccollectiXdpiny ghGcs. @oyU WWWWWSA V*G///(G-ezokex\+2+moXtAarcPsaȦ򁌂"arȨ%alHdiD8ccordxyq2membhipmqgRwe lepsymcauiʀusuo@Xo`nll ށqor??M ׏׏׏H"> First, . . .heoderntatesprimarynstrumentorecuring 1subntiveightsndreedomsoitu ofemocracy. 

Aoreasonzboundxccoro"aries territorialhaooith wNK">solitSԈi notimplyptcisimak)(aean k;talso8key @,ru participat .ċ׃happeYinvacuumut relCachetworkᆑ؃lay}rolerekmmoreike)moParoup)peopwhomogerpe(dIҋbhinfractu؂0?HshaOJpoBXculɆL?;L0rl z)sHcusnecb@eenz irCNM">Pre(xs3 mbІXuspfibMpystemwǔa 7knowdvanceWWWCNNXhom Ɉ(GGwGpOAjanybj{qaih ab,cluBiPbclw)involxerqcoYvewov(membernon|BȞcj@J lu2Ѐ [W]hi Igpvat Lc8"tho(ܗ}<,dis+ꗄPBjڀp tak`1que9nchXggrsY*yP[T]u’sKntm{a@risdi◡ qndЂa)imh؁شorؙhrrvQaytP 9n HidȩȕX<3}XXy@finAself-gn*sos. NQI25{l0fyRL ထargТۘHѠlimd.nursuquPwhmo hXߏȗ haqprovdXsi,ȧshoul !e1gaAˁ ntQr?o ssHe%nsؑX@onXpH yՎmunh,Џ@cԱ ٠؞@'CNRhr`o!basK1n—quirJbcy.ԉ1is ???NS">h sajHQbsolu!tPi“trumps”Ror^?xmlЄ0.0" co="UTF-8"?8ht8Xnhttp://www.w3.org/1999/x!` Unn 1G.A.es. 71/1,ew Yorkerationor`fugeesndigrants, ¶ 3 (Sept. 19, 2016)pȀ8?xmlersX.encoding="UTF-8"?8imlnhttp://www.w3.org/1999/x! UnknownG.A.shy071/pNeworke`forndigrants (Sept.P,016).n,JUniNalutth0fi draftGlobHCompacjafe,rd@yBRegu0 IadopbybMembepin逛. 'ǁǰײρϲ_oo 1Global8gration Gov ance:eyoCoordin JCrises''' 5">inQ TheCommunityearbookfɘa LawJuprudeUnknowP{LOffice 6.1.2.1 (MacOSX)genePor' ArguFuneJosauthǁǁ‹-10-20T22:08xcreatedρρ-29T13:18:36.839972523hh16.;kAppVsVDocSecty__XfalHprsCUpToD(SXeCropooole8ggߵwBJFUCװ+5/UCϤϵ赗TL䵗ǵ**onvention, 56 Columbiaournalf TransnayLaw 296 (2018). /p> Unknow({metaont="LAOffice 6.1.2.1 (MacOSX)"ame="generator"/''"ArguFunes,seauthǁǁ‰-10-20T22:08:08createdρρ-29T13:18:36.839972523hang16.00AppVsVDocSecurity__XfalHyperlinksCUpToD(SeCropooolhare8gg`;;;;Pesdfootno?wrtext/;set=utf蕀-equiv="y-TpK1772߁P4">Article 25 ofheisadeEuxehUnrovides:r a5rbrtx/;1.9with`mi horivdhallessuedxceply,n"fol( casׅׅׄ8LJ4VG9/=A">(a)heMembertoncЇ(Ps rstecessarynumanita(nroundHfor Hs&iprr caus.obligjs . . ___________________'____ǁǻ___ρϽ__________ǽ_____ooo__g__ww__________________MBGP___nj)/_'-轧!7⽧ǽ*u0PP8~fGBOG23WTvؾyon Hightsn770ǎǂǂǂ7_G2_(No onesubjecorturrqinRqdeg\raa tImpunishqZϷϷϷϷϷϷϷϷϷϷϷϷϥϷϷϷϷϷ"/>  ǁ2018-10-20T22:08:00createdρρ-29T13:18:36.839972523hang16.00AppVersionVDocSecurity__XfalHyperlinksC="LUpToD(ScaleCropooolhare8gg`;;;;Pesdfootno?wrtext/html;set=utf-8"ttp-equiv="C{-TpK**TrA tosylumhalleuaraedithupespectorru, [Genevaonv0H]ndnccordancekTynqcingǁՁ. . . .___\7阰8?xml.pencod="UTF?8Qmlnp://www.w3.org/1999/x!؟%Xtitle>Unknown7gg4𰟎ϰǂǂ7_H6_8">No onesubj@ؼȮtureﻠohhumppdeg\ra!8 ipunishq7777777777777777777W'777Ǵo7777ρ϶7777777777_7777϶7ooo77g7g7waontent="text/html;harset=utf-8"ttp-equiv="Content-Type"/>

*Everyone hasraofe,0bertysecurih\pers؀ـx ۃxbeeprivereexcept遠ccordanceithpncipfundntalustice.g 7ggg18?xmlxX.encodi9UTF?8mlnpI://www.w3.org/1999/x! mXtitle>Unknown guaranB fu:itubjHnlysuchaable(mitsescrpdy@wshJmonstrycfi@A惸 1cicociety///////////////////O'///Ƕg////ρϸ//////////_////Ǹ/ooo//g/_/ww///////////Ǹ//////dR42S///?7////./////L/003HC" id="sdfootnote13sym"ameai1R42S3">* Section 117(4)fheanadianmmigraandefugeer Actrovided: (___X2_2S6">[No xceedingsithoutonsent]oyfor؇fencender thismayenstitutedxceptyr4ttorneyeneralɊa. Unknown

**Amotto 4dRepublicsχχχ Unknown,sp_ʄ_XEUawhysis0>eb. 20, 07WP7">availaiat \eulawa .blogspot.com//02/h-d--ecj-s[-c:..'ǁǴ7ρρϵ_ggooogg/wO"ype="text/css"/>

1UnknownWithiewoicipatinON . . ahba2Aony,mayexerciseomeits compePc8Xut5OlzjoXlyorembeStHthroughs(ubφ͸ W687WWWggggggggggggggggggg'ggggǁǸgggρϺggggggggg_Ϻgggggooogggggwwggggggggggggggggggf1PMQggg׵w+270gפ׺gegggggg1IMg׺aoo^iwtXIV____??___note-western2"id="21PMQ6">(1) . . . ForeignerstayingnheerritoryfungaXmaxnlyexpelled obasisqaawfulecision.oXctivulhallX prohibited .

Unknown

*litmus`pт#ann(MOSEʀMonet Workshop, 9ǯǯǯǯǯǯǯǯǯǯǯǯǯǝǯǯǯǯǯǂ''ǯǯǯǁǭǯǯǁρρϯǯǯǯǂǯǯǁǯǯǁ__/ǯDŽǯǁǯǁoooǁggǝǁwǯǯǯǯǯǯǣOǭOOOOǂǂ

*Alectone Sweetndlareyan,osmopolitLegalrder:ant, ConstitutionJupce,ZtheuropeHven9numRights p(203-246 (2018).UnknownColtivHexpulYAensbhibi____________________'____ǁDZ___ρρϳ___߂_________dz______ooo_gg__w__________________6I9K___׮o579K__^______SL_׳___W9K_ Excerpromhomasammeltoft-HansenJsathaway,@iOJ62G9KNon-RefoulePorldCo `erxe, 53spЃbumbiaurnof TrnoLaw`> 235 (P5)߱߱߱߱߱߱߱߱߱߱߱߱ߟߟ߱߱߱߱߱߂'߱߱߱߁<metaontent="2018-10-20T22:08:00"ame="created"/> <ρρ9T13:18:36.839972523hang16.00AppVersionVDocSecurity__Xfalse}HyperlinksC="LUpToD(ScaleCropooolhare8gg`;;;;Pesdfootno?wrtext/html;set=utf-8"ttp-equiv="C{-TpK

*Immigrat eyP,unishmx andheransformsofustice`span˃x6">SocialLegaltudies> (December 26, 7).Unknown

**2.hen HresignificantiskAabsconding,embertatesayetai+erspcednrdtoecu8transf(ceds8 accXaith,nbasȄnidualssessmeandplysoarsIpoonal) sercivel`measjppli0effec)ly.???<78?xml="1.enco="UTF-8"?8imlnphttp://www.w3.org/1999/x!=Xtitle>Unknown “risk ibsq”ansexi(soȌcase,hichr*objeria@finby`w,o beH(thaӽHtrd-countryxĀstwhosurferYcedu mayk___________________'___ǻ____ρϽ___________ǽ_____ooo__g__ww______________link="#000000"link="#8aid="2BASE0">

* (___X7_SE6">42.iberty persondol_[29'SE7i No4halleeprivedhisal xcept . . ./liIo8DŽSEA___nXB">for purepreventingunlawfulntry a%intow {,reffexpuls,Xtradi`rr샳remov`nromǖ4btaPg[oceedpsan thsÌ֊Cooo8?xmlЇ="1.enco="UTF-8"?8mlnphttp://www.w3.org/1999/x! Unknow{metxont="reOffice 6.1.2.1 (MacOSX)-generatorI'&ArguFunes,ʊauǁǁ2018-10-20T22:08createdρρ-29T13:18:36.839972523hang16.{kAppVsVDoc urity__XfalHysCUpToD(SXeCropooolhare8gg`;;;;wwptH;set=utf蕀-equiv="hy-TpK(nk'!flow5?micss"xlPtylesheet"8܁ |38e**

* (___X7_TI6">Noerson shall . . beeprivedlife,0berty,riwithoutue aw.UnknownspanC30 JournalLawZPolitics 411HH> (5)'ǁǰρρϲ__ﲇoooggwװoF4UM47UM𲇲AFCײWUMdarahong__V XWhyoesheHavezRighto rolon?zMXi>ǁoǁj7">NOMOS LVII:̓],Ń,JGC3 (Jackn, ed. X7GGHe8/15UM9Rbr7PȃǶǶǶǶǶǶǶǶd> Unknown <Health,edicines,ndonsutXObligais}AwwwBre4'F8C''(/(D8Discus LZ g9SE"F''+G">Amy Kapczynski,amueloyn,lj ManAJoséepedaspinosa/0XHYփx3F8IߗooHe:pos:fid5E:offJ">IV.EALTHEDICINES,NDONSTITUTIONALBLIGAiSچwtgeǃK">W̑S:߁߁߁Lˎ//1?)MgggggcFg0061ׂN">Juџ(Enforcemhfighto7'pO9KF8Phmed.nIndia (H`uratelh 2014)QI002IǂRgRT-7602008 (Ϭʆ ColombiaecoReviewhamberq08wwwwwSwwwwwsKwp4FF8T">SuspenʇPWriAntpatProtec 175 (SuprXe8Ofrazil0U{MpJEF8VerJo (U.S.istrictdhheor8rn0Floridh87?W????90?????;N?007Q1">Cas. 2.186fChile1'?''''y2'''''#O'pPIF93">R (B)QC8geealthuth(tyφΪature,рApp؀QEngl!Wales,ivil vi9, 1995Lj37F94">Thempactfourts

C.unstein,ocialndconomicights?essonsromHuthfrica (2H)/G////8//////.79HF99">Davidilchitz,ivingRo-/*ee2ARGTF9BLau,ԓpRetyytEnforcement1׆CSPF9D">Katharine.oung,%YQueues67qEV004R7F9F">OctouisottaerraHarmt`PoorroughwRLitigation:gaB0il7ׇRG61h9_H">João0ehl,͎`anaТo,2Joseph.mo`Judi!izʖHp st扰Statecctabi ׈I2L0F9Jinielei.aoUno015DŽ߆džǀ׆DŽKdždždždždž4ǝFJF9L">Allya,scara-VeraClaanella, Colombia—rotec '#׈M{580CF9NEssanecisT-7608)7׆8F9O6J3F9PpEngag wi@пMenesQ84F9Rhie O0rsHttorneyenHourtKenyatairobi, 2DžO77ׇ7S77777387JSF9T">SamuxMoyHumanAreotҔ8G_GG׆GUGGGGGGF6DVKapczynskY^yAgeaNeb1ism (June 26WWWWׇWA0WWWWWSAW5W1">F.ȁP-LaocPLtd.JAnr.9Cip( Delhiewkׇ2"P_GoBack"ame?A38I__BpI4">eB Inc*MercExch e,pL.C. (SuprUnitedtates6G׉5////+C/0074FFA6bg C-620/16 (Constitu嗪׆7FKLFA8">MezaarcíainistrJ@/*TribuI Peru,irsham24h3divider1?FA9"> 7777/FAC">Many healthystemsroundheorldailorovidendiHualsith accessmedicines.necentears,ourtseveralntries havexncludeatuchuresiolat*stitutionrighto5and,oreo ,Schouorderpp-basor qYAxsult,redsfouss—perhaps millpeoplebeend[Ӂy0rwisnotived.<A robusteb1hasmergabouRmplicaىec someuris(2 areartaroaapa(which judg؋Xerstamselvprilyterveningenforce0cioe@omic zBOi@tXcauh backdHemdeferenceYlegisx҅9ern challenmwwwwAGw7w=Hw7w+I">XPqI,In=irohin guaree&.xapcfromolombia, Brazil,dxUnitSt@wx:ognized laimpW ntraHdecis2O KdChile,vad1S adminis@torxiscrenk@btaryuep. TaA᫙M񄛄aԤ, o=1w/ subZmBfacxible.ԅissب ؑk=WW:ow po!oorssis8i8? ߀9症痁J7=K7+L"> excۍlitiga eZIIx(rs\tekcQ٦ (peI vusc)CulsoakXadoub `mull;j` XivailayImb)Rlplan.nk 8ydlx6adj innobbyizy'gra(sksy8msaPcorpoНǏzcxlus`xrcs arguim8vo8 ˴ysiexpexoy set҆0agH;'#m0(Z minh0nonefith Џofhpts effect ;Dajhelpvulner , *ul鎸sQpmidds??AM?7?=N?7?+O:se 0erAusx´9useHӫditpu0raɃAd?׏I!x)iqu’*thPɑY??imp ty, pargi(excpapƃo %HwhJiniduȢ,@o?ĈUp backgr矖 [ket’s g:/P`vunusly n!?:bȧssgb tHbeleanz?P7=Q7+R">S`ed lBraziSColombi89,mpial @SppȮomefheffectsfighPtoedicine. Therefore,fterxaminingheaseaw,eeviewtudies,ome whichrxriticalqj0ci`involvementndHgueat,2 systemuXtistorhealthc9budgequnderes rarnromotesquity.inallyJexplinactiona$encwithZpolbranch` st`,惰 BrazilColombia,responsbybNq!degree -;`alodoorCnotoelibxtive democy.<

7777/FAU">In oneeccuss ailsliaruesboutB economice:o8xt;:hould1gb( rٍef)oegislatu?artI framhp minovel2fo@edSrole ary:haprehipetweenarkQblife.Ϟn,umq oohpPaalm*inc@tfimplrow KSgrned.Ԗ)ؚ[ backgroX7jya.eci ȟ)rdividuwusbrs ifG tp!ab(` yless-cxtrR`pbecapsɥty .Pprecludympeto(so Ѕ! ,ul󓹃blcHian pق9s. SiXPdyncmhyg havgpd1)xPUwȇ UniISt[Eu.óIв canAserRadds ribuҥ engagbroapoS݃yٸ܁i` tutmЧthvitabe,װ7AV7H, agaipou3˩rwheLey sCT(deeptrucinfluenca.ɗis `w gacaYIPKenyǔpPerusk *0i` (pwh)9Zؕ`l!q ƒageȂdos3 avPPhoXwhoe0`mǑJŁqaҏ9MA.zׇ37107FB8x`pt lhi/> W.P.(C) 7279/2013 (04) 9?=AG7+B">Manmohan, J: . . W?BC7=D7+E">1. T`iss=a*i pApexs ainhiboron@belonR9rly weakKsociesufferRPhronicѺeX(loe(APtreatBcok .$8,825-$10,000](ronthspeap[oknowЩgnosgoo0verikelih`U`lead aormlife7777BF777=G777+H">2[T]etitionersoungoygedboutevenearndP represent(throughnextriend,father,r.ohdirajuddin. Theetitionsuffe from`rareenciseaseallGauc D,hich!Lysosomaltor0isord)weine dypnnot procesjesulti0Haccumula f ap(vit organs .fPXleftntrea, ϊunlikelyo@rvive.Ё(fourth2onp[p chilfpnts;jo1eeiblpsavel8suAbed 9same.<

7777/FBK">3. Am( n!EnzyPReplacerapyvailable fo)ǍHtexpecCp`ِ@ceҁ ӊЗdeg0norcv(ow(monthly,ifeloIexorbpnter’whoj rickshawu@raf{f`KBL7=M7+N">4. Cur dru requirѓcond*XeanufactuH ڋphaceu8com8ieslob Sanofi@h JPfizer. . . .O]`lls8d]in I(ascost!ёGstimጰpPx [$8,825 $10,295]pyYshet σϖZ߅fفzc8goHثJs.s`lrpeoplp , 9un1oira dlopɥȁQaar0bYY :ڂpc p(|.onڐ@:ϯ[tox8C7777BO777=P777+Q">9T]yCazpportunit"!C@rStP Gn HPitpcou0bm@bp olved.ȨTZmewॡAXfu`ICDtbdecidI8:l40GFBR“WRS7+T">(i) Followk8 Hon!wedersdplЗ۴1 Lysoso`ora0Dis؂LSDs]Ralson-|Q publicealthoiview,i(gulinԺSmahoPo懰Arepercuzs bee!vi"po`yfinancial 0hn!hmod imAnth -`e΋_ǓǓǑOFBUg?=V7*C0ܯ o]⭘yH ÁeK næaBχχχυoFC1ρ?ρ=2ρ7ρ+3ʇЅ,wrdYmemeacsu2)>throughhndsppoolf(0Bsociety”. /9 7ϯW4/7/=5/7/+6">18. MZubedaegum,(arI nselP]Y N(on0Cap(leyRDelhi󌙟hrp8o,ݡ9try,j[]haloc tibudgehowar c0hHeszq.Ӄts(hav)onA` +pul҆dspe C,8lc"proatac j77FC77d="2G3FC8">19. Ms.ubedaegumointeduthatelhiadomprehensiverug policy.hetaفin 2013the]ssentialedicineist beenevisforeighthimeynxpertommitteekising emn`octor. <

22sub DirioealaevelopcountryikendiQuldotoretchhasime@provide frfacilitieRaerallylla؊while r cxzere҅ndasiccared aS{quobligoywards(andb usepsh8resourcPքmaximbenef0 numberfeopl9 D7=E7+F">4c[T]HGovernmp3doYhaanyysu8in placXdd`spases,`rticularthohronic natP.CrksmHthpe5 ane-rgraAlife-savicedH{doco`mte(nuousXncq8h:pch0 [GaPer],involvx1lo sT` 2no i(Rn@nur*o (orphsOOggCGg7g=Hg7g+I`3. Thisu Ha¥YneiQCromWhw餈nhib@co‘gs’ s@aducunlcPgmaȌ8appabPlaw izj׏oh׬kbمxed׎׎׎׌wCJׁ7ׁ=Kׁ7ׁ+L4. Keehviewp:se9o1co؆LConstq,candirectТhiaben legisnҷPuHcȲw@g ́gHJughbsHyely desiri犇CM7=N7+O5. S0,mPea}8a,exclusQdomalExecve׌refr(蝘PsuaK@s'&P7=Q7+R6aec0dis]whe [ WwqdutXfrmed0l treatݥe؞rfferj(i! όj"`urooooSo7o=To7o+Uh9. Artic21!og΁ Stceser.߈dsÇ41"Hng="en-GBFCV''21. ProtS鍒p(berty.· shaJppr(d᜙Ёyacd 0cHestishPby9___D27=37+4">50. TuPt؇ّ@hhel`ha h$xaundJP Zs 39(e),1@up8aP 41="calibre83"id="2G3FD8">**52. Thhumhhealth9alsoecogniznumer interstrnts.5.1UniversXDer HR郈ffirms: “EyȏBa`dard livingdequateorz<him2zamily,0cludxclothx,(medi(are sociГqi.”ԃICovennœxpc,ӁCul؁PLprovidemost(mxhXHanllaw.ccordeith 12DžՅptЁ1@aë́enjoyقhPeattainphyszۚ,whig.2,yayAillu,(bXstepo(akenч'! achifullpz֑p`ٞWTH7=I7+J3. GenmNo. 14su8ltpNbsbitte /+b/C02H鉱8xer:-'''40FDK(HWGRLG7G+M">Цa@iXmȀlXlsѱCfollowYrelp ele,үse applPechXHdepeqdi3vail{ Zcuy:gGGNjGNo?/=O/7/+P">36+obligKPHfiYquiP,Kiao禐 suciq܂u/ pollegy@mxfxblyi isXimpe dop6icHde`led pl߅ަ__Q7=R7+S">6Undoubxabt*fjGxrna ppfactor.0urcannotunmindh@ s. ȁ䑠chbudgeaIntryld s`ڍxid.f0etوilike edu4dp'ignored/DT7=U7+VC8ȇߦinhpl ɕrttxse.ŁqifX8ȃjwe itA 8re #neinfraxuc @Ѐȿ)s w7777E0777=1777+204. A1meime,KsPZ Pchronicradas8duRIX(t. I]8absursɤ„Bprovidx Hpoonstomaups89Y @cer/HIV/@thosphoxnjurȷccnt!OOOO3O7Od="2G3FE4">65. Diseasesaturalatastrophehatellstsictims unpredhably. Trightodequateealthrelowsrom thsanxtyfumlifendeign"belongsll persons.Ȃ fundament(z,hicha(B risitesocijusticl.thouldccessiblo H.<

s^ "BhronicJ7=K7+L">80gnee piousl exxd!ubudgei͢"ɽP !0enumt0in s 141upaPR21bQ Qllus8.ɲxo偪9ۋx]nefhriv field robcurgenoene<߭:mqxthinkncinvdyorϘϘϊϊPρ7ρ=Qρ7ρ+R5. O]Xccou‡nҌ@8‘prg ’ETb 8FEU">bi>(orphh[csDgg apyspxpiZa⏠`u@\MņpaiPy,quit SzbhByction,heentralndhetate Governmsaveioldrticles 1421fConstitution.<

7777/FF1">86. Justecauseomeonesoor,wannotllowimoie.n fact,LjbouqonsurePatvulnerablecqs society{accesstreatfrax)chronic8seases, likeaucherspeciyhenbprognosgoodalihэpatileadingormplifAft`0,ealth@ RuxuryshouldЋasopossqaivileged fewF27=37+47. Aoughbligh`ndDgest1be rQvexlizdepenˆ maximumvailour@, yetertaih_cHiconon-ogI irXtáڞi0.rovi38@ medicinXaf`d*hs37WWWWF5W7W=6W7W+7P8. Sina onrightakplace;Ct (auP eff$r8ef:ran.he nati{infr 7qQxguida#HappnaIular8sewwwwF8w7w=9w7w+Ap9 3subjp(pe!H`Xof wi@ir=O . . @Delhischargts Zdk,؃enzyme rej9aptAlldia0@M!PSHs] freRp٭equtJԀq2008bׂx5"/gϓ`1E"> Colomb(Sedeviewhamber)(Ju31,)Fh3hF7=G7+H">[ 49-n,Pith),v: 9 OKI“OǁRJǁ7ǁ+K">Puc ėAenvirojxtdpzervi sxѸ `.iȇualgua" ʃm,,rehabiliRt.ɭs 2QyorganizSgXdhiOOe pop:cr{iplKPh y, unstycooph@shoHi9byva(xerX`uxntrom1whwigjurisritol 7d(rmins[pirP7"ɜeimp*und!dsdqlaw.Їobacrman@OLleve຋ZaipcommPty.Ԇaws)\sbasXcYaopL MhHda胘E0sh0qatteœgÔis/ـ߇.”]M LG?=M7+NPce ManueloséepedaspinosauthoryԱh, CPocludxsaimPórdobodrigoscobar.<

7777/FFQ">The ConstitutionalourtasheuthorityoearcIsf ela (‘prote,’lexibleurisdi PSesigned  undament8rights),hosen`ІCfromy decisall"judgeqRepublic. . !J!-7600 2008oll s 22FFSs rtingsystemicɈms inbXlth,ost9whichddressedssuthatpeatedly hade`d@_].ni, 5KXolʊ eristructurflaws T7=U7+V">In qpxѐ ňVexaminXmultiple cainvoke璅ʙĈP—spfily,Jacc )neeQerviؔ\ωωωχoG0ρ7ρ=1ρ7ρ+2S+is_؊Ն37=47+5">3.2.2. {[C]_^xreotbre9sayBy mayimi@ordanceicaareas(8 nd hporset=?⨺prude| [T]ossibi"Penforc袐igXdhvXa ,mPPpdoQsorough 狟G6тdinasepar,GGGOGL7G7G=8G7G+9AQ do8fiosvaawZalways subjaradu8g . “NJDžGA">Whثfailupmeinimumplaaol`nmypgSsuffhunoarm”PȂc08edilyyi2ici uЋapapsug ūȋdeQpa u1l o((NJNJGB">urgygGFGC7=D7+E{9W匘enjoya߬Ktdepend78liz,9htۑResppiautho0y]doammhcivis ' di![']ЁRu@LYXapcipatorymocracis,qcisPo ha-rilPdesignhxʋWWnt H .0wwwwFw7w=Gw7w+H">As aequq?ץwic cer,DZIviol0d;Qye(gunteeǏl evxdwuuo0ьHwoul:advуbpfulfilld /׎I7=J7+K[15fT`noQ!cu`\jurisprud doctxn8qwQs[ _\.ԄeaЂitypoffall;twoAificGL"> ɁM">Butthirdʉ_WN">fulfill,hichomeuthorsallo guaranteecto GP">ensure orQ">satisfy+haveot beenefinednkitiwayiutisagreement. 1<

7777/FGT">3.4.2.9.1. Theommit``dicateshat(eblig0on牗U">respect2“requi Strefrafromterferingrlyrbtyi enjoyifrigh@oealth.” . . ''''GV'7'prot?>NJ\take meaрporev thirdartiȋWTimplĚsovidHfcle 12h (ICESCR, 1966)ڋFH37=47+53H6">fulfiP닥oappriegisl ve,dmpstrbudgetary,uialoPrtowardeurizǗ(I) F_eχχχ7χ(H8xacili) `cularadoptos%3per(ndss@b(ual؀c8us ii)ư(oՖχWWQ9ψρ{A򙡈aific@h(㍳x casXwבgroup;unabl@Psonseyoir(ntrol,yexerciseK4hemselv`bysH8itsal1 08woonB{Cm⎧X )ǒ`underc, mtђ)toHppop؆oGD7=E7+F5iAnda 2isiedbenefipl8need notf(butncircumscribcТӃs ordeȧPqpauthEȑ؅ofPefi1uاscarcesouHs.nsh l𵉀tituCPtaume`c(niservi [such]Psme.HoughPey\lo0run haќIWyaY,8y?loak10zhpownePPry`鿟e`arbeюywe!.nly1n E8ch1xvelXI:ntPly irrsiang`’fԀ `egyoؓ@yXbbDž` aȎ spplԏ1sT+pl(eepd@r1f0ne s eyyɏŭŐ'ж䁴fgyo grxoi[p puHՖan exclud0Q t@礇礂G7=H7+I">4.4.3. {CuXcacߞdepends,first c(P9injonPy 1 whipcptl3be aXliHdQugijg܀ضCwypes:XɆDwith O.Ȇ+P(POS)Ă' J7=K7re77"id="2G3FHL">Currently, theurisprudenceeaffirmshat(ighPoealthfersonho requiresedicalervicnotoveredyjobligatory}plan isiolated,en “(i) lacka72s orteǹXoifendintegrityosebneXit, (i N mcanbQcaheatainclXnyOpati (orddchy". . ,ڃvP ?[hasȃaoc.”[THPromotingnti(s (EPS)1ichdminist蒄age, mseekundsXOSYGAstashhfina1 n.]<

7777/FHS">4.4.5.1.1. E8yon[QconsutiCPiacH1 ԇ,oBprovis(OC d00dm١sumImyCividual QciabilQh#.׋׋׋׉wTׁ7ׁ=Uׁ7ׁ+V">62ӕourtxlad{ᣚegularpdhBenefit PDsnaw 100 1993[ir (g(sive`ifʢtribu"[Ciapac 0Ne]subsidizoor]aim9ulll װoulchievs2001n'ǎ'I0'7'=1'7'+2">DespiteA`Xp,rPdcleleghmyexplily endors?N*Ȗ8lySoSec;,ropgraml:dn0specoals wapxche= twГrtXYasupposuQet҈deadlR omshetep.ɢ Rw88{nowX0 TStɂ@i'xfill"|G '؜ guaraLD eq0ms.hilp1'Z'' Z [rc胹ImdeKadopt`1ow]Xv ^_Xߝǫߛ_\37=47+5">In0ew%ego*ף߃|6߁7߁=7߁7߁+8">Resolves: [zsr`versquiEPSbur(rmedh;rugilaieed`rd1s afidhysPan.]/''9'7'=A'7'+B">SixXntho[zMst\ProtecQR*Commi@on xC!bѸtak neca(8irwo(failu؅AOI,nsYوs (i)[away,7770D0?y upY E ,ribuz subsid*8HOOOFIFHvG ffv delHrG7=H7+IWml,to iPgxlypdatehebligatoryealthlans (POS).oulfillpis orderCommissionustnsureirectndffXivearticipatx of medicalHunityusers;hsystem . .! ThntegrreviewB: (i)0earlyefinehat| vicesᆠincludedHbentQ,valunglegal criteriajurispr@nceConstitu@Court,K estash󅿅exosichnotvered unא!butً(dualXbw,P 1goalsorpH!=datby\X!be s`sfiوFIL<

7777/FIP"> * * * OOO3FIQG7G=RG7G+S">As Colombia,razilmploy(cedyviysgo xrniraescꨨBelow, werppinSupremeePMi(STF), Su𠃀WxAAn(PS175AIPIn addؗAts marespidɀ%@imfncvÅPz+lQ hybrid juQ/tÍ8xtm Am!Europehmo PT{Ї apЂ\"xngwheҪrai qu١q00’ds聲U gnmenPr2Xۥ.,is…ߒ bҠw///IT/7/=U/7/+V">Ȅd n-P,ʪil͈xH@xtxgXo8gۊE wlimiÉ soexompolЍ< moATɁyhoslre. A partydiveu eن5 fre:uc·@Pharmace(8Ѕy , ;Xran.utulfocusX pghciagPapYSadrugbeeHpц bx yet r0Ah藿_J07=17+2">d g`]xchnge@eaftaffiriugi),weȦ𠹕e ;3iPUEeffQHaṱ;lyXinvol)Ȃ)case_J37=47+5">, RE 566741agH*Qalso(9)7$ee.pwH[ (sh3astu;makeWP)VyP9FJ6b/)"/ h3wp38"邸sigil_toc_id_100wFJ7(a22\ ץp"ame8/a×_of_Y?FJ9">Sfritfnticipatedrotection 175  Supreme FederalourBrazil(March, 2010)B">1up>/h3ȁׁ63FJE"7H32?FJF)7577/FJG">[A lowe8granIarpinavoroman sufferingromien-Pickype,`neurodegen0tiveisease.he requirtheƑGovernmentoivide腈withreat freechargÖxesxȂSTF8j?9 ?’s)llengeAdecis hnӁppealed lfulT.ynanimousX,OOe .]րREPORTGGGGJKG?G=LG7G+M">Jus@Hilmarendes (): . . .WWWNO7O=OO7O+P">folactxre cessary@analysiscomplaint:''olτ47Q0 [ her] ablish0eewsnYrclin@aon0onap8stoppJprog sѯnth+vXł4?PrvivXoddsithBmPvGB ?_?ǹǦߊCǁ7W=DW7W+Ecr0argum`[FeGrn)]shi'drug,ڙ(scaϤȏregtNAhhSanSafeH(AVINSA)8Zaȑequly, q*meriznrazilq`hibihόόooKFo7o=Go7o+H">IncdP[%Pu0c͗stsubmit;plaiw eׇׇׇׅwKIׁ7ׁ=Jׁ7ׁ+K">N`l, aearchhgAUwebsxveall, ducanyCTELION,e numb1553800002,dnt1/2012'KL"> Zavesca isotartfny9therotocolsrnstruction [Naal] Colidatedealthervice (SUS),stsigh-costedic2 1contempl:by2publicetwork’s΃harmaceut0l Pcy.<

Aough 2FederhGovernment]8dMunicip@tFortalezargue at \)effPreat0Niemann-Pickype, propreshtoerif+G cliHeveness.Ԇmerelynferscbe,romJfac8@Yinclud0in! CĔggggKRg7g=Sg7g+T">On2o(r,ocu@olloPMxy showaurizphyshcrib׊КDsame drug@recomEuropehJAgen????U?7?=V?7?*L0">It alsorscorjaȡk,)Aof itself,usonДXadmd . .!77771777=2777+3"> anРdecisȅarHxtingZ, StCrá'" &onsurxcc ڤ2fav@CLARICABREUEASTROEVESXspheldNjNjljg4h4ρ?ρ=5ρ7ρ+6">[V Juseilmar͚)s (Pidh)]ooo/7g7g=8g7g+9">BepecCour multiplePquesiYsusp1[ms]whichwis襠g1ڦ Tur(ovparihea@erv(}s, foodp8,as8`hc)ĉip[iHveH 8thospi(Hds;rѫÄ܅rs; exec$urg8iexam(l outYhome,幰broaetc.)O珇LA7=B7+C uxtakoou@gqumb`8pla@đexkIvolveI(mmon@auAudto engageipЅΉHBally$ actormeysmj(pry,gb dvoHUnZ@ t@#ddhadem肪civiloty organiz㐟?LD7=E7+F">Af "ydeposZses8b reЊmdhr sWneyoreevalu@]ߚl rʝ̋pBrazwasstaXshed. Th@becausmajocasmI(does noxakelxDabsolumis8regard) Dpo0AdirȈ*w#?GCybuhr0maq('de minï[ pئ] lHdyE.ư2(bЁىf(cogɁ`z)fp:s8oسow[go nqo!ഁw4ךךךטwG ?߁BH߁7߁+I">[I]n KCMYPyʗߗor siyPerms,he Judicialower’snterferencehhereationr implementfublico0iesnealth,ecausehatappens, almostllases탰lyꄽdehminfqeffective execuexisting. .
<

7777/FLL">Thus, s9firekohonsid8dja,ot@f ae#yHincludproviservice requedepp8ant.Ϗ逡 rys僰Xsha certaؒYdith\soand epomWsormulȄCdHSt 0 new0ut咍aits `per0L.ɅBČ/ubj, lrigh*a ar2ev 8?M7=N7+O">If W__Z)among adopith necessto duСXeHrbsGф׀ɖXsult (1) legis@Padstrmis; (2decd;(3al baoɜ/7777LP777=Q777+R0>rareۛ0gs]seekًireJSȑ_RYybeHran2Nr AgyanitqSafety (AVINSA)''NJ'S'7'=T'7'+U">Af verifyA!xyquX`%roduct, grЂ;y[on,NVISAoቨyz[przfix9me$tak:nccouQclp`nef1 ct騨imil\ dys'"onfanddi# H0may\0mohþ߲zsam`n͑LV7ForlT8scˏeyiguelP` sdrmWs[I%o27=37+4h sdle1upxaрP of1tituSl `esta8shasoyompiಹL`mostechosp`lreMBO7=C7+D">T because BraziliOI@guby “-b din (EBM)//χ/E/7/=F/7/+Gn *cob@ork-Consolidatedealth System,hichsan tobserveheonstitutionalrinciplef universgalitarianccessapublic胺As !i8,ecomesiabthroughelaboraupo0ies thatlloc (naturxycarce)esouPsnmostffntay possi.oopRdnetworkafinanear ouldQult9areinjuryɃx administiorder*promisC0(ȁH0furrejudme8؉He*vulnerZsegm9؈opulj.ɊrrdP`an clud1at,eY,􇩂rHvidb!oi kӆlmubrivilegoyopselecqby@h,oongᔀincrapnk expiȎ̓y@noenst@ished.<

7777/FMJ">TxsdoYrem,exCix,JiaPower,AςitPfȓdec@aasuhy differq0funϏϖ7ә shʏڑ|Pnh+耈sph9irga`wY ђX3xcasP. !9 GCK7=L7+M">ExPial ^s (wittH1ؙ9eRacy) dlop;orh, [deed] ePh.art1oik 8normLdir@:+" Stklig\ہP(e77ts]. 1____FMN_7_=O_7_+P">As cewϏh芰corp8inC7E)pmtacddii*uakeAsmphiz[ʅsQcP˃r@ knowledg>[Ȑ]qvol}ast-pace@ib0aucrЏ rdly8llow ssLߍ狇Q7=R7+S">[T]absX0liProtocols sjifypebetwas accpius࿦+nork+ Є` .ɝYsہ@҇haomi࡭eKdimighsubjjӡviP 39_FMT?=U7+VJ Ell(GiHCelsoe,rosu,yrittȍiMPo Auréliomsepaotes—8concurJjoHngʄC Gilmar0>gzdenyqgovern’qu.]h3Mw 38"@sigil__id_101FN0 a 22\ _Ref48628924name1/ahoq_v_jonesFN2">H.ʀbЂ@5"/WϑP10FN3">U.S.ėyixCourt eάhFlda290.upp. 3d 1292 (N.D. Fla. 2017)h3'!4?=57+6">k E.alker,niqsOJewwwσ7o7o=8o7o+9">TĚCo8c (“FDC”)cgwiХcar 98,000mPtt 7« 00 perhapssansP—arenfectedithheepatitisirus (“HCV”).ԁissu0n8casherDCyscreening, evalu`ndrerCV-ininmatesaann`that comport!consutionalequirements. < 7777/FNC">After hold aive-dayear(incluptimonyromxpert 0nesses,ZofficialxS), CourtHnds! hasotc__sdy Cn. 1T]__ preliminaryjuncِnec@tonsure rP@ediȒXBely}ist`ЅogdAccorAly,laintiffs’o"forgranx. . !ND7=E7+F">Hor b@ diculo.neldthod1 involvdrugsɇrferRiba8inٍ week ؒcoutake9loqwenthpoletesidef9e0riblerTakځh?wЀɁh$flu;PeoPsirell outeXadashcxt8tudal,ۇ] somemmitIDespiteWt0docȩtiPibċntiaighevell8r sjbecaup1Plik`ho;get2c,ichas Bnab 30erc81o5 ԇʙǙǙǙǗgNGǁ7ǁ=Hǁ7ǁ+I">BuY죰 2013newQknows䖸ct-apRDAA )eHo(rket.i>xqro"o a9in w Ća pcHwiHaaySiwis ם-);.orer,xw1/YMoi2p95%whȡ°( ɕjhWWWxKW7W=LW7W+M">UnptunPoocaX` Љq vIneptemb؇X6Xh(ur=$ ap`xi$50,000$75Y.vu *god<MN may+$37ʎNN7=O7+P">,eӅ:Iʈnt-Xare ch(ic-A>nntr88yexcЀpaircumٌ. . ׀;χoχiQρ7ρ=Rρ7ρ+S"y EAPdrYUndtsÆtitxhibiȁH gnfromxfli3cru(nusuPpunishhv)Suh0CPt@n@ ito enpdev,Knopecifl paЏ[a]Hhsu du(riso"AccordQ TerѐɂH A(sIusal need›a9im撘aioѡ ooT">. i'/U/7/=V/7/*O0">PpffXby@agno)’:efi@@Ћ $bequ,Ѓ facsubtiPharm,clu,Jlimto,la anَbodIcu fluidlegabdo0,fe-then2nfections, significantainriscomfort,xganailure,iverancer,nd death.ccordingly,tsoturprishatl tiffs’xpertscribesCVs “aeriousedleed.”΅shouldIbe /+thCourtindshronicto  1 < 7777/FO3">[T]@ Gsaatt ofciFDCsE)trdue aackunQ. . !HeрˌcuseX rovidX!mentthTquestionJ Defendihbeengg145oFO4">deeratelyׁׁׁ5ӊntρρρ6h146FO7Wԁ87<9WGwAGofBqсۑ?;77C777=D777+E">The onlyrm!ڡwillvspomoney1n0 wo.23(up ayP #h(8Rpoutweighedy 9inHipburderadministnconvenie <sConxria  e ginjuriereYrife@thуمxهqful sehؑresulrom wt} ;,eny 7 -ƂincwBcaqtoGoOI ?BJ7+KOOSOqesa8enP /)etimbappriynnnercompl`Â`tu߉߉߉߉߇pL7ׁ=Mׁ7ׁ+N">?y, 2limi1ep9sH _vè炱iownpertqmd0. Specify!mustp-2tolicy4line#QshortHYۂ9+]H8"eh`bef0shpndoctorB prahefollow.͂overρmulakieIscreng,aluabinmhs \di`*YsP oT#exdo1qsystemptmeerHXڮ օ饨a:table,soߚߘߘ~O߁7߁=P߁7߁+Q">TYgnizŇیbroad wastxs@DsclosAargu,tsPwi0prepin lH_/ՃshX bo YysRwilˁr߃ڄڔhr🸯1. InaruЃ'̅:m: “alacr8.”toleryfpot dragg. 1瓶4R?=S7+T">* * *G;?יU777=V7ass="calibre77"id="2G3FP0">In December 2017,heecretaryfFloridaepartmentCorrections filedbrequirireacplan.udgealkhissu areliminp injunrderingoomplyithi issomeodificaand stateAprovide byЈ31, 8Qallpisoners\everei8 damaPaLjnY9thoseignRnt BB.<

77/)3*March legislatup(ed,Gonorickcott QtHatfQ//-a $79 milldePiZits $2.3operxC.ԍddresshortf1whВD]ȄtitisÍr, ae@twor urYׁwxun concinm!healthcare,’sϛanno@@Maywouldubntiyutcbuse0dalggram-.1upaQP ǀ9xh3Mwest38OFP7^22gcase2186倇O8HYoool_no2_ 9">Co. 2.zb (5"/Hh3߆߆߂Aw470B770107FPC">Sume CȜb(2001)߀:FPDW2w??;P???e9?ixexFPE"F">**UJ׮G7=HO7+I">[Tedi8ualsiadv1t8s!HIV/AIDSza hurso tección—arPЀ㦹rgu gzfail1mlife-savtiret!rmed) 8kdhц aXa tuт8aȀPdesxNApp8Sgo rufav؋sgRed.] oOOPKO7O=LO7O+M. UrticX20EPol0Ȉ(WRepublic,ZHȏaf?:guareenumed Aeahecameas@HKa"fxerciMeexihrightroug؁adop safe9Xaken-fa@@arbitror ilawhiimped9rixens`ЅV. .!g;__N_7_=O_7_+P">2.YHhaveequdTor8?madamayaRojas֏ȊZxneed⋰vive,0npa!ular lid(ьaccÁkl dy1℡),; ?submYp"ePniMexaminBallowPσth@ u*" `io*lyZma退monitȂCAtˊ ;develop nes/shebehalf[two o9ls]All s])eg1atParriڥ#[]irueekܐ-2o[] .2Jyɖ؀Ѵ~iRal c bedeniedR*iъndrbitraryeasure whichepresentshreatoPeirighzlifend disturbancef OJequalityeforeAaw . .!<

7777/FPT">3.BanalyzingRimsiolationiconstitual guarantees,tsecessdetermineheracsnder scrpnye)rorllegalU]rticle 11Law 18.469<Min1fealthhall:nor" acю́benefi.T]issue{ed opublic胪,osHoiesust8f Appli`byenuthoritɂЀrelev,ivenih @idlyasta`sh>Ј< ƙ,s1case,PquirseverpmQs[,]includ8] osIssociwi0provi)b6AfpllocȇpurpP7PV74. T1!wXaCour`!nᤑs hЙшi@eorȄ`pla8 reguecis)ward"C#ЕzoccN shoulnot .3Ne0er];robsxx !a>dKd0Reavoiny }qymultromCfAAopH indiqXHvalescbu`it(T1s'Q27=37+4">5e!*[bӌApp@s]hisׁIy%[seek1,causW0fash,|Bp:sole bas`y`v\tej [A]&6I3ePeiBir)pi_3ikڊ*ojI'^[IsQ뤫 caro0' ig"mplem Adis`:Accordɵ+1meaЕP. B77778777=9777+A">8. F@I`egosas0,Omust(missedl//h3wesn38"Ȋil_toc_id_10B22\ cambridgxn_CX/azrb_v_QD">R (B).Á ALy2b?e5"/h3WWQ7EOx470F770107FQG">Sume FJudicature,QEngl!W (Cl D0) (1995)/;焃H4I774J">[I] EWCAiv 439OFQK?=L7+M">Ma RollsS@Thomasšham]:g

The orderhichsheubjectfppealɂp[certiorari quashingecisio@f:CambridgeȂ thuthorityotoundy furrreatmen!childnvolveIhcaseyayP chemo apyecoHbonearrowansplant.B nag10½.neptemb1990 . . [B]sirst diagnossuffer!fromXatRechnilynsXn-Hodgkins lymphoma (“NHL”)iPcommHacute:bticeukaemia AL.ԌCύHva`odthsAugustq2cour i'ya 8plep,otimeqsuccessfu7QUOOO4OjVOO_FR07+1">UnhPily, ՈiQtndureDec63 develop0myx搒AMd] rpy.ϝocСserwفϟotbodyrra8Xn, fasome importancpi1i8irHoc1 yedQpinPL2no-cgoorh!`oooo'R2ooo5oj3o?o_FR4o7o+5">In MarH4‡+DJanuaryyxY[relap//). :hgiveniqpresprocengp[9 'ߌ'67?=7?7?+8ffihuxpgڀsibilnctʥpuႈsurgjservPutside 9highؽlifiphysiciГadrimmernBwhᆨdavreӀHf exPt`ulH B’.Ȅ8sumpdAclure]:SOgG40FR9O?O=AO7O+B">F98@Io8reopҥ 'QclhӤpr0e2(@lso'# %woulЌhn8ve [v]imi!H,ВiniIfutHЎ pH[sr(docto@1|*O8j4*euticro8ndÅifPn cr* ɠ HЊդl`Wpu рdec Î@dgЌ|]+ tePpaiehoP (ripbe8(qКooooRCo?o=Do7o+E ha@beinflu!dJy 1ڍ)sd*dir܁ADeۀgarZ霷p܄┛؜гPbenefipќX ƆmssnؚaA evaluq*I1NHS*4]. `@mXke/ iruޥ'e xstHAnى"xmIO////FRF/?/=G/7/+H).bIti`di2 susIspxI077fWamtfundsvailableorealthare not limitless.heespondentasibilityonsuthat sufficiyfunكromHeirAedources provisionfreatmoratshichshkeljbe effective. . <

8 learnpjudgecknowledpthouldake orderiyequeneseyservic"in ignorack- sp.eɀ،say *“wHeuestY(lifZa 10xchild mightHvbyowevschQ,J~Author. mustooAllbeHYb&.”s:ɀyexplaihpriixhedexoeclin o,afoa ad`atdo soHre_RM29sN_FRO7+P">I :noubЊaerworan. 3,Ȁw’amily,@uwBhdifctoyH wilggt,matt؏1tsticularxwpotHialst.ɄEL .2, Ihutt!*eyaoaldؠ yce9as`rweln1aS8common F+a|Yki)tant@psqke meetiult:agonp鎱smaNbYbyocxCmaximumvah\umb'TsJa ;gcHyN,somRa ?遘o(faicci ʆcbeӄʸggg Q"o7o[I]]tot unic)rHiȔ0 Aiacseek{str𡼏Iis G꟞)BЅ^W,po4gobou.ΗQj?8ruPts finaf!aك3PՆ!׎׎׎׌wTׁ7ׁ=Uׁ7ׁ+V">We I,Xop),妈(os+symhH!B,feel bې9gar)Qmpderdabut8nelPisgu,yinvolinZfiectivѝfiA@ЪHfavXđ<^3FS0?=17+2">TpP[tȅStep)Brown]:ggg3_7_=4_7_+5">Af "ئal@nxiounA]]s I amƢ_!Ȓcasc񛾁y exQp`Ȟ0hsoKze앀lnsͣ2%o@;8ub@tu w*m1򂲻Q‡BT_ @hargЛCe.9ssad sɿp@Xi8parula!7D tJd1issueZcernmu)wofRgray8eu9achX2 g_6?=77+8Lord Si sranچ(app gree ks givbyiromBhMRndir Stephenrown,or overturningheowerourt’srdandeinstatUHealth Authorityzdecisionotoufhh0treatment.]<

777g(B">* * *???63FSC777=D777+E(is?F">R (B).ambridgscognizeds pointncar@itighXEngl .oughC1f AppЃulϏfavor, b9provideʑ60 firsrrejectІKrz.Ԃ1brɂ@fa8of0with$NalmService (NHS))publicattȃҒ߀9 wsG7=H7+I">In wakeaa, oindiuchallengeo Rs,u1quir@/*ir^0sonȣ(ny^n 1999SecretarySp`e`shIitusÏixceIce (NICE)—nowTCirze"imq8ran8rr.elccost-effxivenesata,Ά8 issum(Њ(wheaopul;sle nePGSi( 20050HSbe hcy ?>by.A2boYneve ,et,pr8Gofi "a@Є6Qatidƒ.1upaR_5h3=er0MPb OH5"/Ȁ> h3149|igil_toc_id_10xN22ׂ @_of_FSO">QIis(zgP7=Q7+R">Jurisdiؖp ha(ditiew9rol՗dT­᪸st0UnitCpueervaria񁨃ɘDdelegis uren`ce @soci̚nomiciPs;0ugȜgЩhly ill-suntH胁suchasbuwson xo(Zb chdoguhelpoXm acne.áPauqroduc!riP1cqpWdozϪAHSofr, Bilchitzp׉э taol`j8adt@mt ’mplcKaeى pplluȃh(А<@H /Phr, metimewidep upcepy“ue.”ʈі.-(immiovadI؍Xetp NJollo8cٛ08ii -dIen! mpIWW''S'7'=T'7'+U">Wehift񥩲;xlqeexPiesR adminAMmeynBraziColombia.זroɔbf>(ʉЛl*, ag(Dᤡsays brorӀሌ,sam8}s 9decis;vјx. [wpnourtsaveothevisedheirpproaches toightoedicinesnxongaging:publiclawmakersn exchanges,u@Xtwoourts;udifferent@thodsdoo. Txexamplenabl*hencan,hould,must tects.ndditiopyaPues@bos vollegislaturwhat “dialogue”etween `81brana*ail.ssue0rual enforcem8anti@ticto,rartf@generate(#of;ol).<

S E҉?essfromӎhfrXC R.ӄd (2001)sup8ǂ6?/?+7up dfootn@1"ref="kindle:pos:fid:006R:offH0003N11&ixeFT89_]' 9">*S <ԈA"pg3w8B77re77/FTC">. . :GrboomecisهWWE^S7e12TF"GL۝߯8Þual]@eaovemx}8Y9o-5HYrequicloattH humint stȴsensiApriority-tKwxda p0wh nee0aXriskJHn@virt8’ѱi) 8pfuldemoc8XprerogXvlimitnҀ publeshces,i(alsoAdeaq minimp xQmet.Ԅ` בёtXwerarejoȼ(hoave hd Bsoloxn. Iugg2Cu9serv1 xemptc O @?import 'm0rwipbegl؇@ordinarybate t illuhQe`ea,mphasizbyWself,all ,cl`imostvӿunrrsPps?uȅborn0axpay. 1 _9 A g1nm܍9 (me`peopleڗ#(multiays, Phaps9creAwڂ(llelpmpX,aсInyloo`oN.ЃaPo )*?safeguar;,n iss2юlGhyanxas؛ѐ YerepcBaoXqXhey )htll-sQd.ץbmo`n02AHeuQBg҇نPme eyouldÃ1roPB!whpK7=L7+M">But ׆ aogramٷhrey'x b8eosilh1e(ims violSasami(юȇex2yLcow.RؾQv؅ptyȳ[ed,abstracttplau lyiʔionf socio-economicightsouldotossiblyeooddea. . <

G"ӇERTeeth:heinimumorndɁImportanceDavid BT (2002)sup8wU///+VMup灤dfoote1"ref="kindle:@:fid:006T:offH0003N13ixeFU09_]4'FU1">*C <Ԉ2"`W3g8377re77/FU4">. [ Courtn ]tatedhat ‘i0secessary iappropriHoakdeHratoryrder.’rrequires tZdopZreasonableXu``eliefor peop0despeeedfirsȜ9i0hrgnize abou9Hi0lackfpecificity.smuȅh ̂0littXguidᆢwڂooparticuhas@s.iInndar`lipy,9c=groundsb;dela`obfuscationmuchlse__U67=77+8">s acobligwhave(enefy Wedith`mdniagainwhich judg@bepiiusHe0Xme0ᔨlbe ǎ0,973_on ˜}Jeffect@tYfromelemen servi,󏁕ile$runnwswongsy Ȃturni,
pilat 8mxBgrsulnag8h ceP(y8 8.`lsanoe T owx>sggggU9g7g=Ag7g+B">r(addial॰f˗H0r`cism L) cӛqHn im9m0nHs aJȔg؁developQiamX sh-m͵UC7=D7+E">FiPly,@0aquesñܴtrodu{uvis mechanPBPcrocio-nomright8i2f fpGHum`Rxmmiss*illȃ(1coiZ,c—rgu "ߘelhreidu`Oyob;*x donH9gh0aftri2asow8сHnody locu\i,apaedi𖊚j= gov!ۺp[S] 26;fail:o ncs3meax*ans9)jѳʊqview焟 Hcr 1ouRZoituXawa xhQo0 ĂxdyexpxKsП?=F7=G7+H">Rnp,9НIignif,hʘPepriozuЛT[]혈9hopHz fu4{;:adopЁXrobust ֢ ;ecognizehe existencefinimumorbligations.nhisay,Peurtan showattasinterestsmostulnerable`eart,nd ,Yirefsreparedomgovernment fulfilbasiceeds.<

TR#S"ighhEnforceyDavid̄B (2012)Msup8/PY(wldfootnoteanc1"ref="kindle:pos:fid:006U:offH0003N14ixeFUQ4'FUR">* ǁ?13@T7re77/FUU">. . .cholars(byarkushnetÂ(unH(havrguH “weakorm”ogi啯,hHby `outP failup+2se,ut gelly(rdyqdiscre br` bqba8asiȀt Legmacycapacstrainsuchplac0k.ԅQue-approaЫY8(been usidS`hfr(R#ntryH accomplish(mـ 77V07/9V0/7/+1">A g`robo0AmeksٕK0-1nsxefiGr8boom,0d qwork—-slat؀jdu򒰶OC requydsRvirtubPhingAacadv*shousH.nzaca@ic _ZχχV3χ ha`ole0„ aټ2batHp:s370mtlQȣ,(orderk effective. Ǖ47=57+6">In",dSfr馒manatensbetwyO' 直seglowitT`ear reupiiztXdel_ZiffmkڃYg vi:zmHar0u Picinztt HyaPieH8bv Ybopdon󀰕auvoaplex4:iss Zma([0ervenmȎ`0publicBcy.Ł ougњggregat0 dec"rjSbudg)0veol֝familix-like;siy*2xoБGHiaag)pnIfend.ecowhi8\7.byrnIȁjunxὀidow`wą *st8suo, YPpos襺sA0 to 3spiceQ,dois[Аߒ*radonfirst-gene0!Cae܂Х¬GGGGV7G7G=8G7G+9">BX "illowcarHoXxR8i8ї0ry#ylls`0 prcbeyaP).‚ȅ signifi0b(0ol{heavitil)towaridd@ andpperncomeroupsatherhanoorlaintiffs.nwords, inuchfeldocialightsnforcementsibrant,ut accruesobenefitqh8classׄthose Tmosneed. . <

7777/FVC">M lite uren71,hefav0ag7؃umhaaoun-majoritariexercisend Ori8PiOJwill0arginzed ;.hdonotppeaotx— essPlyomanyaseonare middle u??>'!h4ewesHn2ǎ`D/h4OO2ЁAsigil_toc_id_10_E pt3_queXFVF">RQQ:nistriiveos(yModtateKne G.لq (2016)su#8 KO/O+Lupdfooteanc1"ref="kin:pos:fid:006V:offH0003N15ixeFVM9_]4'FVN">*3FVOOOco_g_ID0EEFAG_xoP삏]Reference_F1454765051MFAWQ_F2RFVR_F3WFVSoo[T7o+U">In Southfrica,ersonsviintol0bconditi whoeek housYhabeenerided “2um,”spȦir imbasic!stitXoJhu0.nanadpthoseY YaccpedxlȼutsyB’srovQrviȆ/abel(#facOOOOOHAua, attemptҋ
Ybya@ylumBdismip߅ۓwithst")9 OIDeepdseh Ӊ;stDropellmpor@{ objecS0ievojsHool,Blegal unrH`]Awocept,T repr(x"undxntPdignity}ꎄ,rċ8(ertyequr0Buto toodoˇ0he fairnAqor. 1;pwwGVwwZIGwmG00Gpp_sp_1117_82׀ׂ1D5G2wr0׀ׂ3C2G4GG_F6g2W05_F58R06HY7OV8EUaid="2G3G09">The twoonceptsogetherorgenmbivalent,nterdependelation: toe8zed,ighpappearometimerohibipto permandρrequireueues;Daheirurn, \c8te stituYorisplac(. 1 [Q]mplema0incif “first8mpcservX” alloc@thosehoavHaitedongesHwhiaXhe xteontrollingQmod8o(g8eferesy*wexemps (onroundneHcrria)(sett!qgorirexi@ninithachK,s wwtiƒy.ɎpA oqasolitiAtrumpsBhAertapoPؕXsuch ygnity xinfi،8lea@uanro@9soov9ajtanuti|bjec, be8P~isufied.ԐmechanismcspeəGwork爈) trib p. .!From spa,rupomedilyA8tweso-lposYnegXh :ǝ*!auf`; 嶟ZggE 8gsXl"uYseem [Wa+iyystem.eaators d*h}yobliY@erlyP civil'(zȮ) ۆnthyllxAЀppa8usenxcanalysXh—Ҏ, tIfulfillhHhelporifPhHdichotom [,]w0coXpt!yfӁty tyogyMCoNGߥߥ1߂FDWO2Q0P3V0Q6ERﯿ_G0S7+T">Tak firs 7᤟0ed 5 .0usuerone, such anyould`hibih.r0work hIexifrepeech,Ibsur1.npagioweذedarطtx ]sonabloceduȅQaccaHcu@PmiدɁQgdemtX8osca ouH implmeiubordinq-set \# . Secondly, theutyorctightssftennderstoodsnbligation @cerninghirdarties.nsense,equiresetate urPhatootepriveeopleguaranteed . .!A]Plvelytrovialxam9woulde oygu(eazardoushemi haahsk9pucealthnYe@gain,ueumaypermissibX)shpy`iori:wiertHimelines,rQsortut`mppʐim even/,infruch lawfacrillegHtyǯǓǓ8ǚ'ǦGǀo9//(4/Z1A51BwJHC8M1D 7׀ׂE_G1F7+G">Finalfulfi?:osȫt ?opo`A,o,dHc system,vidHcceso(,rvic@opp8un0t ueM_恈Xemb)e Qk᳽aangp0!Mworld:Y Z,,py„iZ orIrized .3hiXanh` tloBsHt sugg؂SmQ4?;O؁Иg8struct4Citselbjheĭπ;ǕǭǕHǚ߭ǨHǀoIgRIJ8׀ׂK_G1L7+M">[Despite ]HgruqbetweenHtwoXhaateȿxdqrelC' immedi spcarriith@0uђenXc mha؄Snarulariorsett( We sX⇛—on’lams-{-in-wang,‡٤(oc0vza Ignڃ0a;}s@sJaegm8 ex!s0cysXthȝpWNoJoO??_G1P?7re77"id="2G3G1Q">Yet thisreationfncillaryight . . mayKeonflict betweenSsdueues.рArothYpoeheistributive channelZderide “Jump”fyccessuchoodsr servsefor*m.I]tsʂhniciouselÆ4 ׆-liz*-in-waitingBthatePout d8inhi(merplaAter,,teast, Çmen*claimedostified.Ԏa4basic uctupwQId@if0s/talk.<

<p"`o_g_ID0ELEAI_1"ameoSh/a3KBGTfootnoteReference_F165454765051WWU62V7A20pp_sp_1117_102߀߂21ςςυgga9gaNw2 n Canadihti`course[,]metaphoriڢnd ievonss desc0subv@Q j@ȫ!preeespeprivilegЪpinfluP@asociehtimfimagiH,otna§ propoе[peoplHnOMany؆im`lsoBac&izensal (cularly lower-incs,ive3pKeffeclong-term su0inabi C le-rmode(fD fncAH.ɋcasepsuchA!\"e v08becau(49dcthd(rts oXawayrom9\goHnm@.Œo9s, stooqvXJmɀ sdar2,hnmeVsupublic eTgGZHoH9PWeference_F179454765051_ID0EP"id="2G3G2I">Dnders ofrivatizedccessoealthareoot . . seeheacticen “queueumping”erms;Yirs,aPr,ႀimsfight.he mostell-knownanifestonathissvolv constituQalhallengeount(by0ctoDr.acshaoulli, anpent,́(Geor(Zelioti @bQuebec e insuraȉ.ƒ4-3jority,BSupremeourtof Canada, .e(AG) (2005),]pthatjein@ystemadequirlzpulong waiXimHbublic,,hic9diRs lዸp@secuviol߃ r0oughlyrJu@infr@xntsi肤oc us(mit nHeffecA judgB*overturn{egisvb ,oldHMח׊skЄdissٔ inevitabilȎ郁listɉ esi*cliniXe؟snQsociAus(;!wholllow1or+#[inߓ fdval1solida*coP8ve resppi\+cʄddPs#ahhA j. 72Vdecishase icCs8@0unwarѥHP"v)H p0c%.՚iPviewG뚘mprom0makes :]rspЩ!reachy>role;onin enaɁIorڀ`cb0anism-irwhH@d1Xp0o0Xpora30錧Xs imp ƨTsugge0rbi؀favormiddle+1imarli@uxssful'gggg1ggGLgo26QW37o346߀߀߂35ςςυgga9g灇690W7g_G387+9">[T]f8atOOG3ARablish@onlynow “negve” JioQuebecys8liieffect.Ӏlar hibȣB"viȰ9maorce.ore3m9YdyssuI3Bcasa9؇agst ugnedegislation,tayedorneear—providQuebecith “someoompolicyaneuver.”n 2006, . . [ ]assed anmendingtutehat|empowertheealthinistero ntifyndircumvowaiP`symple`taHernve cedures,:eHbhapecificrketJisaley purchasefnsurance Qhip,neecataracturgeries*. ialsoItiqmem9whiche0;private hwouldeepwguntee1pu@c`yqhrdmissfjcertainyxceesix months. < Thus, tensfRChalici, ncial sle-unr`plansaveotged, part,erhapauIcoӉyzre0m e}lifσfirms遼tinsapptohad(tt8УHlle`t.Ϋ0lesqrxdiscourse rightفІluXr-n!queueump`, nsbme(fux@҆par(dcaryanada+T]rc:soYÈ edx8t s in؆xxsiual’sߓߓG3J">cxx2i!thy iz uma1obJfreelX +҈!ety ThisxstudyhowPhdeebut y`9deolog /atalkq;71KgVHBoLpp_sp_1117_10 ߀ނMςςτNOWN_F256TWO21ǀ߀߂3Pςςυgga7ga`灇Q_G3R7+S">When Yimant ϧȝȀbreirs 骑y(Xcdevispelsewe. omPXccordsmondPtRway whiadjuQt) oodJ ɰ;ex׺!8gocibasic8j `trir-#rsma slong-ardg gXs;b(hbiyyeom YOiȄXsPl`тJor%publ0debRp+bytry ro,ctbhe{Ptab@vaguen؄ɱѺminacsمߎ!cc{betwBzormiddxŒ|TOELoUׂWWP674WVLJ40gc3߀߂41ςςχ85w2ibre"d="co_footnoteReference_F269454765051_ID0ED"ame=aid="2G3G43">In Canada,heriginalebatesgainstSupremeourtudicial reviewfightsnderi0Charthaveeenesuscit0dn y“queuemping”uise.Ԁdissentrittin*oulli . . .asak0up lyithurgxykeeQ㇡sut souestion8ndusxclusivefocusonegns. Such.continutourfacearnolvba. earX'''4B"asinvsuppoforosit obligalifegh deoped,ԗ8rmrlogicidies, whiavoiercepqindividuy.hileX03ЃmЇXcostsdvoc@weak-i!approapoint X1p)atvnsuccessful~+[sometimes changpucx1lorun,iculhealth cscenario. [T]hePXI(icsnBqmo1mYantwb o-eomhdistribu< HPhroughӊ{Rightsitig: Lessonsromrazil䉩ׂ66G4U`4V">Octavio LuizottaerH (2011)*upHTf܇3"7384Y7577/G55">The c0tituف8z"e(omrj,*l 1tenussuenmeountrieisoops؀oversH JxcepS8practXaitnXwas.eH a Iworldurr cognize(naryformu,0r more-l773~educ k,p@,Hod R.uyycommeffecofiincreaslvo@Jse $(IhP)(“judi”),mailysubj.ÄXorsisagrenherp apXpriȋradRɅ2owho port’ZlvemabohowaH sHxgo (of Xhctrumpatecpt bstaXveviewhrSweakasH).ɋ9Xًbiyb. ;oo6o7o=7o7o+8k@؛tuPxEnglish`qlfocus0Sh AfrnokCIbe@moscr8its percepf؜IacHwhiВb8darge8+ trad#dHhlawdeR)(blen`.Ơ 넻K`nd, mH!فrepr n؂Qbyڜr8+RdupHthxirP La`e|deȉir-nmserwiitood a|)opobrІ.GGGG9G7G=AG7G+B">PaciP0 ot@id|''و`[Pguq82)legmolrdemocy(a(s؎ףpac.e0tlf(yp鎨llsctu oAgzYbeliB immij*myqs@i@he t `@oXhaXyno0s di Hn؟tY!cXGB #lyWr9hdgoodobx.e.,OLribu'$ 'GGGGCG7G=DG7G+E">. . thYu?di,0empilٍ.Ͷ< 7777/G5H">C inBalrgnizوHcЍ܇"fygainst AIDSuˎ1-fudrugistribugramtpr gon!-1990WHl1well-knownHIV-inf/cXze8werha@g nIVsܓrdathrougheal,,8un0p hwhichyargeutfuareh<H0limih9QmpWsifqt.stimXsƆ͢pyHp!Sãoaulo,monsopIxicloX40illeoplshowBRL85(xly USD43)—!equivald30%͋؊dgh h-c:oXn 8oiȁrx ƒw(sp2005эHyo0Z͘aPnewt incll{ policȓq10,000iuals.;'!I7=J7+K">I sapat̷3wreaozʶd , b8(hyp on,heuoiAЁЁ cYeye HeasЅ20G5L">M6pAcHZؐIq蓐QX}, !h!ta4law`year ץW;H(llalwayi"nc,entrowAadmsbu@o0sЈ\alYyrxpubsystemL5M7=N7+O">Itycrrom tnorm(oncQ ttqpa`ed`np@ itlt rolXs7J)ofagrB*noxcep.re twolevQ0viiddXs|OK:T4(P?=Q7+R">Art. 6Pduc:x\nut這labohouYeisuraecu(y, sociȀ1temhoo pchildu dY@yC⁐CnOϊϊψoG5Sρ?ρ=Tρ7ρ+U19H1qdutyuHXh buarebke@omp"iЧ9q=risk[maladʀun rsq ؅vservih:جy?5V7<607+18Ȇ!coursaat)bxju b8ty.utoes poimpȠIdiful󉒀Y8alu eff___2_7_=3_7_+4">Formeime,tasargelygreedhat(e 1988onstitutionalorms recognizingociandhomicightsidtavemmediate effect,uerear “programmatic,”.e.,3ai poli branches*depended,orIirullffpcy,n adopfegislxspecify9details1r implementz.ȉBequence,Ayseensnappr di0tdjudbycourts. 1<

7777/G67">[But, s]i97, . . [yBrazili8Ziary]sistxly (la sserti dubstanmodelreviewhich noealthefinp agaiwiȂ$`ce yposed upm(roughPator njuncqs. 9 87=97+A">TpfirsHbabmo@r,Hakemajority /i8rpre{?<at؃turn nxabsolu"[T]iurrh, overwhelm(val9>Cregard xHinviol@e1enꉨfu l X8hve#nextr花linkAoilif+thus ne`b)@sidrvlimitanFsIdae(te.I08th0ner \bmanyMgood (treat,quipZ etc.)!ndividuXcxXXsns,X its c8Ndhlop0n woulp8!af0@0ToѰ`ch~middle- Hw`ke@exetunspGFB7=C7+D">If ai8 1t-to-casHdȿ@ %'vIcerIerlow-sdisadvagg@p%O(puexsសg)X{perhaplesbjqI`slausirguev!yutun q (GDPpitaЁ(dSD10,000)—)t 10%UmyYn(f`ti9THp,up>inf9rقB2`iaѷe脒Qbއ3ЄDŽDŽDŽFƏ aarGony0haaccɠbcanh6primјrXublsystem shaizkӦvlg;_?_9G_7_=H_7_+I">On𧙕"Aempilw#vamajyisbene0ewypxofhsudiabad2@rugs0recqhxhestudyalyzll 23 3pwsuu`nt@az (wiongo eravЀ(nts)tSãoaulo. f,firmvious66.1删ainvolvr(22.3Dbeww),R30.58V0rialk֌.Upum gubepS? cؚber8dHS-eff[ss ( o^whioevail̲'pkeIerm2eseQm#resIbulk%(enditug؇)igov78.4% poxMiniHz.aߟ瞇瞂J7=K7"2G3G6L">It isotifficultouesshoenefitsromhptypefitigation. Itouldighlyurprisingfoseamilies8heottof society,erevcond0onworstndealtheed greate( basicanit;available:infant mortaxy1H)XS3pfor@!-tech, se-of--arHrugs,rocedure`Yequipment.sxpected,insteadcprxrt-to-؂9 ric󄙃cdistHXBrazil.npreAudyQgaZfederalovernI . . tenith Dsco0*Ռed΃s’umanevelodex (HDI)]ave8X93.3%awsuБaȂohnteenlow؅ogeBo0inJon(6.7% os.Ԃ(sameattPccuroud@ U|municip.<

7777/G6O"> las}dedyard:cccourts yesyHmeaipchQpoxi qempidatahowaW_,8s clear`ɨLȄ9ybylargȁFa min0iPvidual˦BiK @c0فXТ0nsitʅubl# sym1-uhrylausiie stitupy{. O9 WWPW7W=QW7W+Rn fielаcᅅs (suX)Z2ȡ ȓziddq9mj0iztakceHd, hr,PXykeRDnePwill >dopsertiaoydonyj1TcВnjB8J deXraebwwh Pr醰m` q urnety. NgqlegislatoradXYb(y尸Zzsupposģ8oooSo7o=To7o+UispXDro ad.or[tecHjud. Asۙ؂()Рwisote po Aineqfromu؏jڳde Xong pkY!chanX9garQPo rregaxsucthd(rYd#und"bddo.ׂs)ȃtimfHrya5pn@tyjfawQJg}H{ QuSjAc0ntA:Ÿ1,262awsuipفyMcSouѥJoão‰, Mra.,Joseph.m(2016)͗x84G/G+5'hdfootheh="kin:pos:fid:0071:offH0003N617@5ixeG76φ4'G>*(up3~87=97+A">. . .۟Xlyze]ppreviousHunBshe0yAcamp leeXgᔦmfil02008gainthe southernraziliantatefiorandeoul.ithopulation@ 11illqpeople,߁aseensharpncreaseH health-reedawsuitsheastecadrisingrom 1,126ew cP2002o 17,02509.oughly 70%1se wereorccessYmedicines.y(11,Khadq higPtumberцountry,(3,953nd.<

7777/G7D">Our fismonstrthat:argumenryjuz#a phenoHirivbyJrich,pyers,ndarmaceutiHmiordx8b-namnd茸-cost >@lHn},rge0false.ψ@rHarchuІ2rt-to-kitig:0;Ha widespd@acpL@xlow-xlaintiffs lЋyveryHor. 1wwwwEw7w=Fw7w+G">[J]߈) ȇbo0metropoh1rura . . .dividu hoilOky_'A dominantXȑhsocioecoicurhalf e0reti (32%)8nemploy21%).an servqsectXworkfjXFm up 15apLhP煟Mof8X,iadpij(techn'7H7=I7+J">Aq widotЅxdataqyˇ’0galhs@fd ct8en ir .M]o /-Public Def ersff hoo)ses aɁifiЫТg0ͷlsl@ؐ@ LbtXHa:requ@ f[feIn 91ޝǂ}upportK7=L7+Mkstudmajor pzugs{*partgopn1)Imu )s`lve bepavailabxvT]ff-xx)h`thҌt!US$185 (ge:z0–@89,172kOؑin>= d-ps: 1.6%rc(20ases)xd gؔP,000 0.8w(1 3E9 N ׁ?BO7+PO]??=Ǯ@ttoxcu2Qα9ghA'"cneydIЀ:neoIbꁲir him"cou@C?/77Q/7/=R/7/+S">In addsrysfuncheaymf؆:Dшxfapx@ٜ҃E(seekprivt)lts)voicHXrncumb!ysoJiory mpalikeȄ@muqȇ(ur @Ɉ rio탩g:,󄉶Oczeare fQnewys!re(ɇi);a arIjusasbjPhoص/Qu, expo!l;kӚ"Qislbod.s nwhXot@smarkets ,Sc`ʀmPuqXizYsitaneousdemervH|o0kehe sрystemespondoheirxpsedeedsitswnailu. 1<

RHitigationnrazil:  Therobl`nstitualҊJsesh4GG23G80" 5667G81div'"!2">Daniel Wei.׉0 (2015)*upT8O7܇ׂ0673?77577/G88">. . .Ғ쒧isainlyriveny@iduims forwtechnologies,special"ugwhichaveoteen incorporat0Pin"8publics2’s (SUS) pharmaceHohy.Ԃpercentagefa`volvixants de@d"„ʃy ph`: 80.6stP9Rioeano92.5 eity.πrrlieadX axysA 9lawsua@n-G@ wased,K8ǂł''gs amo8judiDed—62.2OOJ Saatarina; 68g'"FlorianoQs; 77Vd 66GGSãoaulo;r3Gd E_р ww''93ngv025-FNH G8A_o_[B_7_+C">[Some st0"count]sumblun thoseon[,]buphis]t0tIim8t` ??Ё2# *n. pnȠq,Horean one*TI]߁߁[also]rt ⢟alI B77 cau y w cribQ-laXkprotocolseÁ8mPmspazunapvclinZ!cs)to 7ubpopul;Zhtwwa?תЈwhoJmee(piatashH؁guidees8D1/E_G8F7+G">hr@smʾcorn ًregirwiBrazilμHSurveill Agen(ANVISA),8piblargsaf0nd(QPeirО[w{Ahlovis羌džDžK!cau0riz]@srI^f treatm:c@8effectxsbeen evaluڄgg8Hs6/8I OOO5OO8JOOOOOG8KOOO8OO8LOOO9OO8M//_G8N/7/+O">InHbes[riskt+stᔺd( ׂ`nHeryx.ƓexamplXt*São Paulo,$40ퟠ(ardS$19)spy juidecWrom 2005o 2006. However, 17erentfhismouxwaspnrugsithout sciificvidenceat(eyouldringnyenefioatтPho werelaimQm,becauseڄjnotegistdj ANVISAhcommendfa8’ conditi accordboBex`clinicaluphe0ndrotocols (off-}se). . !< The safetyeffectivssreatsДfirsysx Hsheesignhealthcaxpolis.Țs aelecan9negled:Xst-oht Co`rnbHYr:ackintucapaci lhhZedjudȃ1ic9some-mhHmmon crXcismHci Hvis welf,s viacirigh7onO[hAoؠadvox0aaZolʄinga؃gf8mD,۝Iivilk؇al c,lsoa!plexXsumaerylaoaraispb؅/Thu`q@ cchallengX9 i0rqfroY4lyaceg;_'_!V"7;907+1respX8oIgdva`upr FeXC (STF)]5eNR+nc8hJuce (CNJtextuzRdeb9cҜofȌ} `C1GEBbzk hapG20 pbȂxndaЅ I-makerJ?<27=37+4hhlapperaziliTتͰ.tರaubȈQr2009o 50 ex(incl߉faues, legscho@ۦ)resx"s),a iozsixayouppQ‘hn,iific,ministr"HżHomicinm{relX`ozϞϞpn57=67+7׎was؆znowledg߆n hi aimP &isystem܂Hnedoxsp@Psstx`PA tthHSInxЁHZzdevP feOaga1sIcernYirߚ˪,⪠jtoolI p춀oIlypؕXXenh0democrac parpip$AccorlȨrc[ch a)uBensu*nrhlihrough(co0h sqdiscuz.aOne]utұBOJ˃HBep@shb􀠐inodP Himmede0@IڡUS. [H{seyxфtuwcas8w" shouhqr؈/,bcf:]! W987=97+AfirHn8notny thl`dy or蒲ć,am1 ofxaoreညcommendedylinicalrotocolsnduidees. Ifhereatteingaim(hasoenncorporated,n)re iutyoavtnlyqaBregistdith) NationXHealSurveillancegency (ANVISA);dequ ern@vt}QSUS;29 availablarketor(lot. . !Ev2ougAtest wouldu0out:Bs s!e1iof effecAsafety,rishat(superiojex9es,!llgnoresolicons`lowhadjud0†righosadi0ual trump$<

7777/G9D">TCNJpar+Brazili ibrh,⌈ۀ powehcanrewdec s.tia hp)IulimHst!finXaQitĩrySenPcerH(ges’ f@0PFoA=pubrhe STFÊBsuRel31/2010. ‘rՓour@impl nmeasuYx h #2oegss9ora8p betolpH^s8(PNc. affir!ZS`0causwslpg;duО"ack&imӥ/to 4|܆drugap/KBo sWeuhritysnxrapac 0organiz+&ne guatee0 biWlpoakjnj?9E7=F7+Gre e, M:40_G9H?=I7+J">a. m(chtromoctorphap啰q,p -}ca;wwww9Kw?w=Lw7w+M">b. adʇiyXA01t ireheȟn;2voig( diPxp@J;{ult, wev0ibpo,bZ e؝dewwwwG9Nw?w=Ow7w+P">c.pcludlawisYPbjeczexa0 Х`kBgggg9Qg?g=Rg7g+S">d. 1xtuni`{?T`ap"ngv025-FN85"ame/U(/a\V7*A0 innovry:uilH¾intu9al QQ| 7777/GA3">However, itsuestionablehetherett8trainedudgesssistbyoctors andharmacsillytocquir@evaluateactual infoЃamakeouolic0es.venfeeduchese rehmedi/scientificPsue,toulenre c expectat@groupfM OLhavB necessarisÂrtis燃a comprehens󅧋mx1aXeatbre beingitigdor. . <Priority s@involvpromssocialjc ,ycric csDamor%[cannotd techn~aobjșlydeaodyHttachcouh4wern2Dh4OO2Asigil_toc_id_111GAEcolumbia_alGAF">Colo—JromRighPoȧth:nlupmX?br_"/݅PyaminlGLjǁ?AHOH6/GAI">A0ia EYY,scararra-Vera,jClaianelH(2011)sPOI8HJdfoot8eanchref="kindle:pos:fid:0073:offH0003N619@ixeGAK񅧅 L">*upTɯGAM"g7g. 1A8oughthЀH0]qhasHnnlh0with manjord[Hg*T-76092008 (z/08)],新 utJUriidr{demonrXreluct:to ieJ[it]؂pimwrzargu basuplackYreshces;8ttBne ];wunlicϥϾߍߍ|P߁7߁=Q߁7߁+R">[T]he mosIgovhlXshbnXesidP J’s “Deaӳ;Emergency”@emberi9. Agas,ʄlleg1imbursZ cHsnon-POSwbankrupjsym.Ёuathis mXdwiftissueriofrebircumv؁popuiscusJwHsoe .P (]a tйj8much-needJ4Re hڇLxz,lifraud cor҈osnewaxɾAer,gttep` gambœmHowa`fHxroabdidaemp re­regtpharmaceuuy.ΐ( ؓ8`tricirrit)arbiry(havi\[oEnt(EPS),ich cage]7777AS777=T777+U">In tl|qirtA subhpeblepucb؅0l1unH.Ԃ%0auror abr`҈1)њlen`l c.yebru1,8sstaklacecross Colombiasinghelogan “healthsotavor;t’sright.” Importantly,)serotestsncludedeoplehoeretypical socialissidents,uchshysinndembersfrCatholic hierarchy.<

7777/GB1">If initimmationjudgedontrenrer(`d(abilizeteepymmetrieRpon -capcontextovernZdea(ateXŅrgyㄠgy0dynamicorvapty iXr groups—evenblegislatu؀urtself.ndeed, oneffectT-760/08ay8llaveecrewhatharles Sabel*WilliamimPref(pOK:\507GB2?=37+4">ims `unsett8opupubstituschron1ly failkmeeheirgڑsubn1lyued fromnorm`cesselxccoutNJ??9GB5???=6?7?+7">Foeirsime{Zbecam(tPbroaJ deb1e,.8ignzfeasi럵ireypmsbe activehPcud. . !9 87=97+An April 2010˝_reun֯hwh(llowviseRoaxhremac ȳly.ԃSHodmst{,XiBsu1NAugu[fac maj0Xuit hЅtacklgSfinan crsith4;. 14B?=C7+D">* * *???7E777=F777+G2Dec*I1Mtdy POSarequd by^Y:dXsoЛp0X*poH("iddgx)8ial^ervi(vabmiddle- upper-ixhoholdsributoryChel4direio0pp tof;;ordA Yinuein betwҊoipl>;M2, &stwo sdiA"4,[agxt195%s߫ߘHH7=I7+J">NePl0, afhuckowa8ub0 enjoyBO Vresȋ` PaH)fu2009 (a~o Ya0, Parra-V0GellaaPg-to- igⒶI:ur8gg0`mee롌ҡ@pخ13˃O (poɅConga耩alawɁhaulhc೵pisKwxa aYÁ6)cpJhi8 sxbuar(e?7K7=L7+M">S s=0u Їχ @xr8ex offcio藬psti(X [ lview be9@akctXWAchangeJudgC-313-pvrmm U5LH1751bLamHxFaȕBhapman describe,heaw’sentralhangeasowitchJhealthenefit planromistfncludedervicesndedicinpinto a thatoveralluthorizvailable2cou@y; exceptionrprovibyingon-essi؄J@ wHgpublicunds.* mspan<> In Judg-313;ContuyCourthdermissi0 Law 1751 s(ra2finisustapbilؐeesignormysteՃ pnewG (cqPt-ߌ؂Halysis),utۑPhibituse׃@as yzlhtyarulaase.fte9elKJune 2018p@tpokboutimportA ensurvulnP1peoIruqaac .w;ih4we`rn2pigil_toc_id_11Vdiv0'GC07="ǁay_on_decisGC1">Enā-760 (2008) b"/yamin8퀇2h427h3gGC4'_6/GC5">AiaŒY GGGC6/+7ŮѴG15Oe21C87"9WWGCAW7W=B77W+C">. . . 36.ԝfar-hchpac얽ulnbeen a80,heSantosdistc o.n2,MK0fȪcuare nifyenefits HkaghĤςalsodopmore robxgepharmacepri.IoϋmDρ7ρ=Eρ7ρ+F">37. AtaxoFrworkaw ()15) (Colom))kpl@highoiJxhspsn2al law,#cțи8pxbyqgXMay H4;breviewphYogqÂJudg-313/14modifXzvdorᇠdeferenomy;imQ t0xaGȂchames; pbP٘1umpEinclus hR(ex;:ricomxsкs atinuit9Y ﻗ畇G7=H7+I">40. /08hallenccewisdomAleg0schoship,it bridbonHiduPucturxreyes(YlursXcile tax)sfuny<

7777/GCO">43. FirstoughhPsejute0Ѕ!sists,i judgtrans8mQ!laimscabeingade.hbea clearhiftromicinestreatڄPocernaancillِ,degIlikw9 P7=Q7+Rx4. Se,hilA9isidesmargin0zXgroupslacxxclu2RsXornificegimes incsȘab8cHhșhaHubstaPal bpetS,󂐆ROS-Silycap@BratepproximXone-halCGGύϋoCSρ7ρ=Tρ7ρ+U5. ThirS`odmin@iresp[T-$byoardpharm0xx+EPSsPexample: 2012(N*alЂo؊ AXwouldhav)ppen͟_V7 13ohrgyP0issuyribe*gnY///GD5//_GD6/7/+7">Law(93 (80) (Colom)+ludXmu(eQom wD8dž_GD97+A4381t amot)fis suïåAtȢHOb!‡GDBχ_GDC7+D63Hݜsolv ̏' ''''DE''_GDF'7'+G$751"5'"enshrinԦjfunda!Xh`qu9s. G9 OǮ߄H߁7'=I'7'+J7. WithosɻKpcipH1pubc=gen `,hichade bKrstount`worHadoptatu Frk"Йorganizarh@҂AܻD [A]}o_new PeĭT396, 58840532 7lj ashAcedaccessihmedic{sllAibsjcqaysisin@mb0 ۑseqtechnI ex"dnd`AiMiHescripción (‘mi-PRESp). Nonel tلwriQ,nyty-setHdݑ0pectaXye"bddhsed3iyms uPear0ffR;aBswi(ډX9nsI0ig:|pan> 7777/GDM">49. After-760/08,ivilocietyroupsereuickoppropriatehe definitionfealthsundamentalight,hichedWQ organiza9ndcademiafocusnnstitu19legal reformsaguaranteet.n!(r聈,‘structured particip’aljudgQ r(blyo-optmoradiІ8mobilohpposcXɀerlying systemdel. 1<JŁiPol(aEconomy Menes
T mcrquef3irv(ِccasices ym%isegabackd؂rapid(rug 8.ome;cs`ourtsll-ePppmak ssesss ؃Yt`e-offsetweeccost؃[ HPϔLA0 Binnovvtqxs thisrobl@oneenerdotb ћhusiasm }e,utlssinaأYumsawmovry/ыple;deepςtic鉨haabs1艀iۋmarkpA g9Zh`ˆa,rsi'wm؊hibveҎ!DS7=T7+U">How ouuayp(ffechup# Fropen٪qoomict,spe 疺F?ȑ_ghaadvduntr(mizmpaqfxi𕙱h8er8regimIeorldԝ!τos Agre{"-RelA fɃwlЃuR (TRIPS)*f;սN|S R`orteur,Bexam, fjWShadїIٿ#vailPakit difficulZcoyirblig\rBt,otIfulfilZڑ.”*0up(R ҏd-low-in3 -u so-lА@flPЍJȁppaad2Sba kͻdeopZneedsyùto(begucog`po@y!tex rbnpwaywhiȀQip HsxyitReHx tuAguarak77. 9 h3Uw38,igil_toc_id_11222 ochieng~?38______s?GE4">O O .ttorneyenljbw5"/8h3ooiO5?h107GE6@єRIKenyatirobiFs748">PexNo. 409/09 (2012)ׂT39WGE9" ?32?GEA7re77/GEB">[Bee Judgeumbigugi:]6oC7=D7+EIn 2008,ˍ"ppiAnti-rfeActHifihiaim(s1Y!3byrevent inghe traffickofotentiallyangerousounterfeitrugs.etitioners, Kenyan【zensivwithIV/AIDShosedigeicoXeatirnd,hpeXd “a-t`”aw foroerveubl@healendTheyrguits definaP/twasoroad,8Xnotnly product8wereubstandardriolatrademarks,utlso 0+p0nt? HZirra!aleca1each0sulina؇safe 3Kl,clud)o8r ries.]<

7777/GEH">. . . 44. IhonsidP3ssue|ariInpisF, imporxP@earQminsocio-eom0@texnich .7I7=J7+K">45`Xre cpbe0isputeSމy8ȓhithoHfe1Gn rticulZsbin Õmay infecqbyvirus soregуPchildren"women1 [Anebfed:__-40GEL`‘OWRM7+N">Apxim(@110,000a borHaimJFnsmȞ.cis0haaccumsigniX ch-cevncثhowqapri@ ordablhPɎ(le(betwe3050%.’ߊO߁7g=Pg7g+Q6 ȆЋPcos:po.ɢe˹ NAidsӌtegPl82004-(9lmlame p Ccenaicomced o:FxRmajoHmlAy`sdevelopXtC@s`eirstaHcovPByy1984, 1.5`llpeop:diduI-re`nes*hasḞ1.8^lef0xrph s, 0ryYbinf(or(iretroal9rapy, loHdec9cnumb yfromFQ ????R?7?=S?7?+T">50r ligh" abXz8ic1ʊ؈pSse: ߒڼై:𦚇@wonackgeomed0lvm,ᛡsƑ4ubzopportu0 ۅjohrkm`mmu8system. Many;aYIV,kߋ(oy e0Yna0qcapof ohemselv0㊒IyeremahealthyywdepeHHok/ichmu@c؍m(xcHijmEU7=V7*F01. c[U] lpaXIndustlл0ertyzH1,0[g]s߉tdrugsp"avail""exls didllpalemQUc"ileasi@nK$ilihq"ddaen (lifS ;0Lω"beiv eGGGG1G7G=2G7G+3@2At Xagainsthisontexthatnyegislativeeasurewould affecPccessibilitydvailaofti-retroviral`dicines musteiewed.fuchvJathe僓limiting ,nipsoactoreat8Ylsq healthpetonerrs inedihHIV. . . [AIDS],inoonirightsnder Consu9r .<

7777/GF6">56. In myʊo艂,fehumdign ؎xtricably bop.Ԋ@ePno@gumen|outto Rjeopardylhyllsas deJ@ng/nowe`allyeco s(@be,’s inaxF܁Z˅sensXelfrIYakafRmprom!.׆)may8) agreupb8qarti@؀yn:imple 4Anat)osve obligۋ  o@+Xٖon rxHtpla8P peoooo 7o7o=8o7o+9">63h ‘socio-n c@rotondwhipl leaؓaЋ{WR ےz⪨eqquioXma2y:(il*p0ZS_iÔXor like̝oicz1A7=B7+C6. iOregU׆ӱefore en h`oneu vns׎ӃZservi9IȺJalso'ӅЃτdnypX鿱way߄Eooj(ies. A`legis$W Ȑdrugs un ord" thu7GD7=E7+F7cruxdisxecour,)en @ [cert1sȇof]A-CXfeHAct;S: g|D| 0̋FG7=H7+I">78 i[T]efiJn!ɨ 8pqcludgenerxF [ZBwXϛ)duced 8Kenyalseچ#advers韌manuя,al0tri`܃9v0nof ph9.ԕم˃'vabili ʅW؁l8e0pѬ ,gІЂH̠ho/.J7=K7+L">828Crly,j[orjobj9rotillpual py1dividexPiraZqhol!bosusphhI77ougrad tood.ț82rimary eepafeguȂ0m@romQb)shrd rmphasHHndsqגOOOMO7O=NO7O+OH4. HoweC andealthfeopleikehe petitionershorenfectedi0IVirusannoteecur(by aaguerovisoituaقethoseharge responsibilityenforcementylawayhaveclear undtandingudiffnce@tweeneicndounterfeit medicine.ԁprimaryrndshouliAestsUwsZoXh/AIDSo m@wesu(to(scceso apatee cqA ial톌s.tuviollte’s obligYWŅ)(irighzlife 1"includlegisambiguoh subjprellu0QerPhol ) customafalsuchWsH@`퉷 W(WShxrvival noo` qՒ u,ɑ׋imanenyaabyʕ tak. . .<

7777/GFR">86. WhileH??yst ,'sʥlihooaise,X 4"iluth j ardyaA`)I{, "viewy iwxl?>of cz8or`zooooSo7o=To7o+Uh8hIt `umbrresi;׆[ta ] A-Calong`s u όh=ßBhhabȲby_XdB77X dep6RaꕌGGG4VO?O* * *???2777=3777+4">In 2014eΐxAmblf0Xseverߝ .΍itpaddAkt; licϖcttƏEpharmaces, b8Ʉ׃if8on(&Ⱛa law—ráZ3criehl A(w:qarug/HҝA0N0Enough"b(/5"/ϖ10GG8">Samuelͅsu84GG9(dfooteanc"ref="kindle:8:fid:0077:offH0003Nd>23HixeGGAم'GBupTh3C7=D7+E">. q[W]itho0lngwhyq-lmoveRbeenᰘ coexiHsYmfo weoregimq`s(ao rYurlcwia0wdayomXfairswwGFw7w=Gw7w+Hjq19c8ury˼*tivid w𨸾linkyC(smzuЃmarkets. Thm@a-barhetc8؃Xuoust freehacYv@opXxIK1oxr Marx cluded Bhrvan ologiaoپarrowItcapitчWWSI7bre132"id="2G3GGJ">[When] neoer0smame, . . [h]uman-rightsawndticsever r1tedohearrowrotectionfontrac0ropy,uty wereifIoiridcenturyllianceithedistriive xdemnaefens0minorolenushingack agains(al傘omy.<

The icxamplesqglob@dXiv,rganizaQsuch as AstynternH҂CWatch,䍈pqemphasinPsoci 8imbyUN’s UnHrsPDer⍵]xideahfrom t(latePczhipw antshagt@ressors. Awhi@"Emovemserlook advocac0 rColdr,{ttPdhirchyIwealHc!ߎX.חonHxcep,requpȍnotmet thatO seodOGO7=P7+Qul ha@beenrievouspacu.rehysТmade wt: abans wespibi8Ehhi nfairp@ty sHe.[ww ݍrmȆٍts 1willIriѩ/).vIn)or0focЗqnsurbloГu /inddsa0Gdo1wHowbof1sucdefin1goosȂxrfulharhr IAs&Ɋu(muxr(gnximiњou nelPiYs꺰utsѳjfek.ȋ_elarJ؂YonalQcernEpytႠstyowafocusq2sa,Jpro(itk57=67+7">IIam?>aunliksolЕShdvocacrgzaiٶ Шglac)eat`sfnionsndtherocal actorshatavettackednequalityuccessfullypeast.ute caneepbenefitsfhuman-righmovemenA 40 yea@whileejectingeoliber@sm. . !Aargcommunwithin chgariagPtionp؁ayotPrtNishy DžDž,⇘itubeexsuture<

TR)ó-ً(ANsmbσp5"/h3B؊a 1107GHC">Amyˇ supׁ84GHD/re6g(Egdfoot(eanc"refindle:pos:fid:0078:offH0003N>24HixeGHF׆ׁ'HG">*0up۔ƀ҂3GHH"ߋ32?GHI7re77/GHJ">. Today,8ny untriworldcembrac`socio`nomic i9nstitu9s,moreew{inpreted sHS(giverhtrorxdhividpseeg ޤtreiyprxnYBrazilColombia, aIlimiatwo.urAna,sta Ric`I8SouthfrȮlsordergHrnto Ш.xvcatoeal8 lif[2002ecis(MinhpHvhreat)Hon Campaign (TAC) ܶWxHlyCn`2Af8и @iXR availabivirap—arugs;8vAtransmisHIV/AIDS慸Xycdxunviol(Saڌcaservi,Pspe0im {8SHI’sffcy.]϶ϡώLρ7ρ=Mρ7ρ+N">For cr0cdefXRb,somea1fulnse,tuberdympghi*Іca.«wnaB1l1?P7=Q7+R">Hre tapb1cirbѬeps quonx`foc*i߀pexpXe0s. Clikecta`.ottaer(XguԥGo“alvit[y]”ᮙ equbeJɸde8?(regQc,`4budgexineariXka a0enefi,؈XwHArose whotigpuno9yooY.ӄla8+be,Ɏg1* echoԟ‚byĜel͙rink{Varunauri:TgpzdeX(midrumyY k. 9 S7=T7+U xpPe . . *twofolSx(x4sourefupnarrowmpirlim)showubtnumbf ntsnteastomeettingsreoor.therefendersfhe rightoedicinesintuh0seascanffec institutions,ndOItimrompteformsbenefit broalasnpecificitiganthlone.cholahaveso arguedmplicaT&wouldarore gressixifourpweembracHindividualicdel Ssn0ceme . .!B],engagwitheal8poxy rdialstructurinjunc3gowayX rȆquitabl8jui socioeconomS.<

7777/GI1">So frax, debat@bٕǕƎhasilyo foundHairogic:*Q({yك%ysume. Tpergaɖackgrqmarker4`ellxQty typlyeȒXseeo@urb—ily shappby❨䑈lawrntrHHin1995, aWorT"OrizʁeatyK“TRIPS”З, rrpp@؎.* upaqP (lows0mboverri,,`ycPury hen1(whichexroyiPqea"exclxvs),Z9bee؃HlexyHwjy ntrret́:souуasuأggggI5g7g=6g7g+7">O8 ݷisubst謈ؕu!co88eca expa&x8ato郁 manufahNew(sÃ,xaA,aS$100 @R+akpra$84,niStwցexXxa.ɤA>dgrx{ЂڹYZ*lmAdePH$hdg8r?݄7piaeifromrazi0ColombiHaffirmooooI8o7o=9o7o+A">Uqtux,dotьXinvؐ:inHw qQglobQoor.Џ*upa\nGAE7=F7+G">Prkexpol:(omǦ؀X2Ж9irlawll@uirrtfs @design!oorithрffordableedicines: itandateshatountrixadoptystemsoreevelopmentnd disxbutionf{arxarket-led,orioritize accingotoeedutao “+y”—cB mostulner:haveanxoisplay. < 7777/GIK">A roburighυer atopisegimeslausibly ressive:tcsignificaainealthcibudgets, likelyrfers*romRglobalouNorthprovides onhXterpt@yndHrypinstance,e fitjeorld.ԈBo,8 sh,ako(lm.ɗ/!cretdi(ualXlief,pyemuch0rupunderlyleguctumad)nydin؎h, particula9poor. . ;/)L7=M7+N">Is bePBweimag?r"huȍsiPcontexlPSoЍtorytial?`э a0porag se casargus0iltɌgactstsHeirupp@,~r腻ǂbodAirp؆?ٝۨmhp8it ؁IP">enqageXnǁǁGIQ">requi(ZoHo mZjp00eomWiXaew2excep饘thougڛxPsaS,vqifultpq؃x inviц m[F)xampߘIColombiar9BÃHIV/AIDS, Kaleld*bea҅Ѝd (gP`owdi :esȲ1g`)Scompulicens3 azfdgricH(@ecuid`fusxcp$waH ɫjRIPS{Yn(A @misў Ë<.imi ̇be=Brazil҂yClanshdec㇠o .]皯皫R7=S7+T">Apomalaw,_ anneulRxquX :xPrPgnRloigo, +arkeYincluJhX`eyoC(aertQk*5x9⯭B0Z \xic.ɏ r\gg|@QvHdel end,futHmakʄductRa`AFuՓh3wern38"鐠sigil_toc_id_11_XUBoe22\ hoff"ame?IV8/a___Zf_och.J0">F.ȁ n-Laҁtd.Anr..iplab҃e5"/oϚh10GJ1">HВDelhitδxj'''σ'$2">148 (2008)LT 598,IPR (2) 35E51GJ3744y/:h3739GJ5???=6/7?+7">[Judgmp!MJ(8ӗ9vxra˜:υσ7σ487=97+Ah. PXntiff:suseeka]janAinjun ЪXin infr@epԂe䣐rloHib,8nd`onacndamagYdeluphingoods. . . .<

7777/GJD">2. Jtsqimedhat(drugarkaHjorreakthroughnd innovationnetmentfancer;"us oestroyome typesgellshileusingittxharmnormaluman SOJE7=F7+G">3allegˉP`ntiffsdnter0o DevelopCollaboricenAgree1,ch firstO@p@ oa,offfsalȂldroductsclud1ErlotinibStasarceva. =soubm8e*p.XfurrUp(authorizepcanyectu腨pertyights )`ir.Ԅ^ctiPyXga1in ufurH9pvT1variouountriIndiaj1 tApril 2006. '9 /Ϙ/H/7/=I/7/+J">4. DefendaCIPLA,secobiggHaceutim q J܇bP7"J`ary8,newseporappeaX(wꄛeronice bou* d=’sinoaun`aenervers)vi:Aexُq `_WKW7W=LW7W+M">57dutx8underviZlawnoexcepo exerci@ sociaQwitx@de @ow%Xopy/simul/re-c!М 02nameoǍwwJNw7w=Ow7w+P">1[T]Yvdo notr{,FѲRؙli@91996Ptx0،8 imͨropon G005.venw,`JiHhcx:aeasiavai Ʉp msHG77GJQ777=R777+S0pmapartrom1AterofÛ،Ц1(injȜsXl@erPed[ capsu8cos0$70]QɏA18qui`YԷk/GB24]us,Pmonth2dosa jgoځ(c`(05w( ׄ-we%677WP(Tabifav1X[is]ubl ʔ8!vsuffdas likejq؄dȗcheapaf`dicploa#g a ‘fly-by-nator(ucю)olmJDŽciety/,T7=U7+V">417hc@PՑi]>rxJ-markei-,C ؕScaugIeju@ڒ|lavcrXsa ous@esjRbalQxvtil` towardGGGGiGGGAPnjus@i1huHTarcevgڟcludȁc@oms dusff.Á 8bm1:DOlpays#exciseuဈtiesnherugsanufacturedytndus2price differentialsxtremelyighespitesaiduRpaby par. . <

7777/GK2">82. InprevioXdecision] ,bCourtfppeobservHthat eve)limdnjunct(nsuringBpanPlreadyug inuesshouleo`nuYosupplied,sdiforterlocutoryhraɃ:efendant,proveadequate.he hf(her;such=@cannotwith2issue weemberP public,he(y@ rodepbenefxit* (wh ao[`rcasonmustpls wAXttlPfXypkelihooƇj, ‘irbi8t1n necessary.xfe-sav{sexcepposre qoftCauQɠ{exi`alongsideaxo 9hgr0alllHefficacrculahilmrise.ɉkdencHX@ɋay weGw*make,, ؓaromtisfyp؊+rЁʕakwno쉘v`abn֝؅ `@cgr@iw;E s؉XrR quni0}ny judgɀttePdoubtfu[iX@cre IughIŃ(sthinkxyircumstaנLfinvaris betweH@s@ws.’_[37=47+54. !snselapomXtagYg eloHnt about \ntryhRIPS0giPɍqcompY8glob .Ȥ@iYicti߆fsarceva? duEȷPibɩI8hX joicAs hhd+f,""v/. fH—f(mIG9xx[h] `mporЙdr8 whiignoⲂӸm`la0;CŪormoh unJedww8phahqmanuur1pIndia, T>,h,Zmarke h’p? blQs adp)volisH [$1.94illX]losindep0obje0 .őif9X㥰race藈gh1,000@tiڋhap!nefbR) `nclussorJ 9 67=77+85. U,HP''8@a`dYlaw ulf0[]ernog,e ɨ(ceppȫ4 weigh arel؝sxIɂbackgC>mP tmgPrucQssוhajvailablӜ9su w9ied XBeˁXgreZhanlitxbste;sQ[exexpy;cx0f؛9altoge!X??9SriXJird8`i`un-Hsat).Xwayview AifOO_jʄP,* 30e lAhc21*86. Theastndl(significantctthatbexami@ae questionfrreparablerdshipeixrartyproduced anyvideoumbpatientsufferingrommallell lu(.et鄐nfbNewpxicleyJplaintiff,tatabout 90, enb79zwoPIndia nuy#τȋNhonalÀegistryHport releasƂnedouncil2(g`eve@hour 50ersonsiagndsnEfigures ydžailtTarcevaseekX X(Xore,gtnompirjmrial, HQPeȉwhichrteђ/rsH^who4us၁6’%hf injȗR0@up; oh,遀؂I(rge pmdeprivif0avdrug?=gr袡thȈcHopin betwetwo(mpetIpublicОs iJ8)*ًЄffirmPadu"renyfe(pР8eopgbal til(Yfav@lat8damagb(occychQcapʇssb0m@tary pms.owIs} 1def'ct,mayeashenl K(unknownM88BiɄsui: pi(ituL􇡙tply qnsateuM ca >soughaWSF7=G7+H">[h iхbhp`erossibilier yƒffm-LAocqyclud)iord8ZCio “mfaHfulѱ٣"sac<”dwЭ_⩰uHerx9㶫 @.]__h3wpern38"Xil_toc_id_11Ianj22\ ebay"ameeJ/a///._v_mercGKK">eBInc..PrcExchgL.L.Cȃbr5"/ϓ10GKL">Sumէ UniSqsVh3__YMǃǁ4N">547.S. 388 (2006)OI9GKO?=P7+Q">Ju0ce ThomderT-Z 9 ߃߃{R ?BS7+T1 opyopularebsHnP"x ell!lihgoods@isX,ȟr鼉abrἐx0ce. heKءasinAmepd C*helectronmarke靘nfac񆉳R; jPtwee individ(yPsh;c9au0rmor؊s, suZ infrr. 1ollowʉdictphol7SDhtl ȍ1Pan}vliefppe9FeCirc8@bsequXrѺQru{rt emphasiz P rrqrightsndeldhat,nHe casefnfringementropertyighjunctionshouhonly beenied “unusual”!andnderexcepAal circumstances.]<

7777/GL0">Accord` toell-eblish p0ciples1equity,qlaintiffeek manustatisfyfour-factorHefort mayra suchelief.demtrate: (1)Jtas sufferIrreparery; (2rdiavail"law, asonetaryamagesxinadhompen(e f3c,0nsiibal9hardshipsxtwee{defendЋysared;(4) *apuctwnoisservb>";. . oooo1o7o=2o7o+3">These familiarpplyithalQpu`is҈eЍXActsP8CA9ohrecognized,iaajor dtuXfrom"zdiʙ~0ih< lAimp(dqo 8܅dicx1ChPs d8.o*rexpv؂䏿sّ(uja򋒕rgކG47=57+6osalseHp allPv8attribR0s,*ncluiAij10e Бma,,)salIhvМiփiۄAppeۤ{eeCit]Q`HtuXG@xe`ifigen2rujavkב≠?9 GG7G7G=8G7G+9">J` Diie(11goQ8 ˒k__ZPI$߆|A߁7߁=B߁7߁+C">Becauwr rneer륨low`cѫДڧΫڿ/frameworkgoveradF,eaRjudgm,oo:,firinh?[X twouropinhia0eڍoɝD@H exKaX,befuln 1bauinewechnologandHHnlgazhʣyRob@joinhby sӉaǍburemp1C88eas ear019cus3򔇔pa f1IfTvImaj0Kcases Although%sldexercis[e]+abPxcreY purjeblishțϯȴ(ynot smvow؇xnhyhexslBHgfHvimporqsugg8۝@ripmoPcims.Keny, ݐteSoHr,Breybrgu ohelp؁ru{wheZ 烹92XaubtpaPleЇH+9frobe—aXtuat,?; ed, 0mid8Irapi𜾇legRvpy"symbBiso-Xlȁtrol(agssٟorshotpt enAJsps抈beyoPnly!^y’s 0uHvalue.] 777g(I">* * * Since 2006,omeourtsnhenitedtatesaveelio fyh prongfeBayestojectjuncti=fAcases involvi0medievicandines.hileoqvokaight HN,.S.pachsertaparallelsY5 4Indi 9LN">Roche.orxample,OHmitha Nephew,c..@terlace͈ӀۃI, 955.upp. 2d 69 (D. M`013),:distri0judgrBDCRPusetXthathprnpublicQwe@ed agissu nޒa8roscopic surg"equipment:WWW0GLP_?_=Q_7_+R">. . .Ԙint LS@lookwher aermanhonouldser.ϝcone hہ7geneyavorsrot遁s phenp3ystem. Butre y؃vail8maHolo’s aabPatreaty.phvideshowleadoctspr釸hdu(more effɋz.۝Ν]raue removalf"sOOIpy- 0Imevheleshcqirisillur(negȇ@impafƎHenjod fromel:qi.ecap@ɑ mai@|oitniculaϊ ˍQu,alXgbfitpbstantiiPab ݁蓦market. G@ooptimRLgc ʃgryҟk8ǧh3mw38"`sigil_toc_id_119GLT8/(22\ c62nameeU/a///*)_c-V">JÀ/16brR5"/ph3wwqM0(1ׁ01">Ctitual {0Cmbia2a"ang="es-COGM3G44">No. D-11374 (CC) (@6)O:suS84OGM5}6/6/GM7dfootn"ref="Pdle:pos:fid:007C:offH0003N$>28HuixeGM8ׇׁ'M9">*0up{;?\3@A" ?3߁8BO7re77/GMCwwMD">[P3 Magi(`:ariaiHC(erX:]/,ME?=F7+GMH"> [Thpp,uvooraȆbo,ЈX!Associ8of Phace`9LabRParc+Dlop,rough hngoLaw 1753,hi leqc8izHho sdrug跐ÆAevalu=s effPcyJcost-ehȿybyonagenc`.ϏϞ3gGMIǁ7ǁ=Jǁ7ǁ+K">. 13.1.2.ԇimsatrt. 71}ndw,HLGWB??dle:pos:fid:007D:offH0003N"d="sdfootnote29anc"ameixe"2G3GMM">**3.2.1. Tacɕszunderrt. 7277/Ra"ref="kle:Eפׂ7e30׀ׄMSׁׅ"TФπS] [8ost-ectYess]ps@m8Ileorvalur Healthechnology (IETS)閩8-Jany []xgis AS?9 de(min[h16. UzaroadJ[takanto accouividuHpibilitywe)si*H socioe omxcircumP@YSwideariihim1ЋPgs(8gspllihס(ږg,@abe co`*砠releɄH#incluxa /po'GN17=27+37. A''ufair`sPleasfollowKrxu:g innoťelopah ser)Zrgnizdnt limpqn fscb[bexamp bbHȨЂu胘z47=57+6">22. c fiȭcGG@xCmbiaH䇨2003hMinPW[,87fȏS]T]do +xH:hܮ[ttro fewuppliP{fl2eedH*oZZsch@aimXtra:markeber8zGŋÔcraloalasoistinguish betweenssentialndon-medications,mulate competihroughenericns. . <

7777/GN9">31. cThe0rmtablXesnstrumorehrzed negoofp`p@suppliedev1h0 puco0yasure.tonferpyein`ryHealthq SocWelfare3owexochamsZreg󈨆_alsoticipXhatsequencea ,all]pursy h8eouby(os-???ߒ?A?7?=B?7?+C83. ArHle 71ۆLaw 1753]sepsartargB“s mobility,”hichщ`utQpromoteʂ8secur:nivc(auty葻cIsystemzto enْfinan’ʗ$.Ø _seo1 tood;eor ex{-includrnre`7ND7=E7+F">x ac8bmiH (ZwouldakPe,i>yrPir<sducteit(ft{onlyᛚxofЌ8bPnojQhavuirwnPsoes )ayPl%. 1OG ?BH7+I">H,’sՌ)DNDlopPlan ig1nұmaax󑉡FOM:衠"gohguareei7ß, zrX* 9 lj_lj[Jo7=K7+L">Inard,vecڀxnoە]re Ț@ctl|righj tҏSX8,ustȯ8ogtowIya mۗtPer/GNM7=N7+O4. 3Krpewholɂhea lhipLanogn`s P<邧 `.ԅ]ptri( AeffXptisfahʩh.ɎHs䧰eca @X\ԭjypHz,B̒ affirsseekQlishfaH́9blQ alsom:Qimp3*BsaKoˣdӍ8measux. . OP7=Q7+R6Ctitu<

7777/GO1">38. cTCourtustonduct셁ehde8mineheXr rrinomicreedmposedynor8sist withlaw [T]basX ithaeseeks advanceۀًR]ubl healthcarendoHreasaSyaroadowAo#eύύύϋoO2ρ7ρ=3ρ7ρ+41. ffirms܉schemeZcHrzPpxe negotiasmH!requiringllrkectororadex @t$sexOIouara tainabilityύym??ߌ?5?7?=6?7?+7">Cartic333titu˘ߘܛrdevelop"inCimitsypmmwelf? 0peBncludeHer鎐sp*ițUH legisl"’si3medic erstoodp8appZnciplpunivty, solidaraecacpc0a,`k". [I(;sbecauit]xdAHo agvided Dւɂls1', ow?Ԗ"m1ifer!roughairnwadonotnse𴈂I„p;s.avXh1 engong- gf\7m, shw8ʣ ao(of availayxߟߟߟߝO8߁7߁=9߁7߁+A2OڲkziwoJaspҙed: (i)򩇩9莰9u8rh[!'#kGnm0ishobj circumțq SIuro/on. (i8A 7//)` “un”D;ufК@dribu,e [T]StYhaö'Agularlqu+[rodupxed]mזזזהwBׁ7ׁ=Cׁ7ׁ+D">41 C PiŠawAnewquires issu9aanitaryA)a l:8sHڭ50ne㰟Athroug cost-n(m,uxf rW, puco0oI0maJong-逑cA 8extenthatettingroduct’s`icethe timetirstntersarketfficially,y keasiero rationalizeublicxpenditures.<

7777/GOM">An effectiveontrol2chmedicRsndlevs, ointhenyLjixlsoespondo state ogJvidpc(Bhealthnmannis sisti nciplesIun8rs`tsolidarbHcy, qЅil8obenefHsegm pul˃molimitepurchpowerwhorequiretreatON ?BO7+P">51. TCourYqllenglawas0issua0qframeworkȧcasymichZped importanorm8dAadvaguar(eaundntalutonomourenounceableighВ;ncludasps ne9iI HSza,dd΄P Pgselop. . !/9 7Ϗ7Q?7/=R/7/+S">Duxg ConCdehe:1uesarosȁrZ.؀yjIETScc-nn0mMinryqHish barrӌ$oc8?:rdisx)ₐ ha8a萘naePtl o. 1GT7=U7+VH* Ј?L9d}8edAsٜpiciLbhArtic872t. [I]tȁ8erprePa>n Io-]Zmocomm77Ǎ'P0'7'=1'7'+2 da!l ǀssfy㷠erӃb#N-ӭ ,x I,9le(cognizedZNJmX(ntroll週E’8>qmarket,uarae0roductquPti8nomicdibii`t Dd`CŒXh Nonel,ہQj]lsynormuld- o`k ggappln0"Qě򊈅ʞtiyespe lHt (siѡgovernbexpend0qyeSlikeq(elp aesmwoo97=A7+BexeT:dPkۉtlyffect theightfccessohestttainabletandardihealth,nd orumentalsike(fe,equiresntervPionyy Court. < 7777/GPE">Foratason,ۈqconstituty!Artic72sremised]neringYaddi;stclud(# issuanceiZegistryannof1vailabir kifedicaɌ!dleviXorJpopulB. . . .;h3=w ern38"0sigil_toc_id_120GPFa22\ aza"Xw/G(/aOOOJmeza_garciH">Mǀía.in0Hbr5"/h3/Ig10J">C TribuɄPPeru (Fihamber)&///K///4LILE.° 2945-2003-AA-TC (`4suOc84_GPM/p6/GPN/pdfootPe8"ref="kindle:pos:fid:007F:offH08N>31H퀿ixeGPO׆ׁ'PP">*0up㘎b9GPQ'?'=R7'+S">[MaJates AlvarlA,onzalOjedafToma:]T7=U7+V">TapplntsedᨂaarPprcxsk spber8ˀxl;ѫ}d [HIV/AIDSwhichhouldBЄ: (a)9ovisadϫ+t)}, allcarripouroughxmDosayo Hospi; (b)erioxams,uCD4viloadupon >physi0!nd/whenrgersWגגאwQ0ׁ7ׁ=1ׁ7ׁ+2גӌș˶RS舀f`give hol,c؈qonly sinil,Phaveinpisour managhighstsjMixase,isincycom gPv@Zthyroier,`dԈmeetts obligʓHs Y,sxay w@"Puffpfromuculo,ellow fevQqoraintqwithjpciple p؄hu@gnityrSealh ǀlifa葥%/ E#7777Q3777=4777+5">6. Whؘo0lu,CQituins@nnom`AsoCsjxone*fundnT .2,C@Hlikurp ColombiderZɹpi|㇟HeU 3`#"zreevelopȭ sonA[]crharacpa ]m0safeguar ooooQ6o7o=7o7o+8">7. TIbes,zparularaturc+ !1,ǜǮ Ƀgі֐uq ۡ&irlChip##.time, 0roXɣ!Xyzsr’(ffirms n׽xregxRhealthareervices. . <

7777/GQB">16. Itsndeniablehatnyormfommunitarilifeequires@ organizationrivenowardhdoal,pdhosechievementsn rellimemberXFor son,hxo-lsocial righ؋Yestpishasaqalbs9!H&y, ideducrPryxxgroupمxregulateir@hPshipsithnnoIghprincip`solidty_QC7=D7+E">Sf impli@c*xaew(,5nexus i`t tog(ȉY)#pHt eԈle omotfulfillѕZertai8u,ncluding:|40WGQF?=G7+H">(a) ywpco`ctuppor`PgeRьeآ___I_?_=J_7_+KXb_MleaIx adlydistribuenefrepdyX///ǚ/L'7'=M'7'+N">22qza@Hpeo!diagnةHIV/AIDS suffexg3e toulHeX &se xy10joreed@٦autonomy`sOJ1pPtackfinaX(ourxan (ossi ofpdPdtJ(ow(urzpi.irudigY''''QO'7'=P'7'+Q">[Inj]-X@ӱ hXuno0ce ],,@xI77yhe (dauljakdownYhthةػedskH’sfturnр(indPduin)ormp0a8+accepyp3 Cptiton7R7=S7+T040n0democrc just,pibi)akrњmonyonot1ex0sPXaSt,uPach ߏKor. 17U7=V7*R0">38. S xhrightess8̇ieveMgoom2dtSme(st!ȊKbi;b$ՌHd؅xtecr.ɍregarogz@ЄHhumanverexdP(i(imxsh<rp9d` aaDdeprhsʝobligڴrn@a0anyqfR17=27+39. A_,ѠΑjudgeoexami"o y, e
eln ssar(yzs ВDXr,ú*i air0hhRʆ[n`ang .hihRuѕ㱠a@dPlopountrilikpurwndif0im` uljxecb2 ŋKfavorfs8pdHCt reiPpsua:zpvHnPwhbal-epev PtxpbrAabhpm)ɉorwO*ambiXenceouldringbout conditionfnxstitualityymiss.<

7777/GR7">40. WhilehessueoesotirectlyriseIpresentleaor prot`,isourtidersyveniopportunto add8selatedЃzrightsqintellPual0operty 8ogniz!rnagreems,sAexcepsۄ0commitj]malestablish[ohr]?9 docuinframeworkWorldraderga , whicherubeenmembertince 1995ߑߑߑߏR8߁7߁=9߁7߁+A">The Dohainis`ipDer14ov2001gard WWPndupcealththat,jpmaaBdevelop new@dicʑH!eff`q[y] mayv nic`shou`Abgnored,xpecPwhsay fadifficulti8meetirPg+Bډ ,ai㤈zen’؅life9"cafseXuhHIV/AIDSXu腈osișha nd Jpmics.Ԁe ///Nqarri؁)abi҂wakesaryasuPϊnclu )via in ////RB/7/=C/7/+D1. I18gi0Cwsdۧى1!vi( AWtreaڑlike o0Had)attso@8PʑoagaiibeȍdЅ@H_ZTO,d0`po@IuC JRow/i9objvdefd1( +roughlex*Iɉoxσbounhs`4 'RE7=F7+G2*rң/-ȁl tȐO0Kare id\harmpHducto"C[@ TRIPSfHades.] . . WWWWRHW7W=IW7W+JP8. H`s za[u(erstoo؈HBe Bo0nuousl's (exams, etc.),8quiXovomail"K7=L7+M9. cSoc,7נ ,oi pul mselxpiaH q,caypeI{S’9miPinanq sour.Ιrlmڅ@9ay jifyqlong2aۣԃ wwwwRNw7w=Ow7w+P">It nesarG8dQcreІsst؆ٗrۈporsPsxXUeS legis,rexecpcx)777׊7Q777=R777+S">The ctio1:t40OGRT?=U7+V">1. Toh0shzwriftyw-gh@d.</span>

7777/GS2">2. Torderhat(epplicanteonsiedsnef0oseatients whohalleceivolisticreatm@gainstIV/AIDSrom MinhryHealth,hichincludrovisionImed0tpsnd correspondingalysis,ne8uper phciaSqpital. . <Unknown139.ertH prip(pcyofol๠bSt85VQ6"> 9nghwork,nwoP,Z:e agchildreobuszcitize9 forcj eomnXss л avounsuii(κT7a('ρϼ'_oog?wI0GCW+/WWvGJx** 0a Unknown***43.ivetc.,zɥ50U7">TSt shall8deavourBXbyuitegisle an(պ$way|0gricultural, ustrixw,a`diaځ ensPaectXard!lifefuJjoyqeiЀHoc!Qpportunes,pa!ularWWV8m@ttchpdu co-oPhveasisrbxalUnknown1 Unknown1Healths rightallnduty]Stshbeuateed meysociaeomicoliciePtducrisk illneorazardquni%quQccto ac1servsortsmo,YtebZrhyWWWWWWWWWWWWWפ׸WWWWW'WWWWWWWWρϸWWWWWWWWWWWWWW_WWWWWWooWWgWW?wWWWWWW 23UnknownTaH Bayԑs>9y 6, ) 3JO6pbr h0_____________߲______'_______ρϲ______________Dz__/___ooo__g__ww__________________^OM4A___Ww+9/4A_WW__V____^O_1U_X**a

1Fromdnesburynsonableso AccountabilXorҁ70, 76 Cambridge Journ8642 ( 7).Unknown

**GovmentfheepublicSouthfrica.M06rXboom, [2]ACC 19 (Oct. 4, ),laintiffsoughtnrderequiring gotorovidemiHadateasshelf0yereorciblyvictedrominmalacksyaduilt oniv!land.ԁ im8 iolati8ecZ26劂 nonstitu1,hichat “[e]yoneH ri9 haveccesohous,”pdot]8st mus(ake@asonablegis!Ɂorures0Hints availour8,:chiegs8lisH(b.I` 8CҔWPlPIׂdidopitle[]zXpond Uormi@8uemit oPgJ(dsimpleoPX,P-ind a(ignmeet!'bsyUnknown

* 8>Da Biltz, Giv9Socio-Eomicҹisԑh:Minimumr IImportance, 119 7">B Kn:J `\ 484 (2002).'Wρϴǁ_oogG?wTEN4"d="sdfootnote14"id="2TEN41"> *Theetyfocialightsnforcement, 53 Harvard InationLawoul@> 189 (2012).Unknown

*, Theudici zat8fealthtQuort Accountabil:vidence[1,262suitsessoeqnes inurnrazi@18Q6">Jc iHumRighJournalP9>211 (2016).Unknown

*Colombia—JudAlrXctionfheightoealth: Anusiveymise?6">inQ Litigating cs:pnourtsroreusticeg@> 103 (_[Siriloppends., 2011).Unknow{metontent="LQOff96.1.2.1 (MacOSX)gentor"/''"T8Enzweigauth8-10-21T18:55creapρρ-29T13:19:01.56051315h16.ˁkAppIYaleawchoolCom`yDocSecurit__Yfals{Hyper sC/)UpToDЁSeCropooolhare8gg`;;;;Pwwptext;set=utfx-equivz-TpK<flow5?micss"elPtylesheet"8܁ |3i (Rainerrote, Fraukeachenmann,ndüdig@Woldrumds., 2017).yermission ofxfordniversityress,SA.

Unknown

*availatTAȵ1618ǰǰǰǰǰǰǰǰǰǰǰǰǝGGǰǰǰǰǂ'ǰǰǰǁǰǰǰǁρϰǰǰǰǂǰǰǁǰǰǰǁǰǰǁ_//ǰǁǰ

*Theightoedicinesnnge ofeoer smspB6">Humanityppx(Forthcoming 2018).Unknown

*UnknownNhHon shpepvedqhliferLertyxcepXcc0 roceduidy0w'ρϴ_ﴇoog?wϴ3APVhҭn1C007JUϴWV0 Transla Edgarel9(,.D.Â2020)'ntent="2018-10-21T18:55:00"ame="created"/>

**. . .he Mini)orealthndocialelf( (MSPS)hallstablish meismsonitiP r0zedego@sqtheHiceqdic,ۀsl]uppli idevthatr~hthrough begatoryn rpursy $, seayotqhnsacᅸighbۆ`ooooi]Nral Govxmx,XsubsidiaHmanner,eek=7=Unknown*<Ї0W4R8PArtic72y 1753ovides: 3045br0ggga5g046">Aevalu y"InshuteorŁHealthechnology (IETS)KtJpqS(Minist} Soci0WelfhSPS)0dHn`halloxbHrr`beȻl4MFood Obght (INVIMA)ssuesrnewssanitregIC9X.k@Xatmp ɂmin7 ''& 1p Hq0t from,cRaodifygivenGn’s Ѐs,`ur-Xiacn"i(f sciificPnceinrderoprotect]ublicealth.

Unknown

*8

OPINIONS Excerp1؈/3186(AA.B (Court0eorntario,P07) I-39߂߂87.B.MiniɂSociPDevelopmȃɉ7FSo@ OO43ǃǃǃEBptwoodcmyTennessxondarychoolthletAssщ߈(Supremeourtfhenitedtates, 2001) II-25

Cañas.TPԂ (FederalupremeSwitzerland,irstivil Lawāsion749Gseo. 2.186 (ChileV-21H.K.ndϊ`r"Republikalovenija (fJusticeYEuropean Fifth amber11I-30??68Ogef`aHodgqwy1oom7ichieng¡__ ׎׎ТV-478liari9ItalyƀhR9:2?9PavSmiwwwv-3߃??=A:radisozCampan8ggׇg`wGPׄ62߁߄Bechstei2InternSkP (Fed'DSwitzerl`ivilawĀPY0r5gobre153" aid="3EK19C"> Policeor0ofhezechepubtl..lhodor (Court Just Europeannion,econdpamber, 2017) III-52

h1wesn36"sigil_toc_id_12119Q">COMMENTARYND//ADDITIONALATERIALS ExcerpxAsmopolitLegxOrEssaynecijT-760 08) qiIV-4gA0ggscararra-VX,la GianellaύߍنOOA10olo—JudlQ2o HthY:3ot2myapczynskiW3">Tonin@yߴK Ne@smJu266V-5O/U4BruBρρx5`nnximőuFIFA’s׬CupCorrup66¾gn6Cҹun /7">xEconomic?Lensrom Southfr0/ׄ.8њlRiz(lah߁߁9Dubl8Sym2߂W]AB">Fefugeehen㤷0Conv)RelqoStatusуs (hκ*s, 1951) Draig877ETailorApproach)sovpancG6? FDavidilchitzK1AG">Givingocio-Economicightseeth (2002) IV-28

David.artin, Resolutenforcementsotustor trictionists 15II-69ρτ,JLandauK">Theetyfjal-Wt]1\ Lnielei.angǁDŽǁMpoȄthitiga nrazil =V-3焧Noug eJaimeOKNatureAParhoodf7(-57''P!rafteva@dtxBasLaw1HungaryZ8oonQhFrédériqueautRProhibȇoPitatsy Athletes ɁXConsencyicle 10European `ɃтHuman^4-_׈ESGuidelinmogInvolv{WoPnFIFAuncp(Governancemmittee,??AT"> FIntIaade Footballssс, lI-23$UJoãoiehl,iana.aJoseph.P9׆ׂAV JudiizooYSYQuZ AccHtabiif6߂WB0PKathne.قdž_1sȄ؄ 0OT2 yoǁǁr3">WhpRefugeStoppedeMigra^3à_4XLe r旈ogXGelssܨƓĂagu> LChiefxecutiv@9ClubXes1%x5o8zoéPni6">Gloybr@Public-Privodies:ԅWorlddžA-Dop1Agr(WADA)]09R55_/_7XysworthWW8">IDR,nishq,d Tsm# Juspe5w791oyaoddhair,TaskrО"’sNA">Q,V65c2//DB(Naviillay`ilisdWeilePBC">‘Ourin?GGAWe`(aketatifaoeriously@ a44__DYew rk`tIM (UnitРKs//)Ge0embl0DBEOctHouiottaerraz__F">HarmPoThroughpׅѯ; Litig":ens+Bi1㋇GlympicrAr50 (VA0e, f'H@Fam؎requ ct&-4?Is leaso. 29/@8߁߁J">Xin “diuaoceedÍOOH(Fed"CtitȉChtaGenFirst SeеH)"1wwKpSamBLuҒRtn񤦄!Vς'M"rangxN">Why0XHavezʢtrol n?+71ρׅτTOhHxirgis,obeP.org RyT.np ilass="calibre15"id="3EK1BP">What isarriage? (2011) I-16

Silviaamporesi, Ethicsfegulatingompetitionoromenith Hyperandrogenismn6hI-20wDžwSq(tnglx UKӀǂǁT’sxdeBs Governance59UtatehtA.artlettiamattmisser1Baseball (198943VusedIndict,nitedӄs.a (U.S.istrX`urt وtheastȁNework, 0538GC0T.lexPinikoffǁǁ1">TakYMobilityeriously 8q12yhomasammeltoft-HansJamC thaway773">Non-Refoulj irldCootiveereg4?DŽ-4 maPta7)PesQ3Wׂׂ5ӁNhons؝b Specialapeur-4_''%6 ZTowardsPFr`wjMǝ_wq(hncil 8Eur`,lȈryssembl=-6Tdiv"i="fooh1C7">/8GG>/8?xml8="1.0"ncoq="UTF-8"?8ht8XnXhttp://www.w3.org/1999/x! UnknownProfessor M0hmadb/;Bׁ7"C''+D"> 77E70)F">is DeputyepQExi(ialucat,C8iPЉfaw, )DirecXɀJerome.raLegServsrganiz at٦chool.e-teachxinTXsnhDevelopm IWorkyImmigtightsdvocacy (WIRAC). In׀Y,ehistudspresXhidu ,roupb (bothtignon-atl to酋l’Hlabor[iحc among1m2haa1 يrafficgastxee' a prisontupa`oay; wsOpics.ɏ׏׏t4,ߞSpwaproj`sesignx!ifytiveites A ventionor.S.-basedawyersnlobalovertyork.his ha cludegardingheightsftreetendoIndia, 9barriifacHbymmigrantommunitiesremittancto1iromeuntxs,csti0medicininstitutional habili0amo8internain1nAnd advocacynehalfdisplchang{tradelicy. HischolarshipxamYbZsec$,Kc`zen both쌰l1ornptice.reviously,e wProf`LawtmericannihsIWaXngtCole ijoin ul A2001a SkaddenellostafftorneyAsiPacificL CerLosles.ȑ0led9Hon.illiam.Ӈ؋I IIIJ iXicthurthVert. Ha22\"Pm_5365176668812356861_m_-884502893709061"ameOIH/aф260WHQJP/.1577HQK77re8'HQL 9HQM">TorableartaÀ1bia fulǤhO.Ȓptemb201s appPtItCGA㘪eά؂}4 qservXPV(- sit rsearchcus(U Europeك,,adju20tc9fund0l0tauhâ qiP<ڋHFX SpaiG`an&قHQOiP">Inxu0 HQRS">Su0t8Adv)dtudhJu@ceׄO7O;T遗HQU߅߅߁V">ClyCha؅ J Ethics'R0Notrh` ,da,SA ((2)3a@HR17772l Society'ouncilw_wc3HR45CON•S -Ԥ5ӅPublDŽ?'?+675/HR7PQ DecV7ˍ"Sub|IqVen Commi͋|y׆//8wwwwHR9p૲!sPntif editorhoard8f(nuMacademhleg(jAmo books,rl4char5,ith.arsotti,.qozzaAXicin苑co-authorIQχAϓϓρBȰLד Globbxt C(Ox d)w 0E 0/HRF//O4G77'HRHq 9HRI"> Honorableanueepeda-Espinosa<1l="calibre157"id="3FIHRK">magna cumudeHRM">GA @Bin Krece8dHMasteX1Harvard $7.ɀI93,Or(Boyacá, highestgree]Greatross,ďa.-

O0/HRP//re95/HRQ//4R77re8'HRScHRT">ProfLucGuttag obinaoundDi(nguishSeni`FehwZLectur`in 8Yalol,L쒝Pracˁ StanP잚turs@immiPaitig.Ʊ1416,eerXs a  poybamadmin,cludP xINS v.t.yr,XW?3/44">ec5/46">habeasPrpusview|a!port htifikCPw؀Yspeak772gggeaem؁@*qIepCBaШ,*Pipi honor bCUNYw nam “hum؆4hero”yAci'''7'/'489">H g?g'HSAg/g4B">j, aedanynJ$awardPɏl@ed (drag500a:yers|Zclerk feȬ:ictudgeilliamayneuaraduatyʬvC8nitƒPeleyHarvpl.8p> D0/HSE//4F77re8'HSGqCHSH/'re47(I">0f@Amyapczynskib/J7"K''+L"> 77M70w(N">is ai;yXYale߻Suldit{ GlobHealthPartnPhipHjoin)faculty Èin January 2012.erreasfesearchnclude@formationolicy, intellectualropertyaw,xternzglob`health,nd Aticeconomy.rioroomingQYale,heaughtthe UniversiCaliXnia,erkeley,choolLaw.ӂ(alsoerveds aqliJusesӅraay’ConnȅStephen.reyer .Supremeourt{dgeuidoQabHin IAppXsASdircuit#recedr.B.rom ncet,͊hil#mbriq'!A$QueMWestfieloh׊҄on[J.D. B. Pa 60/HSQ//re1577HSR77re8'HSSq 9HST/'re47(U">Professor HaroHongjuohbG;φ''V7'!T0''+1"> 772705/HT3">is prlQIG9 necountryseadexYs0ubhprivatevsecurhumris)irst begteach1985*>鄸fiftth De(:2004ntilY9.ƀ93,(`ok9vstXRlug @55''wjotDep@m 122d L8ldvi@whi.4retЂDixnguiЂReviewniOP77+8">. BCcom)1'"aB`rkzJuhA(lackmun%SuprurtЫ{JuMalcolm RpWilkeyFAppe 2D.CircuitnnHprivYpҀWaston{ A-̃Offse`A/j<.8p>

A/0/HTB//4C77'HTDq 9HTE/'re47(F">TbHeQKer/bO׆/G7+H">is aЏEuroȫLHR.L#tВPZurich Èandasubsequentlyesearch associatethenstituofaw9UniversityZurichrom 1989o 1993.Ӂ`obtainederoctorin",ollowb`n LL.M.Cège’EuropBruges,elgium,'h feyship-an RDÇ HarvardSchool 5ȉ눟 @Florenc6. 2001,yaiing MaxlanckWrmpa8ublicqInonal Heidelberg2cHlethabilit FaculCwh.Ɛ@4* heldpo9profer (ordinaria)co\{rucHe,witzer@dwqserv Ԃw,@etaught y,iwduntil11.ˎper sp`ostQ9CourHumxRis Strasbg瑰ork 1ject ч friend(settlem@se10ao)Adv؁@StudieysloM( czA[whfy2r2 es81'@memiNs mitteeApr,ParliaYaryssof"nc8el Jjud_X+!beg!8mIqh Ja 60/HTK//re1577HTL77re8'HTMq 9HTN">THon`blHigueloiadceisĵq!ǯǢ:&. oc-GenerJu3Lux39urnumerouVincl0Ue,athoنiNewy ondйcomicChicago {PCWi8Spain, Ort0ǎetri#͇~aYMacau1fiiLGlobHGonrogramm `pĹ$DžFl0,talyVi8Ya 'ʶHortu seR1MiniL CnPri@.nRegsDevelop13–85hhsenWWWQeKDQn7TransepHTP75/HTQ">Q JuneA6QMaya7YChaiOReview fFIFA7߮7??R7߮7HTS7+T//?4U777"V77HU0/'re47(1">^ Sam9Moyn ί7?U2߁7?+3">is OHxoryN?HHinМahslarshipٍٗTLaUtopia:ȅjRkhli???7/7/+8"> (Harvard g,!0)./g7??97'5"/> È

Professor Doug`eJaime isЄ fawtalebSchool. Heeachesnhereas familyaw,egalthicspqndexuty,zconstitutional 0Beforeoining2faculty2017,UCLAĀ,heservedsƂ DirectWilliamsɅ,e.ȁalsoo* irvineLoyolalLos Angeleh1isitHarvarx ` co-auth ߑߐߐIi+WJ/+K">Cases MaiSoGenderdenX!/iL7+M">(with Carlosall,aacpclubexein)ǃǃUNOׁ/ׁ+P">E陸 yng:̛espXibix!Price1GGHQw7w+R"> SPaulyX)pȕpȏ@larshipcludX“TXNatuЅHPnod,” 1267US777Tǁ/ǁ+U">ourh/?@Vo7o*V0)2260 ( );MargeqkNewЉgc9gV1ggg2/+3">zReviewOQ47+5q1185r6); щCXcienWp:omplic-BXd ClReligoQ؊477V67G/G+8oOOR97+A">25165)aaie.G8p> C0/HVD//re9(E//w4F77p'HVG''re2lang="en-GBHVH)HV&4ǁ(Ȱorbww׈ǂP//ǁ2ǁ7ǁ#77)/77(@JudnikO߇//2ׁxG/W)煟gg/g5is yArthurim̡at٢0bS8olheshe teach`aboutederpsm,roced,ts,L,I izen.eraing:pocus(impactdemocraxganinciplgovmxervice`from ˃soosfI;rel@ftattoNBnon-forPQ_;rPJgen.XY’sookclude_ߑV/2I00/ǁRepresЍ JusPe:nvon,trsighCS3DnroomsG߇"Èid="3FII02"> (2011,ithennis.urtis); <95I04ρ/ρ450i62I06">Migrations andobilities:À@zenship,orders(Gen`The InvenfosWwI0C/4DQco-edited{Lindareouse).ecxclesnclude }E/4F___G">Accommod, Discountsxplacem:ԏhVariyRightxorm Fesm(s)߇I0H/4I">, 17ʓPoqcumh9 97 炿炵J/4KL">DiffusingputiPublicPrivateiArbit;,in Erasur#OoGo/I0Mo/o4NJ24aleawʄhnal 2804r5Professor@snikhaiX School’slobCtituxSeminarBy0 on-line bookerȃxalsof0direct(PY Arthur mCerrIest,oaacolloquia accorilciviluceystemawaryear-lofewقJls2radusummtHvI U.S.eg!8monopphߑO/4PoooQ">Who Pays?ƎHHFe1}CopWgg?g'0Rg/g4SaAn-;arli ~ؓ repo (߅T/4UgggVime-in-Cx__7_I10_/_41">) saryAfa-author1Apci aStrAdPis1or''hXșed `AndrewarnegieetwošBsup1莀work wrXqWwo2/434he ImpermissibPPuhَτI15/46aboutjimpacr+pris.Ӂ memb00 A0icHPhilosophplӏetyxAcademyᦫSn 3aanagTre9n§x72Woud[,eiv00HrX Doۯ)sromCL.8p> 8'0/I19//O4A77re8'I1BqI1C/'re47(D"> Ct@odríguezbW߆7E77"F''/+G"> 77H70(I">is LeAHrurbecki`YaaSs faculty83.ƕ1X1- seputyHantt0neyenerpOffiegnseU.S. hartAJb200412*wDžat yNYU5Vrlso@non-resid fiMigration ÈPolicynstitutenashington,.C.,ndas beenermembernheouncilyForeignelationsaisit professofawtlumbia,tanfordHarvard:schools. PRodríguez’sieldsresearch*teacclude immigr;8 alheory;dministve Hc@;nguageightp(czenp .ӉbookorthcogromxynryІsh 2018,ithdam0x,pidentihpow@ .τprcorkes <<1lass="calibre157"id="3FII1J">EYcem, InteFutureI Federsm/i߆M7+N">(7);71O///P'/'+Q">ReguXh PlupM ntsOPR7+S"> ''TU7/7+V">The@Complex 0CQrai(ExecЦBch)OP57+678'/'+9">Negorf tXroughơ'WGG A777+BS4WCWWWD'/'+E">m!!gWWWFG7G+G]ww''HwwwI7/7+0:B`w7ww8߁7g,؇GG2G/W)8 %Deleg҈'炧炨ׁ7ׁ,Ј#0). Be8eqcademia,servedsclerkousticeӊ ra Day’norU.S.upremeurJudgeavid.atel [(Appeals悠D.Circuit.riginallyroma Antonio,exas,rofessRodríguezarn.A.His1: YalqlHe1995,hMas LetPsMo{8 Oxdnrs,hehwRhscholar0a.D.bol2000OLnrl`EdiXn2RS///+T"> J@oOORU7+V"> ao-recipiEBenjam0arpsizebestaper wteny8third-yptud.w8p> 1'0/I32//4377x'I34q 9I35/'re47(6"> SusxRose-Ackerman/bgG77+8">is HenR.uYPolial ce, EmtaPRGisauthb''id="È3FII39">Corruption andovernment:auses,onsequences(Reform (1999, 2ddiithonnieЁfka, 2016); DnOO'E'''F_/_+G">ue Prosfawmaking:henitedtatiSou0AfricGermany, tpEuropeonDŽdžDŽH7+I"> ( StefaEgidy JamXFowk5W'W.JKg/g+L">From ElecIsoemocracy:uildccountableOtnungaryPol8߆OPM7+N200''OP7/7+Qntroll EnviroaliѕLimitPubܐ G@ׄ׆ׄRǁ7ǁ+S''TU7/7+V">RethinAʟgrivegendac1Amengulatoo/ooII40_7_+12);GG423W/W+4won: A`u`tlconomy???5/7/+6|78). Siز1orHׂׂ478/+Comparat8 Administ{W7߁,P0t,{Peter ndsjBlakhPson)Z17).ӊ`holdsh.D.eicsaءPsithaseld fellowshiptWissenschaftsk`eguer3C0HvancB BehaviorSciesaloltoRCium Budapest,  nboXnstitute bGug`heimpu٩ulbrighmmXB pyshwidelnfihlaw,(c, *тpnineook `spzcQ ahsXmpletabanuscript pitled:Wo?oG4CWWWD/+E">#maiH?ׂׄFǁ7ǁ+G">4JexecuێUS,rY, ߑCUK.O8p> I0/I4J//4K77'I4Lq 9I4Mlare Ryan' C`ieQ2hhool.Ȣearii`cludamily zߙEuropeУ i Psc works I4OGP">+’sͨY Margi(7WWWAQ (Xumbiaournof Tsn , 8) lAlec@oSweet,σσσRS">A CosmotLrOrder:anCJup^ECHRσσTgbyxPd?yБs I8H \B.A1 `Maҵ `ؕLaw SchooÈl.fterawchool,heasisitingssistantrofessorf PolcalciencetaesCollege.larlsolerkedthe Honorable.rgP(cKeown().S(ourtAppe`Ninthircuitnderv *RobinaumanightsellowqEuronohintrasbg,raP,heh ȆAndrásajóny.urɋ ʼn+submionsditЂ<1pass="ibre157"id="3FII4U">Yh Jn8Innat؀LawI50">, aeach T DepartmeHX,a@ker .; Unkn A!SCŁCé ȵWW_C9gwA">߂B'7 5/2CC">is third-year.D.4at١xhoolPh9chidȺ hisyPritonnity.ePdedZ VirginiasJefflgraduithigh DЃta.A.Qphilosoph`Beforew, recen͂fromυɊ disserta*isId “TWr0ife:a8gpoHawai‘i, 184H930.”béH*sxtP  'W^DioE/+F">y Journal(&HumanitiYi???G/7/+H">, HrXlyxesimeus񄡗"p4Asylum SeekAdvocac)oject.|spsum2017H8 worraul,e`,ifiؒ#GarriɓNewف C willC clerkonorabGuidoalasi S`esÍ@tAppe؂FSe8dircuitug 2020-(1erm.W8p0I߲ JW+K//4L77"M'2CN/'re47(O">M( BurnϘOOWCP7"Q''+R">777S7+T"> A choolnƈ 2018.eeceivedis.B. <<1lass="calibre157"id="3GH2CU">magna cumaudeViw7ww81g7g+2"> from PrincetonnHrsity’separtmentfrtnd@chaeology.rioro lawchool,ettendYaleivinӁingM.A.R.n ChristiEthics,workXinwhite-collarSuffolk Coun`DPrictttorneOfficeaBos,A.KLaw %serasxecutdix_D3___4/+5"> JournalzTechn߂߅67+7">h ςς89߁/߁+AnegulationςτςB7+C">. MpsummyatavPP &ardwellNew Y`Ùy ̊n-Commisserj0Pai Federȁ)cszYWash"D.Cbcurrly saPwefihHonorabStevenllo Pted Stat0!ppealsA AEighthprcuit.π8p> E0/2DF//_4G77X'2DHq 92DI/'re47(J">Ca(e Crookb'wςK7ρ"L''ǁ+Mу77N7W+O">is aPird-yeHJ.D.tИ8}.ӓp_er BG߅DP'GoQ/+R">(/G S777+T.umbia'''xxhLXurpHSocietosdnpeg ܄ Ox`d,ܩ.Sc.)RefugeorcMigHSxies,an):@5Astance Project (IRAP)٫݆'$3a SecoY ǎW_DUǒǒǁV/*E0䅹?@1o7o+2previously@-ChaiisuhыD} qInclu>Wo@.çDJ reshcɌ'E3'''4/+5">prima faG''g*6W7W+7">r tusemirosB:e inCaribbet A΂sȽءmionP]s (UNHCR)as,.C??GG8??2E9?+A//4B77w"C??2ED/'+E">KyEdwardsϒW_F7+G"> i 2018raduateO%ϟ Execu"Articlє@Essays̙OO'EHO7_I_/_"ˈ3GH2EJ">Yale Lawournal, board memberfheorrisylMootÄhtAppeals,o-directo Ȁth̆andolicyociety,ainitudentnWork)ImmigraRightsdvoca`C*iGlobP JusticeracHum.ˆ8p9hfirst-yearummwingt*DepartmȂivilĀ0sion’Ȉllatetaff IsecondWtρMelvenpboXWashton,.C.ior to@school,Keive0n.B. ǐMi622EN/+O">a 0@Hgw7ww8Pg7g+Q"> from ncePn@rsity:WoodrowilsSPub IntetؑAffah,i8ertifXGendlSexuty SieKD.Phil.y<a7aOxfoxwwas8Marshalllar.Ӏcurr0lyXrveHack XHonorabLerarugySuprem-C`nia 9wiЃRaym ohi (tt8ok>S rcuitu`g 2019-2020er> Sw0/2ET//ρ4U77ȁ'2EVq 92F0">David Louk鎹 5 du IdPh.D.ndidTJhspryp0Prom, ,’eley.X|)hA`din ʒnyB.AXhSxEoldsp͝qoiReXp߆',CxHaodoial reschʁ2lXurМ @Columbia'(hpng viousZ1CdgXot(atzmannU.S. 7777邋JamE.oasg .stricɂu.ƀ OP܇ФLeRuBaGinsburg.ǀ;___2WW2F3W+4//4577W"6WW2F7">Edgar Mel8ggOO 8d s"-y@ʡsp NEaʂ .Ņp1!summer 7JnjLDivisQEuronc!HuightsǏ9؁OOOLAoWǁ+B//4C77ǁ"Dǐǁ2FE">Allison RabkG`enghF0wwww2FG">iXwwwwl5߂H7/4I77(5/2FJ">Sx*⦨lege o߂߅?K7?4L0iρMG/O+N">a cum8/iO74P77߁+Q"> majorssixeeJol sFulbrɽٹHnaHHepartmof StH.&sanagiI?bre158" ˈaid="3GH2FR">Yale Law &olicyeview. Allisonpentastummerorkingthe.S.ttorney’sfficeor Sou8rnistrictfewقH. _wp> 30/2G4//4577'2G6q 92G7/'re47(8">Quirin Weinzierlbwς97+A"> was aL.M.tudL̖Schooln 2017-18,eeerveds edia7wGBׁC/+DJournal!andechnologyυυE7+F">, coachфQwGwOGGw7w+H">Philip C.essupnatioMootÈ1mpeti鄗gnI7+Jteam, ResiFello8ڈGK7+LIn`mpcietyrojectσςςMρ7ρ+NPritoomPq,:i@lYt Ludwig-Maximilans-UniversiPMunich'cuson iEuropex.oi!hissBtook*Bavaribarx a whe kHHum Rightsz9Genarliam2Academicearch S.ȇ8tau@$̉'''" AnkaraԆ80llegHondon.ѫ:urrlys  XIns@utPubdи(Speyer)glsoursuesPh.D. $[YglobHrenXDataotRegul._ ?xmlon="1.encod="UTF-8"?8ht8Xnhttp://www.w3.org/1999/x!"> UnknowH{meta@nt="LaOff8 6.1.2.1 (MacOSX)"="geneor"/''"TEisenzweigauth@8-10-22T21:37:0c`tedρρArguFunJosehangedby߁߃3:4ށρρ16.00oAppVӁǽůanDocSe__Xf Hype8nksC/UpToeSeCooolhare8gg`;;;;Pesdfnwwptext/!;set=utf蘈-equivz-TpKGKRefigus, SOHg @ydayifePisHoHpsh͙ PlsH1X[47WIU6Excerpcomaryrwithfow iz9IU7T.lexxerQ(koff, ϋρU8">TaMobilShousɸModel IrnŒ(9onvention, 56 Columbia JournalfransnaaLaw 296 (2018).eprintedith permisstheʂׂׂ.

Bruceean, AnɄrimssaynIFA’sorldupCorrup: TDes`ateeforSStandardst22׋D">ILSAgfЄmpaive> 3676). authorECraigestoFailorApproachoportsovnce ςςG">6li , Dec. 13X0,vablt https://www.icsa.org.uk/knowledge/ g--c/features/december--s-nj?^HxJoãoiehl,ara.oЉJoseph.mI"> JudicizHealYQu @(Accountability: Evide)from 1,2621suiessiMeinesn؈ @azil18ߐ߅J"> HumxRighx<09hi penᄲ articdistribuunderPmsr!Ps AtNon-erqicenseKDa8lchitzLivingio-EconomicMTeeth:einimum KIIm 110σσMfricX48402WW(ɀJutany,td?MN(yosw@hO@mmig1Det,unishmx; mJus@l &eg@(26, 7WfAGEblPQs. w|PSilv`C0si''Q">Eth`ReguletiZWop{Hyndroge8m35gwgiR">Clcs a393OOM Elsevie׈SLnzos0灧灘TlobPHybrP-PrivBoWorld A-DopAcy (WADA)! 6Uȋal OrganDsRw219wwu Brill__-VXFrédériqueƝwwFIV0Jrohib˃PoPqsy8hl٤CxA,(Eur0annv[nȰohSpeechaerilZGold? 14ww1 l 2534ggןger NatureoDŽ2ThomaHaltoft-Hي@JamC.athawaV3">)Refoul0 a{YCo  r53 4olumbia }j`@!5'?'ԌNׂח7E5herifirgis,obert.eorge[RyT.ndersiV6">Whasriage 37">HarvardfBS:cy.4+1///+'WW8PAmyapczynskH1 osXINe('9 !(June (unpshuscript???;hogADavLau'BKRetyocihn c ߂4"ӈid="3HFIVC">Harvardnternationalaw Joul 189 (2012).epridithermissfheȂ ʂ.

Katyong, Whenfugeestopp(Beingigrants:ovement,b, andumanitarianrotec, 1udi43). Oxfo(UniversiPress77F0David.artinggG">ResolutencsotustorstriJisBuildya@ableEffici mmM tystemk30 <4IVH">\ &olitics 411:5??f 9ooIhOctxouishttaerrazJmPoorhroughociRights Lg::̐Xonsromƒ@ilKTexasrReview 1643777VK 1ljljǔauthPQyAq. ؊GG"L SamuelyMМ reREn{7(N">The NR,. 18, x0availt https://www.إ[.com/Acle/h-r-are-not-e/׊ߊߊbcOIȁ eJaimeǁǁP9uP nxod26ς?ς1Q">Yale  22607W{7D߄RNillayigPoi0aduroJosepheiler߉S">‘Ourin? W`oaktaskifaoeriously,’Y7g7YTGuز(Dec. 21 7gfootball//dec/21/h-P-р(sk-f-~//* ߆UCeciliaz(lahVDubli:`xCHqqCir@ BetweMutu8TrƠoco?FJ00">EUAhysi,b0eulawa.blogspotڌ02/-d"-s"-ecj-s-c.html7r1acRefugehengenŚ(pe:itmus Te00Un8) (unpsh،Xuscript,Xed MOSEʂ Monetorkshopχ 2rang__x3">WhyoStateaveKѠaControl Immigr?D4">ipg[5">NO@ LVII:Ƀ_,ŀgʨ{]3 (Jackn, ed.L@Yversity Ps6?(7">AlecӞClx RyWgga8`smopolitan LegOrder:anstitu1JicCHR {WWWGrDž/Dž>9I.upeiSoci9Economic?̋romHh Africa01߅߅f ߅ׅׅׅADani0X.awǗoB">Heal@`igR!BrazilbomIRense115C"> Review-6175Oxdyg0DAliPlyamOscararra-VerakCla GeX,Colombia—Judlec ilass="ӈcalibre15"id="3HFJ0F">in Litigating Healhtights:ÁCourtsroreusticeoȁth? 103 (Alicia Elyamin &iriloppen,ds., 2011).eptedithermission ofheuthors.

#ń%, Essayneci-760 (2008)q7770J ǁgǁXK">Maxlanckncycaedof Comparventutalaw\ (Rainerrote,rauke Lachenmanandüdig8Woldrum17by 0xfordn8rsityress,SAo/o=LhKathae.oungONJOM">R" QueuexOistrib`tes(in 9Moderntate55oWaN">ColumbJh!Transn6516ߕ̉ꄑʂςς̊W/60?J0OP
WQP /8?xmlon="1.encod`="UTF-8"?8ht8Xnphttp://www.w3.org/1999/x!head> <>Tablejntsfac؂3G794V3G8-8Flyaׁj9҃׀A׃׃B׆B9ritPQNon-Rel*shipetweendul(ǂXCπDτττϖI3GE0LegXusriag"qFGCD3GHHomeffairs.ƨ8i$CtSoHricaCT 60/045'T''$C'H1O'3GLitigRisӎguYͳ`meA DNK3GPoxame-Sexpx0QE0723GPObergefel.odgSupreHF| 135.t. 25817fx774G72ѶWhats?hhfir,o@t.ee,Ryan.nd11)1?9AHP0F3GR">wGSwT4WU">Kexg CommiserPublicealnecticut 289.8WVIKB3HOliIyuropeHumxRights ( aon)08766/11__`__\K_00129_3HxRatzenböckrSeyd2Aust8if߅28475/127ߕOO|τ3φφL002JP3H4Urent-Chil@pW5W6S83H7">UnmQxBiologlƩ8灧H8瀯9M*3HA">Michael.GeraHD.W491.110 (1989O7eB7"kinӈdle:pos:fid:000M:offI07I3"id="3IE3HC">Ahrens.ermanyuropeanourtfuights (Fifthection)o. 45071/09 Non-Biologicala tsAulwHF"kGO003P23HH">PavpSmiIupremewthenitedtates 137.t. 2075 (2017)o4IPV3HJ">formagectKQ001TS3HL0ABB7Ap lsorτ8rio07NCA 20MR*3HN">Allamili8qu6)nterXintoorceanuary 1,17'O QP3HP">Reproduveechn yndnflicoverrrogacygHQR߄߄߄0042T3HS">S.H. AustriaGrhamber57813/001υWTWWVSW002DQW3HUHrtavMurilloCostacaɏi-Amerp-H.R. (serxS257*2//]V//.T/005P5/3I0(.BzMinish*SociDevelopmؐstituI؆~SouAf1CT 155/161U006IM3I2oSpeRapeurnaleSexiExploiP0Child,PcludingrX,ornography,O rAbuseͬ`l43VE4">Johnsal8tՀȬn5i.4H84 (1993ׄ׃5ׄׄ10׌5F3I6Ж!Utah.XDѓـXj261ƷPuppd 1286 (D\/71G8">In@.J0VNewersey (allvis) 419΁. 4092pV13IA">TNatuhoodB3'C">MennesFجϦߦ (FifSe()y65192/114wDwwv4wC8w">adiso{ampaniItaly߅߅߲Q358/127߽OO|sk/YF//.J/V/3IG">gnss1H郟ILx2J3IJ">Do?;ly? K'L'''' JM">rPivech*A{NOhS߁P">LetromogXGHommi`ond+Footballeague,o pefHec(ves+lubesidPړgQggfMgHEg3IR">OlympicѺ8rrtic5OSx6TKXhibiPol`cSHythletIa(encyi`}10uOonvHnw<׆ׅU׆׆Nא5Q3IV(9eleas9/8ߡ߄E3J0O007pJ1PquaPyGJ2G3~P002FE"iӈd="3IE3J4">Sagen.ancouverrganizingommitteeorhe 2010lympicndara|WintGamesurtfppealsBritishlumbia DuCh AthletFederationIndia (AFI)ZTInalssociEsOns (IAAF)__7__^R_0066G_3J8">EthRegulpHŠWom0withypndroismDŽǂ9DŽDŽS004LV3JA">FIFA,ootball2BTJJ3JC">Guidelin؇PromobInvolve{Iqncil/ulI|߄ D߅߅߅003603JE">AreportsPrivatshuSubjectoton?uF"GNP3JH">nawEconomreedomsS_IZgJggggS2g3JK">BrwoodcademyyTen8sSedarychooUהLU0076B3JM">UnRoyaleelgeSétésxnSBLIJean-MarcosmaWWNWWVVWPKO">Meca-Medinass!Euro0nuneooPoom20o0051To3JQpmeric`NPle,c.NLeagueOςRττ1τBF3JSnti-Corrup2EfHtWW3JTWUPOH3JVimssay’srldupׄggge2gBLg3K1tedsHawGG 24@QS3K3Self-GovancehieveǠYǨ"455OA3K6">RA.art@tiamattiρσσϱGп‘Ourin?ep0rذtaketasktifao0ouslyτςτ6πR7пAB镺nOlymp*tteEB78HC9ñaATPԈPWWWW9W*W3KPechsteinwuSkPngհa56N3KWADDopwh62P3KGloybridublic-Priv@hd:ԲХӅOggency (1)4A2E3K)IFedera`nexaútbol (FMF):MrXoséalvadorarmrez?׏׆MBP33KN}׃7K3KEnglCoXp%C7ԼailoApproach9gd|skWWWS3GW3KU">RefugeСaim@f “Unprec 8obility AVLD001L],eӈfugees,ndhebligationsftates Convenelngo1uReNeworkeclarBorƉBMigrantsnitedΉGeneralssembly (2016)1oo7oonFo001H9o3L8">WheYStopphBeɅKatyoi3)**ww9wwww006V2w3LA">TaobiliSerious0T.lexerQinikX8)BG0074C">Kenya܌CommissHumaighAnoHr.ԓHonorablettorneyqOa'σDυυIϘ@LρE">XXYBelgiumurtJusticeYEuropePH(Gdhamber)aseo.-638/16PU7)FJ005IV3LG">R.AppulppaG@/ulA{HNQI3LI">SharRespHiinJK////x0/LDunystem߃GsMGGGGHρNIrakhelISwitzerlnv70 lic!29217/124OPH7P(.K.s!RepkaloijQR6D3LR8akcBHungaryIncilonSS004253LT">’seIrreguS2WithUUT*3LV">DrafSeihmend teBasLaw_E3M01">Fac|9llenge/WW2__^U_K3eterdˢO4瀦5C6">AsmopoLegPOrcnepeetCЉhy`߈ς7ττVϑ8irsiamaaItaय7765/0922/\9//-40/EG/3MA">Non-xouleRaorldCovenThomasammeltoft-Ha؆es.athawa5?EB16F3MCn3DA?E">Imm>f,unish,TsformsJustiMQBosworȈ7F2P83MG">PPFor0CzechYl.YAlodorooHoon3oIhIPato''SJ''&5'TE'3MK">R.I.L-R,ohnsL70MM">Jenn@odriguezg''N׃׃9005D33MOh!feQBo9?gMP?Q׃׃׃׃IN3MR(esolutncsIsXt2or9tricis David.tؠW_HSA`2ρT">Whyo藑StahHaйꫩAControlmmӈigration?arahong (2017)* Health,edicines,ndonstituAalbligs JuaEnforcementfightoz 340065L3N5">Ahmed.nYIndiaow6wwvKw004VVw3N7">SuspensTWriAntpatPProtecy 175upr(ederCourBrazil (MarchX, 00)1υσ8υυMϒU3N9`erAJo.S.istrictheor8rnFlorida 290.p. 3d 1292 (N.D.a.17)//[A//.O/pLA/3NB">R (B)!Cambpgeș"uthty׃ׂC׃׃Q001613ND">TImpaczbE߀F߃߃߃00NGoEconomiccs?essrom`(foHoooo0077Oo3NI">Givio-zeeth:ԉ`MinimumPreIance,JR`F43NK;RHA܄t4LS*3NMSQueues:Ϛ=bvetes(injMontNVPE3NOarmPo0ThrougsitT:WWPWWU61W69W3NQ izbI4!s{ccountabi:vide81,262awsui0дoq//\R//.2/002H'S4醼DŽ);hblemI׌espKOOxTOON4ODQO3NU">Colombia—ƶɄz:xlusqpmise?DV5TF3O0">EssaX eciT-760 (2008?/ul|16H72">^Engagi@B.34p4/5">OchiepOsAttorneyenera68FU3O7XumanANotHsamuelyn*+8qM3O9 相AgeqNe b!ismGGsAGGFAG0SG3OB">F.ȁ`n-LaocLtd.Anr.CiplaHurtDelh`t`wl148LT 598,IPR ) 35ooCoonBopE2o3OD">eB IncMercExchange,.L.C.uprHYUnited߃ E߄߄C0070H3OFbg C-620/16GGsGGGFFGGJG3OH">Mezaarcía2in򨻃ϣߣ܀rkI7G*3OJ8PINIONSxcerpX?iK????pIV?3OL OMMENTARYNDDDITALATERIALBMION">AbCha08oaEdiȓׂO׃׃O00000"ӈid="3IE3OP">Abouthetudentditors Permissionsoepublishaterial @page argin-bottom: 5pt;n-left: 1inrightopize: 8.5in 1X}0.8?πτ.3τׄׄ?πτ.calibrdisplay:lockfont-1empaddingoinxY 1k/*2,background:ransparH3direct:trmline-he2orph: text-gxc ewidow?݈0Dž3?<:i4vansmall-capsoo.2/*5G߁߁6܁autoρϊ th;WR7 .8'.291675/e9t-wtran@rentdirectio`ltrsplablockorph: Ltext-cpeind: 0widowmargi0.17in 0Dž9OOPalatinò(typere90&inQ?;1YLjDzLjLjLjLjLjLjČvariasHl-capsinsid@r9_[gϵgψψψψψϑ߇߇߆߇߆ǼO0'!_''''''''''//߇H88`߇߀߇߇ߏ׏տ0 86ׇ'''06'&͇''''''wjustifyT734=7777ltr; isplay:lock; rphans: 0text-align:ustifywidowGmargi 0.17in85in} .cbre141background:rxparentSdirectiohltrWWT2WWWVDWWo7Dž2DžDžDžDžDžDžDžDžDžDžleft03list-style-type8owerH1em4o085lett`Xcing: -1.1pt|6zon7cpe-8,font-familTimes,erifne-height.2GD9ooooooojsiz `9167em-wDbold.쉧page-pak-af:voiind003inOOOǓā{50GG_gg'߅DžݑXMSinchogc''''''w׈יτordtop8urqColoroneediuTrÁgggdbottom: #000olid 1pxwwwiddX1ͭ/(3ЋEܛsidכ쇯mAq8wg䷵כככ׆74;%/aemOLgGaramond\c(22ρ%gߑߑߑߊ﯏''"6߆LJLJLJǘdivr瀣9167ewbolLoooonaf@`uto'%w/''ggg3pDwww 2"3'%1///////_////////////_??ooo??ggg? #000 solid 3pt; order-left:urrentColoroneedium[padding: 0 0 0.01inmargin.17in 2 0.33in} .divi02ackground:ranspakdirectioltrsplay:lockfont-size: 1.29167eDweighboldline-horph: page-break-after:utotext-aligቈwidowtopVrgggdbottom: #000WWwwWWWWWWRsd-abs-posd{0hiolute|P8Pth81pxfootnotesn///////_-famil"Timesewoman",erif_0.83333?=justify-ind8)25ϒ7 1em2.1Oψo`3Ovois|4'ϊy5'ϊoy6'ϊ04rn7'ψ98Gψ??9OψW1710GgO_ωlj1?Timesewoman",erif; ont-size: 0.83333emorphans: 2page-break-after:voidtext-align:ustify-indent25inwidowmargi1em 03.`} .sdfootnote-wesn12background:rparpdirectioltrsplay:lock?-famil"TG073n14Ϙn15W_teanc//c1625x%x48387sigil__in_to:weighbolNautogestarUOn. 0line-h1.l/χlefבבБ=7variasmall-caps{ce|ψψ-WԺ׈׈׈׈׈׈׈׈׈׈׈׈ׇrnw瘏GGÈwwwB7.078867777 76߈߈ߑ.948:n 3Q9G: 1.2; rphans: 2; ext-align:ight-indent: 0.5inwidowmargi1em 0 0 3Q} .western10background:r(parSdirectiohltrsplay:lockfont-sizeline-he.WUce4.14150%Ǎ__].7in| 02χjustify׆׆׆҈Odž3dždždždždždždždždždždždždždždždždždžǍ_4wlefĆg_[5___________gg?׆ww6w7.29167variasmall-caps-wbold____page-break-af:voiGGGGB0.33'8'''''''g''7777777777'GGGDKws9wwwwwww-famil"Timesewoman",erif_666ωωωωωωψform:ppercaseωωω220׉1/צOOו??t-ind`: - inWWW.83m7"2''<_[3_____n24ׂ5oooooo__ooonGomjustifyϐvoo|GC6GGGGGGGGGGGכo?GGDP27; irection:tr; splay:lockfont-famil"Timesewoman",erif_-size: 1.29167em-variant:mall-caps-weighboldline-horphans: page-break-after:voitext-alig1eft-indei-0.2inwidowmargi0.17in 0N} .wesn28background:rPparH ce\1em 09_׉?wwwwp30wwwwwwwOwwwwww׉wwwwwwwwwɉ1GG 0//2G33G0.5n34g3QGC5GGGGGGGG666''''Zform:ppercaseh0.2WV6WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWgggggggg7ggg;colo#00π-variasmall-caps߉߉߉߉߶838______oooooooooo//9///////_///////////////ZKgb40gggggggϢψggggggϢϢϢψww̘g1d߆߆ 2//,/q332GGGGGGoϿ 1.29167em; ine-height: 1.2orphans: text-align:ustifywidowGmargi 1em 0 0} .western43display:lockfont-sizeh퀢wbold':en0.6pchbre1:kcolor: #000-decoratio8underGC??00f???>lilis@tyle-typpno.a$wt' a:hoverOIred INDXTAGX  0001306289IDXTINDX( 0000001020 0000005892 00000091499 0000017593? 0000025670?? 0000033816~? 0000041983>+ 0000048567˄6 0000055510˄6% 0000061300߅ 0000063030󆊀? 0000071118?< 0000078915|; 000008657376 0000093503n> 0000101501,= 0000109412j> 0000117387(: 0000124842b> 0000132865!> 0000140922`> 0000148944> 0000156922]? 0000165062= 0000172882Z< 0000180613> 0000188655U> 0000196611? 0000204784S8 0000212070 = 0000219991 J? 0000228179 = 0000236059 G? 0000244138 > 0000252098 E= 0000259968 > 0000267907 @? 0000276091 ? 0000284178 ?> 0000292143 } 0000294379 0000295781 0000297797 0000299314Ê 0000302106׋ 0000304830댭 0000306502 0000308000 0000310092 0000311767 0000313199ϑ 0000314668㒳 0000316631; 0000324305;? 0000332379{? 0000340472:= 0000348323w= 00003562365; 0000363903q= 0000371743.; 0000379329i< 0000387067&; 0000394735b= 0000402574? 0000410734_> 0000418795: 0000426329Y? 0000434501= 0000442379V: 0000449868: 0000457351K= 0000465197 < 0000472936 E? 0000481073 = 0000488999 B; 0000496664 ~> 0000504655 << 0000512342 x? 0000520512 8) 0000526832π 0000528520Ѐ 0000530102р 0000531773ǗҀ 0000534402ۘӀ 0000536085Ԁ 0000537623Հ 0000539595ր 0000541417׀ 0000543629؀ 0000545232Ӟـ 0000546833ڀ 0000548747ۀ 0000550361܀ 0000552596݀ 0000554349ހ 0000556040ͤ߀ 0000557575 0000559003 0000560804 0000562509 0000564527 0000566907˪ 0000568729 0000572133 0000574032 0000575546 0000577125 0000579102ɰ 0000580877ޱ> 0000588821ޱ>: 0000596337ޱx= 0000604257ޱ6< 0000611976ޱr> 0000619940ޱ1< 0000627642ޱm; 0000635215ޱ(> 0000643206ޱf8 0000650386ޱ9 0000657807ޱY> 0000665792ޱ< 0000673546ޱS< 0000681274ޱ> 0000689252ޱN> 0000697277ޱ < 0000705028ޱI= 0000712943ޱ? 0000721062ޱG? 0000729140ޱ ? 0000737326ޱ F< 0000745034ޱ 9 0000752383ޱ ;? 0000760559ޱ {? 0000768650ޱ :< 0000776400ޱ w: 0000783947ޱ 2< 0000791659ޱ n? 0000799791ޱ .? 0000807945ޱ m= 0000815827ޱ+; 0000823457ޱg 0000827423 0000828850 0000830242 0000831861 0000833575Ƕ 0000835140ܷ 0000836772 0000838735  0000840520  0000842360  0000844094 ż 0000845879 ڽ 0000847676  0000849396  0000850761  0000852729  0000854450  0000856177  0000857835  0000859703  0000861389  0000862810  0000864338  0000865894  0000867537  0000869132  0000870704  0000872681  0000874620  0000876583  0000878817  0000880653  0000882297  0000883913  0000885713 = 0000893543 =? 0000901663 |7 0000908782 4? 0000916906 s< 0000924630 0> 0000932622 n8 0000939817 &? 0000947883 e? 0000956006 %? 0000964118 d? 0000972258 $; 0000979826 _? 0000987951 ? 0000996128 ^9 0001003518 > 0001011495 V= 0001019318 9 0001026647 M9 0001034048  = 0001041948  D6 0001048947  {< 0001056746  8< 0001064477  t; 0001072119  0< 0001079814  l< 0001087574  )? 0001095741  h7 0001102786  9 0001110152  Y8 0001117370 > 0001125394 P; 0001132955  < 0001140761 H> 0001148792 4 0001156600 р 0001158535 Ҁ 0001160578 Ӏ 0001162674Ԁ 0001164400Հ 0001165811ր 0001167613׀ 0001169262؀ 0001170873ـ 0001172338ڀ 0001173897ۀ 0001175554܀ 0001177940݀ 0001179607ހ 0001181203߀ 0001182831 0001184496 0001186268 0001187901 0001189686 0001191382 0001193139 0001194932 0001196492 0001198079 0001200135 0001201826 0001203506 0001205041 0001207170 0001209439 0001210947? 0001219071?8 00012272754 000123397443 0001240626h7 0001247724% 0001252514E> 0001260575 0001263342< 0001271128<' 0001277331? 0001285404? 0001287594 0001287653* 0001293082*' 0001298174R? 0001306289IDXT.BTgy)=Qey-AUi},?Rex+@Uj'<Qf{ 0CVi|':M`s  2 F [ p   - B W l   / E [ q   + ? S g {   / C W k   3G[o3I_u%;Qg}-CYm !5I]q%9Mau,BXnP-//*[@aid='0']P-//*[@aid='UGI0']P-//*[@aid='1T140']P-//*[@aid='2RHM0']P-//*[@aid='3Q280']P-//*[@aid='4OIQ0']P-//*[@aid='5N3C0']P-//*[@aid='6LJU0']P-//*[@aid='7K4G0']P-//*[@aid='8IL20']P-//*[@aid='9H5K0']P-//*[@aid='AFM60']P-//*[@aid='BE6O0']P-//*[@aid='CCNA0']P-//*[@aid='DB7S0']P-//*[@aid='E9OE0']P-//*[@aid='F8900']P-//*[@aid='G6PI0']P-//*[@aid='H5A40']P-//*[@aid='I3QM0']P-//*[@aid='J2B80']P-//*[@aid='K0RQ0']P-//*[@aid='KVCC0']P-//*[@aid='LTSU0']P-//*[@aid='MSDG0']P-//*[@aid='NQU20']P-//*[@aid='OPEK0']P-//*[@aid='PNV60']P-//*[@aid='QMFO0']P-//*[@aid='RL0A0']P-//*[@aid='SJGS0']P-//*[@aid='TI1E0']P-//*[@aid='UGI00']P-//*[@aid='VF2I0']P-//*[@aid='10DJ40']P-//*[@aid='11C3M0']P-//*[@aid='12AK80']P-//*[@aid='1394Q0']P-//*[@aid='147LC0']P-//*[@aid='1565U0']P-//*[@aid='164MG0']P-//*[@aid='173720']P-//*[@aid='181NK0']P-//*[@aid='190860']P-//*[@aid='19UOO0']P-//*[@aid='1AT9A0']P-//*[@aid='1BRPS0']P-//*[@aid='1CQAE0']P-//*[@aid='1DOR00']P-//*[@aid='1ENBI0']P-//*[@aid='1FLS40']P-//*[@aid='1GKCM0']P-//*[@aid='1HIT80']P-//*[@aid='1IHDQ0']P-//*[@aid='1JFUC0']P-//*[@aid='1KEEU0']P-//*[@aid='1LCVG0']P-//*[@aid='1MBG20']P-//*[@aid='1NA0K0']P-//*[@aid='1O8H60']P-//*[@aid='1P71O0']P-//*[@aid='1Q5IA0']P-//*[@aid='1R42S0']P-//*[@aid='1S2JE0']P-//*[@aid='1T1400']P-//*[@aid='1TVKI0']P-//*[@aid='1UU540']P-//*[@aid='1VSLM0']P-//*[@aid='20R680']P-//*[@aid='21PMQ0']P-//*[@aid='22O7C0']P-//*[@aid='23MNU0']P-//*[@aid='24L8G0']P-//*[@aid='25JP20']P-//*[@aid='26I9K0']P-//*[@aid='27GQ60']P-//*[@aid='28FAO0']P-//*[@aid='29DRA0']P-//*[@aid='2ACBS0']P-//*[@aid='2BASE0']P-//*[@aid='2C9D00']P-//*[@aid='2D7TI0']P-//*[@aid='2E6E40']P-//*[@aid='2F4UM0']P-//*[@aid='2G3F80']P-//*[@aid='2H1VQ0']P-//*[@aid='2I0GC0']P-//*[@aid='2IV0U0']P-//*[@aid='2JTHG0']P-//*[@aid='2KS220']P-//*[@aid='2LQIK0']P-//*[@aid='2MP360']P-//*[@aid='2NNJO0']P-//*[@aid='2OM4A0']P-//*[@aid='2PKKS0']P-//*[@aid='2QJ5E0']P-//*[@aid='2RHM00']P-//*[@aid='2SG6I0']P-//*[@aid='2TEN40']P-//*[@aid='2UD7M0']P-//*[@aid='2VBO80']P-//*[@aid='30A8Q0']P-//*[@aid='318PC0']P-//*[@aid='3279U0']P-//*[@aid='335QG0']P-//*[@aid='344B20']P-//*[@aid='352RK0']P-//*[@aid='361C60']P-//*[@aid='36VSO0']P-//*[@aid='37UDA0']P-//*[@aid='38STS0']P-//*[@aid='39REE0']P-//*[@aid='3APV00']P-//*[@aid='3BOFI0']P-//*[@aid='3CN040']P-//*[@aid='3DLGM0']P-//*[@aid='3EK180']P-//*[@aid='3FIHQ0']P-//*[@aid='3GH2C0']P-//*[@aid='3HFIU0']P-//*[@aid='3IE3G0']P-//*[@aid='3IE3G2']INDXyTAGX SKEL0000000120yIDXTINDX ySKEL0000000000 SKEL0000000001 % % SKEL0000000002 >>SKEL0000000003 SKEL0000000004 ssSKEL0000000005 VVSKEL0000000006 ddSKEL0000000007 ssSKEL0000000008 ~~SKEL0000000009 SKEL0000000010 SKEL0000000011 00SKEL0000000012 EESKEL0000000013 RRSKEL0000000014 ^^SKEL0000000015 nnSKEL0000000016 {{SKEL0000000017 SKEL0000000018 SKEL0000000019 !!SKEL0000000020  SKEL0000000021  SKEL0000000022 % %SKEL0000000023 2 2SKEL0000000024 F FSKEL0000000025 T TSKEL0000000026 ` `SKEL0000000027 o oSKEL0000000028 } }SKEL0000000029 !!SKEL0000000030 !!SKEL0000000031 !(!(SKEL0000000032 !7!7SKEL0000000033 !C!CSKEL0000000034 !U!USKEL0000000035 !b!bSKEL0000000036 !p!pSKEL0000000037 !|!|SKEL0000000038 ""SKEL0000000039 ""SKEL0000000040 """"SKEL0000000041 "2"2SKEL0000000042 "D"DSKEL0000000043 "S"SSKEL0000000044 "m"mSKEL0000000045 "|"|SKEL0000000046 ##SKEL0000000047 ##SKEL0000000048 #$#$SKEL0000000049 #2#2SKEL0000000050 2828SKEL0000000051 2C2CSKEL0000000052 2N2NSKEL0000000053 2Z2ZSKEL0000000054 2h2hSKEL0000000055 2t2tSKEL0000000056 33SKEL0000000057 33SKEL0000000058 33SKEL0000000059 3,3,SKEL0000000060 3:3:SKEL0000000061 3H3HSKEL0000000062 3V3VSKEL0000000063 3c3cSKEL0000000064 3n3nSKEL0000000065 3}3}SKEL0000000066 4 4 SKEL0000000067 44SKEL0000000068 4%4%SKEL0000000069 4444SKEL0000000070 4A4ASKEL0000000071 4L4LSKEL0000000072 4X4XSKEL0000000073 4d4dSKEL0000000074 4q4qSKEL0000000075 4~4~SKEL0000000076 5 5 SKEL0000000077 55SKEL0000000078 5(5(SKEL0000000079 5858SKEL0000000080 5I5ISKEL0000000081 5X5XSKEL0000000082 5d5dSKEL0000000083 5q5qSKEL0000000084 55SKEL0000000085 FCFCSKEL0000000086 FRFRSKEL0000000087 FbFbSKEL0000000088 FrFrSKEL0000000089 GGSKEL0000000090 G G SKEL0000000091 GGSKEL0000000092 G&G&SKEL0000000093 G3G3SKEL0000000094 G>G>SKEL0000000095 GJGJSKEL0000000096 GWGWSKEL0000000097 GjGjSKEL0000000098 GwGwSKEL0000000099 HHSKEL0000000100 HHSKEL0000000101 HHSKEL0000000102 H+H+SKEL0000000103 H8H8SKEL0000000104 HFHFSKEL0000000105 HSHSSKEL0000000106 H`H`SKEL0000000107 HoHoSKEL0000000108 H{H{SKEL0000000109 IISKEL0000000110 IISKEL0000000111 I$I$SKEL0000000112 I1I1SKEL0000000113 I=I=SKEL0000000114 ININSKEL0000000115 I`I`SKEL0000000116 IkIkSKEL0000000117 JlJlSKEL0000000118 MMSKEL0000000119 MrMrSKEL0000000120 NINIIDXT (D`|$@\x <Xt8Tp4Pl0Lh,Hd (D`|  $ @ \ x  < X t  8 T p  4 P l  0 L h INDXTAGXtocIDXTINDXtocIDXTTable of ContentsINDXTAGX0 @7EIDXTINDX 00q01ze02`;0304#-^À056 h06Is=07J1B<08Js09M l0AMzf0B+t́0C {0Dvs0Ei D0F$R 10(X.11,L݁121S8+136t O/14AD/ 15-ʋ16-s͑17 : ϕ/18 EIÂӗ;19  ڂݛ1Azc1B] <1Cu|Â%1Dr<邎*1E.).1FXv)20N_˂&21$ 1わ22$:B 23$}+ 肏 24%(= 725%fV ڂ926&381T),391~ 3A6v'Ƃ13B9zނ'3C:+3D;V-3E;pSԂ 3FAX[邔!40B4.41BbT242C7\낔43D=ₔ344DQ845Ed46.R܃47Q48R*郕-49|!4A-(4B>.ǃ)4Cli4DUK4E I<ۃ4F ><50 d#51 H 52 Q. ރ53 !54 2!䃙 55 SS"56 'D#.57 k6$458"C%+59e1%񃙠15A)&σ$5BA-'5Coi'ƒ5DXC(+5E(/5F) )򃚶606W*61 P+)62r1+63$e, 64 /-1659-߃%66T-67>.768E@/969+/փ=6A1A0(6B}?066C=q0:6D@16EV%16F|Z170VW2$71.)2ɀ72_52Ճ07393(74Z 4175fF4̀76<4ރ77< !5978Av6Ń&7B?8(6)7C?`j87D@K@8ك 7EA 89IDXT /?O^n.ATgz!1AQaq!2CTev'8IZl~.>N]m} -=M]m} -<L\l| Table of ContentsPrefaceConstituting the Familygoverning sportsRefugees in a Time of “Unprecedented” MobilityHealth, Medicines, and Constitutional ObligationsOPINIONS ExcerptedCOMMENTARY AND ADDITIONAL MATERIALS ExcerptedAbout the Chapter Authors and EditorsAbout the Student EditorsPermissions to Republish MaterialsMarital and Non-Marital Relationships Between AdultsThe Parent-Child RelationshipDo Constitutional Rights Apply?Are Sports Organizations Private Institutions Subject to State Regulation?Mobility, Refugees, and the Obligations of StatesSharing Responsibility in EuropeDeterring RefugeesIn Defense of BordersJudicial Enforcement of a Right to MedicinesJudicial Engagement with the Political Economy of MedicinesThe Legal Status of MarriageNon-Marital RelationshipsUnmarried Biological FathersNon-Biological ParentsReproductive Technology and Conflicts over SurrogacyExpressive Speech and Associational RightsEqualityCompetition Law and Economic FreedomsAnti-Corruption EffortsCan Self-Governance Achieve Good Governance?WADA and Anti-Doping EffortsGood Governance EffortsConvention Relating to the Status of RefugeesNew York Declaration for Refugees and Migrants United Nations General Assembly (2016)1When Refugees Stopped Being Migrants Katy Long (2013)**Taking Mobility Seriously T. Alexander Aleinikoff (2018)*Kenya National Commission on Human Rights and Another v. The Honorable Attorney General and OthersX and X v. Belgium Court of Justice of the European Union (Grand Chamber) Case No. C-638/16 PPU (2017)R. v. AppulonappaThe Dublin SystemTarakhel v. Switzerland European Court of Human Rights (Grand Chamber) Application No. 29217/12 (2014)C.K. and Others v. Republika SlovenijaSlovak Republic and Hungary v. Council of the European UnionHungary’s Response to Irregular Migration Within the EUDraft of Seventh Amendment to the Basic Law of Hungary (2018)*Facing the Refugee Challenge in EuropeA Cosmopolitan Legal Order Alec Stone Sweet and Clare Ryan (2018)*Hirsi Jamaa and Others v. Italy European Court of Human Rights (Grand Chamber) Application No. 27765/09 (2012)Non-Refoulement in a World of Cooperative Deterrence Thomas Gammeltoft-Hansen and James C. Hathaway (2015)*DetentionImmigration Detention, Punishment, and the Transformation of Justice Mary Bosworth (2017)*Police Force of the Czech Republic et al. v. Al ChodorNamah v. PatoR.I.L-R, et al. v. JohnsonJennings v. RodriguezResolute Enforcement Is Not Just for Restrictionists David A. Martin (2015)*Why Does the State Have the Right to Control Immigration? Sarah Song (2017)*Ahmed v. Union of IndiaSuspension of Writ of Anticipated Protection 175 Supreme Federal Court of Brazil (March 17, 2010)1Hoffer v. Jones U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Florida 290 F. Supp. 3d 1292 (N.D. Fla. 2017)R (B) v. Cambridge Health AuthorityThe Impact of CourtsOchieng and Others v. Attorney GeneralHuman Rights Are Not Enough Samuel Moyn*The Right to Medicines in an Age of NeoliberalismF. Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd. and Anr. v. Cipla Ltd. High Court of Delhi at New Delhi 148 (2008) DLT 598, MIPR 2008 (2) 35eBay Inc. v. MercExchange, L.L.C. Supreme Court of the United StatesJudgment C-620/16Meza García v. Ministry of HealthHome Affairs v. Fourie Constitutional Court of South Africa CCT 60/04 (2005)Litigation and Legislation Regulating Marriage in Latin AmericaThe Path to Marriage for Same-Sex Couples in the United StatesObergefell v. Hodges Supreme Court of the United States 135 S. Ct. 2584 (2015)What is Marriage? Sherif Girgis, Robert P. George, and Ryan T. Anderson (2011)1Kerrigan v. Commissioner of Public Health Supreme Court of Connecticut 289 Conn. 135 (2008)Oliari v. Italy European Court of Human Rights (Fourth Section) No. 18766/11 (2015)Ratzenböck and Seydl v. Austria European Court of Human Rights (Fifth Section) No. 28475/12 (2017)Michael H. v. Gerald D. Supreme Court of the United States 491 U.S. 110 (1989)Ahrens v. Germany European Court of Human Rights (Fifth Section) No. 45071/09Pavan v. Smith Supreme Court of the United States 137 S. Ct. 2075 (2017)Uniform Parentage Act (2017)AA v. BB Court of Appeals for Ontario 2007 ONCA 2 (2007)Ontario All Families are Equal Act (2016) Entered into Force January 1, 2017S.H. v. Austria European Court of Human Rights (Grand Chamber) No. 57813/00 (2011)Artavia Murillo v. Costa Rica Inter-American Court of Human Rights Inter-Am. Ct. H.R. (ser. C) No. 257 (2012)A.B. v. Minister for Social Development Constitutional Court of South Africa CCT 155/15 (2016)Report of the Special Rapporteur on the Sale and Sexual Exploitation of Children, Including Child Prostitution, Child Pornography, and Other Child Sexual Abuse MaterialJohnson v. Calvert Supreme Court of California 5 Cal.4th 84 (1993)J.R. v. Utah U.S. District Court for the District of Utah 261 F. Supp. 2d 1286 (D. Utah 2002)In re T.J.S. Superior Court of New Jersey (Appellate Division) 419 N.J. Super. 46 (2011)0The Nature of ParenthoodMennesson v. France European Court of Human Rights (Fifth Section) No. 65192/11 (2014)Paradiso and Campanelli v. Italy European Court of Human Rights (Grand Chamber) No. 25358/12 (2017)Letter from Roger Goodell, Commissioner of the National Football League, to the Chief Executives and Club PresidentsOlympic Charter Article 50The Prohibition of Political Statements by Athletes and Its Consistency with Article 10 of the European Convention on Human RightsPress Release No. 29/2018Sagen v. Vancouver Organizing Committee for the 2010 Olympic and Paralympic Winter Games Court of Appeals for British ColumbiaDutee Chand v. Athletic Federation of India (AFI) and The International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF)Ethics of Regulating Competition for Women with HyperandrogenismFIFA, Football and WomenGuidelines for Promoting the Involvement of Women on the FIFA CouncilBrentwood Academy v. Tennessee Secondary School Athletic AssociationUnion Royale Belge des Sociétés de Football Association ASBL v. Jean-Marc BosmanMeca-Medina v. Commission of the European CommunitiesAmerican Needle, Inc. v. National Football LeagueAn Interim Essay on FIFA’s World Cup of CorruptionUnited States v. HawitStatement of A. Bartlett Giamatti‘Our sin? We appeared to take our task at Fifa too seriously’A and B v. International Olympic CommitteeCañas v. ATP TourPechstein v. International Skating UnionGlobal Hybrid Public-Private Bodies: The World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA)World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA) v. Federación Mexicana de Fútbol (FMF) and Mr. José Salvador Carmona AlvarezEngland’s Code for Sports GovernanceA Tailored Approach to Sports GovernanceSocial and Economic Rights? Lessons from South AfricaGiving Socio-Economic Rights Teeth: The Minimum Core and Its ImportanceThe Reality of Social Rights EnforcementRights and Queues: On Distributive Contests in the Modern StateHarming the Poor Through Social Rights Litigation:The Judicialization of Health and the Quest for State Accountability: Evidence from 1,262 Lawsuits for Access to Medicines in Southern BrazilRight to Health Litigation in Brazil: The Problem and the Institutional ResponsesColombia—Judicial Protection of the Right to Health: An Elusive Promise?Essay on Decision T-760 (2008)JFIF``C    $.' ",#(7),01444'9=82<.342C  2!!22222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222N" }!1AQa"q2#BR$3br %&'()*456789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz w!1AQaq"2B #3Rbr $4%&'()*56789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz ?( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( @{[\[ono1F#>| B>~h)4#Oh{ka5q2呂V|n͵и@BX{Y~&/"7G"7Z+{K?iyV7*Fn/+ g𠨼\rLoEt_?ƏEto?Ƶ2xʹ1+B6#R:RQ+6R}>|`Q{*+ϙ4+ϙ5_t'Qq9,L_`^uß3PDy9~&bKIE3;!dlt dhOGA.s񭦉%%Ē|VPG}-T"c2 ; ^-ZI'롏)ӭtߍ/-)؍R^[|%X.ӌU[\|7\'2;(ƭ% *;H2߼K]Hd~ХzNL|#_^&u͊U2.HPIs4km4+KR4 @r=k;;i]BҤd >P=8W5kUFpduβƈU+qIl-{n|?|,ٓ?Xh5]wK񼨢2 `;]-`/-acAMEmcu2f5PFu\6x(pѨ{it{h$#s}/=Ky#G֪4v3iRIõQϽy|_/;KufE*-u'[O6j2"ޠG g­Iw !,:9Qoj}gֹVmBA,ZJ?hñ?J:xgz'&<%VB&3x,pE{ϳXJۀ(BvV(Tv%˶ *Op(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((+ [ETa*9/wH𽬷zuWwLCXLf28Jjl{[Qo?'+O@E'"??_so?_ujT3e c#:OhУF$kc8*^wh˗BU _ݿ$$`1y'"Z'02Emͩ{8ŭ.MLA_>g?pG-K; 3dXQzS7z?זgun続$n:I碢O@dV}5gE7IpJ0?_JM>3ԩ]5f@<|hRQRzEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEP_=b?`x6ZЕWK0-^s|F4O2/48Գ1$#{ KJ% a@pPi88Zh>@0zYڌ.Mu 5X|1(΢Sw}:.t;*6xOge|\B\L(%B(ٌ sU4.//sУ28ق`b]jzHZ#E`KQ @,G!V= !Nh\N\Jv>ʥ,a9]W1Wh׍|H|e#sU|^',ϩxDx< 0#c\vkGd_*=@ JuAwB/5UL[7UQ_ƧYOJ#icpݻorG}]u+Np`f,ua: Zh FuT8e (tZ+qk$&:9?X4[,?s$DmMăKRe̯4^B$6ݱ0=O^7 |IޕȵH#vC^Fo}tz|?_g=,OSԙpnj}V5nߕ{5QH(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((ⵟg<;%}eh\s^+n }t*sۑ5jJ9S{5aguckzC=ӌG882 X/ F>6c|qfxwSm[EyA[WF ȼ0#Ze!b*$:ס'Kt=;FZإn_j;3CpLi[ {3r31V{i9;AGsHd +PXm;_┣ =BY aw\g=2@^I'F)Mjyp*J#2pH9 2G|HOʸ2 )+YJ ^]Z GBN * f-4R:$IQ a5O>9Q؂v" ;IV\pRWӜf}ƁVk@hIpܠ:z%nxqEX& :7OXtWڟF i&H1Ϙ3gI|X${ڮImR0mL40(EPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPIKI@% xCSEۢk|p]cqϥUFaڬf' ydcm HcopN:^'`7ͼwƼ څjwPm5gM E-CmgvI$r3O)ݰq݇AV5hE.imD$aO6KjEyLT's3ԁaosin,Lq\ QsG>]:(jJoޝ Tkƾ$'qO^^7'F jỚBӒcOrj+&.gv}qkYkNc%Z9>\PRHVA+NsZ4F?Uha%I2H_YX,-(V\y h1__meM"#yzU-"QKE%PEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPE'dMLq:#~8No j(O'd#O=M7D@Ԯ5coL%~A?(_C@YHe9{EPE#2qMyx[ @u[bCyszQ@Q@W'ĻNP>i3G4F,́zz+_ 5c»5 ک r08޹pGį -&[${O"5-~e>(#ςtmJ7Idm˩1]/tˋkW*װݖI z> MmȭS/Ũjwq _p;g1붾]ik{ y!]˲H )Pr@u# {Ǒr:t5?5߈uR;#Kx|vG+^:|G; + "_gg;N>볲&c {~?!:]<=n$uV ( &Ś5nuk/&y55CՊ\WCVvCHŘ'}ʯkv"OV]bWΜvUTn9wh1;W;g}C, #˱eJ1^5_l8HU,'Яlմ}gN'-o;R3?G kzǣjb[ݖP?}qڼh|3A*G~+K[ޱ:qeym(̨܌OJ?=zj1i=8&+Ky'p;)cs7Ev,mӮ!AG@/{N^;<_-rZ1E ʬN.}iz7̻dUʰn6> ܢUqJ^@:?}PWNѢ9+&Ÿ\ _(>i qAU'C~`D7YEޡ^GoJs/Fv 7מ*/4FuMHRA^3zoiZ췵FO򯕮 B|YV-LC}^SӴi]jĻ f< 9=' tQ;0[J/bqc6n0ZCuo dף)~/Upgmx1k3wlV/ YP -Tivh E7bZ vf8Wv` 8j((((((((((((((((((((((((((((QWûRbľ6HoOON11L47c+GlzM x@v}!RI }O@1OZ~"[1񝆵gD%%ʹ|?1_@Q@w'>%Hյg^5D0G*:"ef1<ߗ@56h,~Lg:\0cU'i#8 V"jVkkMf8Oze> m{^5=~ ӌw(cՎ3LW |BĻ[x<Ė/E."m1Nk:(ʼA|S2vGP%ڤ3S8W|9և}4ηڽچ!;Tmlj[I?1Q^Ey4j Goqn- }=Üoq W,sKʈY FU28PX >v CοEq$?. }+_^ܨ4ě-*Mgb= Vx,24ȅ#|P?YW5/JcOǽf< v׶d FgĻo'בtZÂ9#؟Ԛɾx|9CoZidp#$[ ܒb2ğ_{a Ьu$8'g v˪b@IrrO1c 1ǩIW~|I] {3MrE*[ {`AOZ|T\v[]+fxWFS^r: Jbd!n9f%%]CZ#7/Z1.WoD:7FwuOgȯ/^;;$FeH*pzZ|E/Gԣ װmqqaЏC\A|dž@X h=oUvW.wh -mBQ ޻9 =?u|^<ڽƕKy6<\.@铞ktzs+``Vwş9[ѦHup鞇h3 o4/O^!Y$wh,Gq68'"=7JAW@p\{s\/x#;?ݳ̿zdEHOJ&{[>{$^#+lb>o_xRѭtxTW2΢xeqk-OHީxkU{\h2{G{K%} @A{KKق\D$-vzMѵMj]cZr׳?$R8UOZHțCizOxoV)h"x"~Wox2ߑr:|[YoRCf0vQ*;)W %ܗG=y>n5MGS֭)O0^ʻFg 0N^V>mOz^^"fU 'z:W_cIg?fZg&_/ZjZY^֒O]<`e875T VMkwkK c2:O;/SR|?s[赠+}^&L~Dgs~Qj?oû eckmJ9V G$^3$Ar_ziwkA17"9Rq`J emCTԮnmGde?j? d`HI.~AG74,O?-2][JÐX^2Nq]uDkvR;ooFGJ?f_dhU[׻P|.z߃Vݙt`281G~VO4<=kеɁ%DQ4|Pekv:n"MBS[v\w4W௏-E}D$seO=TנO_kdSo%2;(lax@J9՘Oּ.*B%.awp8#/fwXѝ*$^)[S5VMeSܢn;OMzW|Mk W͖=W"CSTȼkym.,0LH >Qy']|*ռss#ᑥG2ș>Exk;%ԖW=X8K.jٯEs@o aq+=oIkY9K|-: zWo89y]M%POaT8W7IzoCA2M"OFP|7GŁk'un⳶1, @!IӜ[:N?Fey_MvOy1vM猍Wo~+kI/\M`oĝJȝ}zr3]/^7KacRв1LzgauumV-g;J7eWwˌ .;;ez##=ʚ_#J2#k|9#%6;o_ ǃ1?{Ln$x(ɺ폘18PJ{tLkFȵK`^n[Px/¶[gFh̗7^縕I,139=+jΙEI4Oyֶ`;f>j6q|7{Eòyn'qW 6w? {Xn{,!t>kGQ¾nQt˖4qY4;rntLC-qe@8PQݓB.;Æ | j~ n-xQᴶ% QUE8 ƛewyiwqk6o+.Z"i{dq@wƖѭ!]WRŸMtQ7v23[G/ãY4=2 h ''߿u[t. 5Ŝr9`MhYZi֑Xkm!!09GhߋEhzѸ@ $dֽY񆇪/ԵxuaΛ.iWpv15{/ Wr]x{I7v> B|1[Cq?t=E`u{ ^b6#q@o :5l"رWG'T]G SCt?Mx}Z[~/`[4I*:`&f Z$,^A&5,:vw> ̗7^F$Ԓ&𷇬aCmc:ڤ~j Ms^hqjH\\JO̧;ה[Xj\%@q<{q^u/ ^WcP~̡GA3]/C6Vke 9)o@OS@ecĚUeDP 7G=Qu O)4y,c# ̷7>V/$y$'ޯCYӭ"Y @V `s@-)_-v CZqwqqrOF >oycONs-1yЁ‰ O *Jӵc}aksh1'^>:|c*h.EQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEi~-d.q?<(%A? ޯ>%j75O]\kqn?tr~P}}X,];58KH@`pI*ÿxMY\*ߟY?k?bP6|;5̈́Wڦ-|pH#5-7k+{{id."*TCUbs+s>"jpB4{;[}&!k勡 ꠂ 84 ݽ\OFiQ`7ǵx\cͭ\Gk,FaWs1' p29ҿZx6׋j ٌ3shN wpe0Ege [h $OQ_==Ĭ82 c )8;׷ivvz|p_jpr,eN>U ? M&%k[ELvpv_J&m䷊ɶ9,6'8w5~ύ#y 1qځ]hZ+kH6[G\.-U8bAݑ9}'EyOIfLN'W.P}PlCXcV$\⯈^h1M=қ%waAw@PAbv8#1{"<gRVӮFcD]wf6P7Rz ƫok|I4Z-,}ۜ8Az+.w>/\|Ӕ89bOX8\j'^QG?I ~^<zoi~wa0bwF6g!x$w#ş]ĶSk?&fS1Lc0|>wƺ(εk}ap,ilBloGJJO +汸p6\$k!NAx _<wP1Z%4.ܑ^ ,Zuܱè=qOAz_H>#:w쭖I~¡@` $ٯAY]i|>94FNΓ麞ujqpt蕣3(^}*m:tz^o}}{[puPNx89OK[oZd|˗YugyQU}#ŗۭ_ CoYwWQnJ\^3{{keshhcrUT@>1]5xWUgOI<~ H033+[^ ,Zuܱè=qOAvշ|Ii׶iCv nE cZO>xkXҟ˶ig+.PxxR|5jQ%1K7`Rm|죹oxش3b7|>|9񎣫x[Х$4{tA!nx n9#R|l?(? Օͬ\ֈc_Xq'Mo!uK;kY?5*GǏ*Ŀ&#?yΙkz>vZڴ1!G_Lb=ŠX!ujw? d`p*wM_^jMkVG! p=zm z?ӯ^]NQW!:g'22]]xt{M>7oB)Fvc޽ ( ( ( ( ( (2BԚ%^6kȥ#R<Ga.Zi}Xfgt@A,Nx?tP|7W<);hC<q1mSpFеNCцlfgMXm qQ@ m#–VB{RfuB;H^(w]^[Umewx$[`$`/1ֻ_hڮK+}^gx"C(H(ɮkms[6~w0#1L= $c3<_@]BG+eӟ } k7|}wOkM-̩$kd/SOOYDŽCObE~\FoN@G9zxڮ,D`F@U$ۭfj~|xu spXl=r۫>(ZA?Aۛ6s>&^Y|B[ڊ$:uڐΠ(ګz{sTzׇ5x÷ZՖuInK"H(Ϡ_S<9I]"Zα^lY^=wO_[i(U2fe\f;L1QQ(lr dgҼ xOcоm\X qӷ>E4 lhXIH ӕGZ3|ԭ5ʹʊ\T;\Pc GU𦥦Kjn-5ԌTUXƹOz[(BY nV!pswU5"G}G呝.^ 8X|[Ӧyum^P1ϥQ#ž!= SCLY[,PszV㯉#@bv"-Q m_*-8t3q4J+)>YoTK^/>#{z%`q12q@zίMτyodK(`(VvgG&<#XM7"Nh 0|WRln{ %XUX+>ZmQr~dSbO8:xO^_ >=/fn|,և}Czhi Ž;Ƞ;cB4Ws^>hK0y'elI/[BPvjoQjwz!fӢxьd F(<-ZHBEs!5EP3x罹k[X&Ce#,j?Ea gIo!0 ȧq=yuOx£P{J;{{7Q&R4 㓓ր'r0uGpmGNrJ.22 8h6Ѽ'M]ZI[dx28VlV.&`v v_"ڒ9eN08c(zyЯ4fh J)Pg5+ǩIKz-[Ys)[| `A9< ^ęU!.MxZ择qKwZ{i.r0Q|IC^Ex>&kou+,A"[?.Ys#N޾. c4PEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEP\ğS WMDp"(\mk<",O'A|\Xֽ+^Mym]5ep[uPn}ku>gBCd֍$ ( 0 I$˽ P tRIg&xYXʤ6<{׻@K_Mo\eѵ&Ew?W]a a3-uo^kV.u{{)#m ǩ⾎<&/`64ڌe@ @?5_ uuinwo? c {z"%m-c⹅T)X{WM-5jI}^ZZVY'&7*?60F^Es]i|:3;wn}^q3|s]FúӛNfҧh؝%>lg{E[U;;WkRzG riHkD#8HX##G ^YoHyR N6>iշ#eÓVقf 2I_& BAygI`$=EiPzM]ZM.G# 5^M>;(n)W~==>#ڴVkwt;y lg9; +tjZ[ʑD964`dٔxwV^7zޝ>;vp=0Abo#}?Xml:|13.p90y-[fM6(uT?f,;'<3f4k^ :v5*AmI>qk"&Zhz0Wc0[;@ %Btit{kSmomgm$?8>^HEm{HX8YKgpgrzmoh]O4DL PT}{P]"ͼjwcm,ku$$Id`W;Bմ_I_Vm"_,*X6[##/hum632cI(@uOdž˅`\2VS3'y_>%xoDd-OD:*oޠ|3ìor)ǻ+Y[MsQ˷ImB h׭Mkx?:ι `'x,[!W,߁l?F^qh: ]5lPĿڢ&炼UU ~#s@qy7>0X5nXUOq}(j|>WhW` zt֞E n[ŠR6v«W#[ÿ Bj,d1L$ȫ +_j'IeٖhQ.0Ok~(Դ=k÷PErnUXA_€~m0{cc7Lw>OIhEY>3MiV׺i{@11[[ÃcN $dzs⏆#>6֩=wc@EW ]M^d|4j2ʿפ'? _xcI#TMda5ڑƧ98]ڂ.+ioxFH#9*G($"㇆&GifK7"Ʋo5#-CԂy̞bF n"@j;ǺG[\xz츚?>e Gߝt?~L}&QdvQ<ǭK7<.bm!N {,jbErDQ֡2.dIb@Iq]<Ox#խInlFGU A=3O@x4KoI_m E.@\g&9h7tK_&/(qIeSkmx/D4ۘ!ϑ1#5x,ƇAԴwg[YŘ33> ݸn1A|GxR8JrO_ x7@խeho%3ɓ#zBY>K [M6ɋ_o$5>q HO(ER)/0i!OѴTu{l&ia%@U:s@@]wO-1/g@Cirn<=匌;nlv{Wx7 dd#希֤@Ðs^:?|xm(XAF?UY->(W]!O k, $N$%6}@#V*]|PֵV}'Q%d TKgqֲXuϊ3)HМk_?*wqql|NK#>u| 'F\''ំe_2.m6Cc# ̇⧌<wgi me+VU`8q]/k74ymDG劫0&9kY7GCX,ʢ'#w{S(}Tb?Q?A$ckI(P؆  7k_ Kx BY[wuQjE 8U8ɠ _b5tE kG(Qަ W:>1 6?u+S׳XYA6ɲ h(T+w74xN;b21H rX:|Uiqok'h1">]("94Ѐqq^'?[Y5{=GVY|ٮ$Ic $u>5k? ך[Xv^ P4|1jO300? Ʋyo_ M^{(˱|ke>WfaZ4Fe0bAdS/iϑ;b7#"_\ޫƁ(ߑSOZ>-l|^fa̒HTrV*σ>]]k^#ׄ4yg;>aj=A炬u=_Hp;O~1_T[_'˰6b񝪙`TO-Y7u_|Mӵ;R &HN_%-GiLhOtQt[;PCJa.?]~9? ĥhe)#@=W x¾*u-)46a;ḵF3 iZ꺼LP!bI'8ހ;+>k#վ%nuAy [x1+LyDZ>@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Vf 3:Ltֱ,{*A@tWi2PcFjꈄc#_ i]v[_,UUОv'zev>٧+V''ݟ +Z'NAfgx5W5Zw:և}cݮۘZT0\0<`zNqrdAp{E2a)A"TlYCc@##=+|kPMQSkm^M@%; Yؾ C/4,Pk'? n9vTQEQEQUu =JXqv|LnS\~ C_kK})Zy&oOQ((M wI ȯQцC0A@lm48mmH@ EQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEW8o?|!4 6Jp U+}p6=|N5v}m㷂5"" P0GU쵙nikwӁeZUxp QhY4>I$A)v1 <u93uzd, ɼr8 x󈴯kV~+Qyw7rOz|gg)\fQrzCG5J?,+CO/^U*zhľ.Oɶiw!w(,6ާ沼K]Ӯ/nL7DoPAU`sV&"%Q9urLU\-.Xm[b8@!\{yǗDZԵ{"rDPYu{s[N/ anHh&,@3|><[s·iRH$n@ޟ#PjEṢգjzDc2/ G)np}vyKA]72-6;bhlgUrN v_l@Qj4~!? I"$^8Pn=nTx+оkvvmo_7},)',~|='~%ΝobCuh', b6]Ųxߍx^ndnu3SC;k-;J;ͣ\-nж@$D7~T/j=Я Jtaۆ hl29KOx"t|nPҒ=BǨ 5{BJӹ׵7o[xޘRd:~kV>q8yT$z#@{|e$}Y9Z D*f۹nQpxct߈/RK$a.C7!ppqX5{Zy_r6̮; 5;-k׈l+) )hҀ; 7vOhVVn.1npSc#iAxHhz۬F($K7%_?:_<(Cj9,|ƓZ@5iOc:Dt"0CaWx֕}o>B(.cr< @Ms7 Տƞ- *+X ʧazƷ8<-Ϫks˕W HPm*~A,5X<xim^Sw+GX+d=*? ^7usZ6έB= oUl<6OYQbl`-@~Xz nnKdoa֫|H|_66-kasyB x~ ZXx4boldEZoxú&-W1}B :A:=XGb plOc,A=# WLN 7w$ scsÉcW/EfO٭fP ր,x?< ZjY02]9c#Xo֍eqak ⭽đGU0{uWW.:^ۈF;9'/Z?|'* 4uӖ6}鍑ڠx aӠ372#97``ry,<9$q.1צ3W<3/𾵠KF^hF뽳H#k+>գ1 JP>(ŗ1!i#s(Q܈O΀;ORiCBOQO4jKs%𧉼U}Si֩#Of3ǁ7r:-'@OxnYH[#Ã)R|/:pڐ+O3' Ϡ$;),:n2 PiQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEW-/mMZC]@eAGWSEykx_xM=@Ql[;`bm+úN (6hq6'i@woM^qx7| f19s溪(C|xz)n~#}FHѴ c֯hh'xb1\JPT putP'%7]^d[ 9!I<օj_ln>-\o p!m@Adاi8*}s.noK=rP 6vFyoK͖kuqsgڠ)mǥj  $e%-!ciI$3\~^绞x4OSN+<Z^&azLsnJe'9c0> ٚm!Rx>#$(.7h2g09 {º(((((((((((((((((+!xH< _iw|Ɛ/-=l@|D}Hul^c# '8=y==~EDVJF4:Ĥ>Y 09I$ܓ]OP|5M?]RVcI+aU@E|{톛a .RgܱbۧO |AdyJ;P >hC)S xO4}^}3CWTM|dēϘ չӼOuQi޽a`H"3`9 2((G[-%LI2?F;@+JĞZou[6`';Te\|P3@Ey_]'Me%N.tf#MťaЃ< UmSźQo-@$A#nfI}Mr>:1]h[K LE ?wؑFH/~=^i ]ZI"i%Yd}JU8w_0_MMir=zWi>w,w{zNy0 38q>7=+ßzHh1bp*2Q^/B# %8f`̊Il q>ROLKǍxvm#N4<3jmǣ0u'k+BsᨴQs{ܰd.BptJ/)NWw/\Y#XO M HJ]*]*FCa1n4h-[9\Ka ⵾2$._۹ɸ+*ǓTG?z^ 2x_ED`a*GB hL:Nhuߐh\ccހ9?j_幱ڰe9hVDRGaH7{YS-/%$O\g?!Kh:Nlھm{ 6Y  &q icVx.OllmvUAi}ܐ3Z^/}.F݃l/.0:֤QG IHƊQPo[s {[Rz^+TҒľ#k kɂ#l1.= +|׹z_ںU/V.83 *h.'t; duťy#IȈڬ2~+u;VwsHei-'rJNk_xb;Oi6$t>5@`A(/Z|.m%ϩ^:CA,{ z?4mMg6"=)++˪װ%a>=9/Fz.me73zԒ>do<)hvQ$?z@4KDԎORLmUuSZEW`0/g'MegoXei mkQT +~.jwσuc6VX,Xz7>!hm8jtn  æOehEύu(MTgĺ29,J8-J߃5<1]c--οuz<8_(󞙯+žӵI5;-BK\G$g:|51IyM1nw4B2OB+Y{񿌡w !-N3 fo\ͪ:Zr6kWkIȜ$x!1[ޕfڞk,mJ.Z" -q\G&kN:'.t)D$FP@ _1x~n!x9"I)h6$OIҬM*MӠX--$qaIOrjxh7kkq-h:Xk<?]#lFf!~bNN1['“MIdbaf'I+ɦ 4?C9KyK4iZzm#d( =;f?s5ޯ] mbP[{s{Wn`Z}gu0Fs*9^\<𞓥k74֣k+{($;8 I*KcvP`xvÐe`23޶ !HXҭ/yg1L? =F"Ҽũ_\TMc'ygbxB{s^T#Mm~˥[YAvu5v ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (#6hrPJQjJ(((e X6bb$5TE  }QEQET+il-r,0҄{5QEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQHeԚZ((f 2M-QEQER++ 88= -QEQEQEQH6pA@ E"F " ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ~,x1,h\-B1|Wu^]×cyӮF1* ^~o/Ե=䷒I @<M[WuI]NGQx2")i$Fy@ Lgnҹӟl"׆[+h V4 |2GsKfK;Kf)Lo[ֶ"cOqvitYvHL:L19PX?BԾ)KLѴVmEP1İxHj_|%ϩK$&_g[=k'tgՔrc $g?OG& 0ߓ@w#xs2Y\Ӕw: ͷzm|9P{fgyd{W ׸5?hȀ@a?O\ۏ|N"h> jx'z'>x`k-uC HП1]c>k|chipG|d-% <Ӛ<5?31Ē=Z=(((((((((((((((((((((((~\Ҥ9.։>Oֶѭ$< (W۷1ڦ2 h:K6RI= G@=UeGљ*,"E`xL3]-aY @fǦM[|9SYUbU#0֝|vѼ95LMeTfփqMcnkT1'*zzԢ2 Z۾ݵ&{u}dtObnͮg ,% Q۸ִ C V!fxk(ʣ67 6OxRUE+b\2IkvΏh֚ɍ1r$.xlזh,tGF&uYoRI;߂篮}{#Ï?Lsv\督v}*燴]FEזbG} H0Oִ ?YW W`4FsVLLCRf%Z%@<}kQ@4KЭMYBNKx>M7S χt[M5;"kKui FkJ'†gFh$5D)=H+'r0i 6Cd$\jx+‘$iRPE[p @?n@?- i h.l¥p61{޶| c4/.1w;3o@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@2iI"5,I)&ueK i k] ([oНt|RZWtwVݎG\1kk/|ciuuI+m?,e mr O/ovDf ?O-~1b6hzW+ G),p{Zϋz֛iګբh#TĶ-'sye&u]RԉaF;sQ^a{kFU{k7Cmm<͸O'CQ)/ Ci[la4l x+ô|I|CVWRi7H!mN O>?u{Y\hpK,#jnc9r)Хծ,㍕LVs8$qZ&9BP\`v5ď:_4lw#1 $1Ry3ޮ|@7f 4im0Eogz*Q^mx/Kcs%G=e˃˩sO. xMM*[Rٌc `we+~ i&4eu-LG潦jgx6:>/wrYb1)aaXeGpyj ){&[Dֲ*@A# xGɥ%q<&2۾\r6G^Yis|C[]%PA#T'RGj_~1w3͕rqӌ8tWxV<_gòA4hԧ*y$:s|ED0$LZ!(MoqϷ Q<71 `% |U# ZMWJ:}Ӗ7$p$A~voe[mH{p{vv5VQt+Q|CO}k(((((((((((((((((JFIF``C     C   " ? !"1A#2QBa 3R$Sbq4CTr)!1A2Qq# ?Sh7>u`'-71 2)ڙmJ6$Dg.[-6 ވ:~⥥N[aWu+AΣr )VKC_~A5WT] ZS1N5i ]rWU>r˾q,B~-Ln)S/8HH#UX_zţܥ)DR R R R R R R R~ϑ3&v-dġ08sHWҷ_*fC!0ɘJnSmA:NhcmkcnʒNg-o4D'ړDČo%ِm-#2_ J;Wy$n_/JSXk戝ͭGn#^<9hlV{m\lw≩fCj,7|R*]T~v7Uk6!fmz9gAo7UWِ[D-{}@}wE|L<Ʀb%QTkc#$v޿DSWɇj#[Jpl]4 :{$8OC)KΧbDZJR((((((((*R-L-6fʲ;2*R@S)ӬlE; Ҩm5=ոÒ\rC}-ڐZ@!}[)ǴJ'ϓb1k^J)p h)e q xRU"輎^:u+5y1鿬nu_HXywר"uk8TG#7+Ұh|uqfϦ{A%nDف:_`XZs°Hopgk!sQ'Z|~tKq f/ZD%#~TvJ$I$]2bqZ)XV73L[-?p>+x((((((((((8֫RJRJRJRJRJRJRJRJRJRJRJRJRJR_)IuQ - Rx-ĕ%*ׂ@#cm҂=As -u6 ,ېVU5TRT6; C]G`7na,&7a<;<vGp8:4,ij><A?q_(ߋf}T$-ޢml&{D2cn6ö~-Ȫ|K$yd|'zYk]wLb4$ f:\lN ڜC6ӻ m\q8.kLFW BuaJgr-peS;kl6T>>OAAa;?w>z;IB[; I AJ#/e\c}}ng46C<<\m';l&oK %HmPO>^>R AQ'_sWu^IC)bRRKM9I'ƝHH xY-~^{Ae(Rȁ_ֽ R R R R R R R RWsN㧶9/'MdeiER(-O'ܤ%(_[C &\=75ȵ17ܩIe_IZ.7Ə<ӧPXrU KO8Ĉ觛O6ڊIC`v E+\Aɉlf JySx-n)¥xAd^L }8ù.\h̿"\NBGI 6#)<|\W}Kc(/mؘhPm2ڸʆb-1{JЕ m\GiYmJu._KR kskSC*5e\8p[$*mĶZ)vONl r`=8WI)f1ƕ.jςH? M;ۭ]].ʑdǟ"m4_䴤)ZR>I=.,2_d)T>@ ! #IUWrRn)w0_L 6y.@<Yԥ((((((iA86DΫȍK V Tqbtd?#ֲ_/ H)㣵t?.d/7rkSЈj}9 8ps 㰞H L}PG}~V9)3i2 ?Ixp`?P+ܛ!NM"G3ۻ+[pc|7s_zͯܫӧȰfZJi}+d4ƚqqNG"LqxljD]0<D}mka]!OZ_@}y6X[ݿ?X W r  ^)} eu6<5C oVB` D;߸ y{h}ضvy~n^1FP)m$yݲ:YR9xPs߿{|n&aX6\tD~%e6|$*Q'a4s+ן\`dy8}ɨp֥VEu ވVP3]m JXVBO@-.2#Z {YZ#iam۝mFu\|[*#zʹ_r1[eeFh(TsY8']:y:l+eq+o5%g))Rxh옾m+Ys4KXTfty-Ex\ekJVT}#h=oAqB0C>#xJ48u/8/F~-͇\D8ZTHޒ-OP^40ddzť2fQTeb74rN)]xei~_~dSlaP"?-H^ʼsHq ͊fc.|fܢ=M{i< }?jO>T\29ㄻ!x:f((pNh9U[\b3ɴ6}6$*}e31;ya[۩ҭ:$ rQaD(Pl*HWn\?̈_ HO ^}ZEZb*dWH>SQJVK$6EyI`\%5i@T&;.RX*)Kei.(IN9 ߩlaZ͛nZ[Bb]\f+︅lSc(Z楡q]ҹ#-2!XV#7} zjå\\mӜCRinNPh 3w){F\C*J^f?"]1I<^!<-Q $$u3K ք`'kH5ARHŸMӏ]Yj2\; *qr܉<^rxRIԝ=ڬlWn29=-6Њj:ˀyd%dT%(LG9I"W=]^qL{T)l7ՔñT}: X R 45ؙ۳[ӌ'T-qDŽ#/pn#rLDl3/Aia?YPb!9i5$BU!I.I'ϓQa`;*ˑeTNʐ4;"߈ح6k|$IBZ}1⡰)J% ڕʰoEn.\c6@Ifc0[6ʴJ-iHKuby,_N+HJThw@!_{/QXMZncns*w &Y쯊JueۊJBc?^s.U)s\c;u@{uU/Gpg [ǣcⲧpXy(6LI*Z)Ho&M8)ee)+Z{`\-P! ? :9Ͱe.Ӝ¤!H ZBqY~m[{/-M<d5eE:48yq.9BS^-[˓JCo`J1Mdǀ$G"@N}Әrpn%*,i)j$-+ZJmC 3;?_:y^A1,"Sn6\Z>NQ}Z8e1Yn{25S"E0vZO~;Eťओ -d{x`^Σ͹)`SОXSm_uMyJi uQ4~d6$'CzKcSW^y9͹I59R;TvХETZ RJ\RG':;eٲ)͎ۏ (츗bYqJt\Hв9W'uv7>lqʂoM4|l9ܲ2#%幤khGZT<(A5eH55\h#n%|(yk{ӈ:҆NP쩳w}oHXB T(2א[NϽ(uf#ӻXnWly6Uo_+Q s@)@)@)@iAZZtuny'Yc&pjgGuo0)ƒ4ʔKa)H-}2РUaz:H5jݜA(8Pi:L̩܃jE1jC51 l*@R AjKz( 8 dKIu•s㩬xr AL O<`#[F7"s.roa!EeNh/#z*BFNtYye^]q.Cs*ep8q'͐$6t((l=WE m]&3b(vdx-l̩.|66Fnu3nkj3 Ȩ6̸-ĉRyNva[d(sla}fw%gɍl14i8̀Y-~BT#A@;Ecbma]Xv; !,SPR4QG=U.W"Dh~M>r:RJ\uX.8 ^g7"o9Q { Z[>ܸMJ&\R)mIO,h|TGޛF]9 \ =K:Y`9{mk¤b%j\TSR]q^Iq):;86|wI#bD=asky"\t8qHsVh!Hˌ~x67ݣr,LmR}K~3og!-rSqJKtm@Gkm78(N<+fΟ(m}v{4r* ԟ g,g=Ѫ7z]Jeף{<N[qv&1yRg\G-Gmw +&lhLPS_`7}Iz$'iO.06mGe?8VHIN" ^A5aݏƃ2U0e9syρSqÞJw=[w˵;}]\%ʏ.R:-}YiՒ$Z~ 0lkU%]b)|4^-%b,ը!k IJ{?̻,XmSeؘsRnNp@m塂#W0h'k۝܂޶\XL8қ*BrI˓:Mn=7;I[-ZXJR!J@@FmChJ%D$kdf)JP)JP)JP)JP)JPU@,ٲ;$N9Tox*HDѰV\]@l͠9>)N 6 @J$5((((((((((((((((((fv n\hkݺ&O ̔'A>$x>ܲkeM]1mΆdC`pA)l) q^G/0YG&0N%JC*t$(㸍O+ZOܸ%Q_2PkRRe$xS\Qp<[}w,u/ζr\J]JxJu HA3nBJf2V6<% $iHr>V=)VtmN\I ql4mA_ ?2u3L>켋-?ki Xf;.~Tˏ!Ajx\@Ch߭O+hy:V)I`(+5f=p}gK\q)%D{xF^n|͛*H h}:Zw (N'\Jz %ˎ &EE՞]!e$u++Sjm A^H)4V2۔At2d0 >+qVvSގ3DڗWRݑ G[,ICr-78qL91}8dij~~JCҢ-M,§)qBi{Ce\$4֫)J)J)J)J)J)JQ}MVAmrmzб-2jTfK! 4Ē Rj*'$sDZ~/NY.?:i,W%;)rB>;(&cN_?w31nIIgIK|R@s"Uz_Z|#>[,RJ߹4)*ۉ!c R5hp41ܕ"9`]쏟_z֟kG5v=1K1n iv̕>n)A((((((?GIF89afy!,fy             "  )!-$ 0$ 5) ;, =0$!.&#!+%5-2+?3" " !# "! "&!'! +$)$ /).) %"/*5,3, 60:3;4 ;6###""(",*,*&+++./0!1-+312./52'21-:7#333:63;;;<=@ A. C3 E8 H6 K:Q=UAXC[D\HdGcKjOgQkRmYdTrVtZz]s_|`2D@>AA,hY@6 D;C; I>H? @<B$*H?$A=*(ѣF)p\PqB)*իSZՊu׮`UAMQӪ]˶۷pB}**Wx(rB+_趽7jXK;j1c7եV=9`}S ,Xʵ']'ܩ9qThW U *TD(,v좠+u߾鴶`0D:U E-cS~\/%.wq"PQ [&FUU-aHHC?(ogxKZe\a 0p&d 3t(!-'t+րPقBu[ *D--T1J9N(MEU*s:#,C9#&vp(Qd"O0D+( 98}oGp%O,Bj+ A++'fFPlMi -?0E Ct?4?,QBC4߀}N9ⴢW3 v=V-PfZ%tЉ/CO栲w>툳,`"3>lrr:uKi{>5>O0hW#ۄ€쭥 a`8 ό!xLY.!Bq`@f-@ daMȇ=QW`bybG;\sXGT<Bˇ;K裄Gyȇsb_2r&:6FӹЇ泍h<{cp3hBGF4*mgi`OH O[ p ƃz5E `b8NaK$D1kpAN(*1Ygp -JHvAvYb4H3,LD /`ub s6A8X AA@ PwA@ s1r9o#-4ԕ#/y1Ў $x;$: رlMk4G?΁A4;09r `GA֡ o u3A{P:F Ch2b':MV yAxݨsE.EP0䌍Gd-QB "lI qHA$ Δ&P2~Q;@y.98bE rD H|ncȳ7v8 ѐ=֑8Gv u }PWv1~p lԖg PF  kq 7vGx7JWv1A3WGgGk2 8P 8 QG4h 5@`'rt}xaV(a:80l axAcyi6#2IG01 \H]ug4 8+`GA7y-7 o2XtaLF;!B>z8gp P48hPP u&Q;QTEEJxPm@T'uQ`uq6 P >9gvwr~VIe8W )Ͱ @iπ 09|01 ehEv AI.  Fg'8s|e@CvvhHH'hr QYӳv pQsa 6G}&|x"W08vx?) WX ARDt|7G0{!)W1W8b 1 @ 4Y ` s 0~Q~QS&Ġh2Bgܠrf@q `cLjz5S`B=AO0  xu`BFc#(hr&+' ͰPx 7Y7y7l+g{5Pg!>`o4 P@9x:  p`AC- P Q  A| P oxQ𧭰Q4G Cp'PPGs 0>tg׈ F}j0qKnUdIg  xP|@g(H Awu1aW2n 9g`q> ؐvS [[4fK jeyKA# >1hQ~;4gPh0 ET{ 9;8hڠ Kr{kڸA"Jrt{ [ C{ }ie~Yi0 PsXgK n9e[4 Q=ڰ_@ȃظxV&u7'vz{g+ 'yu4 w8s%7g FP QHt7P+ 00[EPq7 &  Ǹ4PpW70DF`4NMդվ! STARDIV 5.0 T ;GIF89aZ!,Z    !! ! ! ) &8%%+31-34* '' %')21, 3'5466$*)#-1*3)(775%#48'5988J+Bbڭ رzWw>|omO[/=uӮ} t O[Cm71xNDߓw7fzc׽J^ŰF`]kً][Wab}nx>{]nUvu9wO, 6عG<=xVE"T͇xZv-Y` FgNo3VlX'[r=d@VTp u7[aBm('#OcQc"ulȍ Q.KU81=MXaabFxYcϡcY a~ ! /qHat5'm%vT\!Oss Jc O3l0!4u0`!q:*uv5;먃2#U!Ȣu$r!@dF"6&"0Ny؉P~y:S^Z9@uu3G 0'hQ{|p u+PM3Դc*LJ1xP:#N9ѳNzU {N fp0 I0[, _/$r3t0hN((, CP#8)@Q ,KAGZ8 JUb̥u:pBv!a8Al eX\a @ _T"{! " =F@6, /` ' z:ǁz TØ@OP `0zc DHN'T]n5XUr l]qRPA(2q  6QcBW6pb`+{G HAZF$ pPPV@<iC¸R/[ p:0qB P4a±J@  (P4M1!6v= ]t^' W8Ղ})EXT !wzcBb0@HЃ=8}&ٴc Qs ?yp=` \0t0 P P u{~E7"!y|@H`;*M @'0 |0P@  O=D D" eGA Y2?4P4K)p  ^@,30 %. Z`fM `zP.Ph Z J D o!3*r U8&" l;D pP PcC,06P( qxMT0p3K'!uT"I!;= `  , E P.0 5;:P<7Mt>%oX4X RXui"DjPPw 0,P3 ^`0IPMPP)`xf'Fo;/`D5ID^0 0400PB HhpJ$IYi`n0 HQ[! sQ@B =pP20 Iˆ h ]QЌp%)Q wP0l`|hlyU Ոg 4ؚk` q,Ues' lAl%ZTfH$iow /0_PA9 0F$5 P<t@VV0)bv0Ra8\PI$l920% %0bP`S R(FsAyoa@/Z2g٤8:^  2#  0x UMj28* jCDZQ lxq> tlېa`RGDIn3 N~2^1p! `PyQ^Bs1i3/tDҩ*Q`^u56^#& } a RXႃiyP6`q hI@E 00XPO0*ep@88lV RQRJ# |Umf p  / C tPwQ"p PR'ZŁUᲱ}l 8 ;8jـpœzcn` xP`0i RmpaP؀HkrpM+|RT @$>;!u ^o@@ *kSbd>6\5a@7::uG9VQBH UvQ@`؀;pp "5;(0aФQڝADTX= P#\pQ ["p-ﰱ*@́M*} 1p%0 0*` (o; U `Q Qrvs˱p!݁S*Ny%\P  `1\@S/ U8:l?r^U  *4%  y`^ `K; . UРlk@0  /%[@ ]!%P( .%0Vv*.oPz `vҠƜ˱ PcH$P 0%*0 pp0b`% Q'  7|Q |?)>@$. p4pbGPuyUl ' pÀP >C )!Id1%Ѐ::cpŃ |  @pH>m0sLԻ  .qDҝ-A,_  w! %ro P ɚpuK ',6qe  6U2^\l2^Ć̂ @ r0[":0 P  L 0-u"p#@$|900\ߊ (Ę| ##P  pF(ApLF%+0 "N O7pip߅ (0@I["ˠ שMN LⰃIBpu%p&F@t!1؅pi^ z)X*i<P  p`  ܌&@`9ZYg\=1ϱ%^NRpir`p䚜u Nh$@B@D  OZ-~. 6 0 œ ?`TP p  ~p@APN)f 0%  #]20(\s[ 瀺> p p@ bAO#g@oHR &!`;,P┞:H0Qp CXp[`nFK`@S lS0Љ`pK?*B25WWB5Wp@``PpgŐa*PŃq o0,3Kd=9L0`%v R`A pqPp䐢{>% H| `N5@~4<X0.5,6&  Y$ɫQ_V-dO#݅ge*sp|]H ђ ,.%rYyci?R(^ hVȁB`D:WfC:`:P خA\ ,`S'yPi,@,DЅ.qƉCT'(Pg`ҟ  *@曰ƗsV|neHŒ58T0 A@F6Q>aR Ё)zXa .ޒ4l4'uQ @J*! )c+Jg`NxՁ B$.xaA@eD:a#zCb e2$8Fd $/KEJ8D0 7)€Wb@D o 48Pq^h -Bxs0YPJ`m*ja7x !!r]erA T,FF# d@ ̢KbpAբB|`iM-Rbn}ʨE+ 6t /pCDC p14C"UCJD,bH+~9 aa gtZfnb-м7 p`~H`@ P3 A*H91آcCA` lZ}p&MeP@(P '%/KF >h@z HH#Ht,+X@t:ސXA `ܰ$1N1X$ t@΀.-D!`(2`ey*5ʅD`,D7n%"-7+\@C7!:P5, xc {V0pXD B tcu .baC} .E,cu!faa7d P ; vå TϫPywm4ˆ nb$eBH!7U0X!.`aYœ $O\JuXWvD. 7WÛ_V}`pR ȅ nB9O6th( |nD @\!`A#C(K rwø&#X > u;6`mXL Lq5[H=KN| w0pc$vp 0h`V@E||:逃7R'o#:17:n`}]g a Q ĥ K[.p;DwC<X@(@;dWr@~ƒ}a7ÁMXB `D r, Ű fgP+dwtD݋ D7![RGo/^8.(+TI18 UAC`;#s0('U <-% ۿoP3a_8ȋHȝ ,1( A XhUНp:   @(0D;)1xC)aIU<șh9Cx[؝؝Kp\@''P-I7xCX^ fy'3 +A^07n8

&X"1lU\8RXph"73<n`AaTdk01H8 D0HI\TH B42,14е$b >o6oP1N{30FTB d0U,ȅZzǡ*P?8Q9 KCra8VVH 0 *ȋx.c0VX0ȅ&bUXoڔ&nūdYSA_XP C0PZ' TXc8*UB Ѐp'b됞 0LiTXPA%0!7 K '([pA]LUDsb2 E&+0(ɿ8Q-V^̄M4318B,d(T`6T@WbkK11EiUPԙrK1IHo@;) ?L'V; b#"鱢"0;ۿSH21VVP`Loނ2*Pc2#8($'SPB'C0pa'Ў{3 URNXR'7\(0Cr(ȘA\d1TaTa耔BLiT e<LNpRsU(+[SЅdG%A0x C;l)ɶ!)TeI:NQL3|@00e"o1*I eQ?* |0k)% rrIh5LJLIp0 HLQhr(Pd8LnMШH8n(oHeeS8VVhT"H'o\]066p>3@E{်( W[h^p5I`L0PB 0!H,V6G)**X 06WX ZkpR hq8pPeFJDe HBh(3H%h-pK2e 2`u !̕p @0`y0ed`$:VJ`0x xYV,(#pO hOh G`/%p% K8[7 8`(sc`H&Y%T| !0 h*%@` $M$$@Ȁ)s8b0>&aSS(s Px q&(*,t0Ɲ7f*P|s $S%8IS8AxXdIK cAdMJ3{ȇcxb`VXNVp`ȪAdc!xkDc 8 D>Xe89x8p0H}kdƁcN`Tp' 'p*x*.PgiyYz^u+0ujdFn.g^2xr=ehC(VXUH<ppHi(?ż( L (Fihi )rQ08jp#g>3Fg~kf7)n,'0i&6ö! STARDIV 5.0 8k ;JFIFC     C  9j" }!1AQa"q2#BR$3br %&'()*456789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz w!1AQaq"2B #3Rbr $4%&'()*56789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz ?((((((((~~^׾2-oǤhI{Iأ]/+gǿڷ^CEWaʲ'&$4IeM_QpuQ"9iGy۬Zwh{!Sתy]9tm&~f?gK/ J?i_7 | ]+U6SLzmgN*+Ȱޣm]s87x0d[i]???qGִo'Yn>VDL3V*N8$א_~&zw _Ș-VQ@Xy$=/o"69J5v?[<l=v+L> )E,=B$⳾"\^K'ﵗW<1OJ:؎6䫿݈z:)zF|$.ԗXY2#F'Oʽ:_4K&9N`Ҧ7q7F?k_Tw60X|g_*%ܟ\yc8W9[xÊa&vwa}+GWt'~U֫49WJO?.L F756 &jR]ϴ~I?gO2[Q =0''^iyilQ 9appE~Bk6Vj"]]<6<;z|fNc'W_ x |←r yu'S2q5ݿ/CΊ/oSv7~J_`rֳ+C~Rk\,8Sp⻯59^ogxEVJo]?&QEpQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEWR*gd Bl_IqIE+Ylkv?*}k0~vw];}#$HS"i~< yTS?z/i7W/&֧Pڲc=+ج c8ü2Q^j\*T"VGG?eԴ#Jdu^"cF};k +[ºW4n'pA}5~,:<(؜.eOnpWq$gIS+Ii~ F"Ude~Kklx9xwl|ClǘWLEF >Oq[fST񵨊6nErkM( 0+7'B}ߗe9]b0/Ÿ~ӧ\.0b֨^nl+ұ$V]O!?cڎf\[xC_vR~KIKA8q5.#UeK?\/*ʣhn}Wgt(Š((((((((((((4O׾-65-NBk벤F 69ڧLIɿڻwRj~ 𮰳xg·2iz)S]N`BM}/ Uss|IsO=oQ8L N*rT/gMye}9WS/|`QM_\vl`†<Qk<W$-[eϩ }>|w}fܧZk)`%csXW-x uVCqmIF[<\~*-޼Oͦqw{eM+i,ֺ08G@uqWG=:0miyO,Ž@=j- KxKk x[ϣ?Lx,Z%]ѰR>ʐr<ּ,*mSMY.q~u/?<.ZX9I9._~:N /J|Sm.v9f8?|6q(h5j8v8KGyL=8iEbXK v+S1?i ~u}?Jkؐ:T{[G x!%j#κ?׽b=+>.xZ7\"y<؜ç^MR. U+I;?M\;WiZZ@b_մ]+B8Lf䙎X^˿or&l7231μފd7_)"U7Ϸ#T^.7 Kvt?_!k[0KmPrvM5Z>Ϗ-3_]ũ癖ONފK0ٿ[OZZS]%X4G `{+<ɟ>x> |%y8OC(. /j&? h츞b y֗^W sdȏ~;G CN7U+t)5~v? OnyW)7`ӳn˕2}7nv_J?fjeK_2["ѐy {|C"_K^.:HyOdrR46hG  ckS@|m*|H$m.H5[A,7eX͌xktK /v2w^Vyv|" xoiR )Ysۣ#<_4zš|M 7!#C;~K4hH0V\}$t}qēZ|5 ?Ėof)/Ir\} J|)P\ U}qt渗}3&'/׳ѧ+1鴝%+"tz{Wg6ǒ_ϽH*汆f_RБWRt5v**Ed 򯈝]Y$(hf}@%=?Z X (ȎKeoSd:PQ]`~B`>F%(3 %tϛV֬$Rm#N ۏzW>:)g4~IY6' /_|7[HR!oed?/dxK=Mܮ oOf{תm5ix#D>-M%,$~"$Z!|CѢּ#Cy PX# Z,ۆ(B褣ֵ6?gumGf5VO4oE<炭Gԏi.Cuiu h%@*0"%󾠛ogz+!>}km :h)17Cÿ179+ۭm]qjvSZJߋ7s0e@sZp@1+&GrX{;ݓZ}*y# }p}k^8UZձӥs3,c>]C6W<];zZjucZT,ZЏ|]Bh8ySƻTR9k&dWC{k^)yfs`j'-]50(D~DZPAȬ{&l-jj)٣i:ubg#]xk^luͦ{IqHYOgzŶ2No[Qu8?+ 0x_>n['3، |E|@e+/iZ_F `d`2=Gb/,·yu?x׆O]UWtd*oϼM\_Y\F 5p2>'~^yr/ m7 m9+J08oz_EkSտ>C &MCN?(eQ6#U2l>#g[Q'ϱX9;sSi|-I)ǵԝGQEW>QEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQE|`{K S/2G=y|{ǯxZХmsdg~Z-u#)P?~V|'dW1P"@7 3zU+?SZҾw+͜@Ԍz*ҵx67Ԭct$1+i3FW/q|6*^H%7ʃȭ4 5yAiIM_U߸9<*Z:MmNMyҼ}Ǩ\E7[:vbW~ >-*OZwq|,T,=?M@975 my~߶ wmW,%৩ o}xy9|Oh/qVML}>^⎿9+cᕆU۱hϯ<Ѽ%s_xհ5Vj}!Q-}'ߊ8N#DVH2 y2V?|'(4zz[*1 |H֤=# z?Ɨ{dTs|+R>"ӔtF=5H nk&} im#1g7PTP`Wa:\%-NK ar^5e ȣp{7@ep3?M{ioM&-sB[i1ȧv#?j/=Ϥ'W$rszd12~З^ DL -en?tWҾ1yrUb{28e 2Өgϣ_ӡ}o4zpEq=~O^ziWfjPrdQ"~S~|āp46:Յp-WQ_C>?b3jy,@ܑy޻KQpu*U#g+ǝ~M_&㪸ig9Co']菮hz?Š((((((((((]J#PY~_ ~862XPX_K%H|)<ѽY8WgkXsgm &+ig2þQ="YO ݢQe~׀] Isŏ"o2KX\*C?e XǦx£JDP5ǣ;'5ϜYX9wvny(hU4}Zu}hANpyv7=r,JOwmj*?nvijN:66_9y,mVGbL1UFI>%5z] Wnо%wZ-Uԯ칪un5?dh1~F=\sujYWs4eJξ&Q,|ڀpN? k+*$*HvSZ3`M!>W~'.&0%S8īq|We+\B;6c r?:o/EѮ3-V$ uǩWhyҼ//eMQc^M{_}N0?[9hRw] ǩi%SmοLbOL^mrTms˴|wzŧ>+)"awl3yok?`?w?ڥO l${b?J8.')sKX{ӪgfTiV~ic5&iY]&K~P(H!p?>Jb gpYxb nYW`g~=s!~O?[q? |"jO̅:}89#ПJll(t8CKH?T`W>'NA?y gƼE\bj se~m|MZ(!?` ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (>~v_?d_ӝC֠o%Gc#!Yaɯ  8O񠅿S!3 :\[^[2UHOⷄbo]':eM6K9fR\d8>;Wq6" 呥%{{uik? 79^3J2SNKg׎# RN?OvIT;=6>MM}MFo?JRjܢjڰc&#ÿP?YWzln@}#:$6pIB|t,c| {WtgEnU?5~?ŭZ4[<$ r" hGB^iS#c+Jo-@xvQsv8vm[H}y[Q`8~c? 뭲 '8k<_ =VK S-9ð+U~(+j:/!TD;v:톓e&G.e|NaW:]ei3YNCUW{⿌~𻵔oMӓ^?.maGoj׻KOqL5Xlr\̜_S_}2g,≒,F&<@ "/OQ^csb8n8gƐZ髫 o Nsu>-xk=7<{%?mœ^;33N.LDAIs^g?ĩ ڗQX!%~r-?LtB/VRjki/+O·<{"CMyGd[!duY>=Ğozb^f"Yu##w[5?:K=km:˻EGbL>SqYzjSC"kyoj1Iե3'Ǐ?t4fEN(Z Rŷٴ݆&Gg~*H.|A .s\? `bd$ͬ%0Rڬ塷Ǚup|+Gyzv՜8=IŸM}ltI-u%l}?ZӳU TAI1^^%CϳPtǼV2 c_xWp]tz/KnjbuKC1ğW -6Vᡝ}w6wY= tЏZGeg(c kUWcOY?zv>qU3*YS`7~D7񭟃1{K-`,?y*$ž-%Mb͖QHaY% V}O-oCZhM$|R3:WQE\x'{Am>V&ɯ14)C. "]9f3ډmE~fRKysmz_Ɵ"ËXɞ&rpTWu[ҵ -_˦x1Z}A)o~{ ??K~4kNib9HfoMWoֳ \HrCc:FKULʧiS'Myxh<*4[hLw~/M((wUuk-ZYOeqtK ȕM zZk>q 4",gʏ=~D#J?/]R&QaנsɘG5Uwv/0pfj(UM$zJqii,V]B 5+|?޹ڻ"76 `~#<ڽ_πg^>pǛy9lh$oxT2Ik,C.d `Qשd9|x;>˿\[Ĕ8S(}$>Ŀ!yqJN{°S^&,OFՊUj]߈&fG+$.~ş+fk:ׄ>dK0Hc#Itn?@+?gJ6މ#1ç}lQݠ؃D_V K%k7^#Y7DpќR[o:? Sī ҥXVON-p r~$wz5w3[--2I),*8־K`bq8sKO?E pM=]:Mw g⫂Z? kz*IOOף}{Gxb8 8\~u >!ɶ߇(٩^(dh~|;qO {v:&@"tqQ(IXI$_3%arK N{>c~s\͢挔6Wmm?zY.|' 6Kq#ҹcI V*d);m?ѣT$I.(((((((((((((((+Oo Mߊ^,KI$ctR{QWJJ5ɩ-vkEZTStE8z?-<^g&[o PEzO|N?lxK vZ.m%bxT=ذ;DH92+ +.!AS(֊m%i3+:w*z{.R+~Mz 5@6j?wgq^0[Wmo?__׾A+(*?~xq i<[@cIO@j&oZl ##?i' o4M`F δ'#vxXL=׵1q(MܹёsJX˜z*Rd܏gqrV7+Y9M_'/3^dz=~E >w!Ubgxi?,IfM9>~9rYBQ_W;+ j4 <}.]>w^dM}d{W98~.g?_%5ۈtIBp/S t'**=s g46j+f , nr9SQ_umOw [J?gx"o k[hƃ/=&:\G2L(W ?*+)37$RgE6_ (?kG2VIW_R=>O@&s?\_Y~şv¯+'@##{>' ?{~)2Ath խF; 9\C"IVR#5H ۈtxZ4{9 ˑFF}i*9WxZrz@5k? \DQLICEO#G_~NV~Ԟ"1_?9m^.gq#;Ő u9\vQLAEdxƺ5m?ƽei򦍩jV&$Jd@%C) c"rS >Q4{ۛ_ K-:f;I\ҹ ^M|g|+_-gMWF +x$s,q%`2}6~0||>,vm>TFmrP dEl1ցWG?Uٿ猾xmIy\Zx^qA+G(ks+?kJ|(" 3E_ (A"|¿?g?xMܢhi w*' ~"\Uk s{swH^ wA"f N(MQEyUǗ~:<='oCJ]xD 8wv;[1E53UKysczoEQQ_Gt>VKWOTT??s gE37VԴˍ>o6o<,wkBH+.d_Gxo/"P5[bSյKSVB4WɟL,W>ЮKyimk: 2qJCYpHܫ~~{M)iݴqk 8,&MJx.DeO_W qPa9k>$]叇7>:#JwܾKmCrVڋO7x]k!vݴ}ZV=mf?b/| 7VZ7~"0z%V2z""e(k ;kdtk F$VX]|0G^'CdtdnSi&nLy]+hEw#,i 69fR.Ho)y9+oOSOo>8kZy7TG ?(lO_<i j6M5Ŵ4,HDVr EmM};پ"HllYÚ|,cW$%F0| 9=O͏:Qbh.)??i(+ tO?jw_ Fdn8>VE軚U#w ?^jܓ₥RO܏t''oMO%O$-+V(UG}]0xF x  t,ʹ$dl5+Z>f -RoHGgg@yd@7FoT=>iefKB8bVgrM6_r;XxA<- ^`/<8cfFWi)8s X(&_oH!q[ U/I'/)=~=?K߰d-Uzͩ_]Oc .9 I>9O? c|' /axcI=Cӵ2;%60,M"28[c?H2OQ??H2OQ䚹JxK]?_IO>/ ߫3OAj|*ib=kr_·KONզfF9U`b 8_# ٟ GǞ&-Gv: N@Ki`>M7"9-a ~-s*EC\zdfqѵij\"X,a0d?"? 5Jޅq6/YxzF|K+9}ȱ(Kt4+W_%j~%: uZ-eku i$n P#"u_;;5TkqOo i1*%u_;;gр|sZ ?88oQ~;;L7:iN K9UchNc?H&/9{ỿ?Uw \p5xu ^~͚W1;gмI6g/6'E}Z}IvP F9XXU>|*w]ȯ&ú͍/%aFeիmƚ\V@2ꅔ1H!n~/=[wƭ47p(dI8ہp/o7 ?7}hUS/r <`s }~_Maf &mu{ZHREIYyRGJJѱJ/!4?ٶ/? -:Ky5?j%̫3269< W%4jJ/'Zo_5[(?R4s_Dfx_7ؤ kϳ7>}+ӑ_[(?R4s_j#ޭAI4Ѱ"տ²|u![?QG]C-ZTյ-+UHEWTCźK}jVZ\9JlIz,}ƺ/o:֧P6Doq+w D0b=k #P?iĿtjKW !0[>A; xwPFKO^`nS9{2O )$e?XҧQׅ~:Y:?ۼQ$s}= ;[kKRI~O_Q?`I6UC W*T6¾OGR|9@O)K߉7+mxLͩj^ SQ,CP0@?ow߳t؏wN mGO j;0O=[,Ys.{kVHBFe#z+xŸ?|.ix{v,K DtJ?$_%ja|C>^V4B:fGw1~%: uZQN|Ls3_2 =;Ⱦr+`I2+?2 =;+#ZBEdxSǏٛW<3e)o.y)ȑ)bqdEWG~ߌty|;| :O :GNUGA*ː_E:d'_]Kg#H+ů )lcDI&Tw9/Í+>h|)[4]CÚF%n`L-WpakѰ"տ¿!'?m}mJmmmٿW5{%K AX͜bSz8%|3F̤ZGO o_&(x.,P1XQ:TK< VU~U?Bve jniՅ⸆E # A5r> _)[o|={=7⯃>Ԯ@H }!呹䞎|m#?jW)xd=8 0xt`pWO xk+xЮa񹈬3ܕ=jVVggEtֿ^ImSKR0O;Loy!Y& j- bGZgZf?gOF-IcdK @vRqԚ=ipV?-t}qg?-B>?cZdxS ~Xv̒~GE?xWwa54$syUZ#=z|8퓭jp+5<9 0kBݣ@ #l'W fht ȟEMFşeլz:r|F_]?kCşl/5/^i~iq oPw6gʌw߀~=|+ZO!.GO*Ȯ"N5l&Ec =)??lafL;Fv&ݦI`=a|5bhh^6?3D\a7>Zn.ۦUGTM0 AIuF.ui6<W,O 2:0!A`_ |vߍ>x 2I";+q9%mđIB)[RV:tG\w^&񯋼't Z焦c̄zWG?9? v?QW+ Aٺ3_\c7Pj~M 'P=?hǹU?lE K(?-:'j ?`o曨vm pIbYcg̜;z~j/?aQ_ß 6]5k% Ga#ݺolc{H ?kki<+çy=<ٞr B+Jfs*~sLg^i.omKS8wIhz^X][V֖ J8HBU+/1~kVӬ5,%]W{X.JrF] í2S )$e?XҧWs~¿>"6߇F!smg2ynnTnC@ߌi??Kuw:e3<4~-9\AE}7&rOEqo$?+%~'%%W/??M IrCMɴtڳw}{Ś׋.=?PuV20 L6޾^1p+~^C|qV6[7y1P$(__ ?j1Mյ Elo g#A$뱾_ 5dO'g"ԧ7:0PI!*r4jt=~m3$+-'O08H@?QU~%: uZ|?mo~#hlְ& N MdNX8%XqL/W}Y%* ?"JBVO344~1fbX¾/??M S-+ G}~(qG_b9~!ho?_~/6x^Lro(_hڤ_jDa/?਺ƭ[ᅬZg鯴\ s4q´ pBpNY9~!E}7&_A&% _J](,:Qu FҪ',9-,~Wu|m?$n=f]/][A5{Xc"@%C)# ֿ?i5=|xiCQ%MBFEUU$rIɡ+K|<c㶅ËxFLuͬ$|! FA-> l&719 9 &xm^{~f΃A_m|L<{o?f?/"UEiu90xe" C `Veg41f|Pbx_'g7l.]f[AـE_ A|Pо2&i77E}jV ѶFA)rIH+_V{X ;a^y~j ` ׀;HE|yx/ky_Y fRֽ <<$ړ\ɽFwR*AEYZqKY+ұu?>,Ե?U){ˉ6F6^Yc0q$teʸ2Rn~(>*A4׾&kQ3h:LƇ4-{c)Sjw&]5RQZъm+WߴM7㿎k/FĖkh𥕲X*3Iî;Woq?&-/wꚅ>Tz, 9W冣VpJj<-┒oV;7qD1R!7JRk5IN7RKDf{mQ^!Eyo6skRiھЪ@7種xWQ5n\ L,Ik5㋺sp[ݩ,ҋrxU/({}-n[ExW~-W"mWUV"uP̑M (U;WT:v:NTO"ʎqRMF#4I&P(7$x qվ] \ckOyMO/0S%vYcO'cE4)4wʯevKnp+Kx_g;;m*Ĉx|)(P9+?dx߳k VKWU֡y(RB2I6+/RUZ&[Itqi]>,LmV('n咄%{NtiEW}Q_8^5ÿ?5 xSP!jF kˬ_Zsj֞+ҼAwgҬb 6#ۑ8^BQ:漭'_6֗㸾_xjT\R3c+ɨkuֱ^>^6R2RW4>4QExs~&-|oz 3 mK3m GIa9=nJ#5̨e}Led`e1)6մ{E_|M]x7Σx]U#(VHܘ62 `lzWQU˱T.[5ѯ&דS󌶖6fg}c%QwF (g߁QO!z ":DI2Īˆx)B*J)w7#R*89-"M'&:j+x?e6>tmB=6;\(, 8gWu? SN57vVQs^",שPܔehvQR7<a}^AS ܵ9$W5㪋)rɨ7S2,sΝ,O.KOsZ)9E <]+;KC( 3\mwVx@kk;ºՕZ)x`>7'Lk:S7[nFnm, p0H V+*exՉ)%(W<(lU])A/~IvigoWU>|+Ѵ "Mn »j(ZҴܥݶ. a]"WܬO |,7BI8`HutRZjQiTBfZO/? _tKKJCG 8uUTd[ 9o|B~'xZAԾ%x/l' p @0$_@Q^/:ZhС*9f֒U*rIJc/V+aMR\..ӒoJ YAjW(|jƟ :5 g@ #aZ}R{=?^F}=$V/ \;\]CvLcbgO`aE{8,G\Mi.uirgwgtWZ=4h#b3/ƣজn\Ѵ۳Z㿰G?<5o6Y"P?fIQ TQ\e\SRӓnyUP28-R`WPhƽCnog5d0@8Eafl('Ikho/Sĥw )[]lʪEױ#'<_kN]@·g3dP i!rgo⽇,uIqj[:;kITe` kӨNw[T%u.)4#puZ3iU;{M)˖7[^ݰ+>w !uᯉ!?5}CNV:>-ܐ±[dJO#;?wmf |]k뚥*o|?.gcc+pH N䏯g0Z䓖9&m\[޶p|~'++AAs48hgWf!la4|vIPU5WͶۻ>%d'~wl]sw$?>GmJ±ߋU4QܕL}r_]^YTʥRtRQMovIx:Y2*9hү9*p\'GV 8?xǚOū&gtK-BWKPPl8-5Qf3iөV)N1Qm$oRIZ6Y!dYZ Ӝܜ\r\nR4'{Š(,Ox^|^ މyw]-oufXG#k}Eߘ㥘UmCvTr)F\*TQ\|] ɣ]'{xͻZQ+ils9} Eݎ*mܐ=yU<,W2'Sk[.Y3ͧ|!:FH5]:{9FJ=jҢ9S]jSZnWMY3_٧‹/ٯ}cM5^-|hHTUF|~Ǟߍ>8|G|q xV>uX h|`$s2 ^{JkʕJ.fĦce$ed|_µSu(D8iZ0ݠ+O8&Puaak$N8a ?ϿJ2}M{Կ}*j*>GtjPtLjhGI04Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@Q@SeѰኝ~7G&&Yv^XlOM˽V;uϭEӥzT֛k)~HBW?w v/'R6zRd:b={ך訧VVrihn]`Z4 UDVUҨQ_eνg|]"s*K1 b_)*_ʾ{Zf?~gQZ88ӑnGsc5/E"~i~:fp[g_q]%l2_yH"v -t3$~Ҹ1xJ13JVCykp-J$hߎDea`r4p^A N<0%-Mz(Nࢊ(((((((((((((((iڲm Gqư>Ki? a^?TJĎZǖbdd\/On}P?\W]<ƴJu?ø>N$U??ƽsY/ƹR+m\Ws?JC B]uIm2F ARQ챓jÛ2HW{v=furW